TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 117 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105274
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
(4) PROVISION OF FINANCIAL AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO STATE AND
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AS WELL AS INDUSTRY TO REDUCE AND TO MANAGE HAZARDOUS
WASTES, INCLUDING A COMPREHENSIVE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM
FOCUSED ON SITING NEW FACILITIES AND ABATING THE DANGERS POSED BY
ABANDONED FACILITIES.
RICHARD D. LAMM, CHAIRMAN NATURAL RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE
BILL CLINTON, CHAIRMAN SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT ENCL.
CC: STEPHEN H. KLITZMAN CHIEF COUNSEL AND STAFF DIRECTOR
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 118 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105275
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
(SUPPLIED BY THE GENERAL ACCOUNTING OFFICE)
JUL 10, 1979
IN ASSISTING THE SUPCOMMITTEE ON ITS INVESTIGATION OF THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA, WE MADE TELEPHONE INQUIRIES TO THREE EPA
REGIONAL OFFICES -- REGIONS I, V, AND VI; AND FOUR STATES ARKANSAS,
MAINE, MICHIGAN, AND MINNESOTA. THE OBJECTIVE OF OUR INQUIRIES WAS TO
DETERMINE IF ANY PROBLEMS HAVE OCCURRED OR ARE OCCURRING IN THE WORKING
RELATIONSHIP OF THE STATES AND THEIR RESPECTIVE EPA REGIONAL OFFICES
CONCERNING HAZARDOUS WASTE ACTIVITIES; AND HAVE THE REGIONAL OFFICES
PROVIDED THE STATES TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE HEN REQUESTED. WE ALSO
OBTAINED INFORMATION ON THE AMOUNT OF FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE EACH OF THE
FOUR STATES RECEIVED FROM EPA FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE ACTIVITIES.
ALL THREE REGIONAL OFFICES REPORTED THAT THEIR WORKING RELATIONSHIP
WITH THE STATES WAS GOOD. THIS AS CONFIFMED BY OUR INQUIRIES MADE AT
THE STATE LEVEL. HOWEVER, AN ARKANSAS OFFICIAL INDICATED THAT THERE
WERE SOME POLICY PROBLEMS WITH EPA HEADQUARTERS. THESE INCLUDE (1)
EPA'S PROPOSED CHARACTERIZATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, (2) NOT MOVING
QUICKLY ENOUGH ON THE ISSUANCE OF THE REGULATIONS, AND (3) EPA'S
CONTRACTING-OUT TOO MUCH OF ITS WORK. ACCORDING TO THE OFFICIAL, IF EPA
MISSES ITS DECEMBER 1979 DEADLINE FOR ISSUANCE OF REGULATIONS BY SIX
MONTHS OR MORE, IT WILL SERIOUSLY HAMPER STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS.
ALSO, HE BELIEVES THAT THE STATES DO MOST OF THE WORK ON CERTAIN EPA
CONTRACTED STUDIES BUT THE CONTRACTOR ENDS UP WITH THE MONEY FOR THE
WORK.
BOTH THE EPA REGIONAL OFFICES AND THE STATES REPORTED THAT TECHNICAL
ASSISTANCE IS PROVIDED TO THE STATES WHEN REQUESTED. NONE OF THE STATE
OFFICIALS THAT E TALKED TO COMPLAINED ABOUT THE TYPE OF "LACK OF"
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 119 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105276
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
MOST OF THE ASSISTANCE THAT THE REGIONAL OFFICES HAVE PROVIDED HAS
BEEN IN THE AREA OF REVIEWING STATE LEGISLATION AND REGULATIONS FOR
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS.
OTHER AREAS IN WHICH ONE OR MORE OF THE STATES CONTACTED REPORTED
RECEIVING ASSISTANCE WERE LEGAL ADVICE ON INVESTIGATIVE PROCEDURES,
METHODS OF GATHERING EVIDENCE, AND LABORATORY ANALYSIS OF HAZARDOUS
WASTES. TO DATE, THE REGIONS HAVE NOT ASSISTED THE STATES WITH AN
INVENTORY OF HAZARDOUS ASTE SITES ALTHOUGH INFORMAL DISCUUSSIONS ON
APPROACHES TO INVENTORYING HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES HAVE BEEN HELD ITH SOME
STATES.
THE FOUR STATES THAT WE CONTACTED WERE ALLOCATED THE FOLLOING
FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FROM EPA DURING FISCAL YEAR 1979 FOR HAZARDOUS
WASTE ACTIVITIES.
TABLE OMITTED.
FULL TIME EQUIVALENT STAFF POSITIONS FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE ACTIVITIES
IN EPA REGIONS I, V, AND VI
(JULY 1979)
TABLE OMITTED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 120 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105277
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
BLANK PAGE OMITTED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 121 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105278
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
APPENDIX VI
ADDITIONAL EPA RESPONSES TO SUBCOMMITTEE INQUIRIES
NOTE: LETTERS OF REQUEST AND ATTACHMENT TO EPA RESPONSES ARE
AVAILABLE IN SUBCOMMITTEE FILES.
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
NOV. 20, 1979
HONORABLE CARL LEVIN UNITED STATES SENATE WASHINGTON, D.C. 20510
THANK YOU FOR YOUR LETTER OF OCTOBER 24, 1979, IN WHICH YOU DREW MY
ATTENTION TO THE FACT THAT WE HAD FAILED TO REPLY TO REQUESTS FOR
INFORMATION MADE BY YOU IN LETTERS DATED SEPTEMBER 24 AND 28, 1979. YOU
HAD ASKED THAT THE REPLIED BE MADE BY OCTOBER 15 AND OCTOBER 19.
I APOLOGIZE FOR THE UNUSUAL DELAY IN OUR REPLY, AND FOR THE FAILURE
TO ACKNOWLEDGE RECEIPT OF THOSE LETTERS. HOWEVER, I UNDERSTAND THAT MR.
CHARLES WARREN AND MS. SUSANNE WELLFORD OF THE OFFICE OF LEGISLATION DID
MEET WITH MEMBERS OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE STAFF, AND THAT THERE HAS BEEN
FURTHER TELEPHONE CONTACT IN WHICH MR. RICHARD TALLMAN KINDLY AGREED
THAT A FEW QUESTIONS MIGHT BE DROPPED FROM OUR RESPONSE. A MEMBER OF
MR. WARREN'S STATE IS CURRENTLY GATHERING MATERIAL FOR THE ANSWERS TO
FOUR QUESTIONS NOT COVERED IN OUR FIRST REPLY.
I HOPE THAT THE CONTENT OF OUR ANSERS ILL REASSURE YOU THAT THE
AGENCY IS RAPIDLY EXPANDING ITS CAPACITY TO DEAL WITH THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE SITUATION.
BAR0ARA BLUM DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR ENCLOSURE
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 122 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105279
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
SEPTEMBER 24, 1979:
1. THE ESTABLISHMENT OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCE
WAS ANNOUNCED IN BARBARA BLUM'S MEMO OF JUNE 27, 1979. THE MAJOR
FUNCTIONS OF THE TASK FORCE ARE: (1) TO DEVELOP AND MAINTAIN A
NATIONALLY UNIFORM HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM. (THE
RESULTING SYSTEM HAS BEEN DESIGNED TO PROVIDE A STANDARDIZED PROCEDURE
FOR TRACKING THE STATUS OF INDIVIDUAL SITES FROM THE POINT OF INITIAL
IDENTIFICATION THROUGH THE FACT GATHERING AND DECISIONMAKING STAGES.
DATA IN THE SYSTEM DOCUMENTS THE INFORMATION AVAILABLE ON A GIVEN SITE,
INCLUDING ONGOING AND PROJECTED REMEDIAL AND ENFORCEMENT ACTION.) (2) TO
WORK WITH THE REGIONS AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO EXPEDITE THE
DEVELOPMENT AND FILING OF REGIONALLY MANAGED HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE
ENFORCEMENT CASES. (3) TO PROVIDE NATIONAL MANAGEMENT AND DIRECTION FOR
A LIMITED NUMBER OF HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT CASES INVOLVING
PARTICULARLY SIGNIFICANT LEGAL PRECEDENTS OR CUTTING ACROSS A NUMBEF OF
REGIONAL BOUNDARIES.
THE TASK FORCE HAS A STAFF OF TWENTY-SEVEN, ROUGHLY DIVIDED BETWEEN
LOCAL AND TECHNICAL PERSONNEL. THE TASK FORCE PERSONNEL INCLUDE:
JEFFREY MILLER, DIRECTOR
DOUG MACMILLAN, DEPUTY DIRECTOR
LAMAR MILLER, DIRECTOR, TECHNICAL STAFF
EDWARD KURENT, DIRECTOR, LEGAL STAFF
THE FOLLOWING PERSONNEL ARE WITH THE OIL AND SPECIAL MATERIALS
CONTROL DIVISION:
HAL SNYDER, CHIEF, HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE CONTROL BRANCH
HUGH KAUFMAN, PROGRAM MANAGER OF HAZARDOUS WASTE ASSESSMENT.
THE FOLLOWING FIVE PAGES LIST THE NAMES OF OTHER EPA PERSONNEL
RESPONSIBLE FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE PROGRAM.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 123 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105280
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE SYSTEM REGIONAL
CONTACTS
TABLE OMITTED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 124 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105281
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
PAGE TWO OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE SYSTEM
REGIONAL CONTACTS LIST
TABLE OMITTED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 125 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105282
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
ADMINISTRATION & PROMULGATION OF RCRA SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS ---
CURRENT ORGANIZATION
DAA FOR SOLID WASTE: STEFFEN W. PLEHN PROVIDES POLICY DIRECTION TO
RCRA ACTIVITIES PROVIDES LIAISON BETEEN OSW AND CONGRESS, EMP AND
OUTSIDE ORGANIZATIONS DEVELOPS INTERMEDIATE AND LONG-TERM OBJECTIVES FOR
HAZARDOUS WASTE, REGULATORY AND ASSISTANCE PROGRAMS EVALUATES
ACCOMPLTSHMENTS OF RCRA PROGRAMS AND DIRECTS DEVELOPMENT OF RESOURCE,
STAFFING AND PROGRAM STRATEGIES TO ASSURE ACCOMPLISHMENT OF GOALS
COORDINATES RCRA PROGRAMS AND OBJECTIVES ITH THOSE OF OTHER PARTS OF EPA
ADAA FOR SOLID WASTE: GARY M. DIETRICH SHARES IN PROVIDING
LEADERSHIP AND OVERSIGHT TO OFFICE PROGRAMS DIRECTS OSW'S COORDINATION
WITH ORD AND DEVELOPMENT OF RESEARCH NEEDS FOR RCRA REQUIRING ORD
ASSISTANCE ADVISES DAA ON OBJECTIVES AND GOALS FOR OSW'S PROGRAMS,
STRATEGIES FOR ACHIEVING GOALS AND ORGANIZATIONAL, RESOURCE AND ACTIVITY
REQUIREMENTS COOPERATES FULLY WITH DAA IN MANAGING AND EVALUATING RCRA
PROGRAMS OF OSW
DIRECTOR, MANAGEMENT INFORMATION STAFF: EILEEN CLAUSSEN ADVISES DAA
AND ADAA ON MANAGEMENT APPROACHES AND COORDINATION FOR OSW ACTIVITIES
DEVELOPS STRATEGIES FOR FUNDING, STAFFING AND ORGANIZATION OF OSW
ASSISTS DAA AND ADAA DEVELOP OVERALL POLICY AND DIRECTION FOR RCRA
PROGRAMS COORDINATES PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT AND EVALUATION ACTIVITIES WITH
OTHER PARTS OF OWWM AND OPM DIRECTS A PUBLIC PARTICIPATION, EDUCATION
AND INFORMATION PROGRAM TO SUPPORT RCRA ACTIVITIES AND OBJECTIVES OF OSW
PROGRAMS
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 126 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105283
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
DIRECTOR, HAZARDOUS & INDUSTRIAL WASTE DIVISION: JOHN LEHMAN DIRECTS
DEVELOPMENT OF A HAZARDOUS WASTE CHARACTERIZATION, LISTING, SAMPLING AND
TESTING PROGRAM MANAGES THE DEVELOPMENT OF REGULATIONS AND GUIDANCE
GOVERNING THE STORAGE, TREATMENT, RECOVERY, FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND
ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS FOR HAZARDOUS ASTE FACILITIES PLANS AND
MANAGES TECHNICAL, ENVIRONMENTAL, ECONOMIC AND NATIONAL POLICY
ASSESSMENT DIRECTS SPECIAL WASTE STUDIES (S. 8002)
DIRECTOR, LAND DISPOSAL DIVISION: ALBERT A. PETER, JR. PLANS AND
COORDINATES PROGRAM TO CONTROL LAND DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS ASTES DIRECTS
DEVELOPMENT OF REGULATIONS AND GUIDELINES RELATIVE TO LAND DISPOSAL
METHODS FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE LAND DISPOSAL TECHNOLOGIES MANAGES
DEVELOPMENT OF POLICIES AND GUIDANCE FOR GROUND/SURFACE WATER MONITORING
AND PROTECTION
DIRECTOR, STATE PROGRAMS & RESOURCE RECOVERY DIVISION: JOHN SKINNER
MANAGES PROGRAM FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS DEVELOPS
GUIDANCE FOR FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE PROGRAMS AND STATE PLANS DIRECTS
PROGRAM TO DEVELOP REGS AND SYSTEMS TO IMPLEMENT HAZARDOUS ASTE CONTROL
PROGRAM, SUCH AS PERMIT, MANIFEST, ADP, NOTIFICATION, AND REPORTING
SYSTEMS PROVIDES LIAISON ITH REGIONS, STATES AND LOCAL GOVEFNMENTS TO
ENCOURAGE THEIR PARTICIPATION IN SUBTITLE C PROGRAM
DEP. DIR. STATE PROGRAMS & RESOURCE RECOVERY DIVISION: BRUCE WEDDLE
PARTICIPATES WITH DIVISION DIRECTOR IN PLANNING AND DIRECTING EFFECTIVE
IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAMS FOR RCRA SUBTITLE C ADVISES, DIVISION DIRECTOR
ON NE OR STRONGER APPROACHES TO RCRA PROGRAMS FOR FEDERAL-STATE
COOPERATION WORKS FULLY WITH DIVISION DIRECTOR TO ASSURE RCRA
IMPLEMENTATION PROGRAMS ARE CONSISTENT WITH OTHER OSW REGULATORY
ACTIVITIES AND OTHER EPA OUTREACH PROGRAMS
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 127 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105284
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
DEP. DIR. HAZARDOUS & INDUSTRIAL WASTE DIVISION: FRED A. LINDSEY
SHARES RESPONSIBILITY WITH DIVISION DIRECTOR FOR CONCEPTUALIZING,
OVERSEEING, REVIEWING AND COORDINATING ANALYTICAL AND REGULATORY
DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES FOR HAZARDOUS ASTE
ASSISTS DIVISION DIRECTOR EXCHANGE INFORMATION WITH AFFECTED
INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATIONS, SOLICIT INFO AND POINTS OF VIEW FROM THESE
SECTORS, AND JUSTIFY POLICY AND TECHNICAL DIRECTIONS FOR S. 3001 AND
3004 PROGRAMS
ADVISES DIVISION DIRECTOR ON TECHNICAL PROBLEMS AND ISSUES ASSOCIATED
WITH DEVELOPMENT OF REGULATIONS AND GUIDANCE FOR CONTROL OF HAZARDOUS
PROBLEMS AND ISSUES, SHARES ITH DIVISION DIRECTOR IN RESOLUTION OF SUCH
BRANCH LEVEL
AS CHIEF, WASTE CHARACTERIZATION BRANCH, ALAN CORSON PROVIDES
DAY-TO-DAY MANAGEMENT FOR DEVELOPMENT OF CRITERIA FOR AND LISTS AND
CHARACTERISTICS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, AND APPROPRIATE WASTE SAMPLING AND
TESTING METHODS
AS CHIEF, TECHNOLOGY BRANCH, STEVEN LINGLE DIRECTS PROGRAMS TO ASSESS
TECHNOLOGIES AND PRACTICES FOR STORAGE, TREATMENT, INCINERATION AND
RECOVERY OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND DEVELOP APPROPRIATE REGULATIONS AND
GUIDANCE
AS CHIEF, ECONOMICS AND POLICY ANALYSIS BRANCH, GEORGE GARLAND
OVERSEES PREPARATION OF ECONOMIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENTS OF
SUBTITLE C PROGRAMS AND PREPARATION OF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATIONS ON
NATIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT POLICY ISSUES, E.G., SITING
AS CHIEF, HAZARDOUS WASTE IMPLEMENTATION BRANCH, WILLIAM SANJOUR
PROVIDES DAILY MANAGEMENT TO DEVELOPMENT OF REGULATIONS, GUIDANCE AND
ADMINISTRATIVE SYSTEMS TO IMPLEMENT A NATIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTE
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM, INCLUDING PERMIT, NOTIFICATION, ADP, MANIFEST AND
RECORDKEEPING/REPORTING
AS CHIEF, STATE PROGRAM BRANCH, TRUETT DEGEARE DIRECTS PROGRAMS AND
GUIDANCE FOR STATES' PARTICIPATION IN RCRA SUBTITLE C PROGRAM, SUCH AS
STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE GRANTS, DEFINITION OF EQUIVALENCY AND
AUTHORIZATION NEEDS, AND INTEGRATION OF S. 3005-6 REGULATIONS WITH
OTHER EPA PROGRAMS
THE CHIEF, ASSESSMENT PRANCH (VACANT) DIRECTS DEVELOPMENT OF POLICY
FOR GROUNDATER PROTECTION AND MONITORING AND ASSURES THEIR REFLECTION IN
SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS
THE CHIEF, DISPOSAL BRANCH (VACANT) OVERSEES DEVELOPMENT OF S. 3004
REGULATIONS, AND IMPLEMENTING GUIDANCE, TO CONTROL LAND
DISPOSAL/APPLICATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND ASSESSES TECHNOLOGIES FOR
LAND DISPOSAL
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 128 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105285
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
2A). EPA HAS ESTABLISHED A PERMANENT ORGANIZATIONAL UNIT, THE
HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE CONTROL BRANCH, UNDER THE OIL AND SPECIAL MATERIALS
CONTROL DIVISION OF THE OFFICE OF WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT. THE
FUNCTIONS OF THIS BRANCH WILL BE TO DEVELOP EMERGENCY AND REMEDIAL
RESPONSES FOR DEALING WITH HAZARDOUS ASTE SITES AND TO WORK WITH
REGIONAL AND HEADQUARTERS UNITS IN DEVELOPING METHODOLOGIES FOR THE
DISCOVERY AND PRIORITIZATION OF THESE SITES.
THE NATIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCE HAS A PROJECTED
LIFE EXPECTANCY OF APPROXIMATELY 18 MONTHS. AT THE END OF THAT PERIOD
IT WILL FORM THE NUCLEUS OF A NEW PERMANENT ORGANIZATION OR BE
INCORPORATED INTO AN EXISTING ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE. AS PRESENTLY
FORMULATED, THE TASK FORCE HAS THREE BASIC FUNCTIONS: 1) TO ESTABLISH A
NATIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM, WHICH WILL TRACK SITES
FROM THE POINT OF INITIAL IDENTIFICATION THROUGH SITE INVESTIGATION,
ACTION DETERMINATION, AND REMEDIAL OR ENFORCEMENT STAGES; 2) TO ORK
WITH THE REGIONS AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO DEVELOP HAZARDOUS
WASTE ENFORCEMENT CASES AT THE REGIONAL LEVEL; AND 3) TO MANAGE AT THE
NATIONAL LEVEL A LIMITED NUMBER OF CASES INVOLVING PARTICULARLY
SIGNIFICANT LEGAL ISSUES AND PRECEDENTS.
B). IN THE REORGANIZATION PLAN, THE PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY FOR
FINDING AND ASSESSING SITES IS ASSIGNED TO THE REGIONS. THE REGIONS
WILL BE ASSISTED BY HEADQUARTERS WHICH WILL PROVIDE THEM WITH A LIMITED
NUMBER OF INDIVIDUAL CASE OR SITE REFERRALS, ASSIST THEM IN THE
DEVELOPMENT OF METHODOLOGIES TO SCREEN EXISTING DATA SOURCES TO IDENTIFY
AND PRIORITIZE SITES, AND MAKE AVAILABLE THE DATA FROM THE NATIONAL SITE
TRACKING AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEM.
C). THE TRACK RECORD OF THE REGIONS HAS VARIED FROM REGION TO REGION
DEPENDING ON AVAILABLE RESOURCES. REGIONS ARE PEING PROVIDED ITH
ADDITIONAL CONTRACT RESOURCES TO HELP THEM CONDUCT ON-SITE INSPECTIONS
AND ANALYZE THE SAMPLES TAKEN. ROGHLY $10,000,000 WILL BE SPENT TO
PROVIDE CONTRACTOR SITE-INSPECTION PERSONNEL IN EACH REGION. AN
ADDITIONAL $7,000,000 ILL BE SPENT TO HELP ANALYZE THE COMPLEX SAMPLES
REQUIRED BY THIS EFFORT. BOTH OF THESE SETS OF CONTRACTS WILL BE
OPERATIONAL BY JANUARY 1980. THESE RESOURCE ADDITIONS, COMPLEMENTED BY
ON-SITE ASSISTANCE FROM OWNM, THE HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT TASK
FORCE, AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE WILL HELP THE REGIONS DISCHARGE
THIS RESPONSIBILITY.
D). THE NEW HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE TRACKING SYSTEM WILL REQUIRE
REGIONS TO REPORT ROUTINELY ON ALL SITES BROUGHT TO THEIR ATTENTION AS
POTENTIAL HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. THIS COMPUTER-ASSISTED SYSTEM WILL
PROVIDE AN ANALYTICAL AND DECISTON-MAKING FRAMEWORK AND WILL DOCUMENT
THE STATUS OF EACH SITE.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 129 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105286
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
THIS INFORMATION WILL BE REGULARLY REPORTED TO HEADQUARTERS AND WILL
BE USED BOTH AS A TOOL TO MANAGE REGIONAL REMEDIAL AND ENFORCEMENT
ACTIONS AND AS A MECHANISM TO ESTABLISH AGENCY REMEDIAL AND ENFORCEMENT
POLICY.
E). THE SITE TRACKING SYSTEM DEVELOPED AS PART OF THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE SYSTEM DOES REQUIRE THAT THE REGIONS
MAINTAIN A LOG.
F). EPA IS CURRENTLY ASSESSING RESOURCE-EFFICIENT MECHANISMS TO
LOCATE AND PRIORITIZE POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. THIS EFFORT
INCLUDES REVIEW OF RECORDS ALREADY AVAILABLE TO EPA AND THE DEVELOPMENT
OF STATE, CONTRACTOR, AND CITIZEN ASSISTED PROGRAMS TO DEVELOP SITE
INFORMATION.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 130 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105287
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
3. EPA, AND PARTICULARLY THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE, HAS
STUDIED THE PROPOSAL FOR A SEPARATE ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID
WASTE OVER A LONG PERIOD OF TIME. EPA FEELS THAT AT PRESENT SUCH A
COURSE WOULD NOT BE CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICY OF INTEGRATING VARIOUS
PARTS OF THE AGENCY THROUGH CONSOLIDATED PERMITTING, CONSOLIDATED
GRANTS, AND REGULATORY REFORM POLICY. THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE
IS OVERSEEING AND COORDINATING A BALANCED APPROACH BETWEEN WASTE
MANAGEMENT ON LAND AND ON WATER. IF, AFTER EVALUATION OF ANY CONFLICTS
OVER THE NEXT YEAR, THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE CONCLUDES A
SEPARATE OFFICE FOR SOLID WASTE WOULD PE ADVISABLE, SUCH A
RECOMMENDATION WILL BE MADE TO THE ADMINISTRATOR.
8. THE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE SYSTEM FOCUSES
ON ALL MEDIA IN AN EFFORT TO DETERMINE WHERE POTENTIAL HAZARDS EXIST.
RATHER THAN LOOKING AT A PARTICULAR MEDIUM, THE EFFORT HAS ADDRESSED
WHETHER A GIVEN SITE IS POSING A HEALTH OR ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARD AND
WHICH LEGISLATIVE AUTHORITIES MIGHT BEST BE APPLIED FOR A REMEDY.
11. SPECIAL ASTES ARE NOT EXEMPT FROM THE SCOPE OF RCRA REGULATIONS.
EPA IS APPLYING A LIMITED SET OF STANDARDS TO THOSE WASTES UNTIL MORE
INFORMATION IS GATHERED SO THAT APPROPRIATE REGULATIONS CAN BE
PROMULGATED FOR SPECIAL WASTES. THE PRESENT LIST OF SPECIAL WASTE, SET
FORTH IN THE PROPOSED GUIDELINES AND REGULATIONS OF DEC. 18, 1978,
CONSISTS OF CEMENT KILN DUST, UTILITY WASTE (FLY ASH, BOTTOM ASH,
SCRUBBER SLUDGE), PHOSPHATE MINING, BENEFICIATION AND PROCESSING WASTES,
URANIUM MINING AND OTHER MINING WASTES, AND GAS AND OIL DRILLING MUDS
AND OIL PRODUCTION BRINES.
IN THE COMMENTS ON THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER
OF REQUESTS TO HAVE OTHER WASTE STREAMS IDENTIFIED AS SPECIAL WASTES.
THESE REQUESTS WILL BE ADDRESSED IN THE FINAL REGULATIONS.
14. A COPY OF THE LIST OF SITES RELEASED ON JUNE 1, 1979, IS
ATTACHED. THIS LIST HAS BECOME OUTDATED AND IS UNDER REVISION. AS OF
OCTOBER 31, 1979, THE REGIONAL OFFICES HAVE IDENTIFIED 1536 POTENTIAL
HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES OR PROBLEMS. OF THESE SOME 532 SITES HAVE BEEN
INSPECTED. ELEVEN FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT CASES, AND FIFTY-SEVEN STATE
ENFORCEMENT CASES HAVE BEEN FILED. WITHIN NINETY DAYS, THE LIST OF
SITES WILL BE PLACED ON A COMPUTERIZED SYSTEM, WHICH WILL PROVIDE
DETAILED INFORMATION ON SPECIFIC SITES AS REQUIRED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 131 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105288
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
SEPTEMBER 28:
1A). WHILE STATE LAW MAY VARY, FEDERAL LAW PROVIDES A CONSISTENT
STATUTORY FRAMEWORK. EPA INTENDS TO ACHIEVE CONSISTENCY IN ENFORCEMENT
EFFORTS BY FOSTERING CLOSE COORDINATION BETWEEN REGIONS, HEADQUARTERS,
AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE. ADDITIONALLY, EPA HEADQUARTERS IS
DEVELOPING LEGAL GUIDANCE MATERIALS TO INSURE UNIFORM INTERPRETATION OF
LEGAL SITUATIONS. THE HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCE IS ALREADY
SENDING TEAMS, MADE UP OF A LEGAL AND A TECHNICAL REPRESENTATIVE FROM
THE TASK FORCE AND A REPRESENTATIVE (II THROUGH VI) ONCE A MONTH, AND TO
THE OTHER REGIONS ONCE EVERY SIX TO EIGHT WEEKS. THE PURPOSE OF THESE
MEETINGS IS THE JOINT DEVELOPMENT OF "CASE DEVELOPMENT PLANS" WHERE THE
POTENTIAL FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION EXISTS. THIS SORT OF COOPERATIVE
EFFORT WILL HELP INSURE NEEDED CONSISTENCY.
B). THE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE SYSTEM WILL
ASK THE REGIONS TO CHECK ON THE STATUS OF STATE-INITIATED AND MANAGED
CASES EVERY TWO WEEKS AND REPORT THE STATUS OF THESE CASES IN THE SITE
TRACKING SYTEM. IN THOSE CASES WHERE STATE AUTHORITIES AND RESOURCES
ARE INADEQUATE TO DEVELOP AN APPROPRIATE REMEDY ANY NEEDED FEDERAL
ACTIONS WILL BE UNDERTAKEN AFTER CONSULTATION ITH THE AFFECTED STATE.
C). AS DESCRIBED ABOVE, EPA, THROUGH THE REGIONS, WILL TRACK THE
STATUS OF THESE CASES.
D). THE ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR ENFORCEMENT DOES NOT EXERCISE
LINE CONTROL OVER REGIONAL ENFORCEMENT PERSONNEL, BUT THE COOPERATIVE
MECHANISMS OUTLINED IN ANSWER 1(A) PFOVIDE ASSURANCES THAT THE
ENFORCEMENT EFFORT WILL BE COORDINATED.
E). NO SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS UNIT HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED, BUT EPA IS
WORKING WITH A CONSULTANT TO ASSESS THE AGENCY'S TRAINING,
ORGANIZATIONAL AND STAFFING NEEDS IN THE INVESTIGATIVE AREAS.
2C). IN 1979, $500,000 WAS SPENT ON PUBLIC EDUCATION ON THE NEED FOR
SITING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITIES. THE SAME AMOUNT HAS BEEN ALLOTTED
FOR FY 1980. THERE HAS BEEN A MAJOR CHANGE IN THE AMOUNT OF MONEY
ALLOCATED TO THE ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGE FROM EXISTING SITES. IN 1979
$100,000 WAS ALLOCATED WHILE FOR 1980 THE AMOUNT ALLOCATED INCREASED TO
$18 MILLION.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 132 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105289
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
4. IN FY 1977, THE YEAR IN WHICH THE RESOURCE RECOVERY AND
CONSERVATION ACT WAS PASSED, OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE EVALUUATED ITS USE OF
ALL RESOURCES IN ORDER TO RE-PROGRAM THEM AS NECESSARY TO COMPLY WITH
THE RULEMAKING ACTIVITIES MANDATED BY THE ACT. SOLID WASTE
INTERNATIONAL RETRIEVAL SYSTEM (SWIRS), EPA'S COMPREHENSIVE SYSTEM FOR
RETRIEVING SOLID WASTE INFORMATION FROM THE WORLD TECHNICAL LITERATURE,
WAS COSTING OSW AT LEAST $225,000 PER YEAR FOR CONTRACT SERVICES, PLUS
TWO MAN-YEARS, AND OTHER INDIRECT COSTS. THE SEARCHES BEING CONDUCTED
VARIED BETWEEN 600 PER YEAR TO 1,800. THE PASSAGE OF RCRA DID NOT
STIMULATE A HIGHER ANNUAL USAGE OF SWIRS (SEE FOLLOING CHART), AND,
THEREFORE, THE RESOURCES REQUIRED TO OPERATE SWIRS WERE REPROGRAMMED, AT
LEAST TEMPORARILY.
OSW IS ACTIVELY SEEKING A BORROWER FROM THE TECHNICAL COMMUNITY TO
OPERATE SWIRS, AND THIS IS STILL A POSSIBILITY. MUCH OF THE KEY
INFORMATION IN SWIRS HAS BEEN MADE AVAILABLE BY OSW IN A SERIES OF
ABSTRACT BULLETINS COVERING THE ENTIRE PERIOD OF SWIRS OPERATION FROM
1964 THROUGH OCTOBER 1978.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 133 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105290
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
SOLID WASTE INFORMATION RETRIEVAL SERVICE
GRAPH OMITTED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 134 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105291
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
7. A MEETING HAS BEEN SCHEDULED FOR DECEMBER 10, 1979, WITH THE KEY
ENVIRONMENTAL REPRESENTATIVES OF THE FEDERAL AGENCIES MOST LIKELY TO
DEAL WITH HAZARDOUS WASTES (E.G. THE DEFENSE AGENCIES, GSA). AT THAT
MEETING WE WILL EMPHASIZE THE IMPORTANCE OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEM
AND POINT OUT THE LIKELIHOOD OF STATE ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS IF FEDERAL
AGENCIES FAIL TO RESPOND TO THIS PROBLEM.
IN INSTANCES WHERE FEDERAL AGENCIES FAIL TO MEET THEIR
RESPONSIBILITIES IN THIS AREA, EPA WILL UTILIZE THE MEDIATION AND ACTION
ACTIVITIES AVAILABLE UNDER OMB CIRCULAR A-106.
8. IT IS CERTAINLY NOT EPA'S POLICY OR INTENT TO REQUIRE STATES TO
DUPLICATE RCRA OR FEDERAL REGULATIONS. IT IS, HOWEVER, EPA'S
RESPONSIBILITY TO ALERT THE STATES TO THE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS OF RCRA'S
PROVISIONS, AND TO PROVIDE GUIDANCE AS TO THE INTERPRETATION OF TERMS
SUCH AS "EQUIVALENCE" AND "CONSISTENT" FOUND IN RCRA SECTION 3006 AND TO
RECOMMEND HOW THESE REQUIREMENTS CAN BEST OR MOST EASILY BE ACHIEVED.
IN ITS PROPOSED CONSOLIDATED PERMIT REGULATIONS ISSUED ON JUNE 14,
1979, EPA PROPOSED THAT ENFORCEMENT REMEDIES AND PENALTY PROVISIONS IN
STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE LEGISLATION BE THE SAME AS THOSE OF RCRA. THE
INTENT OF THE PROPOSALS WAS TO SOLICIT STATES' REACTIONS AND TO
ENCOURAGE INFORMATION ON STATE ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITIES AND ON CHANGES
SUCH AS REQUIREMENT WOULD FORCE.
THE REGULATIONS WILL BE REVISED AS WARRANTED BY THE COMMENTS AND
INFORMATION EPA RECEIVES.
IN GENERAL, RCRA DOES NOT ALLOW STATES TO IMPOSE PROGRAM REQURFMENTS
LESS STRINGENT THAN THOSE UNDER SUBTITLE C AND ADHERENCE TO RCRA'S
SECTION 3006 MAY BE ACCOMPLISHED MOST EASILY BY ADOPTING EPA'S
REGULATIONS. HOEVER, SUCH AN ADOPTION IS NOT A REQUIREMENT FOR
AUTHORIZATION; THIS IS STRESSED IN THE JUNE 14, 1979, REGULATORY
PROPOSAL.
9. THE COMMENTS EPA HAS RECEIVED TO DATE CONCERNING THE ISSUE OF
EVALUATING THE EQUIVALENCY OF STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS TO THAT OF
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT RANGE FROM ADVOCATING TOTAL DISCRETION FOR THE
EPA REGIONAL ADMINISTRATOR TO RECOMMENDING AGAINST ALLOWING ANY
DEVIATION FROM FEDERAL REGULATIONS. ASSESSMENT OF EQUIVALENCY IS AN
ISSUE UNDERGOING SUBSTANTIAL DELIBERATION WITH EPA IN LIGHT OF THE
PUBLIC COMMENTS. A PLAN WILL BE DEVELOPED WHEN THIS ANALYSIS IS
COMPLETED.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 135 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105292
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
DEC. 11, 1979
HONORABLE CARL LEVIN CHAIRMAN SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20510
THE ENCLOSED MATERIAL COMPLETES OUR ANSWER TO THOSE QUESTIONS RAISED
IN YOUR LETTER OF SEPTEMBER 24, 1979. I HOPE THAT YOU WILL FIND THE
INFORMATION HELPFUL. I REGRET THAT WE WERE NOT ABLE TO MAKE A FULL
REPLY IN OUR LETTER OF NOVEMBER 20, 1979.
BARPARA BLUM DEPTY ADMINISTRATOR ENCLOSURE
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 136 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105293
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
ADDITIONAL RESPONSES TO SEPTEMBER 24 LETTER
4. WE ARE IN THE PROCESS OF PREPARING A BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL FOR FY
1980, PART OF WHICH WILL BE DEVOTED TO FURTHERING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF
THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROVISIONS OF RCRA. ADDITIONAL STAFFING AND FUNDING
OULD BE USED TO TRACK THE PROGRESS OF RCRA IMPLEMENTATION AT THE STATE
AND REGIONAL LEVELS, TO PREPARE CASE STUDIES AND GUIDANCE FOR THE STATES
IN CARRYING OUT THEIR PROGRAMS, AND TO RESPOND TO PROBLEMS AS THEY
DEVELOP IN THE IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS.
5. IN THE BUDGET SUPPLEMENTAL FOR FY 1980 DISCUSSED ABOVE, PLANS ARE
BEING CONSIDERED FOR FUNDING REGIONAL OFFICE PERMITTING AND
IMPLEMENTATION ACTIVITIES FOR THOSE STATES WHICH ILL NOT HAVE THEIR OWN
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS.
9. IMMEDIATELY UPON RECEIPT OF SENATOR HATFIELDS, NOVEMBER 3, 1977
LETTER TO ADMINISTRATOR COSTLE CONCERNING THE LAND DISPOSAL OF DIOXINS,
EPA'S OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE (OS) TOOK STEPS TO LOOK INTO THE MATTER.
WITHIN TWENTY CALENDAR DAYS, BY NOVEMBER 23, 1977, THE OSW HAD MADE A
CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENT WITH A QUALIFIED CONSULTANT HO, WITHIN THAT
TIME-FRAME, COMPLETED A SURVEY THAT IDENTIFIED SEVERAL POTENTIAL SOURCES
(PLANTS) OF DIOXINS, ALL OF HICH WERE THOUGHT, AT THAT TIME, TO BE
ACTIVE.
WITHIN THE NEXT FIVE MONTHS, THE OSW (A) MADE ARRANGEMENTS FOR
IDENTIFICATION OF APPROPRIATE ANALYTICAL PROCEDURES AND SAMPLING
LOCATIONS; AND, (B) INITIATED A PROCESS OF FURTHER
RESEARCH/INVESTIGATION, PRIORITIZATION AND ELIMINATION OF SOURCES
PREVIOUSLY IDENTIFIED (IN THE SURVEY AND THE ENCLOSURES TO SENATOR
HATFIELD'S LETTER).
WITH RESPECT TO (B), THE OSW LEARNED THAT THE CHEMICAL PLANTS
ORIGINALLY THOUGHT TO BE PRODUCERS OF DIOXIN-CONTAINING PRODUCTS (TCP),
IN ACTUALITY WERE NOT PRODUCERS OF TCP AND, THUS, NOT TCP SOURCES OF
DIOXINS. IT WAS THEN THAT TRANSVAAL, IDENTIFIED BY THE CONSULTANTS AS A
TCP PRODUCER IN JACKSONVILLE, ARKANSAS, WAS SELECTED BY THE OSW AS A
POTENTIAL SOURCE OF DIOXIN. MR. PLEHN'S MEMORANDUM OF MAY 4, 1977 WAS
THEN PREPARED AND SENT TO THE EPA REGION VI ADMINISTRATOR.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 137 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105294
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
I HOPE THE ABOVE INFORMATION IS RESPONSIVE TO YOUR QUESTIONS AND
BETTER EXPLAINS EPA'S CONCERN AND ACTIVITIES WITH RESPECT TO DIOXINS
BETWEEN THE TIME OF SENATOR HATFIELD'S LETTER AND THE ISSUANCE OF THE
PARTICULAR MEMORANDUM FROM MR. PLEHN TO WHICH YOU HAVE REFEFRED.
YOU MAY ALSO BE INTERESTED IN KNOWING THAT AN IMPORTANT RESULT OF THE
SENATOR'S LETTER AND EPA'S RESPONSE TO IT HAS BEEN THAT A CHLORINATED
DIOXIN WORK GROUP HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED WITHIN EPA TO COORDINATE THE
INVOLVEMENT OF EPA'S TECHNICAL AND REGULATORY ACTIVITIES.
13. WE HAVE NO RELIABLE ESTIMATES OF FINANCIALLY VIABLE ONERS BEYOND
THOSE CONTAINED IN THE EPA CONTRACT STUDY ENTITLED "PRELIMINARY
ASSESSMENT OF CLEAN-UP COSTS FOR NATIONAL HAZARDOUS ASTE PROBLEMS," FROM
WHICH YOUR FIGURE OF 32,000 TO 50,000 SITES WAS DERIVED. MANY OF THOSE
SITES HAVE NOT ACTUALLY BEEN LOCATED, AND THEREFORE DETERMINING
OWNERSHIP OR RESPONSIBILITY IS NOT YET POSSIBLE.
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 138 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105295
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
DEC. 11, 1979
HONORABLE CARL LEVIN CHAIRMAN SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20510
THIS IS IN RESPONSE TO YOUR LETTER OF OCTOBER 24, 1979, IN WHICH YOU
REQUESTED ANSWERS TO TWO QUESTIONS INVOLVING IMPLEMENTATION OF THE
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT REGULATIONS UNDER THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT OF 1976 (RCRA). I APOLOGIZE FOR THE DELAY IN
RESPONDING TO YOUR INQUIRIES.
REFERRING TO YOUR FIRST QUESTION CONCERNING INFORMATION TO BE
SUBMITTED BY THE MITRE CORPORATION, THE REPORTS FROM MITRE WILL BE
PLACED IN THE RCRA PUBLIC DOCKET. BEFORE ANY REGULATIONS WHICH MAKE USE
OF THAT DATA ARE PROMULGATED, THERE WILL BE A PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD.
ON THE SECOND QUESTION ABOUT THE JUNE 15, 1978 MEETING, I DISCUSSED
THIS MATTER IN A PHONE CONVERSATION ITH STEVE KLITZMAN OF YOUR STAFF ON
JULY 27, 1979. AS I SAID AT THAT TIME, I HAVE NO RECOLLECTION OF
REFERRING, IN THAT MEETING, TO EITHER PRESIDENT CARTER'S DIRECTIVE TO
REDUCE THE FEDERAL BUDGET TO FIGHT INFLATION OR TO THE STATE "TAX
REVOLT" AS REASONS FOR REVIEWING THE RCRA HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATIONS.
MY NOTES FROM THE JUNE 15 MEETING CONTAIN NO SUCH REFERENCES. FORMER
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT THOMAS JORLING
TESTIFIED AT YOUR AUGUST 1 HEARING THAT HE CONVEYED NO SUCH REASONS TO
ME.
I HOPE THESE RESPONSES WILL BE HELPFUL TO YOUR INVESTIGATION OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA.
JOHN P. LEHMAN
TESTIMONY OF BLUM B ACCOMPANIED BY JORLING T C AND MILLER J G
STATEMENT OF BLUM B 790801
OVERSIGHT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION
AND RECOVERY ACT _90801
PART 139 OF 140
LEVIN SENATOR
BLUM B DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR
JORLING T C ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR
MILLER J G DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR CHAIRMAN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE EPA ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT EPA
105296
HEARING
REPORT STUDY
SENATE
ACT HEARINGS REPORT STUDY
ATTACHMENT TO 08104814 PARENT DOCUMENT.
(SUBSEQUENT TO THE HEARING, THE FOLLOWING LETTER TO SENATOR LEVIN
FROM MR. KAUFMAN WAS RECEIVED FOR THE RECORD:)
HONORABLE CARL LEVIN
PURSUANT TO YOUR REQUEST OF AUGUST 1, 1979 RE FLESHING OUT MY
TESTIMONY LAST JULY BEFORE YOUR SUBCOMMITTEE, I HAVE SURVEYED EPA'S
DAMAGE ASSESSMENT FILES AND HAVE CATEGORIZED THE CASES THEREIN INTO
THREE GROUPS: ACTIVE, INACTIVE, AND ABANDONED. I DEFINED AS ABANDONED
THOSE SITES FOR WHICH THERE ARE NO LIABLE "DEEP POCKETS". I SUSPECT
THAT THROUGH VIGOROUS ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS, EPA COULD FIND LIABLE PARTIES
BY "PIERCING THE VEIL" OF THE COMPANIES OWNING AT LEAST ONE OF THE FOUR
ABANDONED SITES IDENTIFIED IN THE SURVEY. I, THEREFORE ALSO REFER TO
THE THIRD GROUP OF SITES AS POTENTIALLY ABANDONED RATHER THAN AS
ABANDONED.
BASED ON THE SURVEY, I ESTIMATE THAT 70% OF THE CASES INVOLVE ACTIVE
SITES, 28% INVOLVE INACTIVE SITES, AND 2% INVOLVE POTENTIALLY ABANDONED
SITES. THIS ESTIMATE WAS DERIVED FROM AN EXAMINATION OF THE CASES FROM
EPA REGION V AND VI, WHICH SHOWED THAT THERE WERE SEVENTY-FIVE ACTIVE
SITES, THIRTY-THREE INACTIVE SITES, AND ONE ABANDONED SITE IN REGION V,
AND THIRTY-EIGHT ACTIVE SITES ,TWELVE INACTIVE SITES, AND THREE
POTENTIALLY ABANDONED SITES IN REGION VI.
I HOPE THAT THIS INFORMATION WILL HELP THE SUBCOMMITTEE IN ITS REVIEW
OF EPA'S EFFORTS TO DATE IN PROTECTING THE PUBLIC FROM THE DANGERS
ASSOCIATED ITH HAZARDOUS WASTE.
HUGH B. KAUFMAN
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 001 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105298
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
TITLE PAGE OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 002 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105299
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
ABRAHAM RIBICOFF, CONNECTICUT, CHAIRMAN HENRY M JACKSON, WASHINGTON
THOMAS F. EAGLETON, MISSOURI LAWTON CHILES, FLORIDA SAM NUNN, GEORGIA
JOHN GLENN, OHIO JIM SASSER, TENNESSEE DAVID PRYOR, ARKANSAS CARL LEVIN,
MICHIGAN CHARLES H. PERCY, ILLINOIS JACOB K. JAVITS, NEW YORK WILLIAM V.
ROTH, JR., DELAWARE TED STEVENS, ALASKA CHARLES MCC. MATHIAS, JR.,
MARYLAND JOHN C. DANFORTH, MISSOURI WILLIAM S. COHEN, MAINE DAVID
DURENBERGER, MINNESOTA
RICHARD A. WEGMAN, CHIEF COUNSEL AND STAFF DIRECTOR PAUL HOFF,
COUNSEL CONSTANCE B. EVANS, MINORITY STAFF DIRECTOR ELIZABETH A. PREAST,
CHIEF CLERK
CARL LEVIN, MICHIGAN, CHAIRMAN DAVID PRYOR, ARKANSAS WILLIAM S.
COHEN, MAINE DAVID DURENBERGER, MINNESOTA
LINDA J. GUSTITUS, CHIEF COUNSEL AND STAFF DIRECTOR RICHARD L.
TALLMAN, STAFF INVESTIGATOR KATHLEEN F. CHAPMAN, CHIEF CLERK FRANCES C.
DE VERGIE, ASSISTANT CHIEF CLERK JAMES ROSEN, RESEARCH ASSISTANT.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 003 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105300
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
DEAR MR. CHAIRMAN: THE ATTACHED REPORT IS THE CULMINATION OF AN
ELEVEN-MONTH SUBCOMMITTTEE INVESTIGATION INTO THE MANAGEMENT OF
HAZARDOUS WASTES IN THIS COUNTRY. THE SUBCOMMITTEE HAS CONCLUDED THAT
AS A RESULT OF THE INADEQUATE HANDLING OF HAZARDOUS WASTES, HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT HAS BECOME THE COUNTRY'S MOST PRESSING ENVIRONMENTAL
CONCERN.
THE SUBCOMMITTE HELD HEARINGS ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT (RCRA) ON
JULY 19 AND AUGUST 1, 1979. SUBTITLE C OF RCRA REQUIRES THE
ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (EPA) TO PROMULGATE
REGULATIONS SETTING STANDARDS FOR THE CONTROL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES FROM
THEIR POINT OF GENERATION TO THEIR POINT OF ULTIMATE DISPOSAL. CONGRESS
FULLY INTENDED THAT THE CONTROL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES BE PRIMARILY A STATE
RESPONSIBILITY, AND AS SUCH, IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS
WILL OCCUR FOF THE MOST PART THROUGH AUTHORIZED STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE
MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS.
IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA HAS BEEN DELAYED FOR AN EXTRAORDINARY PERIOD
OF TIME DUE TO EPA'S FAILURE TO PROMULGATE SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS BY THE
STATUTORY DEADLINES. IN FACT, REGULATIONS TO IDENTIFY WASTES AS
"HAZARDOUS" HAVE YET TO BE PROMULGATED -- A DELAY OF TWO YEARS SINCE THE
STATUTORY DEADLINE.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE HAS EXPRESSED ITS CONCERNS RELATIVE TO THIS
EXTRAORDINARY DELAY, ITS ADVERSE EFFECTS ON HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATION
AND THE CONTENT OF PROPOSED REGULATIONS IDENTIFYING WASTES AS HAZARDOUS.
IN ADDITION, THE SUBCOMMITTEE IS VERY CONCERNED OVER THE FAILURE OF
BOTH THE STATE AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS TO RESPOND ADEQUATELY TO
ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS CAUSED BY THE IMPROPER HANDLING OF HAZARDOUS
WASTES. FINALLY, THE SUBCOMMITTEE HAS ANALYZED EPA'S ORGANIZATIONAL
APPROACH TO HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATION, AND HAS CONCLUDED THAT EPA'S
CURRENT MANAGEMENT OF HAZARDOUS AND SOLID WASTE PROGRAMS REQUIRES
ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE. A LEGISLATIVE RESPONSE TO THE NEED FOR SUCH
RESTRUCTURING IS IMPERATIVE.
THE RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE AS EXPRESSED IN THE REPORT
INCLUDE THE NEED FOR EPA TO HASTEN PROMULGATION OF RCRA SUBTITLE C
REGULATIONS, TO PROMULGATE ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS FOR THE
INDENTIFICATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND TO IMPROVE ITS PERFORMANCE IN
RESPONDING TO ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 004 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105301
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO TAKE THIS OPPORTUNITY TO COMMEND THE STAFF OF
THE SUBCOMMITTEE FOR THEIR DEDICATION AND PERSEVERANCE THROUGHOUT THIS
LENGTHY INVESTIGATION, INCLUDING STEVE KLITZMAN, STAFF DIRECTOR, RICHARD
TALLMAN, INVESTIGATOR, JIM ROSEN, RESEARCHER, KATHLEEN CHAPMAN, CHIEF
CLERK AND FRANCES DE VERGIE, ASSISTANT CHIEF CLERK; STEVE MICHAELS,
MINORITY PROFESSIONAL STAFF.
SINCERELY.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 005 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105302
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
TABLE OF CONTENTS OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 006 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105303
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
YEARS OF INADEQUATE HANDLING AND DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICAL
WASTES HAVE PUSHED HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT TO THE FOREFRONT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION CONCERNS FACING THIS NATION OVER THE LAST
DECADE. TO DATE, GOVERNMENT REGULATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, FROM
GENERATORS TO DISPOSERS, HAS BEEN VIRTUALLY NON-EXISTENT.
TOXIC AND OTHER ORGANIC AND INORGANIC HCEMICAL WASTES ARE ONLY
BEGINNING TO PLAGUE THIS COUNTRY. SUCH WASTES HAVE BEEN SHOWN TO ENTER
THE FOOD CHAIN AND THE NATION'S MOST ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF DRINKING WATER,
THE GROUNDWATER, BECAUSE WASTES IMPROPERLY DISPOSED OF IN LANDFILLS OR
OTHER SURFACE IMPOUNDMENTS ARE LEACHING OFFSITE AND ARE THREATENING THE
ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC HEALTH.
A VISIBLE AND POIGNANT EXAMPLE OF THE POTENTIAL CONSEQUENCES OF THE
FAILURE OF GOVERNMENT TO ADEQUATELY REGULATE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
IS PROVIDED BY LOVE CANAL, WHERE 239 FAMILIES WERE FORCED TO EVACUATE
THEIR HOMES WHEN CHEMICAL WASTES DISPOSED OF BY THE HOOKER CHEMCIALS AND
PLASTICS CORPORATION BEGAN SEEPING INTO THEIR YARDS AND BASEMENTS.
PERHAPS THE MOST APPALLING FACT OF ALL THIS: HAD THE PROPER
GOVERNMENT REGULATION BEEN IN FORCE AT THE TIME, (1950S) IT WOULD HAVE
COST HOOKER CHEMICAL A MAXIMUM OF $4 MILLION -- THAT'S IN CURRENT 1979
DOLLARS -- TO FUND, CONSTRUCT AND SEAL A SECURE, HAZARDOUS WASTE
FACILITY. INSTEAD, THE PUBLIC HAS ALREADY SPENT $23 MILLION - AND THE
ULTIMATE COST TO FORMER LOVE CANAL RESIDENTS AND TO THE COMPANY IS
BEYOND CREDIBLE CALCULATION.
FEBRUARY 7, 1979.
WE ARE ONLY BEGINNING TO DISCOVER THE DIMENSIONS OF THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE DISPOSAL PROBLEM. A CONTRACT STUDY PERFORMED FOR THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (EPA) HAS ESTIMATED THAT 30,000 TO
50,000 SITES IN THE UNITED STATES COULD CONTAIN SOME DEGREE OF HAZARDOUS
WASTE. OF THESE, THE STUDY INDICATES, 1,200 TO 2,000 MAY POSE AN
"IMMINENT HAZARD" TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT. OF OVER 100
BILLION POUNDS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATED ANNUALLY, THE EPA MAINTAINS
AS MUCH AS 90 PERCENT ARE BEING DISPOSED OF IN NON-SECURE PONDS,
LANDFILLS AND LAGOONS, AND THAT 10 PERCENT IS BEING INCINERATED WITHOUT
PROPER CONTROLS. FURTHER, 80 PERCENT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IS DISPOSED OF
ON-SITE (ON COMPANY PROPERTY).
THE CHEMICAL INDUSTRY IS THE LARGEST PRODUCER OF HAZARDOUS WASTE,
ACCOUNTING FOR NEALY 50 PERCENT OF THE ESTIMATED 34.5 MILLION METRIC
TONS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE PRODUCED BY 17 INDUSTRIES EPA STUDIED IN 1977.
COSTS TO TOTALLY ALLEVIATE THE ENVIRONMENTAL AND PUBLIC HEALTH THREAT
POSED BY CURRENT HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SITES ARE ESTIMATED TO BE IN
THE RANGE OF 26.2 TO 44.1 BILLION DOLLARS. TO PROVIDE EMERGENCY
RESPONSE AND SITE CLEANUP FOR THE SO-CALLED "TICKING TIME BOMBS," SUCH
AS LOVE CANAL, ALONE WOULD COST FROM 3.6 TO 6.1 BILLION DOLLARS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 007 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105304
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/1/ SEE APPENDIX I FOR A SUMMARY OF RCRA SUBTITLE C PROSISIONS.
TO PLACE THESE COSTS IN PROPER PERSPECTIVE, THE COST TO INDUSTRY TO
COMPLY WITH THE PROPSED REGUALTIONS UNDER THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND
RECOVERY ACT, OR RCRA (ENACTED IN 1976 TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE REGULATION OF
SOLID AND HAZARDOUS WASTES) WILL BE IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD OF $750 TO $900
MILLION PER YEAR.
CASES OTHER THAN LOVE CANAL WHICH DEMONSTRATED TO THIS SUBCOMMITTEE
THE WIDESPREAD NATURE OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEM INCLUDED:
(1) JACKSONVILLE, ARKANSAS, WHERE WASTES FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF
2.4.5-T, A PRINCIPLE COMPONENT OF THE DEFOLIANT AGENT ORANGE HAVE BEEN
DISPOSED OF BY THE VERTAC CORPORATION ON COMPANY PROPERTY, AND HAVE
RESULTED IN THE HIGHEST LEVEL OF TCDD (DIOXIN) EVER RECORDED IN THIS
COUNTRY.
(2) MONTAGUE, MICHIGAN, WHERE THE ON-SITE DISPOSAL BY HOOKER CHEMICAL
OF CHEMICAL WASTES IN THOUSANDS OF 55-GALLON DRUMS RESULTED IN THE
LEACHING OF ORGANIC CONTAMINANTS INTO GORUNDWATER SUPPLIES AND INTO A
NEARBY RECREATIONAL LAKE.
(3) HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN, WHERE A NOT-YET-VERIFIED CONTAMINANT LOCATED
EITHER IN THE AIR, FOOD CHAIN OR THE GROUNDWATER HAS RESULTED IN
INCREASED HEALTH DISORDERS BOTH FOR LIVESTOCK AND HUMAN RESIDENTS.
(4) GRAY, MAINE, WHERE 750 FAMILIES DRANK POLLUTED GROUNDWATER FOR
FOUR YEARS, AS A RESULT OF LEAKS FROM AN INACTIVE SOLVENT AND OIL
PROCESSING FACILITY.
(5) SHAKOPEE, MINNESOTA, WHERE POLLUTION CONTROLS, INC., WHICH
INCINERATED COMBUSTIBLE PAINT SLUDGES, SOLVENTS AND WASTE OILS, IS UNDER
COURT INJUNCTION TO CLEAN UP AND ELIMINATE AN INVENTORY OF 30,000 DRUMS.
WASTES DISPOSED OF AT THESE AND OTHER SITES THAT THE SUBCOMMITTEE HAS
REVIEWED INCLUDE HIGHLY-TOXIC DIOXIN, C.5-6 (HEXACHLOROCYCLOPENTADIENE),
TRICHLOROPHENOL, TRICHLOROETHYLENE, AND OTHER ORGANIC AND INORGANIC
CONTAMINANTS. SUCH WASTES CAN AND DO PRODUCE TOXIC EFFECTS IN HUMANS
AND ANIMALS INCLUDINC POSIONING, CARCINOGENICITY, MUTAGENICITY, AND
TERATOGENICITY (FETUS-DEFORMING QUALTIIES).
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT WAS ENACTED ON OCTOBER 21,
1976 TO PROTECT THE LAND, DRINKING WATER SUPPLIES AND THE FOOD CHAIN
FROM ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION. /1/ SUBTITLE C OF THE ACT ESTABLISHES A
SYSTEM OF REGULATORY CONTROL OVER HAZARDOUS WASTES FORM THE POINT OF
GENERATION OF THESE WASTES TO THE POINT OF ULTIMATE DISPOSAL.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE BEGAN ITS INVESTIGATION INTO HAZARDOUS WASTE
MANAGEMENT AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND
RECOVERY ACT (RCRA) IN THE SPRING OF 1979. FOUR ISSUES IN PARTICULAR
PROMPTED THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S INQUIRY AND PROVIDE A BASIS FOR THE
SUBSTANCE OF THIS REPORT:
(1) THE CONTENT OF PROPOSED REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT SECTION 3001
IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE UNDER THE SUBTITLE C OF
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT (RCRA);
(2) THE CONTINUING FAILURE OF EPA TO PROMULGATE RCRA SUBTITLE C
REGULATIONS ACCORDING TO THE STATUTORY SCHEDULE;
(3) ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS INITIATED BY THE EPA REORGANIZATION,
APPLICABLE STATUTORY AUTHORITY, COMPILATION OF AN ADEQUATE WASTE SITE
INVENTORY, STATE AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS' WILLINGNESS AND ABILITY TO
RESPOND TO ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS AND FEDERAL ASSISTANCE TO STATES FOR
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS: AND.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 008 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105305
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
(4) EPA ORGANIZATION AS RELATED TO IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA.
DURING ITS INVESTIGATION, THE SUBCOMMITTEE MADE NUMBEROUS INQUIRIES
OF CONSUMERS, INDUSTRY OFFICIALS, AGENCY OFFICIALS AND VARIOUS
ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS. THE INVESTIGATION PROMPTED TWO DAYS OF
SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS, WHICH WERE HELD ON JULY 19 AND AUGUST 1, 1979.
TESTIFYING AT THE HEARINGS WERE THE FOLLOWING INDIVIDUALS:
MRS. CAROL JEAN KRUGER, CITIZEN, HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN.
MRS. KATHRY JUNGNITSCH, CITZEN, HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN
DR. HOWARD A. TANNER, DIRECTOR, MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL
RESOURCES.
WILLIAM MARKS, ASSISTANT CHIEF, BUREAU OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION,
MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
JACK BAILS, CHIEF, ENVIRONMENTAL ENFORCEMENT DIVISION, MICHIGAN
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
DR. JAMES TRUCHAN, ENVIRONMENTAL SPECIALIST, MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF
NATURAL RESOURCES.
MR. THOMAS F. SCHIMPF, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL, ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION DIVISION, STATE OF MICHIGAN.
JOHN MCGURIE, REGIONAL ADMINISTRATOR, REGION V. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY.
FRAN PHILLIPS, ASSISTANT REGIONAL ADMINISTRATOR, REGION VI,
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
LEE BOTTS, CHAIRMAN, GREAT LAKES BASIN COMMISSION.
A. BLAKEMAN EARLY, WASHINGTON REPRESENTATIVE, SIERRA CLUB.
WILLIAM SANJOUR, CHIEF, HAZARDOUS WASTE IMPLEMENTATION BRANCH, STATE
PROGRAMS AND RESOURCE RECOVERY DIVISION, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY.
HUGH B. KAUFMAN, PROGRAM MANAGER, DAMAGE ASSESSMENT PROGRAM,
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT DIVISION, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
BARBARA BLUM, DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
THOMAS C. JORLING, ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER AND WASTE
MANAGEMENT, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
JEFFREY G. MILLER, DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER
ENFORCEMENT AND CHAIRMAN, TASK FORCE ON HAZARDOUS WASTES, ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY.
THE FOLLOWING REPORT IS BASED ON THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S HEARINGS AND DATA
RECEIVED IN RESPONSE TO ITS INQUIRIES THROUGHOUT THE INVESTIGATION.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 009 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105306
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
INTENTIONAL BLANK
BLANK PAGE OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 010 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105307
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/1/ SEE PAGE 9 FOR A DESCRIPTION OF THE REQUIREMENT TO USE
CHARACTERISTICS.
THE FOLLOWING IS A BRIEF SUMMARY OF MAJOR FINDINGS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS WHICH ARE EXPRESSED IN GREATER DETAIL IN THE TEXT OF
THIS REPORT.
IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING OF HAZARDOUS
WASTES
1. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT EVEN RECENT INCREASES IN THE NUMBER
OF SUBSTANCES TO BE REGULATED UNDER SECTION 3001 OF RCRA ARE NOT
SUFFICIENT TO ENSURE PROTECTION OF THE PUBLIC AND THE ENVIRONMENT FROM
PROBLEMS EMANATING FROM IMPROPER DISPOAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE. FURTHER,
EPA'S DEPARTURE FROM THE USE OF CHARACTERISTICS AS INDICATORS OF A
CHEMICAL'S HAZARDOUS NATURE LEAVES A MAJOR GAP IN THE REGULATORY SCHEME.
/1/
2. THE REVISION OF EPA'S MARCH 1979 DRAFT REGULATIONS REDUCING THE
USE OF CHARACTERISTICS FOR SECTION 3001 HAS CONTRIBUTED GREATLY TO THE
REGULATORY DELAY.
3. EPA'S EXPLANATION FOR FAILING TO USE CHARACTERISTICS TO IDENTIFY
TOXIC, READIOACTIVE, INFECTIOUS PHYTOTOXIC, TERATOGENIC AND MUTAGENIC
SUBSTANCES UNDER PROPOSED REGUALTIONS FOR SECTION 3001 -- THAT OF NOT
HAVING RELIABLE TEST PROTOCOLS FOR THOSE CHARACTERISTICS -- IS NOT
CONSISTENT W-TH THE AGENCY'S USE OF TEST PROTOCOLS.
IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
1. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS EPA'S JUSTIFICATIONS FOR THE DELAY AS
LACKING IN MERIT.
2. IN DEVELOPING REGULATIONS UNDER SUBTITLE C OF RCRA, THE
SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT EPA INCREASED THE DELAY IN PROMULGATION BY ITS
REVISION AND REDUCTION OF THE SCOPE OF THE DRAFT REGULATIONS. THE
EFFECTS OF THE DELAY WERE:
TO FUTHER RETARD IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACT AT THE STATE AND FEDERAL
LEVEL;
TO ALLOW UNSAFE DISPOSAL PRACTICES TO CONTINUE AND TO FURTHER
ENDANGER PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONEMTN;
TO INHIBIT WASTE DISPOSAL COMPANIES FROM INVESTING IN NEW EQUIPMENT
FOR FEAR OF THE FACILITIES' INABILITY TO MEET EPA STANDARDS;
TO INCREASE PUBLIC UNCERTAINTY RESULTING IN AN INCREASE IN THE
OPPOSITION TO SITING OF NEW HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITIES;
TO FORCE THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO RESORT TO COMMON LAW AND
VARIOUS STATUTORY AUTHORITY, SUCH AS THE "IMMINENT HAZARD" PROVISION OF
RCRA, FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION, RESULTING IN LESS EFFECTIVE ENFORCEMENT;
TO REDUCE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF EPA'S INTERNAL REGULATORY DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS BY REDUCING MORALE AND CONFIDENCE AMONG EMPLOYEES AT THE PROGRAM
LEVEL.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 011 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105308
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
AND ENFORCEMTN
1. EPA HAS FAILED TO MAKE FULL USE OF ITS AUTHORITY TO IDENTIFY AND
MITIGATE THE HAZARDS POSED BY THE IMPROPER DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE.
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE AGENCY TO REMEDY INDADEQUATE DISPOSAL
PROBLEMS AHVE BEEN INSUFFICIENT TO DATE.
2. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT THE COSTS TO REMEDY PAST UNSOUND
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PRACTICES ARE EXTREMELY HIGH, AND THAT A
MECHANISM FOR THE FINANCING OF MOST IDENTIFICATION, ENFORCEMENT, AND
REMEDIAL EFFORTS DOES NOT EXIST AT THE STATE OR FEDERAL LEVEL.
3. THE EPA AND STATE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCIES HAVE FAILED
TO SCRUTINIZE THE DISPOSAL ACTIVITIES OF INDUSTRY TO PREVENT THE
TREMENDOUS LEVELS OF ENVIRONMENTAL DISRUTPION THAT HAVE AND WILL PREVAIL
WITHOUT ADDED CONTROLS.
REQUIRING DISPOSAL FACILITIES TO OBTAIN A NATIONAL POLLUTANTS
DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES) PERMIT MAY HAVE THE EFFECT OF
REDUCING EFFLUENTS REMOVED FROM SUCH DISCHARGES IN AN UNSOUND MANNER ON
THE LAND.
5. EPA HAS NOT YET ADEQUATELY ASSESSED THE EXTENT OF THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE PROBLEM BY COMPILING A COMPREHENSIVE INVENTORY OF FACILITIES AND
SITES.
6. THE STATE AND FEDERAL GOVERNMENTS HAVE NOT RESPONDED ADEQUATELY
TO SERIOUS PUBLIC ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS OVER INADEQUATE HAZARDOUS WASTE
DISPOSAL WHEN THOSE CONCERNS WERE BROUGHT TO THEIR ATTENTION. AS
EVIDENCED IN CHAPTER 3, BY FAILING TO REVIEW ONGOING INDUSTRY ACTIVITY,
SUCH AS IN THE MONTAGUE CASE, AND BY FAILING TO RESPOND TO CITIZEN AND
CONGRESSIONAL CONCERNS IN THE HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN AND JACKSONVILLE,
ARKANSAS CASES, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES HAVE NOT FULFILLED THEIR OBLIGATION
TO RESPOND.
7. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT COOPERATION BETWEEN STATE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCIES AND THE EPA REGIONS HAS BEGUN TO
INCREASE AND AGGRESSIVE STEPS TO ADDRESS HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEMS ARE
BIGINNING TO TAKE PLACE.
8. STATE ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES ARE IN NEED OF FINANCIAL AND
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS IN
HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES.
ORGANIZATION.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT THERE IS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE SUPPORTING
THE ELEVATION OF THE EPA OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE TO THE STATUS OF THE
OFFICE OF ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR DUE TO CURRENT AND PAST INADEQUATE
MANAGEMENT OVER THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA.
3001: IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE
1. EPA SHOULD INCORPORATE INTO ITS FINAL SECTION 3001 REGULATIONS
THE MOST RECENTLY PUBLISHED ('44 FEDERAL REGISTER, PAGE 15926) WATER
QUALITY CRITERIA UNDER THE CLEAN WATER ACT. SUCH AN ADDITION WILL
ENHANCE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF RCRA BY BRINGING THE MAJOR PRIORITY
POLLUTANTS UNDER THE CONTROL OF SUBTITLE C.
2. EPA SHOULD REFRAIN FROM ANY FURTHER MAJOR REVISIONS OF THE
PROPOSED REGULATIONS SO THAT THOSE REGULATIONS MAY FINALLY BE
PROMULGATED WITHOUT FURTHER DELAY.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 012 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105309
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
3. EPA SHOULD PROMULGATE REGULATIONS EXPANDING THE CHARACTERISTICS
OF HAZARDOUS WASTE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE, TO INCLUDE CHARACTERISTICS FOR
RADIOACTIVITY, UNNATURAL GENETIC ACTIVITY AND BIO-ACCUMULATION.
IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
EPA SHOULD HASTEN THE PROMULGATION OF RCRA SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS IN
ORDER TO IMPLEMENT THE STATUTE IMMEDIATELY AND TO PROVIDE FOR STATE
CONTROL OVER THE PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH HAZARDOUS WASTE.
RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
1. EPA AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE SHOULD MAKE FULL USE OF SECTION
7003 (IMMINENT HAZARD AUTHORITY) AND OTHER LEGAL AUTHORITY TO IDENTIFY
THE TRANSGRESSORS AND ALLEVIATE THE HAZARDS POSED BY TOXIC AND HAZARDOUS
WASTES, PRIOR TO AND BEYOND THE PROMULGATION OF SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS.
2. CONGRESS SHOULD ENACT "SUPERFUND" LEGISLATION TO PROVIDE AMPLE
FUNDS TO COVER INITIAL CLEANUP COSTS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE REMEDIAL EFFORTS
AND A SUFFICIENTLY STREAMLINED FEE SYSTEM TO ALLOW PROMPT RECOVERY OF
FEDERAL EXPENDITURES.
3. WHEN A STATE HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO OPERATE ITS OWN HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM UNDER RCRA, IT SHOULD USE ITS FULL AUTHORITY
UNDER SECTION 3007 TO INSPECT FACILITIES SUCH AS THE MONTAGUE, MICHIGAN
DISPOSAL SITE OWNED AND OPERATED BY HOOKER CHEMICAL CORPORATION. THE
EPA SHOULD ASSUME THIS RESPONSIBILITY IN LIEU OF A STATE AUTHORIZED
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM.
4. THE EPA AND THE STATES SHOULD CAREFULLY REVIEW ALL ALTERNATE
DISPOSAL PLANS SUBMITTED BY ANY FACILITY APPLYING FOR AN NPDES PERMIT
CONCENTRATING ON WHAT PRECISE METHOD OF DISPOSAL IS BEING USED TO TREAT
EFFLUENTS REMOVED FROM THE WATER DISCHARGE.
5. IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THE INVENTORY OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES, THE
SUBSOMMITTEE RECOMMENDS THAT EPA AND THE STATES REVIEW ALL NPDES PERMIT
APPLICATIONS AND ALL PERMITTED FACILITIES TO DETERMINE WHAT ALTERNATE
FORMS OF DISPOSAL WILL BE OR ARE BEING UTILIZED TO TREAT THE EFFLUENT
DISCHARGES.
6. EPA SHOULD USE ALL AVAILABLE TOOLS TO ENHANCE ITS ADMITTEDLY POOR
INVENTORY.
7. EPA REGIONAL AND HEADQUARTERS OFFICES SHOULD, TO THE BEST OF
THEIR ABILITY, RESPOND TO PUBLIC AND PRIVATE CONCERNS OVER ENVIRONMENTAL
PROBLEMS POSED BY DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES.
8. EPA SHOULD BE FLEXIBLE IN ADMINISTERING RCRA TO ENSURE MAXIMUM
STATE IMPLEMENTATION.
9. UPON REQUEST BY A STATE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY THAT RCRA
SECTION 3001 FUNDING OR OTHER EXISTING FUNDS BE REPROGRAMMED AND
CHANNELED INTO STATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL OFFICES FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION.
EPA REGIONAL ADMINISTRATORS SHOULD APPROVE SUCH REPROGRAMMING OF FUNDS.
IF IT BECOMES APPARENT THAT SUCH FUNDING CONTINUES TO BE INSUFFICIENT
FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES, CONGRESS SHOULD ENACT
LEGISLATION TO AUTHORIZE ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATIONS FOR SUCH ASSISTANCE.
ORGANIZATION
CONGRESS SHOULD ENACT LEGISLATION TO CREATE AN OFFICE OF ASSISTANT
ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE WITHIN EPA.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 013 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105310
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
INTENTIONAL BLANK
BLANK PAGE OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 014 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105311
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
INTENTIONAL BLANK
BLANK PAGE OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 015 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105312
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/1/ 42 U.S.C. 6921, SEC. 3001(A).
/2/ 42 U.S.C. 6921, SEC. 3001(B).
/3/ SEE SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING OF AUGUST 1, 1979.
THE CORNERSTONE OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATIONS, SECTION 3001 OF
SUBTITLE C OF RCRA WAS A MAJOR FOCUS OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S AGUST 1
HEARING, SECTION 3001 REQUIRES THE ADMINISTRATOR TO PROMULGATE
REGULATIONS SETTING STANDARDS FOR THE IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE.
SPECIFICALLY, THE ADMINISTRATOR IS REQUIRED TO:
DEVELOP AND PROMULGATE CRITERIA FOR IDENTIFYING THE CHARACTERISTICS
OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, AND FOR LISTING HAZARDOUS WASTE, WHICH SHOULD BE
SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SUBTITLE, TAKING INTO ACCOUNT
TOXICITY, PERSISTENCE, AND DEGRADABILITY IN NATURE, POTENTIAL FOR
ACCUMULATION IN TISSUE, AND OTHER RELATED FACTORS SUCH AS FLAMMABILITY,
CORROSIVENESS AND OTHER HAZARDOUS CHARACTERISTICS. /1/
IN ADDITION, UNDER SECTION 3001(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR MUST:
. . . PROMULGATE REGULATIONS IDENTIFYING THE CHARACTERISTICS OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE, AND LISTING PARTICULAR HAZARDOUS WASTES (WITHIN THE
MEANING OF SECTION 1004(5)) (DEFINITION UNDER THE ACT OF "HAZARDOUS
WASTE"), WHICH SHALL BE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SUBTITLE.
SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL BE BUSED ON THE CRITERIA PROMULGATED UNDER
SUBSECTION (A) (ABOVE)." /2/
IN SIMPLER TERMS, THE AGENCY IS TO:
(1) DEVELOP CRITERIA FOR IDENTIFYING THE CHARACTERISTICS OF HAZARDOUS
WASTE AND FOR LISTING SPECIFIC WASTES:
(2) SPECIFY THOSE CHARACTERISTICS; AND
(3) LIST PARTICULAR SUBSTANCES AS BEING HAZARDOUS.
REGULATIONS FOR SECTION 3001 WERE PROPOSED IN THE DECEMBER 18, 1978
FEDERAL REGISTER; HOWEVER, THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS DIFFER GREATLY FROM
DRAFT REGULATIONS DRAWN UP BY THE AGENCY IN MARCH, 1978.
ACCORDING TO WILLIAM SANJOUR, CHIEF OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE
IMPLEMENTATION BRANCH OF THE STATE PROGRAMS AND RESOURCE RECOVERY
DIVISION OF EPA, WHO TESTIFIED BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON AUGUST 1,
1979, THE MARCH 6, 1978 DRAFT REGULATIONS:
. . . CONTAINED PROPOSED TEST PROTOCOLS FOR THE FOLLOWING HAZARDOUS
CHARACTERISTICS: IGNITABILITY, CORROSIVITY: REACTIVITY:
RADIOACTIVITY, MUTAGENICITY, BIOACCUMULATION: AND TOXICITY WHICH
INCLUDE SEVERAL FACTORS: FIRST OF ALL, BIOASSAY TESTS: SECOND, THE
INCLUSION OF THE 26 CHEMICALS ON THE EPA WASTE QUALITY CRITERA; AND
ALSO, ANIMAL TOXICITY VALUES SUCH AS THOSE IN THE NIOSH (NATIONAL
INSTITUTE ON OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH) REGISTRY OF TOXIC EFFECTS
OF CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES . . . IT CONTAINS SOMETHING OVER 20,000
CHEMICALS, OF WHICH EPA'S STAFF DETERMINED THAT APPROXIMATELY 4,000 OF
THEM ARE SUFFICIENTLY TOXIC SO THAT THEIR PRESENCE IN A WASTE WOULD MAKE
THAT WASTE HAZARDOUS.
THESE REGULATIONS ALSO LISTED SPECIFIC HAZARDOUS WASTES. SCIENTIFIC
DATA AND ACTUAL EXPERIENCE WITH HUMAN HEALTH EFFECTS ESTABLISHED THAT
ANY SUBSTANCE THAT EXHIBITED ANY ONE OR MORE OF THESE CHARACTERISTICS
WAS INDEED "HAZARDOUS." /3/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 016 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105313
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/4/ F.R. VOL. 43, NO. 243, DEC. 18, 1978, P. 58950.
/5/ F.R. VOL. 43, NO. 243, DEC. 18, 1978, P. 58950.
/6/ AUGUST 1, 1979 HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 189-190.
THUS, BASED ON MILLIONS OF DOLLARS SPENT ON SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH
STARTING WITH THE PASSAGE OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT IN 1970, THE
AGENCY'S EFFORTS HAD RESULTED IN DRAFT REGULATIONS OF IMMENSE PROPORTION
AND REGULATORY COVERAGE.
HOWEVER, VERY SIGNIFICANT STRUCTURAL CHANGES OCCURRED IN THE
REGULATION, AS EVIDENCED BY THE VERSION PROPOSED IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER
ON DECEMBER 18, 1978.
IN PROPOSING REGULATIONS FOR SECTION 3001 DIFFERENT FROM THE DRAFT
REGULATIONS, EPA ELECTED TO RELY ON ONLY THE FOLLOWING CHARACTERISTICS:
(1) IGNITABILITY;
(2) CORROSIVITY;
(3) REACTIVITY; AND
(4) TOXICITY (USING AN EXTRACTION PROCEDURE DESIGNED TO DETERMINE THE
POLLUTANTS THAT COULD MIGRATE FROM A WASTE WHEN DISPOSED IN AN OPEN DUMP
ENVIRONMENT). /4/
THE AGENCY FAILED TO RELY ON ANY OTHER CHARACTERISTICS BASED ON THE
BELIEF THAT THE ABOVE:
" . . . ARE THE ONLY ONES FOR WHICH THE AGENCY CONFIDENTLY BELIEVES
TEST PROTOCOLS ARE AVAILABEL." /5/
THAT ASSERTION, AFTER EIGHT YEARS OF RESEARCH CULMINATING IN THE
IDENTIFICATION OF TEST PROTOCOLS FOR SEVEN CHARACTERISTICS IN THE MARCH
6 DRAFT REGULATIONS, INDICATES A CLEAR DEPARTURE FROM PREVIOUS AGENCY
EFFORTS TO ACCOMPLISH MAXIMUM COVERAGE UNDER THE HAZARDOUS WASTE
REGULATIONS.
DURING THE AUGUST 1 HEARING, WILLIAM SANJOUR SUMMARIZED THE APPARENT
REASON FOR THE "CHANGE" AS FOLLOWS:
. . . BY MARCH OF 1978 THE TECHNICAL STAFF HAD COMPLETED DRAFTING
HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATIONS. THIS WAS DONE WITH THE PARTICIPATION OF
ALL OFFICES IN EPA. INNUMERABLE MEETINGS HAD BEEN HELD WITH EVERY
SEGMENT OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, STATE GOVERNMENTS, LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
AS WELL AS INDUSTRY, LABOR, ENVIRONMENTALISTS, AND OTHER AFFECTED
PARTIES.
EVERY CONCEIVABLE ISSUE HAD BEEN REPEATEDLY DEBATED AND REPEATEDLY
RESOLVED. AT THAT POINT, THE DRAFT REGULATIONS REFLECTED A CULMINATION
OF YEARS OF STAFF TIME AND MILLIONS OF TAXPAYERS' DOLLARS. WE EXPECTED
THE REGULATIONS TO BE PROPOSED IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER AFTER A FEW
MONTHS OF UPPER MANAGEMENT REVIEW AND REVISION.
IN JUNE OF 1978, HOWEVER, WE WERE INFORMED BY OUR MANAGEMENT THAT
BECAUSE OF PRESSURE FORM THE WHITE HOUSE TO FIGHT INFLATION, THE SCOPE
OF THE DRAFT HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATIONS WOULD HAVE TO BE REDUCED.
TO THAT END, WE WERE DIRECTED NOT TO RELY ON OBJECTIVE
CHARACTERISTICS AND TEST PROTOCOLS TO IDENTIFY HAZARDOUS WASTE, BUT TO
LIMIT REGULATIONS TO A LIST OF SPECIFIC INDUSTRIES.
WE WERE TOLD TO AVOID REGULATING HAZARDOUS WASTE FROM THE OIL AND GAS
INDUSTRY, FROM ELECTRIC POWER COMPANIES, AND FROM OTHER LARGE
INDUSTRIES.
WE WERE TO AVOID REGULATING HAZARDOUS WASTE FROM INDUSTRIES OR
MUNICIPALITIES WHICH HAVE WATER DISCHARGE PERMITS UNDER THE CLEAN WATER
ACT.
WE WERE ALSO TOLD TO STOP LOOKING FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES WHICH
POSED AN IMMINENT HAZARD TO PUBLIC HEALTH; TO DELAY GETTING OUT THE
REGULATIONS WHILE WE "RESTUDIED" ALL POSSIBLE OPTIONS; AND TO KEEP ALL
THIS FROM THE PUBLIC. /6/
CHAIRMAN LEVIN, IN ORDER TO DETERMINE WHERE THE ORDER FOR THE
"CHANGE" ORIGINATED, QUERIED MR. SANJOUR AS FOLLOWS:
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 017 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105314
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/7/ AUGUST 1, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 202.
/8/ TESTIMONY OF A. BLAKEMAN EARLY ON BEHALF OF THE SIERRA CLUB,
BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, AUGUST 1,
1979, P. 2.
/9/ AUGUST 1, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 259.
/10/ TESTIMONY OF A. BLAKEMAN EARLY ON BEHALF OF THE SIERRA CLUB,
BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, AUCUST 1,
1979, P. 3.
/11/ IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT IN THIS CONTEXT, HAZARDOUS WASTES REFER
TO HAZARDOUS BY-PRODUCTS FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF ORGANIC CHEMICALS AS
WELL AS TO THE CHEMICALS THEMSELVES IF DISPOSED OF IMPROPERLY. BOTH THE
CHEMICALS PRODUCED AND THEIR BY-PRODUCTS HAVE DEMONSTRATED HAZARDOUS
CHARACTERISTICS.
SENATOR LEVIN: "YOU'VE INDICATED IN A NUMBER OF PLACES REFERENCE TO
EPA'S TOP MANAGEMENT; OR "UPPER LEVEL MANAGEMENT" WHO SPECIFICALLY ARE
YOU REFERRING TO IN THOSE INSTANCES?"
MR. SANJOUR; "WHEN THOSE JUNE CUTBACKS CAME ABOUT, WE WERE GIVEN
INSTRUCTIONS BY JACK LEHMAN AND GARY DIETRICH AND WERE TOLD BY BOTH OF
THEM THAT THESE INSTRUCTIONS WERE COMING FROM MR. JORLING." /7/
A. BLACKEMAN EARLY, WHO TESTIFIED BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON BEHALF
OF THE SIERRA CLUB, WAS CONVINCED THAT THE INFLATION FIGHT ALLEGATION
WAS THE REASON FOR THE "CHANGE".
WHY DID EPA MANAGEMENT ALLOW SUCH FUNDAMENTAL ISSUES TO GO UNRESOLVED
AS LATE AS JULY OF 1978, THREE MONTHS AFTER THE REGULATIONS SHOULD HAVE
BEEN PUBLISHED IN FINAL FORM? MANAGEMENT CAN BE THE ONLY CONCLUSION.
A MORE IMPORTANT QUESTION MIGHT BE WHY MR. JORLING MADE DECISIONS TO
CUT BACK VERY SIGNIFICANTLY THE SCOPE AND COVERAGE OF THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT REGULATIONS. CLEARLY, THE OVERRIDING CONCERN WAS THE
BUDGETARY IMPACT THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM MIGHT HAVE. /8/ (EMPHASIS
ADDED)
AT THAT TIME, AND UNTIL SEPTEMBER 1979, MR. THOMAS JORLING WAS THE
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT AT EPA. MR.
JORLING ALSO TESTIFED BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON AUGUST 1, AND WHEN
ASKED BY CHAIRMAN LEVIN WHETHER ECONOMIC CONSIDERATIONS OR THE
PRESIDENT'S FIGHT AGAINST INFLATION WERE REASONS FOR THE CHANGE, MR.
JORLING RESPONDED: "THAT IS A DESPICABLE LIE." /9/
MR. EARLY SUMMED UP THE EFFECTS OF THE REGULATORY REVISION OF SECTION
3001 AS FOLLOWS:
THESE BUDGETARY CONSIDERATIONS HAVE HAD AND WILL HAVE ON THE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM A SERIOUS ADVERSE IMPACT ON THE PROTECTION
AFFORDED THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT. THE PROPOSED
REGULATIONS WHICH EMERGED FROM THIS BUDGET-TRIMMING PROCESS ELIMINATED
SOME OF THE WASTES THAT ARE OF GREATEST CONCERN TO THE AMERICAN PUBLIC.
ELIMINATED FROM PREVIOUS DRAFTS OF THE REGULATIONS WERE SUCH
CHARACTERISTICS AS CARCINOGENICITY, BIRTH DEFECT AND GENETIC DAMAGE
CAUSING PROPERTIES. EVEN TOXICITY WAS ELIMINATED AS A CHARACTERISTIC
EXCEPT FOR THE SPECIFIC IDENTIFICATION OF FOURTEEN SUBSTANCES REGULATED
UNDER THE SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT. THE AGENCY CLAIMED IT COMPENSATED
FOR THESE OMMISSIONS BY ADDING A NEW LIST OF PROCESS WASTES THAT WOULD
BE CONSIDERED TO BE HAZARDOUS UNLESS PROVEN OTHERWISE. HOWEVER, THE
LIST OF THESE PROCESSES CONTAINS MANY OMISSIONS AND GAPS. FOR INSTANCE,
THE LIST FAILS TO CONTAIN MANY PROCESS WASTES THAT ARE REGULATED BY THE
STATEOF CALIFORNIA HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM. WE FAIL TO COMPREHEND A
MANAGEMENT AND BUDGETARY SYSTEM WHICH ELIMINATES FROM REGULATORY CONTROL
SUCH SUBSTANCES AS MIREX, BENZEDINE, TRIS, AND KEPONE WHICH HAVE BEEN
SHOWN TO POSE SUBSTANTIAL THREATS TO MAN AND THE ENVIRONMENT FROM POOR
WASTE DISPOSAL PRACTICES. /10/
WILLIAM SANJOUR CITED CLEAR EXAMPLES OF HAZARDOUS WASTES /11/ THAT
WILL NOT BE COVERED BY THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS BECAUSE OF THE REVISION:
WASTE RESIDUES FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF C-56, WHICH WAS IDENTIFIED IN
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PROBLEMS AT LOVE CANAL AND "BLOODY RUN" IN
NIAGARA FALLS; THE "VALLEY OF THE DRUMS" IN KENTUCKY; MONTAGUE,
MICHIGAN; TOONE, TENNESSEE; THE LOUISVILLE SEWER SYSTEM; AND THE
MEMPHIS SEWER SYSTEM.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 018 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105315
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/12/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 194-196.
/13/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 277.
/14/ STATEMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY'S PROPOSED REGULATIONS IMPLEMENTING SECTION 3001 OF
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT, FEB. 20, 1979, PP. 4-5.
/15/ SUBTITLE C. RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT OF 1976;
DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT, ENVIRONMENTAL PORTECTION AGENCY,
JAN. 1979, PP. 7-5 THROUGH 7-6.
ALSO, WASTE RESIDUE FORM THE MANUFACTURE OF KEPONE, WHICH DESTROYED
THE FISHING IN THE JAMES RIVER.
ALSO, WASTE RESIDUE FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF MIREX, WHICH DESTROYED
FISHING IN LAKE ONTARIO.
ALSO, WASTE RESIDUE FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF HEPTACHLOR, WHICH IS A
CARCINOGEN.
ALSO, WASTE RESIDUE FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF DBCP, WHICH CAUSES
STERILITY.
WHEREAS PREVIOUSLY THESE WASTES MAY HAVE BEEN DISPOSED OF
INADEQUATELY AND SECRETLY, THEY CAN SOON -- THANKS TO A CLEAN BILL OF
HEALTH FROM THE EPA -- BE DISPOSED OF INADEQUATELY AND OPENLY. THIS
MEANS THAT SUCH A WASTE
MAY LEGALLY BE USED, FOR EXAMPLE, AS A FERTILIZER WHERE IT CAN ENTER
THE HUMAN FOOD CHAIN;
CAN BE USED AS LANDFILL WHERE IT CAN LEACH INTO UNDERGROUND DRINKING
WATER SUPPLIES;
CAN BE STOCKPILED WHERE IT CAN RUN OFF INTO SURFACE WATER AND LEACH
INTO GROUND-WATER; AND
FINALLY, IF THE WASTE IS VOLATILE -- AS IN LOVE CANAL -- IT WILL BE
ALLOWED TO POISON THE AIR WITHOUT CONSTRAINTS. /12/
BECAUSE C-56 IS THE PRIMARY SOURCE OF CONTAMINATION AT THE MONTAGUE,
MICHIGAN SITE OWNED BY HOOKER CHEMICAL AND BECAUSE IT IS A SOURCE OF
MAJOR CONTAMINATION IN MANY AREAS OF THE COUNTRY, CHAIRMAN LEVIN
ATTEMPTED TO ESTABLISH WHETHER OR NOT THE WASTE WAS COVERED IN THE
PROPOSED REGULATIONS IN HIS QUESTIONING OF MR. JORLING;
SENATOR LEVIN: ". . . IS IT TRUE THAT WASTE MATERIAL THAT CONTAINS
SOME C-56, AS WELL AS OTHER SUBSTANCES, AND WHICH IS NOT HAZARDOUS IN
ANY OTHER RESPECT OTHER THAN THE FACT THAT IT HAS SOME C-56 IN IT, WOULD
NOT BE IDENTIFIED AS "HAZARDOUS" UNDER THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS, SINCE
C-56 IS NOT INCLUDED IN THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTICS?"
MR. JORLING: "SENATOR . . . THE ANSWEER IS YES." /13/
OTHER CRITICS OF EPA'S PROPOSED REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT SECTION 3001
OF RCRA HAVE VOICED SIMILAR CONCERNS OVER THE LACK OF COMPREHENSIVE
REGULATORY COVERAGE. ONE SUCH CRITIC, LESLIE DACH, A SCIENCE ASSOCIATE
WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND, CHARACTERIZED THE PROPOSED
REGULATIONS AND SPECIFICALLY THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTICS AS FOLLOWS:
UNFORTUNATELY, THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS FALL FAR SHORT OF
GUARANTEEING PUBLIC SAFETY. WHILE THEY WILL RESULT IN FAR BETTER
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT THAN CURRENTLY PRACTICED, THE REGULATIONS ARE
UNACCEPTABLE IN THEIR PRESENT FORM. THEY LEAVE THE PUBLIC UNPROTECTED.
. . . EDF STRONGLY BELIEVES THAT THE PROPOSED 3001 REGULATIONS EXEMPT
SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS OF TOXIC HAZARDOUS WASTE FROM RCRA REGULATION. THIS
IS UNACCEPTABLE. EPA ADMITS AS MUCH IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
STATEMENT (EIS) ACCOMPANYING RCRA. /14/
THE EIS DOES INDICATE, IN FACT, THAT THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC
PROPOSED BY EPA WILL EXEMPT A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF TOXIC HAZARDOUS
WASTE FROM REGULATION:
THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC IS BASED SOLELY UPON THE EPA PRIMARY
DRINKING WATER STANDARDS AND, AS A RESULT, MANY WASTES THAT ARE
POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS DUE TO OTHER INDICATORS OF TOXICITY, ESPECIALLY
ORGANIC WASTES, WOULD PRESENTLY BE EXCLUDED FROM REGULATIONS. /15/
THE NET EFFECT OF THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC PROPOSED BY EPA WILL BE
THAT IT WILL LEAVE UNREGULATED 65 PERCENT OF THE POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS
WASTE GENERATED BY THE CHEMICALS AND ALLIED PRODUCTS INDUSTRIES.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 019 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105316
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/16/ IBID, PP. 6-3 AND 7-6.
/17/ FR, DEC. 24, 1975, P. 59570-71.
/18/ FR, AUGUST 22, 1979, PP. 49402-4.
/19/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 192.
/20/ STATEMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND ON THE ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY'S PROPOSED REGUALTIONS IMPLEMENTING SECTION 3001 OF
THE RESOURCE CONSEFVATION AND RECOVERY ACT, FEB. 20, 1979, PP. 5-6.
/21/ PER EPA'S STATEMENT THAT 65 PERCENT OF THESE WASTES WILL BE LEFT
UNREGULATED (EIS) -- 42.9 MILLION FIGURE IS BASED ON A PERCENTAGE OF
WASTE GENERATED IN 1978 BY THE 53 LARGEST CHEMICAL COMPANIES IN THE U.S.
ACCORDING TO A RECENT SURVEY CONDUCTED BY THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES'
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS, P.X. COMM. PRINT 96-IFC
33.
THIS MEANS THAT OF 29.7 MILLION METRIC TONS PRODUCED BY THOSE
INDUSTRIES IN 1976, ONLY 9.8 MILLION METRIC TONS WOULD FALL UNDER RCRA
REGULATIONS. /16/
THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC AS CURRENTLY PROPOSED COVERS ONLY 14
SUBSTANCES, OF WHICH 6 ARE ORGANIC CONTAMINANTS. THESE 14 SUBSTANCES
WERE CHOSEN FROM THE NATIONAL INTERIM PRIMARY DRINKING WATER STANDARDS
UNDER THE SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT (SDWA). /17/ EPA HAS JUSTIFIED THIS
PROPOSAL BY STIPULATING THAT MANY TOXIC SUBSTANCES ARE INCLUDED IN THE
LISTS OF PROCESS WASTES AND PURE CHEMICALS FOUND IN THE APPENDICES OF
THE DEC. 18 PROPOSAL, AND WOULD THEREFORE BE SUBJECT TO REGULATION. IN
ADDITION, EPA HAS STATED THAT IT PLANS TO EXPAND THE TOXICITY
CHARACTERISTIC TO INCREASE THE COVERAGE OF TOXIC SUBSTANCES, AND TO
INCREASE THE NUMBER OF SPECIFICALLY LISTED WASTES AND PROCESSES.
EPA PROPOSED ADDING APPROXIMATELY 45 WASTES IN THE AUG. 22, 1979
FEDERAL REGISTER. /18/ THIS EXPANSION, AMONG OTHER THINGS, PROVIDED FOR
THE COVERAGE OF ALL WASTES FROM THE PRODUCTION OF C-56.
WHILE THE SUBCOMMITTEE COMMENDS EPA FOR THESE CHANGES, THE "INCREASE"
STILL FAILS TO EXPAND THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC. THIS STILL LEAVES AS
UNREGULATED MANY CHEMICALS WHICH HAVE SHOWN CARCINOGENIC PROPERTIES IN
BIOASSAY TESTS, AND THE CHEMICALS IDENTIFIED BY WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
UNDER THE CLEAN WATER ACT. THE "INCREASE" STILL FAILS TO TAKE INTO
ACCOUNT TOXICITY VALUES SUCH AS THOSE IDENTIFIED IN THE NIOSH REGISTRY
OF TOXIC EFFECTS OF CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES. /19/
IN ADDITION, EPA'S SOLE RELIANCE ON REGULATORY "GUIDELINES" UNDER THE
SDWA, IN IDENTIFYING SUBSTANCES AS TOXIC UNDER THE RCRA TOXICITY
CHARACTERISTICS, CASTS A SHADOW OVER THE AGENCY'S APPARENT ATTEMPTS TO
COMPLY WITH CONGRESSIONAL INTENT TO PROTECT, UNDER RCRA, THE PUBLIC
HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
CLEARLY, THESE ARE ONLY A FEW OF THE SUBSTANCES KNOWN TO POSE A HUMAN
HEALTH OR ENVIRONMENTAL RISK. THE 14 DO NOT INLCUDE SIGNIFICANT NUMBERS
OF KNOWN CARCINOGENS, TERATOGENS AND MUTAGENS. THE ORGANIC STANDARD
ALREADY PROPOSED UNDER THE SDWA IS NOT EVEN INCLUDED. ALSO, THE SDWA
AIMS AT PROTECTING HUMAN HEALTH. IT DOES NOT REQUIRE STANDARDS TO
PROTECT THE ENVIRONMENT. YET RCRA CALLS ON EPA TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH
AND THE ENVIRONMENT. /20/
1. THE EXTENT TO WHICH EPA HAS INCREASED ITS COVERAGE UNDER PROPOSED
REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT SECTION 3001 OF RCRA IS NOT SUFFICIENT TO
INSURE PROTECTION OF THE PUBLIC AND THE ENVIRONMENT FROM PROBLEMS
ASSOCAIATED WITH THE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE. CHEMICALS LEFT
UNREGULATED BY THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC ARE SUFFICIENT TO CAUSE
EXTREME DAMAGE TO THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE PUBLIC HEALTH.
IN 1980 ALONE, ACCORDING TO EPA AND HOUSE ESTIMATES, AT LEAST 42.9
MILLION METRIC TONS OF POTENTIALLY HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATED BY THE
CHEMICAL AND ALLIED PRODUCTS INDUSTRIES WILL BE LEFT UNREGULATED BY THE
REGULATIONS IF PROMULGATED IN THEIR PROPOSED FORM. /21/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 020 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105317
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/22/ FR, JUNE 14, 1979.
/23/"-AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 193.
/24/ NOTE: EPA MENTIONS THE POSSIBLE INCLUSION OF WATER QUALITY
CRITERIA ON P. 58956 OF THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS, DEC. 18, 1978, FEDERAL
REGISTER.
THE AGENCY'S DEPARTURE FROM THE USE OF CHARACTERISTICS AS INDICATORS
OF A CHEMICAL'S HAZARDOUS NATURE LEAVES A MAJOR GAP IN THE REGULATORY
SCHEME.
2. EPA'S REVISION OF THE DRAFT REGULATIONS OF MARCH, 1979, FOR
SECTION 3001 HAS EXACERBATED THE DELAY IN THEIR PROMULGATION. THE
SUBCOMMITTE HAS BEEN UNSUCCESSFUL IN IDENTIFYING THE TRUE REASONS FOR
THE REVISION, BUT REGARDLESS OF THE REASONS, EPA UPPER MANAGEMENT IS
DIRECTLY RESPONSIBLE, AND HAS CONTRIBUTED TO EPA INTERNAL
DISSATISFACTION WITH THE REGULATION-WRITING PROCESS. MANAGEMENT
DEFICIENCIES SUCH AS DELAYS IN DECISION-MAKING HAVE ADVERSELY AFFECTED
THE TIMING OF PROMULGATION.
3. EPA'S EXPLANATION FOR FAILING TO USE CHARACTERISTICS TO IDENTIFY
TOXIC RADIOACTIVE, INFECTIONS, PHYTOTOXIC, TERATOGENIC AND MUTAGENIC
SUBSTANCES UNDER RCRA -- THAT OF NOT HAVING RELIABLE TEST PROTOCOLS FOR
THOSE CHARACTERISTICS -- IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE AGENCY'S USE OF TEST
PROTOCOLS. INDEED, EPA HAS PROPOSED USING TEST PROTOCOLS FOR THE
IDENTIFICATION OF CHEMICALS WHICH FALL UNDER THE WATER QUALTIY CRITERIA
OF THE CLEAN WATER ACT. /22/
AS WILLIAM SANJOUR POINTED OUT. ". . . TEST PROTOCOLS ARE AVAILABLE
TO PROTECT FISH, BUT NOT PEOPLE." /23/
THESE CHEMICALS ARE THE SAME AS THOSE THAT WOULD FALL UNDER THE
PROPOSED SECTION 3001 REGULATIONS IF THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC WERE
EXPANDED. /24/
EPA HAS INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT THE AGENCY'S INTENT IS TO
BRING THE MOST EGREGIOUS WASTES INTO THE SYSTEM OF REGULATORY COVERAGE
FIRST, AND TO ADD ADDITIONAL WASTES TO THE LISTS OVER A GRADUAL PERIOD
OF TIME. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FAILS TO UNDERSTAND HOW THE MAJOR EXCLUSIONS
ESPECIALLY UNDER THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC COINCIDE WITH BRINGING
UNDER CONTROL THE MOST EGREGIOUS WASTES AT THE EARLIEST POSSIBLE TIME.
1. THE SUBCOMMITTEE BELIEVES THAT EPA SHOULD INCORPORATE INTO ITS
FINAL SECTION 3001 REGULATIONS THE MOST RECENTLY PUBLISHED (44 FR 15926)
WATER QUALITY CRITERIA UNDER THE CLEAN WATER ACT. THE AGNECY NOTED IN
ITS DECEMBER 18 PROPOSED REGULATIONS THAT IT WAS CONSIDERING SUCH AN
ADDITION, AND THE SUBCOMMITTEE IS CONVINCED THE EFFECTIVENESS OF RCRA
WILL BE ENHANCED IF THE TOXICITY CHARACTERISTIC WERE EXPANDED TO INCLUDE
THE WATER QUALITY CRITERIA, THUS BRINGING THE MAJOR PRIORITY POLLUTANTS
UNDER THE CONTROL OF SUBTITLE C.
2. EPA SHOULD REFRAIN FROM ANY FURTHER MAJOR REVISIONS OF THE
PROPOSED REGULATIONS, SO THAT THOSE REGULATIONS MAY FINALLY BE
PROMULGATED WITHOUT FURTHER DELAY.
IN ADDITION, EPA MUST RESOLVE ITS INTERNAL MANAGEMENT DIFFICULTIES TO
FACILITATE THE PROMULGATION OF THESE REGULATIONS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 021 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105318
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/25/ FR, DEC, 18, 1978, P. 58950.
3. EPA SHOULD PROMULGATE REGULATIONS EXPANDING THE CHARACTERISTICS
OF HAZARDOUS WASTE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. THE AGENCY PUBLISHED AN
ADVANCED NOTICE OF PROPOSED RULEMAKING, ALSO IN THE DEC. 18 FEDERAL
REGISTER, WHICH WOULD "EXPAND THE CHARACTERISTICS TO INCLUDE
RADIO-ACTIVITY, UNNATURAL GENETIC ACTIVITY, BIOACCUMULATION, AND
SEPARATE CONSIDERATIONS OF TOXICITY TO AQUATIC ORGANISMS, TERRESTRIAL
PLANTS AND HUMANS (VIA CHRONIC EXPOSURE TO ORGANIC CHEMICALS)." /25/
PROMULGATION OF THESE REGULATIONS WILL SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASE THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROVISIONS OF THE STATUTE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 022 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105319
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
INTENTIONAL BLANK
BLANK PAGE OMITTED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 023 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105320
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/26/ ON TUESDAY, FEB. 26, 1980, EPA PROMULGATED REGULATIONS TO
IMPLEMENT SECTIONS 3002, 3003, AND 3010 OF SUBTITLE C OF RCRA.
HEREINAFTER REFERENCES TO THE DELAY IN PROMULGATION OF SUBTITLE C
REGULATIONS SHALL PERTAIN PRIMARILY TO SECTION 3001.
/27/ JULY 19, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 9-10.
/28/ COMPLAINT FILED BY ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND AND ENVIRONMENTAL
ACTION, INC., IN THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, SEPT.
13, 1978.
WITH THE PASSAGE OF RCRA IN OCTOBER, 1976, THE EPA ADMINISTRATOR WAS
REQUIRED TO PROMULGATE REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT SUBTITLE C OF THE ACT
WITHIN 18 MONTHS OF THE DATE OF ENACTMENT. TO THIS DAY, OVER THREE
YEARS FROM THE PASSAGE OF RCRA, THOSE REGULATIONS HAVE YET TO BE
PROMULGATED. /26/
AS SENATOR COHEN SUMMARIZED IN HIS OPENING REMARKS, THE EFFECTS OF
THE DELAY HAVE BEEN PERNICIOUS:
NOW THE COST OF THE DELAY IN DOLLARS AND HARM TO THE PUBLIC IS
IMMENSE. WITHOUT REGULATIONS, NO PRIVATE FIRM IS GOING TO BUILD A TOXIC
WASTE FACILITY AND THUS RISK LOSING HUGE INVESTMENTS IF THE FACILITY
DOES NOT COMPLY WITH THE YET-TO-BE ISSUED CRITERIA. AND MANY STATES,
INCLUDING MY OWN STATE OF MAINE, CANNOT AFFORD TO ENACT THEIR OWN WASTE
TREATMENT LAWS. SO LONG AS OTHER STATES REMAIN FREE TO SUBSIDIZE THE
POLLUTION CREATED BY LOCAL INDUSTRY, HONEST BUSINESSMEN ARE FORCED TO
CHOOSE BETWEEN DISPOSING OF THEIR WASTES IN AN UNSAFE MANNER OR PAYING
EXORBITANT AND POSSIBLY BANKRUPTING FEES TO HAVE THEIR WASTES
TRANSPORTED TO SAFE FACILITIES.
IN THE MEANTIME THE PUBLIC SUFFERS BOTH THE ECONOMIC UNCERTAINTY AND
THE THREAT OF CANCER AND TOXIC POISONING. THE LAW WE PASSED IN 1976
PROVIDED A SO-CALLED CRADLE-TO-GRAVE MONITORING FOR THE LOCATION OF
TOXIC WASTES. THE PROBLEM HERE IS THAT THERE AREN'T ENOUGH SAFE GRAVES
TO CONTAIN THE TOXIC WASTES GENERATED BY AMERICAN INDUSTRY. IN FACT, IN
MY OWN REGION IN NEW ENGLAND, THERE IS NOT A SINGLE DISPOSAL SITE THAT
IS CONSIDERED BY ENGINEERING EXPERTS TO BE SAFE FOR THE STORAGE OF
HAZARDOUS WASTES. I AM NOT CONCERNED, MR. CHAIRMAN, SO MUCH WITH THE
LEGALITY OF DELAYS AS I AM WITH THE SOCIAL IRRESPONSIBILITY THAT THEY
IMPLY. /27/
IN SEPTEMBER OF 1978, A COALITION OF ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS AND THE
STATE OF ILLINOIS FILED SUIT AGAINST EPA IN THE U.S. DISTRICT COURT FOR
THE AGENCY'S FAILURE TO PROMULGATE SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS BY THE
STATUTORY DEADLINE. THE ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS WERE THE ENVIRONMENTAL
DEFENSE FUND (EDF), CITIZENS FOR A BETTER ENVIRONMENT AND THE NATIONAL
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT ASSOCIATION.
IN ITS SEPTEMBER 13, 1978 COMPLAINT FILED WITH THE US DISTRICT COURT,
EDF CHARGED EPA WITH VIOLATING THE PROVISIONS OF RCRA, AND SPECIFICALLY
CHARGED THAT:
AS A REULST OF (EPA'S) VIOLATION OF THE ACT, REGULATION OF THE
DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES . . . WILL BE UNLAWFULLY DELAYED. DURING
THIS PERIOD, SOLID AND HAZARDOUS WASTES WILL BE DISPOSED OF WITHOUT
ASSURANCE THAT SUCH ACTIVITIES WILL NOT FURTHER DEGRADE THE NATION'S
WATER, LAND AND AIR, EXPOSING THE POPULACE TO HEALTH HAZARDS. /28/
THE COMPLAINT REQUESTED THAT THE COURT GRANT APPROPRIATE RELIEF BY
ESTABLISHING NEW MANDATORY DEADLINES FOR THE PROMULGATION OF RCRA
REGULATIONS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 024 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105321
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/29/ STATEMENT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT, BY DOUGLAS M. COSTLE,
ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, OCT. 12, 1979.
/30/ FIGURES SUPPLIED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE BY EPA. SEE CHART IN
HEARING RECORD.
/31/ TESTIMONY OF LEE BOTTS, CHAIRMAN, GREAT LAKES BASIN COMMISSION,
JULY 19, 1979.
/32/ (FUNDING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS WITHIN EPA WILL ALSO BE
ADDRESSED IN CHAPTER FOUR OF THE REPORT.)
/33/ JUNE 22, 1979, LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGNT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
IN RESPONSE TO THE SUIT, JUDGE GERHARD GESELL DID, IN FACT, SET NEW
DEADLINES IN HIS JANUARY 3, 1979 DECISION. THE DEADLINE APPLIED TO THE
PROMULGATION OF SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS AS FOLLOWS:
TABLE OMITTED
AS YET, IN A STATEMENT REGARDING HIS THIRD QUARTERLY AFFIDAVIT TO THE
COURT FILED ON OCTOBER 12, 1979, EPA ADMINISTRATOR DOUGLAS COSTEL
STATED:
I HAVE INFORMED JUDGE GESELL THAT OUR INITIAL HAZARDOUS WASTE
REGULATORY PACKAGE WILL MOST LIKELY BE PROMULGATED IN LATE WINTER AND
EARLY SPRING (1980). I AM EXTREMELY FRUSTRATED THAT WE ARE NOT ABLE TO
MEE THE SCHEDULE WE PROPOSED, AND THE JUDGE ADOPTED, WHICH CALLED FOR
PROMULGATION OF THE REGULATIONS BY DECEMBER 31. /29/
EPA HAS STRESSED A LACK OF MONETARY RESOURCES AS A JUSTIFICATION FOR
ITS FAILURE TO PROMULGATE THE REGULATIONS UNDER RCRA. WHILE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ACKNOWLEDGES EPA'S ASSERTION THAT A NUMBER OF PEOPLE AND
FUNDS WERE TRANSFERRED FROM OTHER PORGRAMS TO ASSIST IN THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE EFFORT, THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT A DISPROPORTIONATELY SMALL
SHARE OF FUNDS HAVE BEEN ALLOCATED BY THE AGENCY TO INSURE LAND
PROTECTION. IN FACT, IN FISCAL YEAR 1978, THE PORTION OF EPA'S BUDGET
DEVOTED TO ALL HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS COMPRISED ONLY ONE PER CENT OF
EPA'S TOTAL BUDGET. ESTIMATES FOR FISCAL YEAR 1980 RAISE THE FIGURE TO
A MERE THREE PER CENT. /30/
LEE BOTTS, CHAIRMAN OF THE GREAT LAKES BASIN COMMISSION, TESTIFIED IN
REGARD TO BOTH STAFFING AND FUNDING DEFICIENCIES:
ANOTHER RCRA PROBLEM IS THE WAY STAFF AND FUNDING RESOUFCES WERE
FIRST IDENTIFIED AND ALLOCATED. BECAUSE OF THE UNREALISTIC ESTIMATES
ABOUT WHAT WOULD BE NEEDED TO GIVE TO CONGRESS DURING CONSIDERATION OF
RCRA, TOO FEW STAFF POSITIONS WERE AVAILABLE IN THE EARLY STAGES. THIS
HAS BEEN A MORE IMPORTANT CAUSE FOR DELAY IN DEVELOPMENT OF RCRA
REGULATIONS THAN THE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION PROCESS THAT IS SOMETIMES
BLAMED. /31/
AT BEST, EPA'S CLAIMS THAT THE AGENCY LACKS SUFFICIENT RESOURCES TO
PROMULGATE RCRA REGULATIONS PROVIDE MINIMAL JUSTIFICATION, AS THE LACK
OF RESOURCES STEMS FROM THE AGENCY'S OWN FAILURE TO RECOGNIZE RESOURCE
NEEDS. /32/
BECAUSE OF THIS FUNDING SHORTAGE, EPA HAS BEEN PLACED IN THE TRAGIC
POSITION OF CHOOSING BETWEEN PROMULGATION OF RCRA REGULATIONS AND
ATTNEDING TO THE PROBLEMS OF ABANDONED HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES.
IN A JUNE 22, 1979, RESPONSE TO A SUBCOMMITTEE REQUEST FOR
INFORMATION, EPA CITES A MAJOR REASON FOR THE DELAY IN PROMULGATION OF
SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS AS:
SEVERAL KEY PERSONNEL, WHO OTHERWISE WOULD HAVE BEEN INVOLVED IN THE
INITIAL REVIEW OF COMMENTS RECEIVED ON THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS, HAVE
SPENT AND ARE CONTINUING TO SPEND TIME WORKING ON THE PROBLEMS
ASSOCIATED WITH ABANDONED HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. /33/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 025 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105322
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/34/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 212 AND
222.
/35/ NOVEMBER 14, 1979, LETTER TO SENATOR CARL LEVIN FROM HUGH
KAUFMAN, PROGRAM MANAGER, DAMAGE ASSESSMENT PROGRAM, U.S. ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY.
/36/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS TRANSCRIPT, P. 238.
AT THE VERY LEAST, THIS DIVERSION HAS CAUSED CONTROVERSY WITHIN THE
AGENCY ITSELF, AS INDICATED BY THE STATEMENT OF ONE OFFICIAL, HUGH
KAUFMAN, TESTIFYING AT THE HEARINGS ON AUGUST 1:
EPA TOP MANAGEMENT SHOULD STOP USING DIVERSIONARY TACTICS, SUCH AS
EXAGERATING THE EXTENT OF THE ABANDONED HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE PROBLEM TO
MOVE PUBLIC ATTENTION AND RESOURCES AWAY FROM THE MORE SERIOUS PROBLEMS
OF EXISTING SITES FOR WHICH WE HAVE STATUTORY REMEDIES . . . WE HAVE IN
OUR FILES OVER 1,000 CASES OF PROBLEMS FROM HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. AND
I THINK, AT THE MOST, 10 PER CENT ARE FROM ABANDONED SITES. /34/
AND, AT LEAST FOR REGIONS V AND VI, MR. KAUFMAN'S ALLEGATIONS MAY
HAVE SOME VALIDITY. ACCORDING TO INFORMATION FROM EPA'S OWN FILES, THE
ABANDONED SITE PROBLEM DOES NOT SEEM TO BE OF AS GREAT A MAGNITUDE AS
MADE OUT BY EPA:
TABLE OMITTED
THIS TABULATION INDICATES THAT ONLY 2.5 PERCENT OF THE SITES IN
REGIONS V AND VI ON WHICH EPA HAD INFORMATION COULD BE CLASSIFIED AS
ABANDONED. /35/
NEVERTHELESS, THE SUBCOMMITTEE RECOGNIZES THE IMPORTANCE OF BOTH THE
ABANDONED SITE PROBLEM AND RCRA IMPLEMENTATION. THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S
CONCERN IS THAT EPA'S FAILURE TO RECOGNIZE FUNDING NEEDS HAS FORCED THE
AGENCY TO MAKE SUBSTANTIAL CHOICES BETWEEN THESE TO COMPETING INTERESTS.
AN EVEN MORE FRE-UENCY CITED JUSTIFICATION BY EPA FOR THE REGULATIORY
DELAY IS THAT THE REGULATIONS INVOLVE EXTREMELY COMPLEX ISSUES. AS
BARBARA BLUM, EPA DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR, POINTED OUT IN THE AUGUST 1
HEARING:
THE HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATORY PROGRAM INVOLVES PROBABLY AS LARGE A
NUMBER OF DIFFICULT ISSUES AS ANY REGULATORY PROGRAM THAT WE'VE EVER
ADDRESSED.
SOME OF THE ISSUES WHICH WE ARE GOING TO HAVE TO RESOLVE BEFORE
OUR DEADLINE OF DECEMBER 31 INCLUDE, FOR EXAMPLE:
TO WHAT EXTENT CAN AND SHOULD REGULATIONS VARY WITH THE DEGREE OF
HAZARD OF THE WASTE?
HOW SHOULD GENERATORS OF SMALL QUANTITIES OF HAZARDOUS WASTE BE
REGULATED?
HOW CAN FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY BE ASSURED AT PERMITTED SITES?
HOW CAN RCRA BEST BE INTEGRATED WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE CLEAN
WATER ACT, THE CLEAN AIR ACT, AND THE OTHER FEDERAL STATUTES?
SENATOR LEVIN: "LET ME INTERRUPT YOU JUST FOR A MINUTE. HOW LONG
HAVE THOSE ISSUES BEEN APPARENT?"
MS. BLUM: "THESE ISSUES HAVE BEEN ISSUES THAT WE HAVE BEEN TRYING TO
ADDRESS THROUGHOUT THE REGULATIONS AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
REGULATIONS." /36/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 026 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105323
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/37 AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 252.
/38/ PREPARED REMARKS OF WILLIAM SANJOUR, CHIEF, HAZARDOUS WASTE
IMPLEMENTATION BRANCH, STATE PROGRAMS AND RESOURCE RECOVERY DIVISION,
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, AUGUST 1, 1979, P. 4.
/39/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 237.
/40/ LETTER OF THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND
ECOLOGY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JUNE
26, 1979.
AND AT A LATER POINT IN THE HEARINGS, MS. BLUM ELABORATED FURTHER ON
THIS PROBLEM:
IN THE CASE OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, THERE WAS VIRTUALLY NO AVAILABLE
EXPERTISE WITHIN THE AGENCY, OR VERY LITTLE (WHEN RCRA WAS ENACTED IN
1976.) /37/
HOWEVER, AS WILLIAM SANJOUR STATED IN HIS PREPARED TESTIMONY:
THE RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS ON THIS HAZARDOUS WASTEPROBLEM WAS DONE
UNDER THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT OF 1970, AND WAS CLOSELY MONITORED BY
SEVERAL COMMITTEES OF CONGRESS. WE WORKED CLOSELY WITH THESE COMMITTEES
IN DEVELOPING VARIOUS LEGISLATIVE PROPOSALS OVER A PERIOD OF SEVERAL
YEARS. THIS WORK CULMINATED IN OCTOBER 1976 WITH THE PASSAGE OF RCRA.
THE APPROACH TAKEN IN THIS ACT TO REGULATE HAZARDOUS WASTE WAS BASICALLY
THAT APPROACH DEVELOPED BY EPA'S HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT DIVISION AS
AN OUTGROWTH OF ITS STUDIES. /38/
THUS, AS MENTIONED EARLIER, AND AS MS. BLUM ACKNOWLEDGED, THESE
COMPLEX QUESTIONS HAD BEEN CONSIDERED THROUGHOUT THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
REGULATIONS, BEGINNING WITH THE PASSAGE OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT
OF 1970. EVEN CONCEDING COMPLEXITY, EIGHT YEARS IS A SUFFICIENT AMOUNT
OF TIME TO THOROUGHLY EVALUATE ALL ISSUES RELATING TO HAZARDOUS WASTE
REGULATION.
ANOTHER EPA JUSTIFICATION FOR THE EXTREME DELAY IS THE DESIRE TO
PROMOTE PUBLIC PARTICIPATION TO THE FULLEST IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE
REGULATIONS. AS MS. BLUM ADVISED THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON AUGUST 1:
WE HAD . . . FIVE PUBLIC HEARINGS DURING THE 90-DAY COMMENT PERIOD.
ABOUT 1200 PEOPLE ATTNDED THE HEARING AND ABOUT 200 TO 250 MADE ORAL
PRESENTATIONS.
THERE WERE ABOUT 1100 WRITTEN COMMENTS THAT CAME IN DURING THAT
PERIOD OF TIME. WE HAD A STACK THAT WAS OVER SIX FEET TALL.
EACH OF THESE COMMENTS HAS GOT TO BE REVIEWED AND RESPONDED TO AS WE
DEVELOP OUR FINAL REGULATIONS. /39/
AS MENTIONED IN THE PREVIOUS SECTION, EPA HAD AMPLE TIME TO
THOROUGHLY EVALUATE ALL ISSUES RELATING TO HAZARDOUS WASTE. WHILE IN
GENERAL PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IS A WORTHY GOAL, THE AGENCY SHOULD HAVE
ANTICIPATED THE EXTENT TO WHICH THE REGULATIONS WOULD AFFECT INDUSTRY
AND THE LARGE DEGREE OF COMMENTS WHICH EXUDED FROM INDUSTRY AND THE
PUBLIC IN RESPONSE TO THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS.
FINALLY, A REASON FREQUENTLY CITED BY EPA FOR THE DELAY IS THE NEED
TO PRODUCE REGULATIONS WHICH WOULD SURVIVE JUDICIAL REVIEW. THE NATURE
OF THIS JUSTIFICATION WAS HIGHLIGHTED IN A LETTER TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE
FROM THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND ECOLOGY:
BECAUSE THE STATES AND INDUSTRY MUST CONFORM TO YET-TO-BE DEVELOPED
REGULATIONS, THE STATES CANNOT MOVE AUTHORITATIVELY IN THE FIELD OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT. IN FACT, EVERY MOVE IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE
AND MORE IMPORTANTLY SUBJECT TO CHALLENGE FROM ALL SIDES. /40/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 027 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105324
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/41/ 42 U.S.C. 6926.
HERE, IT IS APPARENT THAT EVEN THE DESIRE TO REDUCE TE CHANCE OF
HAVING ITS SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS REJECTED BY THE COURTS AS A
CONTRIBUTING FACTOR MAY BE UNJUSTIFIED. TO INTERPRET THE ABOVE
STATEMENT, IT IS ESSENTIAL TO DISCUSS THE REQUIREMENTS FOR STATE
IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA.
THREE REQUIREMENTS ARE IMPOSED UPON STATES FOR AUTHORIZATION OF STATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS UNDER SUBTITLE C OF RCRA.
SUCH STATE IS AUTHORIZED TO CARRY OUT SUCH PROGRAM IN LIEU OF THE
FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER THIS SUBTITLE . . . UNLESS . . . THE ADMINISTRATOR
. . . FINDS THAT
(1) SUCH STATE PROGRAM IS NOT EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER
THIS SUBTITLE,
(2) SUCH PROGRAM IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE FEDERAL OR STATE PROGRAMS
APPLICABLE IN OTHER STATES, OR
(3) SUCH PROGRAM DOES NOT PROVIDE ADEQUATE ENFORCEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SUBTITE. /41/
STATES DEVELOPING IMPLEMENTING REGULATIONS DURING THE FEDERAL DELAY
MUST RELY ON PROPOSED REGULATIONS AS GUIDELINES. IF THE PROPOSED
FEDERAL REGULATIONS UNDERGO SIGNIFICANT CHANGES, THE PROBABILITY
INCREASES THAT REGULATIONS DEVELOPED BY THE STATES WILL NOT SATISFY THE
ABOVE EQUIVALENCY AND CONSISTENCY PROVISIONS. THUS, THE LONGER THE
DELAY CONTINUES AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL, THE GREATER THE CHANCES BECOME AT
THE STATE LEVEL FOR REJECTION OF A STATE PROGRAM BY THE ADMINISTRATOR
(REFUSED AUTHORIZATION). EPA AND CONGRESS MUST RECOGNIZE, MOREOVER,
THAT IN AN AREA AS CONTROVERSIAL AS ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION, LAW SUITS
MAY, PERHAPS, BE ASSUMED TO BE A COST OF DOING BUSINESS.
WITH THE PASSAGE OF RCRA IN 1976, CONGRESS INTENDED THAT EPA
ESTABLISH FEDERAL MINIMUM STANDARDS FOR REGULATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE,
AND THAT THE STATES IMPLEMENT THE ACT BASED ON THESE STANDARDS. AS
NOTED ABOVE, THE ACT PROVIDES FOR THE AUTHORIZATION OF STATE HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS TO REGULATE HAZARDOUS WASTE IN LIEU OF THE
FEDERAL PROGRAM. IF THE STATE PROGRAM IS EITHER INCONSISTENT WITH OTHER
STATE PROGRAMS OR NOT EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM, THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT WILL ASSUME THE RESPONSIBILITY FOR REGULATING HAZARDOUS
WASTES IN THAT STATE.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE CONTACTED SEVERAL STATES DURING ITS INVESTIGATION TO
ASCERTAIN WHTAT EFFECT THE FEDERAL DELAY IN ISSUING SUBTITLE C
REGULATIONS UNDER RCRA HAS HAD ON IMPLEMENTATION OF STATE HAZARDOUS
WASTE LEGISLATION OR REGULATIONS. THE RESPONSES WERE OVERWHELMING:
THE DELAYS IN ISSUING SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS HAVE CREATED SUBSTANTIAL
DIFFICULTIIES.
THE PRE-EMPTIVE ASPECTS OF RCRA AND OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION
COMPOUND THE PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH DELAYED PROMULGATIONS OF
REGULATIONS, ESPECIALLY REGULATIONS CONCERNING TOXIC CHEMICALS AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE. IDEALLY, SUCH REGULATIONS WOULD HAVE BEEN THE FIRST
REGULATIONS ISSUED IN THE UNITED STATES' ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
PROGRAM, RECOGNIZING THAT EMPHASIS SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THE MOST HAZARDOUS
SITUATIONS FIRST. UNFORTUNATELY, THE REGULATIONS DEALING WITH TOXIC
EFFLUENTS UNDER THE (F)EDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT (FWPCA) AND
THE SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS (RCRA) HAVE BEEN AMONG THE LAST REGULATIONS
TO BE DEVELOPED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 028 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105325
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/42/ LETTER OF THE ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND
ECOLOGY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JUNE
26, 1979.
/43/ LETTER OF THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT FOR NATURAL RESOURCES AND
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION TOTE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT, JULY 11, 1979.
/44/ LETTER OF MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES TO
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, SEPTEMBER 27, 1979.
/45/ LETTER OF MINNESOTA POLLUTION CONTROL AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE
ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JULY 27, 1979.
/46/ JULY 24, 1979 LETTER FROM RICHARD D. LAMM, CHAIRMAN, NATURAL
RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE AND BILL CLINTON,
CHAIRMAN, SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, NATIONAL GOVERNORS
ASSOCIATION TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/47/ RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT OF 1976. REPORT OF THE
COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES ON H.R. 14496, SEPTEMBER 9, 1976. REPORT NO. 94-1491,
P. 30.
THIS PLACES INDUSTRY AND THE STATES IN A VERY UNDESIRABLE SITUATION.
/42/
THIS DEPARTMENT HAS NOT YET BEEN ABLE TO IMPLEMENT THE (LEGISLATIVE)
PROVISIONS BECAUSE OF THE DELAY IN ISSUING FEDERAL REGULATIONS FOR
SUBTITLE C REQUIREMENTS.
THERE IS NO QUESTION THAT DELAYS IN ISSUING SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS
ARE SERIOUSLY HAMPERING STATE PROGRAM E-FORTS . . . PRESENTLY, WE ARE IN
THE IRONIC POSITION OF PROMULGATING STATE REGULATYONS IN THE ABSENCE OF
ANY FEDERAL ONES. HOW THIS SITUATION WILL AFFECT OUR CHANCES OFRPRIMACY
AND WHAT CHANGES AT THE STATE LEVEL WILL BE REQUIRED WHEN FIANL FEDERAL
REGULATIONS GO INTO EFFECT REMAIN TO BE SEEN. /43/
WE HAVE BEEN ASSURED BY EPA THAT THE EXISTING STATE PROGRAMS, IN
MICHIGAN'S CASE SEVERAL YEARS AHEAD OF FEDERAL EFFORTS, WILL NOT BE SET
BACK BY NEW EPA REQUIREMENTS. HOWEVER, THE SAME ASSURANCES WERE GIVEN
WHEN THE CLEAN WATER ACT WAS PASSED AND A LOT OF STATE EFFORT WAS
DIVERTED FROM PROBLEM-SOLVING TO PAPERWORK GENERATED BY FEDERAL
REGULATIONS. TIME WILL TELL.
OUR GREATEST CONCERN IS THAT EXISTING STATUTES, RULES, AND
ADMINISTRATION PROCEDURES CONTROLLING HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT IN
MICHIGAN WILL HAVE TO BE MODIFIED AGAIN TO MEET SPECIFIC FEDERAL
REQUIREMENTS. IF A MAJOR OVERHAUL IS NECESSARY TO OBTAIN FEDERAL FUNDS,
IT WILL SLOW DOWN THE PROGRESS A LREADY MADE IN MICHIGAN. /44/
THE DELAY IN THE PROMULGATION OF FEDERAL RULES CONTROLLING HAZARDOUS
WASTES HAS PLAYED A ROLE IN DELAYING IMPLEMENTATION OF THE STATE'S
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM . . . THE DELAY IN THE FEDERAL PROGRAM WILL
CONTINUE TO CAUSE PROBLEMS AS WE IMPLEMENT OUR PROGRAM BECAUSE OF THE
INTERSTATE NATURE OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND A RECOGNIZED NEED
FOR EQUIVALENCE AND CONSISTENCY IN IMPORTANT AREAS SUCH TRANSPORTATION
AND CRITERIA FOR IDENTIFICATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTES. /45/
IN FACT, THE NATIONAL GOVERNORS ASSOCIATION FOUND THAT THE DELAY WAS
THREATENING THE VERY PASSAGE OF STATES' IMPLEMENTING LEGISLATION:
IN STATES SUCH AS FLORIDA AND OHIO LEGISLATION HAS EITHER BEEN
DEFEATED OR FACES SEVERE OBSTACLES TO PASSAGE -- TO A LARGE PART AS A
RESULT OF THE AGENCY'S DELAY IN PROMULGATING SUBTITLE C RULES,
REGUALTIONS, AND GUIDELINES. /46/
CONGRESS PROVIDED THE OPTION OF STATE IMPLEMENTATION OF STATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM, BASED ON
FEDERAL MINIMUM STANDARDS, FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS:
(1) IT PROVIDED UNIFORMITY AMONG THE STATES AS TO HOW HAZARDOUS
WASTES ARE REGULATED.
(2) IT PROVIDED INDUSTRY AND COMMERCIAL ESTABLISHMENTS THAT GENERATE
SUCH WASTES UNIFORMITY AMONG STATES.
(3) BY PROVIDING SUCH UNIFORMITY A STATE WITH ENVIRONMENTALLY SOUND
LAWS DOES NOT DRIVE BUSINESS OUT OF THE STATE TO A STATE WHICH, FOR
ECONOMIC REASONS, DECIDES TO BE A DUMPING GROUND FOR HAZARDOUS WASTES,
AND
(4) BY PERMITTING STATES TO DEVELOP AND IMPLEMENT HAZARDOUS WASTE
PROGRAMS EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM, THE POLICE POWER OF THE
STATES ARE UTILIZED RATHER THAN THE CREATION OF ANOTHER FEDERAL
BUREAUCRACY TO IMPLEMENT THIS ACT. /47/
THE INTERSTATE NATURE OF HAZARDOUS WASTES WAS CLEARLY RECOGNIZED BY
CONGRESS, AS INDICATED IN THE LEGISLATIVE HISTORY OF RCRA. HOWEVER.
STATUTORY AUTHORITY TO DEAL WITH HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PROBLEMS STILL
VARIES FROM STATE TO STATE, AND THE FOLLOWING CASE PROVIDES AN EXAMPLE
OF WHAT CAN HAPPEN WHEN ENVIRONMENTAL LAW IS APPLIED IN AN INCONSISTENT
FASHION.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 029 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105326
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/48/ LETTER OF JUNE 6, 1979 FROM HELEN SINCLAIR TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE
ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/49/ HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL. REPORT BY THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS. COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN
COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, SEPTEMBER, 1979, COMMITTEE
PRINT 96-IFC31, P. 72.
/50/ LETTER OF THE ARKANSAS DEPRATMENT OF POULLUTION CONTROL AND
ECOLOGY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JUNE
26, 1979.
POLLUTION CONTROLS, INC., A CORPORATION LOCATED IN SHAKOPEE,
MINNESOTA, OPERATED AN INCINERATOR FOR YEARS TO DISPOSE OF COMBUSTIBLE
PAINT SLUDGES, SOLVENTS AND WASTE OILS. AFTER A CIVIL SUIT BY THE STATE
WHICH RESULTED IN A COURT ORDER TO CLEAN UP THE SITE, POLLUTION
CONTROLS, INC., RELOCATED IN EL DORADO, ARKANSAS, WHERE IT CHANGED ITS
CORPORATE NAME TO ENERGY SYSTEMS COMPANY (ENSCO). THE COMPANY MAY SOON
BE LICENSED BY EPA AS AN INCINERATOR FOR PCBS (POLY-CHLORINATED
BIPHENYLS).
A PUBLIC NUISANCE SUIT WAS FILED AGAINST THE COMPANY ON MAY 24, 1979,
AS A RESULT OF CITIZEN COMPLAINTS OVER INTOLERABLE AIR EMISSIONS. ONE
CONCERNED AREA RESIDENT INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE, IN REGARD TO THE
RELOCATION OF THE COMPANY IN EL DORADO, THAT:
WE FEEL WE ARE A DUMPING GROUND FOR THE ENTIRE COUNTRY. CHEMICALS
ARE HAULED TO OUR CITY (FROM) AS FAR AWAY AS CANADA. /48/
THIS "POLLUTION SINK" PROBLEM WAS RECENTLY DESCRIBED FURTHER BY
REPRESENTATIVE MARC MARKS IN A REPORT BY THE SUBCOMMITEE ON OVERSIGHT
AND INVESTIGATIONS:
NO STATE SHOULD BECOME A DUMPING GROUND FOR THE HAZARDOUS WASTES OF
ANOTHER. YET THAT IS EXACTLY THE POSITION PENNSYLVANIA IS IN TODAY.
TESTIMONY AT OUR SUBCOMMITTEE'S HEARINGS REVEALED THAT THE STATE OF NEW
JERSEY CURRENTLY IS DUMPING 65 TO 70 PERCENT OF THEIR HAZARDOUS WASTES
MATERIAL IN PENNSYLVANIA. NEW JERSEY'S OWN RECORDS VERIFY THESE
FIGURES.
THE REASON FOR THIS IS SIMPLE: NEW JERSEY HAS ENACTED STRICT LAWS
REGULATING THE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES. PENNSYLVANIA HAS NOT.
THEREFORE, TO AVOID THE EXPENSE AND EFFORT OF COMPLYING WITH NEW
JERSEY'S LAWS, HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATORS IN THAT STATE SIMPLY SEND
THEIR HAZARDOUS WASTES TO PENNSYLVANIA. UNDOUBTEDLY, OTHER STATES ARE
FOLLOWING THE SAME PATTERN. /49/
CLEARLY, IT IS UNDESIRABLE FOR ONE STATE TO BECOME THE DUMPING GROUND
FOR ANTOHER'S WASTES. AND YET, THE DELAY IN THE ISSUANCE OF SUBTITLE C
REGULATIONS HAS CONTRIBUTED GREATLY TO THIS PHENOMENON, INCREASING
PUBLIC AWARENESS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEMS AND DECREASING STATE'S
CAPABILITIES TO CONTROL THEM.
ANOTHER UNINTENDED BUT NEVERTHELESS SERIOUS DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATED
WITH THE DELAY IS THAT UNCERTAINTY HAS BEEN INCREASED ON THE PART OF
PUBLIC OVER HAZARDOUS WASTE REGULATION. THE RESULT: THE PEOPLE THAT
SHOULD BE PROTECTED BY THE ACT ARE INCREASINGLY OPPOSED TO THE SITING OF
NEW HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES. AS POINTED OUT BY THE ARKANSAS
DEPARTMENT OF POLLUTION CONTROL AND ECOLOGY:
UNTIL THEY (HAZARDOUS WASTE TOOLS) ARE AVAILABLE, PUBLIC CONCERN AND
THE SUBSEQUENT OPPOSITION TO THE SITING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITIES
WILL CONTINUE TO MOUNT AND THE DIFFERENTIATION BETWEEN FACILITIES WHICH
CAUSE THE PROBLEMS WILL BECOME MORE CONFUSED. CONSEQUENTLY, STATE
AGENCIES AND EPA REGIONAL PERSONNEL WILL CONTINUE TO EXPERIENCE THE
RESPONSIBILITY ASSOCIATED WITH INADEQUATE FACILITIES AND YET WILL NOT
HAVE WITHIN THEIR GRASP THE TOOLS REQUIRED TO SOLVE THE PROBLEMS. /50/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 030 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105327
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/51/ TESTIMONY OF JAMES W. MOORMAN, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL, LANDS
AND NATURAL RESOURCE DIVISION, DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS, COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE
AND FOREIGN COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, MAY 16, 1979, PP.
719-720.
/52/ AUGUST 1, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 191-198.
THUS, UNTIL EPA GETS DOWN TO THE BUSINESS OF REGULATING HAZARDOUS
WASTE AS CONGRESS INTENDED, THE AGENCY WILL FACE NOT STATIC BUT
INCREASING OBSTACLES TO CARRYING OUT ITS MANDATE.
ANOTHER EFFECT OF THE DELAY IS THAT IT FORCES THE DEPARTMENT OF
JUSTICE TO RESORT TO COMMON LAW AND VARIOUS STATUTORY AUTHORITY, SUCH AS
THE "IMMINENT HAZARD" PROVISION OF RCRA, FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION.
ACCORDING TO JAMES MOORMAN, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL OF THE LANDS
AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE:
UNTIL THE SUBTITLE C REGULATORY PROGRAM IS IN PLACE, AND UNTIL IT IS
EXPANDED TO COVER INACTIVE OR ABANDONED DISPOSAL SITES, ENFORCEMENT MUST
BE APPROACHED UNDER ANOTHER PROVISION OF THAT ACT.
THERE ARE, IN ADDITION, MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS IN (OTHER
ENVIRONMENTAL) STATUTES . . . AS WELL AS LEGAL THEORIES UNDER THE COMMON
LAW, WHICH CAN BE APPLIED DEPENDING ON THE SPECIFIC FACT SITUATION. OUR
LAWYERS WORKING IN THIS NEWLY DEVELOPING FIELD OF HAZARDOUS AND TOXIC
WASTE CONTROL WILL BE UTILIZING THESE PROVISIONS IN VARIOUS COMBINATIONS
AS APPROPRIATE. /51/
WILLIAM SANJOUR CHARACTERIZED THE EPA MANAGEMENT CONSEQUENCES OF THE
CUTBACK, WHICH RESULTED IN THE EXTREME DELAY, AS FOLLOWS:
TO IMPLEMENT THIS NEW POLICY, WE WERE TOLD TO DO MANY THINGS WHICH WE
KNEW WERE NOT RIGHT.
WE WERE REQUIRED TO WRITE PUBLIC DOCUMENTS WHICH WE KNEW WERE
MISLEADING. THE PRESS AND CONGRESS AND THE PUBLIC WERE GIVEN
MISINFORMATION, WHILE ACCURATE INFORMATION WAS SUPPRESSED.
OUR TASK SHIFTED TO DEVELOPING AFTER-THE-FACT EXPLANATIONS TO JUSTIFY
DEPARTURES FROM THE MANDATE AND THE INTENT OF THE ACT.
EVERY ONE OF US ON THE EPA TECHNICAL STAFF HAS TO MAKE HIS OWN
DECISION AS TO WHAT EXTENT HE OR SHE WOULD BE A "GOOD SOLIDER" AND OBEY
ORDERS, OR TO BE A "GOOD CITIZEN" AND OBEY THE LAW.
I WAS NOT A VERY GOOD SOLIDIER, AND AS A RESULT I WAS TRANSFERRED TO
A MEANINGLESS JOB OUT OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT DIVISION WHER I
COULD NO LONGER AFFECT THE REGULATIONS.
I WOULD ASK CONGRESS TO HAVE COMPASSION FOR THE CIVIL SERVANT CHARGED
WITH WRITING REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT THE LAW.
HE IS CAUGHT BETWEEN HIS CONSCIENCE AND HIS CAREER. /52/
SEVERAL OTHER OFFICIALS WITHIN EPA INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE STAFF
THROUGHOUT ITS INVESTIGATION THAT THEY WERE NOT SATISFIED WITH THE
METHODS CHOSEN TO REGULATE HAZARDOUS WASTE, THE DECISIONS WHICH LED TO
THOSE METHODS AND THE RESULTING DELAY IN PROMULGATION.
1. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS EPA'S JUSTIFICATIONS FOR THE DELAY WITHOUT
MERIT.
2. RECOGNIZING THE VIRTUAL CERTAINTY OF JUDICIAL CHALLENGE TO ITS
FINAL REGULATIONS, THE EPA SHOULD NOT BE SPENDING SUCH AN INORDINATE
AMOUNT OF TIME TRYING TO SECOND-GUESS THE COURTS.
3. IN DEVELOPING REGULATIONS UNDER SUBTITLE C THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS
THAT EPA INCREASED THE DELAY IN PROMULGATION BY ITS REVISION AND
REDUCTION OF THE SCOPE OF THE DRAFT REGULATIONS. THE EFFECTS OF THE
DELAY WERE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 031 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105328
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
TO FURTHER RETARD IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ACT AT THE STATE AND FEDERAL
LEVEL;
TO ALLOW UNSAFE DISPOSAL PRACTICES TO CONTINUE AND TO FURTHER
ENDANGER PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT;
TO INHIBIT WASTE DISPOSAL COMPANIES FROM INVESTING IN NEW EQUIPMENT
FOR FEAR OF THE FACILITIES' INABILITY TO MEET EPA STANDARDS;
TO INCREASE PUBLIC UNCERTAINTY RESULTING IN AN INCREASE IN THE
OPPOSITION TO SITING OF NEW HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITIES;
TO FORCE THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO RESORT TO COMMON LAW AND
VARIOUS STATUTORY AUTHORITIES, SUCH AS THE "IMMINENT HAZARD" PROVISION
OF RCRA, FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION;
TO REDUCE THE EFFECTIVENESS OF EPA'S INTERNAL REGULATORY DEVELOPMENT
PROCESS BY REDUCING MORALE AND CONFIDENCE AMONGST EMPLOYEES AT THE
PROGRAM LEVEL.
EPA SHOULD HASTEN THE PROMULGATION OF RCRA SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS IN
ORDER TO IMPLEMENT THE STATUTE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE, AND TO PROVIDE FOR
STATE CONTROL OVER HAZARDOUS WASTE AS ENVISIONED BY CONGRESS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 032 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105329
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/53/ NOVEMBER 20, 1979 LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
THROUGHOUT ITS INVESTIGATION, THE SUBCOMMITTEE ATTEMPTED TO DETERMINE
WHETHER, PRIOR TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA, EPA WOULD PROVIDE FOR A
COHESIVE NATIONAL PROGRAM FOR RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT TO ENVIRONMENTAL
PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH THE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE.
A MAJOR EFFORT BY EPA TO ESTABLISH A NATIONAL ENFORCEMENT AND
RESPONSE SYSTEM TO ADDRESS THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEM CULMINATED IN THE
CREATION OF A HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT TASK FORCE THROUGH A JUNE 27,
1979 EPA DIRECTIVE. THE SYSTEM (HEREINAFTER REFERRED TO AS THE "TASK
FORCE") WAS CREATED TO FULFILL THE FOLLOWING FUNCTIONS:
"(1) TO DEVELOP AND MAINTAIN A NATIONALLY UNIFORM H-ZARDOUS WASTE
SITE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM;
(2) TO WORK WITH THE REGIONS AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE TO
EXPEDITE THE DEVELOPMENT AND FILING OF REGIONALLY MANAGED HAZARDOUS
WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT CASES;
(3) TO PROVIDE NATIONAL MANAGEMENT AND DIRECTION FOR A LIMITED NUMBER
OF HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT CASES INVOLVING PARTICULARLY SIGNIFICANT
LEGAL PRECEDENTS OR CUTTING ACROSS A NUMBER OF REGIONAL BOUNDARIES."
/53/
THE TAKS FORCE IS A TEMPORARY UNIT WHICH WILL BE INCORPORATED INTO
EXISTING ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURES WITHIN TWO YEARS.
EPA HAS ALSO RECENTLY ESTABLISHED A PERMANENT UNIT TO COORDINATE
EMERGENCY AND REMEDIAL RESPONSES TO VARIOUS HAZARDOUS WASTE SITUATIONS.
THIS IS THE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE CONTROL BRANCH UNDER A DIVISION OF THE
OFFICE OF WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT. BOTH SYSTEMS MESH TO FORM WHAT
EPA REFERS TO AS THE HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ENFORCEMENT AND RESPONSE
SYSTEM.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE BELIEVES THAT IN ORDER TO IMPLEMENT SUCH A SYSTEM,
KNOWLEDGE OF SITE INFORMATION SHOULD BE ROUTINELY TRANSMITTED TO EPA
HEADQUARTERS, AND THAT THE SYSTEM NECESSITATES CONTROL AND COORDINATION
FROM UPPER MANAGEMENT.
WHEN ASKED ABOUT THE EFFECTS OF THE MEMORANDUM WHICH ESTABLISHED THE
SYSTEM, HUGH KAUFMAN, MANAGER OF THE EPA DAMAGE ASSESSMENT PROGRAM,
CHARACTERIZED IT AS FOLLOWS:
THAT MEMORANDUM STRENGTHENS THE REGIONAL OFFICE'S CAPABILITIES. IT
SAYS THE REGIONS ARE BASICALLY IN BUSINESS FOR THEMSELVES TO ADDRESS
HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE ISSUES, WITHOUT HEADQUARTER'S OVERSIGHT. AND I
THINK THE RECORD SHOWS THAT IT'S THE HEADQUARTER'S OVERSIGHT THAT HAS
FORCED CLEANUP OF MANY BAD SITES.
WHEN THE REGIONS WERE IN BUSINESS FOR THEMSELVES, THINGS WERE NOT
BEING DONE. I THINK THERE ARE MANY OTHER PROBLEMS WITH THAT MEMORANDUM
IN TERMS OF NOT SETTING UP A GOOD INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK.
WE HAVE MANY DIFFERENT ACTORS INVOLVED, WHICH LEADS TO MORE TURF
FIGHTING. IN FACT, TURF FICHTING GOES ON EVERY DAY. WHAT PIECE IS
ENFORCEMENT (DIVISION) RE SPONSIBLE FOR?
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 033 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105330
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/54/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 217-18, REGARDING ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY INTERNAL MEMORANDUM OF JUNE 27, 1979.
/55/ SEE PAGE 52 FOR FULL DESCRIPTION OF IMMINENT HAZARD PROVISION.
/56/ INTERNAL JUSTICE DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM SUPPLIED TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, P. 8.
/57/ IBID, P. 8.
/58/ IBID, PP. 27-28.
WHAT PIECE WITH THIS REGIONAL GROUP OR THAT REGIONAL GROUP HAVE?
(EMPHASIS ADDED) /54/
IN SHORT, THE UPPER LEVEL COORDINATION REQUIRED TO MANAGE SUCH A
SYSTEM IS INSUFFICIENT.
ALTHOUGH EPA'S NEW HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE TRACKING SYSTEM (CREATED TO
FACILITATE THE TASK FORCE AND SITE CONTROL BRANCH) PROVIDES A MECHANISM
FOR ROUTINE TRANSMITTAL OF SITE INFORMATION TO HEADQUARTERS, THERE
APPEAR TO BE NO MANDATORY PROCEDURES WHICH THE REGIONS MUST FOLLOW TO
ASSURE FULL RESPONSE AND CONTINUOUS SITE INFORMATION FLOW. LACKING A
CENTRALIZED REGULATORY FRAMEWORK PROVIDED FOR UNDER RCRA SUBTITLE C,
THIS SYSTEM MUST BE CENTRALLY CONTROLLED TO ENSURE THAT REGIONAL OFFICES
ARE ACCOUNTABLE TO CONGRESS.
DIFFERING VIEWS
ABSENT THE ENFORCEMENT MECHANISM PROVIDED UNDER SUBTITLE C OF RCRA,
EPA MUST USE OTHER AVAILABLE LEGAL AUTHORITY TO BRING ENFORCEMENT
ACTIONS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES. RECOGNIZING THE CONTINUING OCCURRENCE
OF HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS POSED BY BOTH ACTIVE AND INACTIVE
HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES, THE EPA SHOULD BROADLY INTERPRET AVAILABLE LEGAL
AUTHORITY TO FACILITATE ITS UTILIZATION.
A POWERFUL TOOL AVAILABLE AT THIS TIME TO THE EPA ADMINISTRATOR TO
TAKE EMERGENCY LEGAL ACTION IN CASES OF EXTREME ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS
POSED BY HAZARDOUS WASTES IS SECTION 7003 OF RCRA, THE "IMMINENT HAZARD"
AUTHORITY. /55/
AN INTERNAL JUSTICE DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM WHICH THE SUBOMMITTEE
OBTAINED SUGGESTS THE NEED FOR MORE AGGRESSIVE USE OF SECTION 7003 THAN
HAS BEEN THE CASE TO DATE. IT INTERPRETS THIS AUTHORITY AS BEING
APPLICABLE TO INACTIVE, AS WELL AS ACTIVE, OR EXISTING SITES.
THE MEMO EVALUATES SECTION 7003 AS:
AMPLE LEGAL AUTHORITY . . . FOR THE UNITED STATES TO ENJOIN OR
OTHERWISE REMEDY HAZARDOUS WASTE POLLUTION THAT DOES NOT REACH UNITED
STATES WATERS. /56/
FURTHERMORE, THE DEPARTMENT SEES THIS PROVISION AS PROVIDING
AUTHORITY . . . FOR PURSUING FORMER OWNERS OF A POLLUTING SITE (AND
PERHAPS EVEN THE GENERATOR OF THE WASTE), UNDER CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES,
AND FOR PURSUING WASTE GENERATORS WHO USE INDEPENDENT CONTRACTORS TO
SURREPTITIOUSLY DUMP THEIR HAZARDOUS WASTE. /57/
ACCORDING TO THE MEMO, THERE IS ONE FUNDAMENTAL LIMITATION TO THE USE
OF SECTION 7003 AUTHORITY:
IF SECTION 7003 HAS ANY DRAWBACK, IT IS THAT THE SECTION IS
UNFAMILIAR AND UNTESTED . . . IN CONCLUSION, THERE IS AMPLE, IF
UNTESTED, AUTHORITY FOR PURSUING HAZARDOUS WASTE POLLUTION UNDER MOST
SITUATIONS." (EMPHASIS ADDED) /58/
EPA, IN TURN, HAS TESTIFIED THAT SECTION 7003:
. . . AUTHORIZES US TO TAKE ENFORCEMENT ACTION AGAINST THE OWNER OF
AN INACTIVE SITE IF THE SITE IS PRESENTING AND IMMINENT AND SUBSTANTIAL
DANGER TO HUMAN HEALTH OR THE ENVIRONMENT. HENCE, WE CAN EFFECTIVELY
EXERCISE THIS AUTHORITY WHERE THE PRESENT OWNER IS IN SOME WAY
RESPONSIBLE FOR THE IMMINENT HAZARD AND IS FINANCIALLY OR OTHERWISE ABLE
TO REMEDY IT.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 034 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105331
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/59/ OVERSIGHT OF RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT, HEARINGS
HELD BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATION. COMMITTEE
ON INTERSTATE NAD FOREIGN COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES,
OCTOBER 30, 1978, PP. 27-8, SERIAL NO. 95-183. (NOTE, ADDITIONAL
REFERENCE AVAILABLE ON P. 230 OF AUGUST 1, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING
TRANSCRIPT).
/60/ JUNE 22, 1979 LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO
THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/61/ SECOND RESTATEMENT OF TORTS, AMERICAN LAW INSTITUTE, SECTION
373, "DANGEROUS CONDITIONS CREATED BEFORE VENDOR TRANSFERS POSSESSION",
1965.
HOWEVER, WHERE THESE TWO CIRCUMSTANCES ARE NOT PRESENT, 7003 IS NOT
AN EFFECTIVE TOOL. /59/
THE DISAGREEMENT BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, WITH RESPECT TO APPLICATION OF SECTION
7003 TO "PRESENT" (EPA) OR "FORMER" (DOJ) OWNERS, IS ONE THAT HAS
EVIDENTLY LIMITED THE USE OF SECTION 7003 AS AN ENFORCEMENT TOOL. AS OF
AUGUST, 1979, ONLY SEVEN CASES HAD BEEN BROUGHT IN FEDERAL COURT
RELATING TO HAZARDOUS WASTE. THESE CASES HAVE RELIED ON SECTION 7003,
IMMINENT HAZARD AUTHORITY UNDER OTHER FEDERAL STATUTES, AND OTHER COMMON
LAW AND STATUTORY AUTHORITY. /60/
THE SUBCOMMITTEE ACKNOWLEDGES EPA'S CHARACTERIZATION OF THE
TREMENDOUS BURDEN OF PROOF ASSOCIATED WITH AN IMMINENT HAZARD ACTION
(PLAINTIFF MUST SHOW HAZARDOUS WASTE . . . "IS PRESENTING AND IMMINENT
AND SUBSTANTIAL ENDANGEMENT . . ."). CLEARLY, HOWEVER, WITHOUT
AGGRESSIVE EFFORTS TO BRING SUITS UNDER THE PROVISION, SECTION 7003 WILL
REMAIN, AS THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE SUGGESTS, LARGELY UNTESTED.
EPA HAS APPARENTLY DETERMINED THAT ITS LEGAL AUTHORITY IS
INSUFFICIENT BASED ON THE VIEW THAT THE AGENCY CANNOT CURRENTLY TAKE
ACTION IN HAZARDOUS WASTE SITUATIONS WHERE A RESPONSIBLE OWNER WITH
FINANCIAL RESOURCES IS NOT AVAILABLE (ACCORDING TO EPA, THIS WOULD
INCLUDE "ABANDONED SITES" SUCH AS LOVE CANAL). HOWEVER, AS INDICATED IN
THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM, THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS SUFFICIENT
AUTHORITY TO PURSUE EVEN FORMER OWNERS OF A PULLUTING SITE FOR REMEDIAL
EFFORTS. THE KEY TO THE SECTION 7003 PROVISION, IN THIS RESPECT LIES
NOT WITH CURRENT OWNERSHIP BUT WITH RESPONSIBILITY. THUS, EVEN LOVEL
CANAL CANNOT BE CONSIDERED AS TRULY ABANDONED (DESPITE THE FACT THAT
HOOKER CHEMICALS AND PLASTICS CORPORATION IS NO LONGER THE OWNER OF THE
SITE) BECAUSE OF HOOKER'S CONTINUING RESPONSIBILITY TO MAINTAIN THE
SITE.
THE SECOND RESTATEMENT OF TORTS BY THE AMERICAN LAW INSTITUTE
SUPPORTS THE ARGUMENT THAT HOOKER CHEMICAL COULD BE LIABLE FOR PREVIOUS
ON-SITE DISPOSAL ACTIVITIES DESPITE THE TRANSFER OF OWNERSHIP TO THE
STATE OF NEW YORK:
A VENDOR OF LAND WHO HAS CREATED OR NEGLIGENTLY PERMITTED TO REMAIN
ON THE LAND A STRUCTURE OR OTHER ARTIFICAL CONDITION WHICH INVOLVES AN
UNREASONABLE RISK OF HARM TO OTHERS OUTSIDE OF THE LAND, BECAUSE OF ITS
PLAN, CONSTRUCTION, LOCATION, DISREPAIR, OR OTHERWISE, IS SUBJECT TO
LIABILITY TO SUCH PERSONS FOR PHYSICAL HARM CAUSED BY THE CONDITION
AFTER HIS VENDEE HAS TAKEN POSSESSION OF THE LAND. /61/
IN FACT, THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT, IN COOPERATION WITH STATE OFFICIALS,
HAS RECENTLY FILED A CIVIL SUIT AGAINST HOOKER, BASED ON SECTION 7003,
TO RECOVER MONIES SPENT TO REMEDY THE DAMAGES CAUSED BY ITS
IRRESPONSIBILE DISPOSAL PRACTICES AT LOVE CANAL. IN ANY EVENT, EPA'S
INTERPRETATION REGARDING THE POSSIBLE APPLICATIONS OF SECTION 7003 HAVE
RESULTED IN LESS THAN AGGRESSIVE USE OF ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 035 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105332
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/62/ TESTIMONY OF JAMES W. MOORMAN, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL, LAND
AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMEBNT, JULY 19, 1979.
/63/ TESTIMONY OF JAMES W. MOORMAN, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL, LAND
AND NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISION, U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS, COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE
AND FOREIGN COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, OCTOBER 30, 1978,
SERIAL NO. 95-183.
/64/ LETTER OF JUNE 22, 1979, FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, P. 8.
NOT ONLY ARE THERE DIFFERING VIEWS ON THE APPLICATION OF RCRA'S
IMMINENT HAZARD AUTHORITY, THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE AND EPA ALSO DIFFER
IN THIER INTERPRETATION OF THE USE OF OTHER FEDERAL STATUTES.
EPA AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE RESPONSES TO SUBCOMMITTEE INQUIRIES
HAVE DISCLOSED THAT A WIDE VARIETY OF STATUTORY AUTHORITY CAN BE USED TO
ADDRESS HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEMS PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF RCRA SUBTITLE
C REGULATIONS. ACCORDING TO JUSTICE, THERE ARE 20 FEDERAL STATUTES IN
ADDITION TO RCRA AND THEORIES OF COMMON LAW WHICH RELATE TO HAZARDOUS OR
TOXIC WASTES, AND WHICH CAN BE APPLIED TO VARYING HAZARDOUS WASTE
PROBLEMS. /62/
THE DEPARTMENT HAS ALSO CITED THIRTEEN IMMINENT HAZARD PROVISIONS IN
ADDITION TO SECTION 7003 OF RCRA THAT CAN BE CONSIDERED AS APPLICABLE TO
CERTAIN HAZARDOUS WASTE SITUATIONS. /63/
EPA HAS A MUCH MORE LIMITED VIEW OF STATUTORY CAPABILITIES. THE
AGENCY HAS CONCEDED THAT ONLY 6 FEDERAL STATUTES OTHER THAN RCRA CAN BE
APPLIED TO SEEK REMEDIAL ACTION AT HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. /64/
THE SUBCOMMITTEE IS AWARE THAT THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK PROVIDED
UNDER RCRA IS THE ONLY TRULY COMPREHENSIVE STATUTORY TOOL DESIGNED TO
DEAL SPECIFICALLY WITH HAZARDOUS AND SOLID WASTE. WE ALSO RECOGNIZE THE
LIMITED NATURE OF OTHER AUTHORITY IDENTIFIED BY EPA AND THE JUSTICE
DEPARTMENT. HOWEVER, WE FIND THAT THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT HAS MORE
ADEQUATELY IDENTIFIED APPROPRIATE LEGAL TOOLS FOR EFFECTIVE ENFORCEMENT
ACTION.
2. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT EPA HAS FAILED TO MAKE FULL USE OF
ITS AUTHORITY TO IDENTIFY AND MITIGATE THE HAZARDS POSED BY INDUSTRY'S
HANDLING OF HAZARDOUS WASTES.
3. AS NOTED IN THE INTRODUCTION TO THIS REPORT, THE COST FOR CLEANUP
OF LOVE CANAL IN NIAGARA FALLS, N.Y., HAS ALREADY EXCEEDED $23 MILLION.
MICHIGAN OFFICALS ESTIMATE THAT AT LEAST $500 MILLION WILL BE REQUIRED
FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE CONTAINMENT AND REMEDIAL MEASURES IN THAT STATE
ALONE. ACCORDINGLY, THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT THE COSTS TO REMEDY
PAST UNSOUND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PRACTICES ARE EXTREMELY HIGH, AND
THAT A MECHANISM FOR THE FINANCING OF MOST IDENTIFICATION, ENFORCEMENT,
AND REMEDIAL EFFORTS DOES -OT EXIST AT THE STATE OR FEDERAL LEVEL.
FURTHER, IN THE CASE OF LOVE CANAL AND MANY OTHER SITES, MAJOR LIABILITY
QUESTIONS REMAIN UNRESOLVED.
1. EPA AND THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE SHOULD MAKE FULL USE OF ALL
LEGAL T-OLS IDENTIFIED BY THE DEPARTMENT, INCLUDING SECTION 7003 AND ANY
OTHER AVAILABLE LEGAL AUTHORITY, TO IDENTIFY SITES AND MITIGATE THE
HAZARDS POSED BY TOXIC AND HAZARDOUS WASTES, PRIOR TO AND BEYOND THE
PROMULGATION OF SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS.
2. CONGRESS SHOULD ENACT A VERSION OF THE PROPOSED "SUPERFUND"
LEGISLATION WHICH WOULD PROVIDE AMPLE FUNDS TO COVER.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 036 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105333
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/65/ JUNE 27, 1978, EPA INTERNAL MEMORANDUM, AND DECEMBER 11, 1979
LETTER FROM ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
/66/ NOVEMBER 9, 1979, LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
(A) EFFORTS TO IMPROVE SITE INVENTORIES;
(B) INITIAL CLEANUP COSTS;
(C) LIABILITIES ARISING FROM DAMAGES CAUSED BY SITES; AND
(D) ACTIONS FOR RECOVERY OF FEDERAL AND STATE EXPENDITURES.
A MAJOR PROBLEM WITH THE JUNE 27, 1979 MEMORANDUM ESTABLISHING THE
TASK FORCE (REFERRED TO ON P. 27), IS THAT IT DOES NOT REQUIRE MANDATORY
REPORTING BY THE REGIONS TO HEADQUARTERS AS TO LOCATIONS OF HAZARDOUS
WASTE SITES.
EPA ESTIMATES THAT THERE ARE 32,000 TO 50,000 SITES ACROSS THE
COUNTRY CONTAINING HAZARDOUS MATERIALS, OF WHICH 1,200-2,000 "MAY
CONTAIN SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND POSE SUBSTANTIAL
RISKS TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT." /L5/ HOWEVER, RELATIVE TO
THESE FIGURES, EPA INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT:
WE HAVE NO RELIABLE ESTIMATES OF FINANCIALLY LIABLE OWNERS BEYOND
THOSE TONTAINED IN THE EPA CONTRACT STUDY ENTITLED "PRELIMINARY
ASSESSMENT OF CLEAN-UP COSTS FOR NATIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTES PROBLEMS,"
FROM WHICH (OUR) FIGURE OF 32,000 TO 50,000 SITES WAS DERIVED. MANY OF
THOSE SITES HAVE NOT ACTUALLY BEEN LOCATED, AND THEREFORE DETERMINING
OWNERSHIP OR RESPONSIBILITY IS NOT YET POSSIBLE.
FURTHER, EPA INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE BY LETTER OF NOVEMBER 9, 1979,
THAT THE AGENCY HAD IDENTIFIED 1,536 POTENTIAL HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES OR
PROBLEMS AS OF OCTOBER 31, 1979. OF THESE, ONLY 532 SITES HAVE BEEN
INSPECTED. /66/
IT IS CLEAR THAT EPA ITSELF DOES NOT KNOW THE EXTENT OF THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE PROBLEM, MUCH LESS WHETHER THE ESTIMATED 30,000 TO 50,000 SITES
COULD BE CLASSIFIED AS ABANDONED, EXISTING, OR INACTIVE.
THE AGENCY COULD GREATLY ENHANCE ITS INVENTORY THROUGH THE
UTILIZATION OF THREE TOOLS PRESENTLY AT TIS DISPOSAL.
FIRST, EPA COULD REQUIRE MANDATORY REPORTING BY THE TEN REGIONS OF
ALL DISCOVERIES OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES. THE MECHANISM FOR SUCH
REPORTING IS IN PLACE AT THE PRESENT TIME. THE EPA HAS ESTABLISHED A
COMPUTERIZED LOGGING SYSTEM TO RECORD SITE INFORMATION. ENFORCEMENT OF
THE USE OF THIS SYSTEM, INCLUDING PERIODIC UPDATING, WOULD BE O GREAT
BENEFIT.
THE SECOND METHOD EPA COULD USE TO IMPROVE ITS SITE INVENTORY IS BY
FOLLOWING UP ON THE CHEMICAL INDUSTRY SITE SURVEY CONDUCTED BY THE HOUSE
INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN COMMERCE COMMITTEES' OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS
SUBCOMMITTEE, WHICH BEGAN AN INVESTIGATION INTO THE DISPOSAL OF
HAZARDOUS WASTES IN THE FALL OF 1978. THAT SUBCOMMITTEE, CHAIRED BY
REPRESENTATIVE BOB ECKHARDT OF TEXAS, CONDUCTED 13 DAYS OF HEARINGS ON
WASTE DISPOSAL AND THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
AMONG THE MANY ELEMENTS OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE ISSUE UNDER
INVESTIGATION BY THE SUBCOMMITTEE WAS EPA'S INADEQUATE SITE INVENTORY.
ACCORDINGLY, THE SUBCOMMITTEE CONDUCTED A SURVEY OF THE 53 LARGEST
DOMESTIC CHEMICAL COMPANIES TO ASCERTAIN HOW MANY SITES HAD RECEIVED
THEIR MANUFACTURING WASTES.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 037 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105334
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/67/ WASTE DISPOSAL SITE SURVEY. REPORT BY THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATION, COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN
COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, OCTOBER, 1979, SERIAL NO.
95-IFC 33, P. 111.
/68/ SUBCOMMITTEE STAFF INTERVIEW OF MAY 1979 WITH OFFICIALS OF THE
MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES.
THE SURVEY REVEALED THAT OF 1,604 FACILITIES OPERATED BY THE
COMPANIES SINCE 1950, 762 MILLION TONS OF CHEMICAL PROCESS WASTES WERE
DISPOSED OF AT 3,383 SITES. /67/
ALTHOUGH LIMITED TO THE 53 LARGEST CHEMICAL COMPANIES AND RESTRICTED
IN ITS DISCLOSURE OF LEVELS OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS AND DEGREE OF HAZARD
OF EACH SITE, THE SURVEY WAS THE FIRST MAJOR NATIONAL EFFORT TO COMPILE
A COMPREHENSIVE SITE INVENTORY.
THIRD, EPA COULD REVIEW ALL NATIONAL POLLUTANTS DISCHARGE ELIMINATION
SYSTEM (NPDES) PERMIT APPLICATIONS AND ALL PERMITTED FACILITIES
(PERMITTED UNDER THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT (FWPCA)) TO
DETERMINE WHAT ALTERNATE FORMS OF DISPOSAL HAVE BEEN UTILIZED TO TREAT
EFFLUENT DISCHARGES. THE SUBCOMMITTEE WAS LED TO THIS CONCLUSION BY THE
DISCOVERY OF THE UNSOUND DISPOSAL PRACTICES UTILIZED BY THE HOOKER
CHEMICALS AND PLASTICS CORPORATION AT ITS MONTAGUE, MICHIGAN
MANUFACTURING FACILITY.
THE HOOKER CHEMICALS AND PLASTICS CORPORATION, A SUBSIDIARY OF
OCCIDENTAL PETROLEUM, HAS OPERATED A PRODUCTION FACILITY ON A 880-ACRE
SITE NEAR MONTAGUE, MICHIGAN, ADJACENT TO LAKE MICHIGAN, SINCE 1952.
HOOKER MANUFACTURES AT THE FACILITY A WIDE RANGE FO CHLOR ALKALI
PRODUCTS AND, UNTIL 1977, THE PESTICIDE AND FIRE RETARDANT INGREDIENT
HEXACHLOROCYLOPENTADIENE, COMMONLY KNOWN AS C056.
THROUGH A SERIES OF ON-GOING EFFORTS TO ASSURE ADEQUATE WATER QUALITY
IN THE MONTAGUE AREA, THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
(MDNR) DISCOVERED IN THE SPRING OF 1976 AN UNLAWFUL DISCHARGE OF
CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS (BY-PRODUCTS OF C-56 PRODUCTION) INTO WHITE
LAKE, LOCATED JUST SOUTH OF THE HOOKER FACILITY. A DISCHARGE OF EFFUENT
WAS ALLOWED AT THIS FACILITY THROUGH THE ISSUANCE OF A NATIONAL
POLLUTANT DISCHARGE ELIMINATION SYSTEM (NPDES) PERMIT, WHICH WAS ISSUED
PURSUANT TO THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT (FWPCA). HOWEVER,
THIS PERMIT DID NOT AUTHORIZE THE DISCHARGE OF CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS.
/68/
IN MID-1976, THE MDNR RECEIVED EVIDENCE OF CONTAMINATION IN A PRIVATE
RESIDENTIAL WELL ON THE PROPERTY OF MR. AND MRS. W. G CARROLL. THIS
RESIDENCE IS LOCATED IMMEDIATELY SOUTH OF THE HOOKER FACILITY, BETWEEN
THE FACILITY AND WHITE LAKE. TESTING OF THE WELL DISCLOSED HARMFUL
LEVELS OF CHLOROFORM, TRICHLOROETHYLENE, AND A SAMLL CHAIN OF
CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS. THE DISCOVERY LED TO THE REQUIREMENT BY MDNR
OF HOOKER TO PERFORM A THOROUGH GROUNDWATER STUDY. AT THAT TIME MDNR
ALSO DETERMINED THAT A DIRECT EFFLUENT DISCHARGE FROM HOOKER'S
EQUALIZATION BASIN INTO WHITE LAKE, EVEN THOUGH PERMITTED THROUGH THE
ISSUANCE OF AN NPDES PERMIT, WAS UNACCEPTABLE.
IN FEBRUARY 1977, HOOKER NOTIFIED MDNR THAT IT WAS TERMINATING ITS
C-56 PRODUCTION FACILITY FOR ECONOMIC REASONS. THE DEPARTMENT BELIEVED
THAT THIS WAS DUE TO THE ECONOMIC BURDEN THAT WOULD BE IMPOSED TO TREAT
C-56 WASTE PROPERLY TO MEET MDNR LIMITATIONS ON DISCHARGE. THE
CONTINUING GROUNDWATER STUDY BY BY HOOKER WAS DISCLOSING INORDINATE
AMOUNTS OF CHLORIDE AND CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS.
IN AUGUST, 1977, FORMER HOOKER EMPLOYEE WARREN DOBSON FILED AN
AFFIDAVIT WITH THE COUNTY PROSECUTOR DISCLOSING ANOTHER DISCONCERTING
FACET OF THE UNFOLDING ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER CAUSED BY HOOKER.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 038 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105335
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/69/ SEE P. 51 FOR DESCRIPTION OF SECTION 3007 INSPECTION AUTHORITY.
THOSANDS OF 55-GALLON DRUMS CONTAINING VARIOUS DISTILLATION RESIDUES
FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF C-56 HAD BEEN LOADED ON TRUCKS AND DUMPED AT THE
NORTHERN END OF THE SITE.
IN MARCH, 1978, MDNR INSPECTED THE SITE TO DETERMINE THE EXTENT OF
POTENTIAL CONTAMINATION. TESTING OF THE CHEMICAL RESIDUES ESTABLISHED
THEIR CHEMICAL CONTENT: KEPONE, MIREX, WASTE FROM THE MANUFACTURE OF
C-56, VARIOUS CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS AND TCDD DIOXIN. THE RUSTED AND
LEAKING METAL DRUMS HAD EXUDED LARGE QUANTITIES OF THESE CHEMICAL
RESIDUES INTO THE SOIL.
FEARING THE LEACHING OF THESE WASTES INTO THE GROUNDWATER, AND
ULTIMATELY INTO PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL WELLS, WHITE LAKE, AND LAKE
MICHIGAN; ON FEBRUARY 2, 1979, MICHIGAN STATE ATTORNEY GENERAL FRANK
KELLEY FILED A CIVIL SUIT AGAINST HOOKER IN THE INGHAM COUNTY CIRCUIT
COURT SEEKING REMEDIAL ACTION AT THE MONTAGUE SITE. THAT SUIT RESULTED
IN AN OUT-OF-COURT SETTLEMENT BETWEEN THE STATE AND HOOKER ON OCTOBER
24, 1979, AND ENTAILED A PLAN FOR RECTIFYING THE ENVIRONMENTAL DAMAGE AT
A COST OF OVER $15 MILLION TO HOOKER.
1. PAST ACTIVITIES OF CERTAIN ELEMENTS OF THE CHEMICAL INDUSTRY CAN
AND HAVE RESULTED IN TREMENDOUS LEVELS OF ENVIRONMENTAL DIRUPTION.
2. ADEQUATE PUBLIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION CANNOT BE ACHIEVED
WITHOUT COMPLETE SCRUTINY OF THE DUMPING ACTIVITIES OF THE CHEMICAL
INDUSTRY. HAD DNR OR EPA USED SECTION 3007 INSPECTION AUTHORITY IN
DEVELOPING REGULATIONS UNDER RCRA, WHEN THE MONTAGUE PROBLEM FIRST CAME
UNDER PUBLIC SUSPICION, THE AGENCIES MAY HAVE STARTED EARLIER IN
PREVENTING OR MITIGATING THE ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTER. /69/
3. DNR AND/OR EPA COULD PREVENT ENVIRONMENTAL DISASTERS SUCH AS THAT
WHICH OCCURRED AT MONTAGUE BY THOROUGHLY REVIEWING THE ALTERNATE
DISPOSAL PLAN (TYPICALLY SUBMITTED WITH NPDES APPLICATIONS) IN THE
HOOKER SUBMISSION OF AN APPLICATION FOR AN NPDES PERMIT. AN
ADMINISTRATIVE POLICY DECISION WITHIN EPA TO SCRUTINIZE ALTERNATE
DISPOSAL PLANS UNDER NPDES PERMIT APPLICATIONS OWULD HAVE DISCLOSED OR
PREVENTED THE UNDESIRABLE DISPOSAL TECHNIQUES UTILIZED BY HOOKER.
ACCORDINGLY, THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT REQUIRING FACILITIES TO
OBTAIN AN NPDES PERMIT MAY HAVE THE EFFECT OF REDUCING THEIR EFFLUENT
DISCHARGE INTO NAVIGABLE WATERS, BUT MAY NOT PREVENT SUCH FACILITIES
FROM DISPOSING OF EFFLUENTS REMOVED FROM SUCH DISCHARGE IN AN UNSOUND
MANNER ON THE LAND.
4. CONGRESS, IN PARTICULAR THE OVERSIGHT AND INVESTIGATIONS
SUBCOMMITTEE AND ITS CHAIRMAN, BOB ECKHARDT, AND THE SURVEYED CHEMICAL
COMPANIES, INSTEAD OF EPA, HAVE MADE THE MOST AGGRESSIVE EFFORT TO DATE
IN IMPROVING THE SITE INVENTORY. THIS SUBCOMMITTEE CONCURS WITH
CHAIRMAN ECKHARDT THAT EPA HAS FAILED TO FULFILL THE SITE INVENTORY
RESPONSIBILITY ON ITS OWN. UNDERSTANDING THE MAGNITUDE OF THE GENERIC
ENVIRONMENTAL THREAT POSED BY HAZARDOUS WASTE IS THE FIRST AND MOST
IMPORTANT STEP TOWARD AFFORDING THE NATION ADEQUATE REGULATORY
PROTECTION.
1. THE SEVERITY OF THE ON-SITE DUMPING ACTIVITIES OF HOOKER
CHEMICALS IN MONTAGUE EXHIBITS A CLEAR NEED FOR GOVERNMENT TO ROUTINELY
INSPECT SUCH FACILITIES.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 039 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105336
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/70/ JULY 19, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P.6.
WHEN A STATE HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO OPERATE ITS OWN HAZARDOUS WASTE
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM UNDER RCRA, IT SHOULD USE ITS FULL AUTHORITY UNDER
SECTION 3007 TO INSPECT SUCH A FACILITY IN DEVELOPING RCRA REGULATIONS.
THE EPA SHOULD ASSUME THIS RESPONSIBILITY IN LIEU OF A STATE-AUTHORIZED
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM.
2. THE EPA SHOULD CAREFULLY REVIEW ALL ALTERNATE DISPOSAL PLANS
SUBMITTED BY ANY FACILITY APPLYING FOR AN NPDES PERMIT, CONCENTRATING ON
WHAT PRECISE METHOD OF DISPOSAL IS BEING USED TO TREAT EFFLUENTS REMOVED
FROM THE WATER DISCHARGE.
3. IN ORDER TO IMPROVE THE INVENTORY OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES, THE
SUBCOMMITTEE RECOMMENDS THAT EPA REVIEW ALL NPDES PERMIT APPLICATIONS
AND ALL PERMITTED FACILITIES TO DETERMINE WHAT ALTERNATE FORMS OF
DISPOSAL WILL BE OR ARE BEING UTILIZED TO TREAT THE EFFLUENT DISCHARGES.
SUCH A REVIEW MAY WELL ENLIGHTEN THE AGENCY AS TO WHAT ADDITIONAL
FACILITIES, SUCH AS HOOKER IN MONTAGUE, HAVE DISPOSED OF THESE AFFLUENT
MATERIALS IN AN ENVIRONMENTALLY UNSOUND MANNER ON THE LAND.
CURRENT EFFORTS OF EPA TO ESTABLISH A SYSTEM OF CONSOLIDATED
PERMITTING UNDER THE SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT, THE FEDERAL WATER
POLLUTION CONTROL ACT, THE UNDERGROUND INJECTION CONTROL ACT AND OTHER
FEDERAL STATUTES WILL GREATLY ASSIST IN THE DRIVE TO CHECK SHODDY
ALTERNATE DISPOSAL ACTIVITIES. HOWEVER, THESE CURRENT ACTIVITIES SHOULD
BE SUPPLEMENTED BY THE ABOVE-MENTIONED REVIEW TO UPDATE AN ADMITTEDLY
POOR INVENTORY.
4. THE INADEQUATE INVENTORY PROBLEM IS AGAIN IN THE HANDS OF EPA.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE RECOMMENDS THAT EPA BUILD ON THE OVERSIGHT AND
INVESTIGATIONS SUBCOMMITTEE'S SITE SURVEY. MAJOR TOOLS TO ENHANCE ITS
POOR INVENTORY ARE NOW WITHIN EPA'S GRASP, INCLUDING MANDATORY REGIONAL
REPORTING OF SITE DISCOVERIES, REVIEW OF ALL NPDES FACILITIES AND
FOLLOW-UP TO THE CONGRESSIONAL SITE SURVEY.
GOVERNMENTAL RESPONSE
TOW CASES IN PARTICULAR ILLUSTRATED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT AT ALL
LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT, PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH HAZARDOUS WASTE AND
CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION HAVE NOT BEEN ADEQUATELY RESPONDED TO. THE CASES
ARE HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN AND JACKSONVILLE, ARKANSAS.
CHAIRMAN LEVIN EXPRESSED THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S CONCERNS RELATIVE TO THIS
PROBLEM THE OPENING DAY OF HEARINGS:
THE ISSUES THE SUBCOMMITTEE WILL EXAMINE ARE ALL COMPLEX AND INCLUDE
THE GOVERNMENTAL RESPONSE TO THE HEALTH PROBLEMS AT HEMLOCK; THE
GOVERNMENT RESPONSE TO THE DIOXIN CONTAMINATION IN JACKSONVILLE,
ARKANSAS.
BUT MORE IMPORTANT STILL IS THE OVERRIDING ISSUE -- PROTECTION OF THE
PUBLIC FROM THE INVIDIOUS EFFECTS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE. WE NEED TO KEEP
AT ALL TIMES THE HUMAN FOCUS IN MIND AS WE CONDUCT THESE HEARINGS . . .
OUR GOAL SHOULD ALWAYS BE TO MAKE GOVERNMENT MORE RESPONSIVE AND
PROTECTIVE OF THE PUBLIC REGARDING . . . (HAZARDOUS) . . . WASTES AND
THEIR ADVERSE HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS. /70/
IN JUNE, 1979, THE SUBCOMMITTEE LEARNED OF A POTENTIAL CHEMICAL
CONTAMINATION PROBLEM IN AND AROUND THE AREA OF HEMLOCK, MICHIGAN.
FURHTER SUBCOMMITTEE INVESTIGATION DISCLOSED SERIOUS HUMAN AND ANIMAL
HEALTH DISORDERS THAT AS YET HAD NOT BEEN RESOLVED BY RESPONSIBLE STATE
AGENCIES.
HEMLOCK, A SMALL TOWN OF 2,000 TO 3,000 RESIDENTS, IS LOCATED IN THE
FREMONT AND RICHLAND TOWNSHIPS, 15 MILES WEST OF SAGINAW, MICHIGAN.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 040 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105337
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/72/ THE HEMLOCK AREA STUDY: AN INVESTIGATION INTO REPORTED HEALTH
PROBLEMS AND POSSIBLE WATER CONTAMINATION. MARCH, 1979. CHEMICALS &
HEALTH CENTER, MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH, P. 14.
/72/ INVESTIGATION OF GROUNDWATER QUALITY IN THE HEMLOCK AREA OF
SAGINAW COUNTY, MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES WATER QUALITY
DIVISION, GROUNDWATER COMMPLIANCE AND SPECIAL STUDIES SECTION, APRIL
1979, P. 18.
/73/ TESTIMONY OF CAROL JEAN KRUGER BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JULY 19, 1979.
/74/ JULY 19, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 22-23.
/75/ IS HEMLOCK BEING SLOWLY POISED? BROWN, MICHAEL H., NEW YORK
TIMES MAGAZINE, JULY 15, 1979.
AS THE AREA IS HIGHLY INDUSTRIALIZED, SEVERAL POSSIBLE SOURCES OF
CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION ARE SITUATED IN THE VICINITY OF HEMLOCK. AMONG
THEM ARE DOW CHEMICAL AND DOW CORNING LOCATED IN MIDLAND, MICHIGAN 20 TO
25 MILES NORTH OF THE HEMLOCK AREA.
AN ABNORMAL NUMBER OF HEALTH COMPLAINTS BY AREA RESIDENTS RESULTED IN
STUDIES BY THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH (MDPH) AND THE
MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES (MDNR) IN LATE 1978 AND EARLY
1979. THE MDPH STUDY, BASED ON A DOOR-TO-DOOR SURVEY OF HEMLOCK
RESIDENTS, CONCLUDED:
THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH, IN COOPERATION WITH THE
SAGINAW COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT, DISCOVERED A GREATER NUMBER OF HEALTH
CONPLAINTS IN THE (HEMLOCK) AREA THAN IN A COMPARISON TOWNSHIP AREA BUT
HAS BEEN UNABLE TO ESTABLISH A LINK BETWEEN THE COMPLAINTS AND PRIVATE
WELL WATER. /71/
SIMILARLY, THE REPORT BY MDNR CONCLUDED:
THIS STUDY HAS ATTEMPTED TO DETERMINE IF AQUIFERS IN THE HEMLOCK AREA
SHOW EVIDENCE OF ARTIFICAL CHEMCIAL CONTAMINATION. DATA COLLECTED THUS
FAR HAS NOT SHOWN ANY SUCH CONTAMINANT TO BE PRESENT. /72/
FURTHER SUBCOMMITTEE INQUIRY INDICATED THAT THERE WAS SUFFICIENT
ADVERSE EVIDENCE TO PRECLUDE THE "CLOSING OF THE BOOKS" BY THESE TWO
STATE AGENCIES.
CAROL JEAN KRUGER, A LIFETIME RESIDENT OF THE HEMLOCK AREA, BEGAN
OBSERVING PERSONAL HEALTH PROBLEMS AS EARLY AS 1968. AMONG THOSE WERE
SKIN PROBLEMS, DISCOLORATION OF THE EYES AND TEETH, WEAKENING OF TOOTH
ENAMEL, BACKACHES, FATIGUE, NIGHT BLINDNESS AND WEIGHT LOSS. IN
OCTOBER, 1977, AFTER PURCHASING FIVE TOP QUALITY PRODUCING HOLSTEIN
DAIRY COWS ONLY TO WATCH THEM DEVELOP DISABLING AILMENTS AND DIE OFF,
MRS. KRUGER BEGAN TO PIECE TOGETHER A HISTORY OF ANIMAL AS WELL AS HUMAN
HEALTH PROBLEMS THAT DATED BACK TO THE EARLY 1970S. /73/
MRS. KRUGER AND HER NEIGHBOR, KATHRYN JUNGNITSCH, TESTIFIED BEFORE
THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON JULY 19, 1979. THEIR PERSONAL INVESTIGATION INTO
AREA HEALTH PROBLEMS DISCLOSED A GRAPHIC DISPLAY OF WIDE-RANGING
AILMENTS IN LOCAL RESIDENTS; LUPUS, TUMOROUS CYSTS AND LUMPS, ONE CASE
OF A BRAIN TUMOR, BONE DISORDERS, CONVULSIONS, SPASMS, CANCER,
HIGH-BLOOD PRESSURE, HEART ATTACKS, GALL BLADDER, SPLEEN AND LIVER
PROBLEMS, HYSTERECTOMIES, MISCARRIAGES, STILLBIRTHS, BIRTH DEFECTS AND
KIDNEY AND BLADDER DISEASES.
MRS. KRUGER ALSO TESTIFIED IN REGARD TO AILMENTS AMONG HER ANIMALS,
INCLUDING HER HOLSTEIN DAIRY HERD, BELGIAN DRAFT HORSES,
HOGS,-ORNAMENTAL FOWL-AND-PEACOCKS..THESE-AILMENTS INCLUDED WEIGHTS
LOSS, LAMENESS, SWELLING, HAIR LOSS, CONSTANT BOUTS WITH MASTITIS,
RETARDED GROWTH, INABILITY TO DIGEST FEED, STERILITY AND ULTIMATELY,
DEATH. /74/ MILK PRODUCTION DROPPED FROM 25,000 POUNDS A YEAR DOWN TO
NEXT TO NONE BY 1978. IN ONE YEAR MRS. KRUGER LOST A TOTAL OF FORTY
ANIMALS. /75/
IN LATE 1977, CAROL JEAN DRUGER BEGAN HER PERSONAL INVESTIGATION INTO
THE PROBLEM TO DETERMINE ITS CAUSE. SHE WAS LATER JOINED BY KATHRYN
JUNGNITSCH, WHO ALONG WITH HER HUSBAND AND FAMILY, HAD ALSO SUFFERED
MYSTERIOUS HEALTH PROBLEMS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 041 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105338
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/76/ JULY 10, 1979 LETTER FROM DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, P. 3.
/77/ ID. PAGE 4.
/78/ TESTIMONY OF CAROL JEAN KRUGER BEFORE THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT, JULY 19, 1979.
IN THEIR SEARCH FOR THE ANSWER, THE TWO WOMEN CONTINUED TO COME UP
WITH THE SAME COMMON DENOMINATOR -- THE WATER. IN FACT, A SWITCH TO
DISTILLED WATER IN SEVERAL AREA RESIDENCES ALLEVIATED MOST, IF NOT ALL,
OF THE ADVERSE SYMPTOMS.
THE PREDOMINANT WATER SUPPLY OF MIDDLE MICHIGAN, INCLUDING THE
HEMLOCK AREA, IS THE GROUNDWATER AQUIFER. THIS VAST WATER SUPPLY IS
TAPPED BY A NUMBER OF PRIVATE AND MUNICIPAL GROUNDWATER WELLS.
MRS. KRUGER AND MRS. JUNGNITSCH, SUSPECTING CHEMCIAL CONTAMINATION,
SEARCHED OUT POSSIBLE SOURCES FOR CHEMICAL WASTES. THEIR ENSUING
EFFORTS DISCLOSED A VAST NETWORK OF BRINE PRODUCTION AND INJECTION WELLS
OWNED AND OPERATED BY DOW CHEMICAL COMPANY AT ITS MIDLAND, MICHIGAN
FACILITIES.
IN THE IMMEDIATE VICINITY OF HEMLOCK, DOW HAS INSTALLED 11 PRODUCTION
AND 5 INJECTION BRINE WELLS. RAW BRINE IS EXTRACTED FROM THE PRODUCTION
WELLS AND FED INTO A GATHERING SYSTEM OF BRINE LINES FOR TRANSPORTATION
TO DOW'S MIDLAND FACILITIES. THE EXTRACTED MATERIAL CONSISTS MAINLY OF
CALCIUM CHLORIDE, -MAGNESIUM CHLORIDE, SODIUM CHLORIDE, POTASSIUM
CHLORIDE, BROMINE, IODINE AND WATER. THROUGH A SERIES OF STEPS,
MATERIALS ARE EXTRACTED FOR DOW'S BROMINE-IODINE PLANT, MAGNESIUM
HYDROXIDE PLANT AND CALCIUM CHLORIDE PLANT. WHEN BROMINE, IODINE,
MAGNESIUM IONS AND CALCIUM IONS ARE EXTRACTED FOR THE THREE PLANTS, A
STREAM OF UNUSED MATERIALS IS SPLIT FROM THE PRODUCTION MATTER AT EACH
STEP. THE UNUSED, "SPENT" MATERIAL IS THAT WHICH IS DIVERTED INTO THE
INJECTION WELL SYSTEM. /76/
THE INJECTION WELL SYSTEM, COMPOSED OF A NETWORK OF BRINE LINES AND
DEEP WELLS, TRANSPORTS THE SPENT MATERIAL FROM THE MDILAND FACILITIES
BACK TO THE ORIGINAL GEOGRAPHIC FORMATIONS. THIS MATERIAL, COMMONLY
KNOWN AS "SPENT BRINE," IS INJECTED TO A DEPTH OF 1,500 TO 3,000 OR MORE
FEET, WHERE IT IS DEPOSITED IN VIRTUALLY NONPOROUS LIMESTONE FORMATIONS.
/77/
IT IS MRS. KRUGER'S BELIEF THAT THE SPENT BRINES ARE CONTAMINATED
WITH HAZARDOUS ORGANIC CHEMICAL WASTES, AND THAT THEY HAVE WORKED THEIR
WAY INTO THE GROUNDWATER AQUIFER -- EITHER BY GRADUAL UPWARD MIGRATION,
UPWARD PRESSURE FROM INJECTION OPERATIONS OR SEEPAGE UPWARD THROUGH OLD
ABANDONED OIL WELLS IN THE AREA. /78/
LARGELY DUE TO MRS. KRUGER'S CONTINUED EFFORTS, DOW CHEMICAL AND MDNR
CONDUCTED VARIOUS CHEMICAL DETECTION TESTS OF HER WELL WATER AND THAT OF
OTHERS NEARBY. THE MDNR INITIAL TESTING EXPANDED AND RESULTED IN A
COMPLETE GROUNDWATER STUDY.
THROUGH SUBCOMMITTEE HEARINGS HELD ON JULY 19, 1979, THE SUBCOMMITTEE
ATTEMPTED TO EVALUATE THE STUDIES PERFORMED BY THE TWO STATE AGENCIES TO
DETERMINE WHETHER THESE AGENCIES HAD ADEQUATELY RESPONDED TO CITIZENS
CONCERNS FOR THEIR HEALTH, SAFETY, AND LOCAL ENVIRONMENT.
THE HEARINGS DISCLOSED THE FOLLOWING POINTS HAD BEEN LEFT UNANSWERED
BY THE MDNR STUDY.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 042 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105339
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/79/ JULY 19, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PP. 103-106.
/80/ HAZARDOUS AND TOXIC EFFECTS OF INDUSTRIAL CHEMICALS. M. SITTIG,
NOYES DATA CORPORATION, PARKRIDGE, NEW JERSEY, 1979.
/80/ JULY 19, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, PGS. 108-10.
THERE HAD BEEN NO TESTING FOR THE CHEMICAL CONTAMINANT DIOXIN, A
HARMFUL BYPRODUCT OF A WIDE VARIETY OF INDUSTRIAL CHEMICAL PROCESSES.
THERE WERE NO EVALUATIONS OF THE SURFACE PONDS NEXT TO DOW BRINE
WELLS. SUCH EVALUATIONS MIGHT INDICATE A CORRELATION BETWEEN THE SPERT
BRINES AND COMPOUNDS DISCOVERED IN THE LOCAL WELLS.
THERE WAS NO LONG-TERM WELL MONITORING AND SURVEILLANCE PROGRAM
CONDUCTED BY MDNR TO IDENTIFY FLUCTUATIONS IN TRACE LEVELS OF
CONTAMINANTS.
THERE WAS NO COMPLETE STUDY OF GROUNDWATER PATTERNS TO DETERMINE FLOW
AND DIRECTION OF GROUNDWATER.
THERE WAS NO TESTING OF WELL BOTTOM SEDIMENTS TO IDENTIFY
"SETTLED-OUT" CONTAMINANTS. /79/
THE MDNR, HOWEVER, HAD IDENTIFIED TRACE LEVELS OF ORGANIC
CONTAMINANTS IN HEMLOCK WELLS INCLUDING POLYCHLORINATED BIPHENOLS
(PCBS), CARBON TETRACHLORIDE AND PHTHALATES. IN ADDITION, AN
INDEPENDNET ANALYSIS PERFORMED FOR AND AT THE EXPENSE OF LOCAL RESIDENTS
DISCLOSED TRACE LEVELS OF DIETHYL ETHER, 1.1.2-TRICHLOROTRIBLUOROETHANE,
TRICHLOROETHYLENE AND TOLUENE, ALL HARMFUL ORGANIC CONTAMINANTS. IN
FACT, PCBS ARE KNOWN TO CAUSE LIVER DAMAGE IN HUMANS. TRICHLOROETHYLENE
(TCE) AND CARBON TETRACHLORIDE AHVE BEEN SHOWN TO CAUSE CANCER IN
LABORATORY ANIMALS AND HUMAN AILMENTS IMILAR TO SOME OF THOSE EXHIBITED
IN HEMLOCK RESIDENTS. /80/
CHARIMAN LEVIN SUMMED UP THE SITUATION AS FOLLOWS:
SENATOR LEVIN: "THERE ARE SOME FOLKS WHO ARE VERY UNDERSTANDABLY
DISTURBED BY WHAT THEY SEE, BY WHAT THEY FEEL, AND THEN THEY GET REPORTS
THAT SCIENTISTS AT THE HEALTH DEPARTMENT FIND THAT THERE IS A HEALTH
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THEIR AREA AND ANOTHER AREA. AND THE ONLY WAY
THEY'VE MEASURED IS BY ANALYZING COMPLAINTS.
"YOUR (MDNR) REPORT FINDS SOME INDICATORS OF PROBLEMS, BUT YOU CAN'T
SAY THAT YOU KNOW THE CAUSE OF THE PROBLEM OR THAT YOU FOUND THE CAUSE
OF THE PROBLEM. THEN YOU SAY AT ONE POINT THAT THE BIOASSAY (ORGANIC
ANALYSIS OF WATER) DID NOT GIVE STRONG EVIDENCE THAT A CHEMICAL
CONTAMINANT WAS PRESENT IN THE GROUNDWATER, NOR DID IT COMPLETELY RULE
OUT THE POSSIPILITY. IN OTHER WORDS, IT'S INCONCLUSIVE, THE WAY IT'S
WRITTEN. IN THE SUMMARY, HOWEVER, YOU WRITE THAT SAMPLING OF WATER
SUPPLY WELLS IN THE HEMLOCK AREA HAS NOT DEMONSTRATED ORGANIC CHEMICAL
CONTAMINANTS TO BE PRESENT."
MR. BAILS: (MDNR) "THAT'S ABSOLUTELY RIGHT."
SENATOR LEVIN: YOU DON'T SAY, ". . . NOR IS IT DEMONSTRATED THEY ARE
NOT."
MR. BAILS: "DEMONSTRATES THAT THOSE THAT WERE TESTED FOR AN REPORTED
IN THE REPORT WERE -OT THERE. IT DOESN'T RULE OUT THAT THERE ISN'T ANY
POSSIBILITY . . ."
SENATOR LEVIN: "THEN AREN'T YOU IN ESSENCE SAYING YOU CAN'T FIND THE
CONTAMINATION? ISN'T THAT THE ESSENCE OF YOUR REPORT?"
DR. TANNER: (MDNR) "NOT YET, WE HAVEN'T." /81/
AND YET, IN REFERRING TO AN MDNR LETTER TO EPA AT AN EARLIER POINT IN
THE HEARINGS:
SENATOR LEVIN: "THE DEPARTMENT HAS RANKED VARIOUS ENVIRONMENTAL
EFFORTS IN TERMS OF THEIR PRIORITY FOR CONSIDERATION FOR APPLICATION OF
SECTION 208 FUNDS. IN PAGE 3 OF THE FIRST ATTACHMENT, ABOUT HALFWAY
DOWN THE PAGE, YOU WILL SEE THAT WE'VE UNDERSCORED THE HEMLOCK
GROUNDWATER SAMPLING PROBLEM. THERE'S A ZERO AT THE LEFT AND THE TOP OF
THAT COLUMN TO INDICATE APPARENTLY A ZERO PRIORITY RATING TO THAT
EFFORT. IS THAT ACCURATE, OR IS MY READING OF THIS ACCURATE . . .?"
"IF YOU'LL LOOK AT PAGE ONE OF THAT LETTER, IT SAYS THAT THE STATE OF
MICHIGAN CERTIFIED THAT THOSE ELEMENTS IN THE AREA PROGRAMS RANK HIGHER
THAN ZERO, SO I PRESUME THAT ZERO IS THE LOWEST RANKING ON THAT."
"YOU APPARENTLY GIVE THE HEMLOCK GROUNDWATER SAMPLING PROBLEM A ZERO
PRIORITY. THE BASIC QUESTION IS, AM I READING THAT RIGHT?"
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 043 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105340
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/82/ JULY 19, 1979 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 74-75.
EXHIBIT I: JULY 3, 1979 LETTER TO MR. CHARLES H. SUTFIN, DIRECTOR,
WATER DIVISION, EPA, REGION V, FROM RONALD B. WILLSON CHIEF, WATER
QUALITY MANAGEMENT PLANNING SECTION, DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES,
MICHIGAN.
/83/ JULY 26, 1979 LETTER FROM THE EAST CENTRAL MICHIGAN PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT REGION TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT.
/84/ JULY 19, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 37.
/85/ SEPTEMBER 4, 1979, LETTER FROM JOHN MCGUIRE, REGION V
ADMINISTRATOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
MR. MARKS: (MDNR) "SENATOR, I THINK IT DEPENDS. THIS IS VIEWING
WHAT LOCAL AGENCIES WOULD DO, THE LOCAL 208 AGENCIES, AND SOME OF THEIR
ABILITY TO DO THAT KIND OF WORK. IT DOESN'T NECESSARILY REFLECT THAT
THE PROBLEM HAS NO PRIORITY . . ." /82/
MR. MARKS' ACCOUNT OF THE PRIORITY RATING, HOWEVER, BECOMES
QUESTIONABLE IN LIGHT OF INFORMATION PROVIDED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE BY THE
LOCAL 208 PLANNING AGENCY, THE EAST CENTRAL MICHIGAN PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT REGION (ECMPDR). IN A JULY 26 LETTER TO SUBCOMMITTEE STAFF
FROM JIM SYGO, CHIEF ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNER OF ECMPDR, THE LOCAL AGENCY
VIEW OF THE PRIORITY RATING IS CLEARLY STATED:
THE PRIORITY OF ZERO IS NOT INDICATIVE OF THIS AGENCY'S CAPABILITY TO
COMPLETE THE PROPOSED WORK, AS IT HAS BEEN STATED IN THE HEARING RECORD
AND LOCAL NEWSPAPERS. THE PROJECT WAS PRIORITIZED ZERO FOR ONE OF TWO
REASONS: EITHER THE PROPOSED WORK THAT HAS BEEN OR IS SCHEDULED TO BE
COMPLETED BY STATE PERSONNEL, OR THE PROPOSED WORK WAS CONSIDERED
INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE STATE'S FIVE-YEAR STRATEGY, RANKING PRIORITY
POLLUTANT PROBLEMS FROM A STATE PERSPECTIVE. (EMPHASIS ADDED)
THE PERFORMANCE RECORD AS A 208 PLANNING AGENCY IN THIS STATE AND EPA
REGION V HAS BEEN EXCELLENT, AS CAN BE ATTESTED TO BY BOTH STATE AND EPA
208 PROJECT OFFICERS. /83/
CAROL JEAN KRUGER WROTE A LETTER TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY'S REGION V OFFICE ON DECEMBER 15, 1977, APPEALING TO THE AGENCY
FOR HELP IN IDENTIFYING THE CAUSE(S) OF THE HEALTH PROBLEMS IN HEMLOCK.
SHE NEVER RECEIVED A REPLY TO THAT LETTER. /84/
PRIOR TO THE HEARING OF JULY 19, 1979, THE SUBCOMMITTEE REQUESTED
FROM EPA REGION V AN EVALUATION OF THE HEMLOCK STUDIES PERFORMED BY MDPH
AND MDNR. THE SUBCOMMITTEE RECEIVED THE EVALUATION ALONG WITH PROPOSALS
FOR FURTHER STUDY FROM EPA IN A SEPTEMBER 4, 1979 LETTER FROM EPA. /85/
THE SUBCOMMITTEE CONCURRED WITH THE SUGGESTED PROPOSALS AND ARRANGED FOR
A TOWN MEETING IN HEMLOCK WHEREIN EPA WAS TO INFORM AREA RESIDENTS OF
ITS UPCOMING EFFORTS TO ISOLATE AND ALLEVIATE THE CAUSE(S) OF THE HEALTH
AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEMS.
IN COOPERATION WITH MDNR, MDPH AND THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR DISEASE
CONTORL, EPA LAUNCHED A MAJOR EFFORT TO DETERMINE WHAT IS HAPPENING IN
HEMLOCK, AND WHAT SOLUTIONS ARE AVAILABLE.
CORPORATION
AS EARLY AS 1955, JACKSONVILLE RESIDENTS BEGAN TO NOTICE SYMPTOMS
ATTRIBUTABLE TO WATER POLLUTION IN THE BAYOU METRO AREA. THE ARKANSAS
GAME AND FISH COMMISSION COMPILED A REPORT ON THE PROBLEM AND CIRCULATED
IT TO VARIOUS STATE AND INDUSTRY OFFICIALS, BUT NO FURTHER ACTION WAS
TAKEN. IN 1957, POLLUTION WAS TRACED TO THE EFFLUENT DISCHARGE OF THE
REASOR HILL COMPANY.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE TRACED WHAT IS NOW A TREMENDOUS ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARD
IN JACKSONVILLE BACK IN 1975 AND REASOR HILL'S OPERATIONS. SINCE THAT
TIME, THAT COMPANY'S SITE HAS CHANGED OWNERSHIP THREE TIMES:
(1) FROM REASON HILL TO HERCULES POWER COMPANY
(2) FROM HERCULES TO THE TRANSVAAL CORPORATION;
(3) FROM TRANSVAAL TO THE VERTAC CORPORATION.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 044 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105341
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/86/ JULY 19 SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 7.
THE LAST THREE COMPANIES WERE ALL MANUFACTURERS OF 2.4.5
TRICHLOROPHENOL (2.4.5-T), THE WIDELY USED HERBICIDE WHICH IS PRIMARY
INGREDIENT OF "AGENT ORANGE," A DEFOLIANT USED IN VIETNAM AND IN SEVERAL
AREAS OF THE UNITED STATES. A KNOWN BY-PRODUCT OF 2.4.5-T IS THE DEADLY
CHEMICAL COMPOUND, TETRACHLORO-DIBENZO-P-DIOXIN (TCDD), WHICH IS
CONSIDERED BY MANY EXPERTS TO BE ONE OF THE DEADLIEST CHEMICALS IN
EXISTENCE. IN 1964 SAMPLES OF AREA WATER WERE TESTED AND EXHIBITED A
LEVEL OF 27.7 PPM (PARTS PER MILLION) OF 2.4.5-T.
THROUGHOUT THE HISTORY OF THE CONTAMINATION PROBLEMS IN THE
JACKSONVILLE AREA, GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES HAVE TAKEN INADEQUATE STEPS TO
PROTECT LOCAL HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
IN LATE 1977, AS A RESULT OF A RECOMMENDATION BY SENATOR MARK
HATFIELD, EPA BEGAN AN IN-DEPTH STUDY INTO THE PRESENCE OF DIOXINS IN
WASTES GENERATED BY HERBICIDE PRODUCTION FACILITIES. THE VERTAC
FACILITY IN JACKSONVILLE WAS INCLUDED IN THAT STUDY AND ULTIMATELY THE
PRESENCE AT HIGH LEVELS OF TCDD DIOXIN IN THE VERTAC WASTES DEMONSTRATED
A NEED FOR EPA TO PERFORM A PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE SITE AND TO
BEGIN DEVELOPING CLEAN-UP STRATEGIES. CURRENTLY, CLEANUP OPERATIONS ARE
UNDER WAY DUE TO A STATE ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER JOINTLY DEVELOPED BY EPA
AND ARKANSAS. ENFORCEMENT STRATEGIES FOR RECOVERY OF FUNDS USED FOR
CLEANUP ALSO PRESENTLY ARE BEING CONSIDERED.
THE INABILITY OF THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES (MDNR)
TO IDENTIFY THE SOURCE OF PROBLEMS IN HEMLOCK IS INDICATIVE OF A LACK OF
GOVERNMENTAL RESPONSE TO AN APPARENT ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARD. LOCAL
RESIDENTS SHOULD NOT HAVE HAD TO INCURE PERSONAL FINANCIAL LIABILITY IN
AN ATTEMPT TO IDENTIFY THE SOURCE OF APPARENT CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION.
2. THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY (EPA) DID NOT SUFFICIENTLY
OVERSEE THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION EFFORTS OF THE STATE OF MICHIGAN IN
THE HEMLOCK CASE.
3. MDNR, BECAUSE OF ITS ZERO PRIORITY RATING ASSIGNED TO THE HEMLOCK
GROUNDWATER PROBLEM, EFFECTIVELY BLOCKED ANY FURTHER EFFORTS TO SOLVE
THE HEMLOCK MYSTERY. SUCH A RATING WOULD HAVE PRVENTED ANY TYPE OF
FUNDING -- 208 OR OTHER -- TO BE ALLOCATED FOR FURTHER STUDY IN THE
HEMLOCK AREA.
4. CAUSES OF CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION ARE NOT ALWAYS READILY
IDENTIFIABLE, AND THEREFORE REQUIRE THOROUGH AND PERSISTENT ATTENTION.
5. EPA FAILES TO RESPOND TO A PRIVATE CITIZEN'S PLEA FOR HELP IN THE
AREA OF RESPONSIBILITY THAT THE AGENCY WAS CREATED FOR ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION.
AS SENATOR COHEN POINTED OUT DURING THE HEARINGS, WITH REGARD TO THE
GOVERNMENT'S OBLIGATION TO RESPOND:
TODAY, WE HAPPEN TO BE FOCUSING UPON MICHIGAN, BUT I THINK IT'S WITH
THE UNDERSTANDING THAT THE HORROR OF HEMLOCK IS BUT ONE EPISODE IN THE
TRAGEDY OF MAN'S EFFORTS TO HARNESS THE BENEFITS OF NATURE WITHOUT
DESTROYING HIMSELF IN THE PROCESS. AND THE QUESTIONS THAT WE ARE GOING
TO TRY TO ADDRESS, I DON'T BELIEVE REQUIRE AN ESOTERIC KNOWLEDGE OF
TOXICOLOGY. THEY DON'T REQUIRE A DOCTORAL DEGREE IN GEOPHYSIOLOGY OR IN
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING. THEY ARE QUESTIONS FOR EVERY MAN AND WOMAN WHO IS
CAPABLE OF SOUND JUDGMENT. IN SHORT, THEY ARE VERY BASIC QUESTIONS
ABOUT RESPONSIBILITY. /86/
6. THE SUBCOMMITTEE IS VERY CONCERNED THAT SOME GOVERNMENTAL
OFFICIALS WERE GENERALLY AWARE OF PUBLIC CONCERN OVER POLLUTION PROBLEMS
IN THE JACKSONVILLE AREA AND THAT LITTLE REMEDIAL ACTION WAS TAKEN UNTIL
1979.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 045 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105342
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
A VARIETY OF PRESS ACCOUNTS IN THE STATE INDICATE THAT GENERAL PUBLIC
CONCERN WAS EXPRESSED ABOUT THIS POLLUTION AS EARLY AS 1955. NOT UNTIL
SENATOR HATFIELD URGED EPA TO LOOK INTO A GENERIC HERBICIDE PRODUCTION
PROBLEM WAS ANY SUBSTANTIAL ACTION TAKEN. HAD VERTAC AND ITS
PREDECESSORS NOT BEEN IN THE HERBICIDE BUSINESS, ACTION MAY STILL HAVE
NOT BEEN TAKEN TO ELIMINATE THE POLLUTION PROBLEM.
7. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT THE TWO-YEAR LAG BETWEEN SEN.
HATFIELD'S RECOMMENDATION AND CLEANUP EFFORTS AT VERTAC IS AN INORDINATE
AMOUNT OF TIME FOR AN AGENCY RESPONSE.
1. EPA REGIONAL AND HEADQUARTERS OFFICES SHOULD IMMEDIATELY
INSTITUTE A POLICY OF PROVIDING A PROMPT WRITTEN RESPONSE TO ANY
INDIVIDUAL OR GROUP THAT IS CONCERNED OVER ANY SUSPECTED ENVIRONMENTAL
PROBLEM. SUCH A RESPONSE SHOULD INCLUDE A STATEMENT OF WHETHER THE
AGENCY HAS SUFFICIENT JURISDICTION AND FUNDING TO TAKE ACTION ON THE
PROBLEM, A DESCRIPTION OF ANY ACTION TAKEN OR PLANNED BY EPA OR A STATE
OR LOCAL ENTITY WITH REGARD TO THE PROBLEM, AND A REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION IF APPROPRIATE. EPA SHOULD THEN TAKE ACTION ON THE PROBLEM
OR REFER IT TO THE STATE SO THAT APPROPRIATE STEPS AMY BE TAKEN.
2. EPA SHOULD ALWAYS COMMUNICATE WITH LOCAL RESIDENTS, EITHER BY
LETTER OR THROUGH PUBLIC MEETINGS, ON ANY ACTIONS THE AGENCY PLANS TO
TAKE IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION WHICH WILL IN ANY WAY EFFECT THE
PARTICULAR LOCAL COMMUNITY.
3. AS WAS ULTIMATELY THE CASE IN THE HEMLOCK SITUATION, THE EPA
SHOULD ROUTINELY COMMUNICATE AND COOPERATE WITH THE APPROPRIATE STATE
AND FEDERAL AGENCIES, ICNLUDING THE NATIONAL CENTER FOR DISEASE CONTROL,
WHEN APPROPRIATE, WHEN RESPONDING TO A PUBLIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION CONCERN.
4. STATE AGENCIES, SUCH AS MDNR, SHOULD AVOID RANKING CASES ON A
PRIORITY BASIS WHEN SUCH RANKING COULD BE SO MISCONSTRUCED AS TO BLOCK
ANY FURTHER FUNDING AVENUES FOR HANDLING SUCH CASES.
5. STATE OFFICIALS SHOULD ROUTINELY NOTIFY EPA REGIONAL OFFICES OF
SUSPECTED HAZARDOUS WASTE SITE PROBLEMS. EPA SHOULD EXERCISE ITS
RESPONSIBILITY UNDER RCRA TO OVERSEE STATE ACTION FOR A DETERMINATION OF
ITS ADEQUACY. WHERE APPROPRIATE, EPA AND THE STATE SHOULD JOINTLY
DEVELOP STRATEGIES TO MITIGATE THE HAZARD, AND IF THE STATE SHOWS
RELUCTANCE TO TAKE ACTION, EPA SHOULD ASSUME THE RESPONSIBILITY (AS IS
ENVISIONED IN THE LEGISLATIVE HISTORY OF RCRA).
NOTING CONGRESS' DESIRE TO IMPLEMENT RCRA PRIMARILY THROUGH
AUTHORIZED STATE PROGRAMS, THE SUBCOMMITTEE SOUGHT INFROMATION TO
ASCERTAIN WHAT LEVEL OF COOPERATION EXISTS BETWEEN EPA AND THE STATES,
AND TO WHAT EXTENT EPA WAS PROVIDING TECHNICAL AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE
TO STATES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF STATE HAZARDOOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT
PROGRAMS. A PARTICULAR CONCERN IS THE LEVEL OF ASSISTANCE PROVIDED TO
STATES FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION IN HAZARDOUS WASTE SITUATIONS PRIOR TO THE
PROMULGATION OF SUBTITLE C REGULATIONS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 046 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105343
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/87/ JULY 11, 1979 LETTER FROM EUGENE F. MOONEY, SECRETARY KENTUCKY
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/88/ JULY 27, 1979 LETTER FROM TERRY HOFFMAN, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,
MINNESOTA POLLUTION CONTROL AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF
GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/89/ SEPTEMBER 27, 1979 LETTER FROM HOWARD A TANNER, DIRECTOR,
MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES, TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON
OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
WITH RESPECT TO STATE-FEDERAL EFFORTS TO REMEDY THE ENVIRONMENTAL
DISASTER CAUSED BY THE "VALLEY OF THE DRUMS" NEAR LOUISVILLE, EUGENE
MOONEY, SECRETARY OF THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION, INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT:
THE STATE WAS NOT GIVEN SUFFICIENT NOTIFICATION PRIOR TO THE OUTSITE
APPEARANCE OF THE EPA (REGION IV) TEAM, NOR WAS THE STATE CONSULTED AS
TO THE EXTENT, AND DESIGN OF THE CLEAN-UP EFFORT. IT IS THE STATE'S
OPINION THAT A MORE COST-EFFECTIVE CLEAN-UP COULD HAVE BEEN ACHIEVED
WITH GREATER COOPERATIVE PLANNING. SOME OF THE MEASURES MAY HAVE BEEN
UNNECESSARY IN RETROSPECT. /87/
SIMILARLY, THE MINNESOTA POLLUTION CONTROL AGENCY ADVISED THE
SUBCOMMITTEE THAT:
THE EPA AND THE STATE HAVE CONFLICTING HAZARDOUS WASTE PRIORITIES.
WE BOTH SHARE THE GOAL OF ESTABLISHING A PROGRAM TO IDENTIFY HAZARDOUS
WASTES AND MONITOR THEIR MANAGEMENT FROM "CRADLE-TO-GRAVE". THIS NEEDS
TO BE A NUMBER ONE PRIORITY WITH BOTH STATE AND FEDERAL AGENCIES.
HOWEVER, TI TAKES TIME TO DEVELOP A SUFFICIENTLY STAFFED AND EXPERIENCED
PROGRAM. THE TENDENCY TO PROCEED ON AS MANY OTHER FRONTS AS POSSIBLE,
AND THE CONFLICT COMES WITH RESPECT TO THE PRIORITY GIVEN TO NEW SITE
DEVELOPMENT GOALS AND ABANDONED SITE CLEANUP BOALS. IN MINNESOTA, OUR
BIGGEST CONSTRAINT TO SUCCESSFUL RCRA IMPLEMENTATION IS INADEQUATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT CAPACITY. THE DEVELOPMENT OF NEW FACILITIES
IS A HIGH PRIORITY ISSUE. THE EPA DECIDED IN 1973 THAT SITING OF NEW
FACILITIES WAS PRIMARILY AND APPROPRIATELY A STATE OBJECTIVE AND
ABANDONED ITS STUDY OF REGIONAL FEDERAL SITES. EVEN SO, EPA HAZARDOUS
WASTE PROGRAM GOALS SHOULD ENCOURAGE STATE INITIATIVES TO PLAN FOR AND
SITE NEW FACILITIES. HOWEVER, WE FEAR THAT THE EPA EMPHASIS ON
ABANDONED SITES COULD, WHEN COUPLED WITH THEIR INCREASED CONTROL OVER
THE STATE PROGRAM, FRUSTRATE STATE SITING GOALS . . . THE EMOTIONS
INDUCED ARE COUNTER-PRODUCTIVE TO THE NATIONAL PROCESS OF IDENTIFYING
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT NEEDS AND CONDUCTING RISK BENEFIT ANALYSES.
IN ADDITION, UNLESS THE PRIMACY OF THE FACILITY SITING EFFORTS IS
RECOGNIZED, THE EMPHASIS ON PERMIT PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT WOULD TEND TO
SHIFT TO THE VERY VISIBLE CLOSING OF FACILITIES AND REMEDIAL ACTION FOR
ABANDONED SITES.
IF THE EPA IS TO ENCOURAGE STATE INITIATIVES IN DEALING WITH STATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PRIORITIES, THEN THEY MUST BE FLEXIBLE IN ADMINISTERING
THE RCRA PROGRAM. /88/
IT APPEARS, HOWEVER, THAT IN MANY AREAS COOPERATION BETWEEN STATE
AGENCIES AND EPA REGIONAL OFFICES RECENTLY HAS INCREASED SIGNIFICANTLY.
FOR EXAMPLE, MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES DIRECTOR HOWARD
TANNER INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT WITH RESPECT TO EPA REGION V:
UNFORTUNATELY, THE EPA AND MY AGENCY HAVE HAD SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES
IN ENFORCEMENT PRIORITIES IN THE PAST . . . NEW LEADERSHIP IN THE REGION
AND A NEW EPA EMPHASIS UNDER RCRA AND TOSCA (TOXIC SUBSTANCES CONTROL
ACT) HAVE CHANGED THIS PAST PROBLEM. WE HAVE HAD SEVERAL MEETINGS WITH
THE EPA IN RECENT MONTHS TO ESTABLISH JOINT PRIORITIES, AND COOPERATIVE
EFFORTS ARE PROCEEDING IN A NUMBER OF AREA. /89/
DURING THE SUBCOMMITTEE'S INQUIRY A NUMBER OF STATE ATTORNEYS BENERAL
WERE PROBED ON THE NEED FOR FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR STATE ENFORCEMENT
ACTIONS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES. CLEARLY, THE EFFECTIVENESS OF STATE
ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS IS DEPENDENT UPON RESOURCES PROVIDED FOR CASE
DEVELOPMENT.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 047 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105344
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/90/ JUNE 19, 1979 LETTER FROM ELDON G. KAUL, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY
GENERAL, STATE OF MINNESOTA, OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/91/ JUNE 28, 1979 LETTER FROM PAUL N. MEANS, ASSISTANT ATTORNEY
GENERAL, STATE AGENCIES DIVISION, STATE OF ARKANSAS, OFFICE OF THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL, TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT
MANAGEMENT.
/92/ JUNE 13, 1979 LETTER FROM C. RAYMOND MARVIN, COUNSEL, NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF ATTORNEYS GENERAL TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF
GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
A SAMPLING OF ATTORNEY GENERAL RESPONSES DEMONSTRATES THE NEED FOR
ADDITONAL FINANCIAL SUPPORT TO SUCH OFFICES FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS:
IF DIRECT FEDERAL FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO STATE ATTORNEYS' GENERAL
OFFICES IS GRANTED ONLY TO PROVIDE ADDITONAL LEGAL EXPERTISE THEN SUCH
FUNDING WOULD NOT BE EFFECTIVE. WHAT IS NEEDED IS ADDITIONAL FUNDING TO
PERFORM TECHNICAL ASSESSMENTS (E.G., HYDROGEOLOGIC STUDIES AND AIR
MONITORING) OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SITES COUPLED WITH DIRECT FUNDING OF
STATE ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES. THESE TECHNICAL ASSESSMENTS COULD BE
CARRIED OUT DIRECTLY BY THE EPA, STATE ENVIRONMENTAL AGENCIES, OR
THROUGH CONTRACTS WITH PRIVATE CONSULTING FIRMS. IN MY OPINION, STATE
ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES SHOULD PLAY A MAJOR ROLE IN COORDINATING
THESE TECHNICAL ASSESSMENTS TO ENSURE THE ENFORCEABILITY OF ANY REQUIRED
LEGAL ACTION. /90/
OUR OFFICE HAS BEEN HAMPERED BY A SHORTAGE OF MANPOWER AND RESOURCES
TO DEVOTE TO HAZARDOUS WASTE ENFORCEMENT. THERE IS LITTLE STATE MONEY
AVAILABLE AT THE PRESENT TIME TO EMPLOY ADDITIONAL STAFF TO DEAL WITH
HAZARDOUS WASTE AND TO COVER THE COST OF ENFORCEMENT. FEDERAL FINANCIAL
ASSISTANCE TO EMPLOY STAFF AND TO AID IN COVERING THE COST OF
INVESTIGATION, PREPARATION AND ENFORCEMENT WILL BE CRITICAL TO A RAPID
EXPANSION OF THE ENVORCEMENT EFFORTS BY THE ATTORNEY GENERAL. /91/
SIMILAR SENTIMENTS WERE EXPRESSED TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE BY A NUMBER OF
ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES, STATE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCIES, AND
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ATTORNEYS GENERAL (NAAG). THE NAAG
ELABORATED ON THE NEED AND POSSIBLE MECHANISMS FOR SUCH SUPPORT AS
FOLLOWS:
THE COSTS OF ENVIRONMENTAL LITIGATION ARE STEADILY GROWING IN
RESPONSE TO THE GROWTH OF NUMEROUS FEDERAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROGRAMS,
REGULATIONS AND LEGISLATION. CLEAN AIR AND WATER, HAZARDOUS WASTE
DISPOSAL AND MANAGEMENT, OPEN DUMP MATTERS AND SO ON REQUIRE AN ARSENAL
OF LEGAL AND SCIENTIFIC TALEN WHICH IMPOSES CONSIDERABLE STRAIN ON
ALREADY STRETCHED STATE BUDGETS.
IT WOULD BE VERY HELPFUL IF THE CONGRESS RECOGNIZED THIS PROBLEM AND
SOUGHT SOME SOLUTION WHICH WOULD HELP TO DEFRAY THE STATES' COSTS OF
ENVIRONMENTAL LITIGATION. ALLOCATION OF FUNDS DIRECTLY TO THE ATTORNEYS
GENERAL IS IMPORTANT. THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY RECENTLY
AMENDED 40 CFR 35.1016(B) TO PROVIDE THAT THE DESIGNATED GRANT RECEIPT
AGENCY IN EACH STATE COULD REPROGRAM MONEY CURRENTLY AVAILABLE WITH THE
APPROVAL OF THE REGIONAL ADMINISTRATOR. THIS AMENDMENT FAILS TO ASSURE
THAT MONIES AVAILABLE FOR THIS REALLOCATION WILL IN FACT BE MADE
AVAILABLE TO THE ATTORNEYS GENERAL TO SUPPORT ACTUAL ENFORCEMENT.
SOME FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO STATE ATTORNEYS GENERAL FOR ENFORCEMENT
OF ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS WILL PRODUCE WIDESPREAD BENEFITS TO ALL CITIZENS,
WHETHER THIS ASSISTANCE OCCURS THROUGH A SEPARATE AUTHORIZATION AND
APPROPRIATIONS BILL FOR ENVIRONMENTAL LITIGATION SUPPORT TO STATE
ATTORNEYS GENERAL OR WHETHER EXISTING FUNDS ARE REPROGRAMMED DIRECTLY TO
ATTORNEYS GENERAL. /92/
1. AS THE CONTROL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES IS A RELATIVELY NEW CONCEPT,
THE SUBCOMMITTEE RECOGNIZES THE OCCURRENCE OF STAFFING AND MANAGEMENT
DEFICIENCIES IN PROVIDING TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO STATES. HOWEVER, MDNR
AND EPA REGION V HAVE SHOWN THAT FEDERAL AND STATE AGENCIES CAN OVERCOME
SUCH DEFICIENCIES THROUGH INCREASING COOPERATION AND JOINTLY DEVELOPING
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT PRIORITIES.
2. EPA REGION V HAS OPENED THE DOOR TO AGGRESSIVE FEDERAL ACTION IN
ASSISTANCE TO THE STATES, AS SHOWN BY ITS EFFORTS TO COOPERATE WITH THE
STATE OF MICHIGAN.
3. THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS THAT STATE ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES ARE
IN NEED OF FINANCIAL AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 048 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105345
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
FURTHER, SUCH ASSISTANCE CAN BE PROVIDED THROUGH EXISTING AGENCIES
AND AUTHORITIES, OR THROUGH SEPARATE APPROPRIATIONS BY CONGRESS.
1. EPA HEADQUARTERS AND THE OTHER NINE REGIONS SHOULD FOLLOW THE
LEAD OF REGION V IN INCREASING COOPERATION WITH AND ASSISTANCE TO THE
STATES. FURTHER, THE AGENCY SHOULD BE FLEXIBLE IN ADMINISTERING RCRA TO
INSURE MAXIMUM STATE IMPLEMENTATION, AS ENVISIONED BY CONGRESS UPON
PASSAGE OF RCRA.
2. UPON REQUEST BY A STATE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY THAT RCRA
SECTION 3011 FUNDING OR OTHER EXISTING FUNDS BE REPROGRAMMED AND
CHANNELED INTO STATE ATTORNEYS' GENERAL OFFICES FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION.
EPA REGIONAL ADMINISTRATORS SHOULD APPROVE SUCH REPROGRAMMING OF FUNDS.
IF IT BECOMES APPARENT THAT SUCH FUNDING CONTINUES TO BE INSUFFICIENT
FOR ENFORCEMENT ACTION IN HAZARDOUS WASTE CASES, CONGRESS SHOULD ENACT
LEGISLATION TO AUTHORIZE ADDITIONAL APPROPRIATIONS FOR SUCH ASSISTANCE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 049 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105346
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/93/ RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT OF 1976, THE REPORT OF
THE COMMITTEE ON INTERSTATE AND FOREIGN COMMERCE, U.S. HOUSE OF
REPRESENTATIVES ON H.R. 14496, REPORT NO 94-1491, P. 12.
WHEN THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY WAS CREATED IN 1970, THE
AGENCY WAS CHARGED WITH PROTECTING THE PUBLIC AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL FROM
POLLUTION TRANSMITTED THROUGH THREE DISTINCT MEDIA; AIR, WATER, AND
LAND. AS THE THREAT TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT WAS PERCEIVED
AS EMANATING MOSTLY FROM AIR AND WATER POLLUTION, THE EPA WAS ORGANIZED
ACCORDINGLY. THUS, THE PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY FOR REGULATION OF AIR
POLLUTION FELL UNDER THE OFFICE OF AIR, NOISE, AND RADIATION, AND
REGULATION OF WATER POLLUTION CAME UNDER THE OFFICE OF WATER AND WASTE
MANAGEMENT. POLUTION DERIVED OF THE OTHER MEDIUM, LAND, WAS NOT GIVEN
GREAT EMPHASIS AS ITS POTENTIAL THREAT WAS NOT REALIZED, AND REGULATORY
RESPONSIBILITIES FOR LAND POLLUTION WERE ORGANIZED UNDER THE OFFICE OF
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT IN THE OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE.
THE OFFICE OF WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT AND THE OFFICE OF AIR, NOISE
AND RADIATION WERE, AND STILL ARE, HEADED BY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATORS
WHO ARE DIRECTLY RESPONSIBLE TO THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR AND THE
ADMINISTRATOR. THE OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE, ON THE OTHER HAND, IS
DIRECTED BY A DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR WHO REPORTS TO THE
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT. AS THE OFFICE
OF SOLID WASTE HAS DIRECT RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA,
IT APPEARS THAT THE HAZARDOUS AND SOLID WASTE PROGRAMS OF EPA ARE ON AN
UNEQUAL FOOTING WITH EPA'S OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION PROGRAMS.
NOTE THAT THE LEGISLATIVE HISTORY OF RCRA ENVISIONS AN OFFICE OF
"DISCARDED MATERIALS" (SOLID WASTE) WITHIN EPA HEADED BY AN ASSISTANT
ADMINISTRATOR:
AT THE PRESENT TIME THERE ARE OFFICES WITHIN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY FOR WATER AND AIR. THERE IS, HOWEVER, NO OFFICE FOR LAND
MANAGEMENT. THIS TITLE CREATES SUCH AN OFFICE WITHIN THE EPA TO BE
DESIGNATED AS THE OFFICE OF DISCARDED MATERIALS, AND HEADED BY AN
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR. THIS STATUTORY ESTABLISHMENT WOULD GIVE
MANAGEMENT PARITY WITH THE AIR AND WATER OFFICES. IN ADDITION TO GIVING
AND POLLUTION PARITY, THE ESTABLISHING LANGUAGE ALSO SETS OUT THE DUTIES
AND RESPONSIBILITIES TO BE UNDERTAKEN BY THE OFFICE.
UNDER THIS BILL IT WOULD BE MUCH MORE DIFFICULT TO CUT THE PERSONNEL
OR BUDGET OF THE OFFICE OR TO SACRIFICE THE WASTE MANAGEMENT FUNCTIONS
FOR THE SAKE OF AIR OR WATER PROGRAMS SINCE ALL THREE OFFICES WOULD
ENJOY SIMILAR STATUTORY AUTHORIZATION. (EMPHASIS ADDED).
THE LANGUAGE OF RCRA AS ENACTED, HOWEVER, DID NOT REFLECT THIS IDEA
FOR ORGANIZATIONAL PARITY, AS IT CREATED AN OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE TO BE
HEADED BY A DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR. /93
THE SUBCOMMITTEE IS CONCERNED WITH THE IMPLICATIONS OF EPA'S CURRENT
ORGANIZATION.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 050 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105347
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/94/ SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT HEARING
TRANSCRIPT, P. 169.
/95/ NOVEMBER 20, 1979, LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/96/ JUNE 22, 1979, LETTER FROM THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/97/ AUGUST 1, 1979, SUBCOMMITTEE HEARING TRANSCRIPT, P. 185.
IT IS CLEAR THAT AS THE MAGNITUDE OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROBLEM IS
PERCEIVED AS HAVING INCREASED TREMENDOUSLY IN RECENT YEARS, EPA MUST BE
RESPONSIVE ORGANIZATIONALLY TO THIS INCREASE. AS CHAIRMAN LEVIN STATED
IN HIS OPENING STATEMENT DURING THE AUGUST 1 HEARING:
THE FACT THAT BOTH WATER AND WASTE PROGRAMS ARE ADMINISTERED BY A
SINGLE ADMINISTRATOR SUGGESTS TO MANY THE NEED FOR A MORE INDEPENDENT
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE FOR WASTE MANAGEMENT, POSSIBLY HEADED BY AN
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR, TO ENSURE INCREASED BUDGET AND ORGANIZATIONAL
PRIORITY FOR THE SOLID AND HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS. /94/
EPA'S CURRENT OFFICIAL POSITION ON THE CREATION OF AN OFFICE OF
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE IS:
EPA, AND PARTICULARLY THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE, HAS STUDIED
THE PROPOSAL FOR A SEPARATE ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE OVER
A LONG PERIOD OF TIME. EPA FEELS THAT AT PRESENT SUCH A COURSE WOULD
NOT BE CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICY OF INTEGRATING VARIOUS PARTS OF THE
AGENCY THROUGH CONSOLIDATED PERMITTING, CONSOLIDATED GRANTS, AND
REGULATORY REFORM POLICY. THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE IS
OVERSEEING AND COORDINATING A BALANCED APPROACH BETWEEN WASTE MANAGEMENT
ON LAND AND ON WATER. IF, AFTER EVALUATION OF ANY CONFLICTS OVER THE
NEXT YEAR, THE DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE CONCLUDES A SEPARATE OFFICE
FOR SOLID WASTE WOULD BE ADVISABLE, SUCH A RECOMMENDATION WILL BE MADE
TO THE ADMINISTRATOR. /95/
THE AGENCY ALSO ADVISED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT:
WE ARE FINDING THAT ATTACKING PROBLEMS ON A MEDIA BASIS CAN AND DOES
TRANSFER THE PROBLEM, IN PART, TO ANOTHER MEDIA. /96/
CHARIMAN LEVIN ASKED MR. EARLY OF THE SIERRA CLUB WHAT HE THOUGHT OF
EPA'S "MEDIA TRANSFER" THEORY:
THE EPA . . . HAS INFORMED THE SUBCOMMITTEE THAT IT IS OPPOSED TO AN
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR POSITION BECAUSE, "ATTACHKING PROBLEMS ON A
MEDIA BASIS CAN AND DOES TRANSFER THE PROBLEM IN FACT TO ANOTHER MEDIA."
MY QUESTION IS THIS: ISN'T THAT EXACTLY WHAT'S HAPPENING NOW? THAT
WATER POLLUTION CONTROL HAS HELPED TO CREATE LAND POLLUTION AND WILL
CONTINUE TO DOMINATE UNLESS THE TWO MEDIA, LAND AND WATER, ARE PUT ON AN
EQUAL FOOTING?
MR. EARLY. "I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY TRUE." /97/
IN OTHER WORDS, EFFORTS TO CLEAN UP WATER AND AIR POLLUTION HAVE
DIRECTLY PROMOTED THE USE OF UNSOUND LAND DISPOSAL PRACTICES, RESULTING
IN AN INCREASE IN THE OCCURRENCE OF LAND POLLUTION.
IT APPEARS THAT EPA WOULD BE WILLING TO ACCEPT A REORGANIZATION IF IT
IS DEMONSTRATED THAT THE CREATION OF AN OFFICE OF ASSISTANT
ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE IS JUSTIFIED.
BUDGETARY AND PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS CONSIDERATIONS PROMPTED A NUMBER
OF GROUPS AND INDIVIDUALS TO INFORM THE SUBCOMMITTEE OF THEIR VIEWS IN
SUPPORT OF THE CREATION OF AN OFFICE OF ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR
SOLID WASTE. SUPPORT FOR A REORGANIZATION WAS UNANIMOUS AMONG THESE
GROUPS AND IDIVIDUALS, AND AMONG WITNESSES WHO TESTIFIED BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE OTHER THAN THE EPA DEPUTY ADMINISTRATOR AND TWO ASSISTANT
ADMINISTRATORS.
THERE ARE SEVERAL REASONS JUSTIFYING THE NEED FOR THE CREATION OF AN
OFFICE OF ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE WITHIN EPA.
FIRST, THERE IS A BUILT-IN CONFLICT OF INTEREST IN THE OFFICE OF
WATER AND WASTE MANAGEMENT WITH RESPECT TO THE OBLIGATIONS OF THE
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 051 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105348
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/98/ PRESS CONFERENCE BY DOUGLAS M. COSTLE, ADMINISTRATOR,
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 26, 1980.
/99/ JULY 24, 1979, LETTER FROM RICHARD D. LAMM, CHAIRMAN, NATURAL
RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE AND BILL CLINTON,
CHAIRMAN, SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, NATIONAL GOVERNORS
ASSOCIATION, TO THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT OF GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT.
/99A/ ADDITIONAL SUPPORT FOR CREATION OF SUCH AN OFFICE APPEARS IN
APPENDIX II IN A LETTER FROM THE CALIFORNIA STATE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
BOARD.
HE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF BOTH EPA'S WATER PROGRAMS
(INCLUDING THE MULTI-BILLION DOLLAR CONSTRUCTION GRANTS/WASTEWATER
TREATMENT PROGRAM) AND EPA'S SOLID WASTE PROGRAM UNDER RCRA. THE
CONFLICT ARISES BECAUSE THERE ARE LIMITED RESOURCES FOR BOTH PROGRAM
AREAS, AND THE POLITICAL ADVANTAGES OF IMPLEMENTING MASSIVE WATER
PROGRAMS MAKE IT DIFFICULT TO FIGHT FOR RESOURCES FOR RCRA
IMPLEMENTATION. IF THE ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR REQUESTS ADDITIONAL
RESOURCES TO IMPLEMENT RCRA, IT IS LIKELY THAT HE WILL BE FORCED TO MAKE
A CUT IN THE WATER PROGRAMS.
SECOND, THE WATER PROGRAM IS WELL ESTABLISHED WITHIN THE EPA
HIERARCHY, AND PROGRAM LEVEL STAFF SEEM TO BE MORE INFLUENTIAL IN
LETTING PROGRAM NEEDS BE KNOWN THAN THE LESS EXPERIENCED RCRA PROGRAM
STAFF.
THIRD, AS THE SOLID WASTE PROGRAM IS A NEW PROGRAM WITHIN EPA, AND AS
ADMINISTRATOR DOUGLAS COSTLE RECENTLY HAS POINTED OUT, . . . "IT WILL
HAVE TO GROW ESSENTIALLY TO (THE) SIZE THAT WE NEED (TO) ALLOW US TO
HANDLE THE PROBLEMS." THE NEED FOR AN ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR TO FIGHT
FOR RESOURCES DURING PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT IS CRUCIAL. /98/
FINALLY, CONTINUED PROGRAM AND RESOURCE EMPHASIS ON AIR AND WATER
PROGRAMS RATHER THAN ON SOLID WASTE PROGRAMS WILL RESULT IN CONTINUED
DEGRADATION OF THE LAND FROM ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION.
AS THE NATIONAL GOVERNORS ASSOCIATION POINTED OUT:
THE FINANCIAL AND STAFFING RESOURCES AVAILABLE TO THE OFFICE OF SOLID
WASTE HAVE NOT BEEN COMPARABLE TO THAT ACCORDED DEVELOPMENT OF THE CLEAN
WATER ACT, THE CLEAN AIR ACT, AND THE TOXIC SUBSTANCES CONTROL ACT. YET
THE RCRA EFFORT MUST ENCOMPASS THE MANAGEMENT OF THE RESIDUALS OF ALL
THESE PROGRAMS. MOREOVER THE AGENCY'S UTILIZATION OF THOSE RESOURCES
HAS EMPHASIZED ENFORCEMENT AND ATTENDANT LEGAL ACTIVITIES WITHOUT
COMPARABLE EMPHASIS AND CONSIDERATION GIVEN TO PLANNING AND
IMPLEMENTATION -CTIVITIES. THE LATTER ARE VITAL TO THE ACHIEVEMENT OF
THE RCRA GOAL OF ESTABLISHING A NATIONAL PROGRAM TO MANAGE AND CONTROL
HAZARDOUS WASTES IN AN ENVIRONMENTALLY ACCEPTABLE MANNER." /99/
THE SUBCOMMITTEE FINDS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TOWARD THE ELEVATION OF
THE EPA OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE TO THE STATUS OF ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATIOR.
THE CURRENT ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE HAS RESULTED IN MISMANAGEMENT IN THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA IN SEVERAL WAYS. THESE INCLUDE:
(A) INADEQUATE BUDGET ALLOCATION TO SOLID WASTE PROGRAMS;
(B) INADEQUATE APPLICATION OF HUMAN RESOURCES TO SOLID WASTE
PROGRAMS;
(C) CONTINUED DELAY IN THE PROMULGATION OF RCRA REGULATIONS; AND
(D) INTERNAL CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AND INFIGHTING THROUGHOUT THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF RCRA.
CONGRESS SHOULD HASTEN TO ENACT LEGISLATION TO CREATE AN OFFICE OF
ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE WITHIN EPA. /99A/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 052 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105349
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
THE SUBCOMMITTEE BELIEVES THAT THE INSIGHTS PROVIDED IN THIS REPORT,
BOTH TO THE CONGRESS AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, WILL BE
USEFUL IN OUR STRUGGLE TO ACHIEVE CONTROL OVER THE IMMENSE PROBLEM OF
LAND POLLUTION. THE RECOMMENDATIONS EXPRESSED THROUGHOUT THE TEXT,
BASED ON AN INTENSE SUBCOMMITTEE INVESTIGATION INTO THE MANAGEMENT OF
HAZARDOUS WASTES WILL, IF FULLY RECOGNIZED AND IMPLEMENTED, PROVIDE
ADDITONAL INCENTIVES TO THE EPA AN1 THE STATES IN THIER UPHILL BATTLE TO
FULFILL THE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROVISIONS OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND
RECOVERY ACT.
THE SUBCOMMITTEE HOPES THAT THESE RECOMMENDATIONS WILL BE CARRIED OUT
TO THE GREATEST EXTENT POSSIBLE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 053 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105350
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/100/ 42 U.S.C. 6903, SECTION 1004 (5)(A)(B).
THE CLEAN AIR ACT OF 1963, WHICH UNDERWENT MAJOR REVISION IN 1970,
WAS THE FIRST MAJOR PIECE OF LEGISLATION DESIGNED TO ELIMINATE
ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION IN THE AIR. THE CLEAN WATER ACT, FEDERAL WATER
POLLUTION CONTROL ACT AND MARIEN PROTECTION ACT WERE DESIGNED TO
ELIMINATE ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION IN NAVIGABLE WATERS. NOT UNTIL 1976
DID CONGRESS PERCEIVE THE NEED TO COMPLETE ITS ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
EFFORTS BY ENACTING LEGISLATION TO PROTECT THE LAND, DRINKING WATER
SUPPLIES AND THE FOOD CHAIN FROM ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION. THE RESOURCE
CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT (RCRA) WAS ENACTED ON OCTOBER 21, 1976 TO
SERVE THIS PURPOSE. THUS, IN ESSENCE, CONGRESS CLOSED THE GAP IN
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION WITH THE PASSAGE OF RCRA IN 1976.
HAZARDOUS WASTES, ESSENTIALLY A SUBSET OF SOLID WASTES, REQURE A
GREATER DEGREE OF REGULATION THAN SOLID WASTES AS SOLID WASTES DO NOT
POSSESS HAZARDOUS CHARACTERISTICS. SUBTITLE D OF RCRA PERTAINS TO THE
REGULATION OF SOLID WASTES, BUT HAZARDOUS WASTES WERE SEPARATED OUT INTO
SUBTITLE C FOR A MORE COMPREHENSIVE AND RIGID REGULATORY APPROACH.
SUBTITLE C ESTABLISHES FEDERAL STANDARDS FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT,
AND A SUMMARY OF ITS MAJOR PROVISIONS FOLLOWS.
LISTING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
SECTION 3001 IS THE CORNERSTONE FOR THE ENTIRE "CRADLE-TO-GRAVE"
REGULATORY SCHEME UNDER RCRA. THE SECTION PROVIDES FOR THE
IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE. "HAZARDOUS WASTE' AS
DEFINED UNDER THE ACT IS:
A SOLID WASTE, OR COMBINATION OF SOLID WASTES, WHICH BECAUSE OF ITS
QUANTITY, CONCENTRATION, OR PHYSICAL, CHEMICAL, OR INFECTIOUS
CHARACTERISTICS MAY
"(A) CAUSE, OR SIGNIFICANTLY CONTRIBUTE TO AN INCREASE IN MORTAILITY
OR AN INCREASE IN SERIOUS IRREVERSIBLE, OR INCAPACITATING REVERSIBLE,
ILLNESS;" OR
"(B) POST A SUBSTANTIAL PRESENT OR POTENTIAL HAZARD TO HUMAN HEALTH
OR THE ENVIRONMENT WHEN IMPROPERLY TREATED, STORED, TRANSPORTED, OR
DISPOSED OF, OR OTHERWISE MANAGED." /100/
IF A SUBSTANCE IS DETERMINED IDENTIFIABLE AS "HAZARDOUS" UNDER
SECTION 3001, THEN IT IS REGULATED BY ALL PROVISIONS OF SUBTITLE C OF
RCRA. SECTION 3001 REQUIRES THE EPA ADMINISTRATOR TO PROMULGATE
REGULATIONS WITHIN 18 MONTHS OF ENACTMENT FOR THE PURPOSES OF:
(1) DEVELOPING CRITERIA TO ESTABLISH CHARACTERISTICS WHICH IDENTIFY
HAZARDOUS WASTE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 054 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105351
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/101/ 42 U.S.C. 6921.
/102/ 42 U.S.C. 6922.
/103/ 42 U.S.C. 6923.
/104/ 42 U.S.C. 6924.
(2) IDENTIFYING THE ABOVE-REFERENCED CHARACTERISTICS; AND
(3) LISTING PARTICULAR SUBSTANCES AS HAZARDOUS. /101/
A WASTE IS CONSIDERED HAZARDOUS EITHER IF IT POSSESSES ONE OR MORE OF
THE IDENTIFYING CHARACTERISTICS OR IF IT FALLS ON THE LIST OF SUBSTANCES
IDENTIFIED AS HAZARDOUS.
REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT SECTION 3001 WERE PROPOSED IN THE FEDERAL
REGISTER ON DECEMBER 18, 1979.
GENERATORS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
SECTION 3002 REQUIRES THE ADMINISTRATOR OF EPA TO PROMULGATE
REGULATIONS WITHIN 18 MONTHS OF THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF RCRA
ESTABLISHING STANDARDS OF REQUIREMENT APPLICABLE TO GENERATORS OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE. THESE STANDARDS REQUIRE THE GENERATOR TO KEEP RECORDS
OF QUANTITIES AND CONTENTS OF WASTES PRODUCED; LABEL CONTAINERS USED IN
THE STORAGE, TRANSPORTATION OR DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES; USE
APPROPRIATE CONTAINERS; FURNISH CHEMICAL CONSTITUENT INFORMATION TO
PERSONS TRANSPORTING, TREATING, STORING OR DISPOSING OF THE WASTES;
PARTICIPATE IN A MANIFEST SYSTEM TO TRACK THE WASTES FROM THE POINT OF
GENERATION TO THE POINT OF ULTIMATE DISPOSAL; AND SUBMIT REPORTS TO EPA
OR AN AUTHORIZED STATE AGENCY REGARDING QUANTITIES AND ULTIMATE
DISPOSITION OF WASTES. /102/
TRANSPORTERS OF HAZARDOUS WASTES
SECTION 3003 REQUIRES THE ADMINISTRATOR TO PROMULGATE REGULATIONS
SETTING STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO TRANSPORTERS OF HAZARDOUS WASTES. SUCH
STANDARDS INCLUDE REQUIREMENTS FOR RECORDKEEPING, LABELING, COMPLIANCE
WITH THE MANIFEST SYSTEM, AND TRANSPORTATION TO ONLY PERMITTED DISPOSAL
FACILITIES (AS PROVIDED FOR UNDER SECTION 3005). THE SECTION ALSO
PROVIDES FOR COORDINATION WITH REGULATIONS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF
TRANSPORTATION UNDER THE HAZARDOUS MATERIALS TRANSPORTATION ACT (88
STAT. 2156; 49 U.S.C. 1801 AND FOLLOWING). /103/
OWNERS AND OPERATORS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
TREATMENT, STORAGE, AND DISPOSAL
FACILITIES
SECTION 3004 REQUIRES THE ADMINISTRATOR TO PROMULGATE REGULATIONS
SETTING STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO OWNERS AND OPERATORS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
TREATMENT, STORAGE, AND DISPOSAL FACILITIES. AS IN SECTIONS 3002 AND
3003, THESE STANDARDS WILL APPLY TO RECORDKEEPING, COMPLIANCE WITH THE
MANIFEST SYSTEM, AND PERMITTING REQUIREMENTS. IN ADDITION, THE
REGULATIONS SET STANDARDS APPLYING TO TREATMENT, STORAGE AND DISPOSAL,
DESIGN OF DISPOSAL FACILITIES, CONTINGENCY PLANS FOR ANY EMERGENCY
ACTION REQUIRED, AND MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS. /104/
STORAGE OR DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
SECTION 3005 REQUIRES THE ADMINISTRATOR TO PROMULGATE REGULATIONS
REQUIRING THE OWNER OR OPERATOR OF A TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL
FACILITY TO OBTAIN A PERMIT ISSUED BY EPA OR A STATE WITH AN AUTHORIZED
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT PROGRAM UPON A DETERMINATION THAT THE
FACILITY COMPLIES WITH SECTION 3004.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 055 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105352
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/105/ 42 U.S.C. 6925.
/106/ 42 U.S.C. 6926.
/107/ 42 U.S.C. 6926.
/108/ 42 U.S.C. 6927.
/109/ 42 U.S.C. 6928.
FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE TERMS OF THE PERMIT MAY RESULT IN ITS
REVOCATION, THUS DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE MUST BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH
SUCH TERMS. THE BURDEN OF AUTHORIZING A LARGE AMOUNT OF PERMITS UPON
SUBMISSION TO EPA IS REDUCED BY THE PROVISION OF AUTHORIZING INTERIM
STATUS (FACILITY MAY OPERATE AS A PERMITTED FACILITY) TO A FACILITY
WHICH HAS SUBMITTED AN APPLICATION, UNTIL THE AGENCY CAN MAKE A FINAL
DECISION ON THE APPLICATION. /105/
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS
CONGRESS FULLY INTENDED IN THE PASSAGE OF RCRA THAT THE STATES SHOULD
ESTABLISH THEIR OWN PROGRAMS TO ADMINISTER AND ENFORCE THE NATIONAL
STANDARDS PROMULGATED BY EPA. THUS, SECTION 3006 PROVIDES FOR THE
AUTHORIZATION OF STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGMENT PROGRAMS. AFTER
SUBMISSION OF AN APPLICATION TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR AN AUTHORIZED
STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM, SUCH PROGRAM WILL BE AUTHORIZED IN LIEU
OF THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNLESS THE ADMINISTRATOR NOTIFIES THE STATE THAT:
(1) SUCH STATE PROGRAM IS NOT EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER
THIS SUBTITLE;
(2) SUCH PROGRAM IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE FEDERAL OR STATE PROGRAMS
APPLICABLE IN OTHER STATES; OR
(3) SUCH PROGRAM DOES NOT PROVIDE ADEQUATE ENFORCEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SUBTITLE. /106/
AFTER SECTIONS 3002-3005 H-VE BEEN PROMULGATED, A STATE MAY BE
GRANTED INTERIM AUTHORIZATION TO OPERATE ITS OWN PROGRAM IN ACCORDANCE
WITH SECTION 3006(C) OF RCRA. THIS PROVISION GRANTS THE STATE A 2-YEAR
AUTHORIZATION TO OPERATE ITS OWN HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM IF IT IS
EQUIVALENT TO AND CONSISTENT IWTH THE FEDERAL PROGRAM. /107/
SECTION 3007(A) PROVIDES FOR FEDERAL OR STATE ACCESS TO THE RECORDS
AND PLACE OF BUSINESS OF ANY GENERATOR, TRANSPORTER OF HAZARDOUS WASTE,
OR OWNER/OPERATOR OF A HAZARDOUS WASTE FACILITY. THE PURPOSE OF SUCH
ACCESS IS FOR EITHER ENFORCING OR DEVELOPING REGULATIONS UNDER SUBTITLE
C.
SECTION 3007(B) PROVIDES FOR PUBLIC ACCESS TO INFORMATION RECEIVED BY
THE STATE OR FEDERAL GOVERNMENT FROM SUCH AN INSPECTION. /108/
THE FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT PROGRAM IS OUTLINED IN SECTION 3008. THIS
SECTION PROVIDES FOR COMPLIANCE ORDERS, CIVIL SUITS, AND CRIMINAL
PENALTIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF ANY OF THE PROVISIONS OF SUBTITLE C.
VIOLATIONS MAY RESULT IN A CIVIL PENALTY OF $25,000 FOR EACH DAY OF
NON-COMPLIANCE IWTH A COMPLIANCE ORDER IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION
3008(A) (3), OR IN THE CASE OF A CRIMINAL VIOLATION, A FINE OF $25,000
FOR EACH DAY OF NON-COMPLIANCE AND/OR ONE YEAR IMPRISONMENT IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 3008(D). /109/
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 056 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105353
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
/110/ 42 U.S.C. 6929.
/111/ 42 U.S.C. 6930.
/112/ 42 U.S.C. 6931.
/113/ 42 U.S.C. 6973.
SECTION 3009 PREEMPTS STATE AND LOCAL REGULATIONS THAT ARE LESS
STRINGENT THAN THE FEDERAL STANDARDS, BUT STATES AND LOCALITIES ARE NOT
PROHIBITED FROM APPLYING THEIR OWN STANDARDS, IF APPLICATION OF THE
FEDERAL REGULATION IS POSTPONED OR ENJOINED. /110/
WITHIN 90 DAYS AFTER THE SECTION 3001 REGULATIONS ARE PROMULGATED,
ANY PERSON SUBJECT TO SECTIONS 3002, 3003, OR 3004 MUST NOTIFY EITHER
EPA, OR THE STATE, IF THERE IS AN AUTHORIZED STATE PROGRAM, OF THE
LOCATION AND GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE ACTIVITIES THAT WOULD SUBJECT IT
TO REGULATIONS AND THE WASTES THAT ARE IDENTIFIED UNDER SECTION 3001
REGULATIONS. /1I1/
TO STATES
THIS SECTION AUTHORIZES GRANTS TO THE STATES TO ASSITS IN THE
DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF AUTHORIZED STATE HAZARDOUS WASTE
PROGRAMS. /112/
EPA'S "IMMINENT HAZARD" AUTHORITY, APART FROM THE SUBTITLE C
ENFORCEMENT PROVISION, PROVIDES THE ADMINISTRATOR WITH BROAD STATUTORY
AUTHORITY TO REMEDY IMPROPER DISPOSAL OF SOLID AND/OR HAZARDOUS WASTE ON
THE LAND THAT HAS OR WILL RESULT IN AN IMMINENT AND SUBSTANTIAL
ENDANGERMENT TO THE PUBLIC HEALTH OR THE ENVIRONMENT. THIS AUTHORITY IS
GRANTED UNDER SECTION 7003 OF RCRA, AND SPECIFICALLY STATES:
NOTWITHSTANDING ANY OTHER PROVISION OF THIS ACT, UPON RECEIPT OF
EVIDENCE THAT THE HANDLING, STORAGE, TREATMENT, TRANSPORTATION OR
DISPOSAL OF ANY SOLID WASTE OR HAZARDOUS WASTE IS PRESENTING AN IMMINENT
AND SUBSTANTIAL ENDANGERMENT TO HEALTH OR THE ENVIRONMENT, THE
ADMINISTRATOR MAY BRING SUIT ON BEHALF OF THE UNITED STATES IN THE
APPROPRIATE DISTRICT COURT TO IMMEDIATELY RESTRAIN ANY PERSON FOR
CONTRIBUTING TO THE ALLEGED DISPOSAL TO STOP SUCH HANDLING, STORAGE,
TREATMENT, TRANSPORTATION, OR DISPOSAL OR TO TAKE SUCH OTHER ACTION AS
MAY BE NECESSARY. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROVIDE NOTICE TO THE
AFFECTED STATE OF ANY SUCH SUIT. /112/
AS THE LANGUAGE OF SECTION 7003 CLEARLY INDICATES, THIS BROAD SWEEP
OF AUTHORITY, WEHN PUT TO USE, IS TO TAKE PRECEDENCE OVER ANY OTHER
PROVISION OF THE ACT. THE SECTION PROVIDES EXTREMELY ADEQUATE AUTHORITY
TO THE ADMINISTRATOR TO DEAL WITH EMERGENCY SITUATIONS CAUSED BY SOLID
OR HAZARDOUS WASTE AND RELATING TO THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND/OR THE
ENVIRONMENT.
(ACTUAL LANGUAGE OF SUBTITLE C FOLLOWS.)
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 057 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105354
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
OCT. 21, 1976 (S.2150)
TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF
MANAGEMENT PLANS AND FACILITIES FOR THE RECOVERY OF ENERGY AND OTHER
RESOURCES FROM DISCARDED MATERIALS AND FOR THE SAFE DISPOSAL OF
DISCARDED MATERIALS, AND TO REGULATE THE MANAGEMENT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE.
42 USC 6921. "SEC. 3001. (A) CRITERIA FOR IDENTIFICATION OR
LISTING. -- NOT LATER THAN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF THE
ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, AFTER NOTICE AND
OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARING, AND AFTER CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE
FEDERAL AND STATE AGENCIES, DEVELOP AND PROMULGATE CRITERIA FOR
IDENTIFYING THE CHARACTERISTICS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE, AND FOR LSITING
HAZARDOUS WASTE, WHICH SHOULD BE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
SUBTITLE, TAKING INTO ACCOUNT TOXICITY, PERSISTENCE, AND DEGRADABILITY
IN NATURE, POTENTIAL FOR ACCUMULATION IN TISSUE, ANDOTHER RELATED
FACTORS SUCH AS FLAMMABILITY, CORROSIVENESS, AND OTHER HAZARDOUS
CHARACTERISTICS. SUCH CRITERIA SHALL BE REVISED FROM TIME TO TIME AS
MAY BE APPROPRIATE.
REGULATIONS. "(B) IDENTIFICATION AND LISTING. -- NOT LATER THAN
EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, AND AFTER
NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARING, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL
PROMULGATE REGULATIONS IDENTIFYING THE CHARACTERISTICS OF HAZARDOUS
WASTES, AND LISTING PARTICULAR HAZARDOUS WASTES (WITHIN THE MEANING OF
SECTION 1004(5)), WHICH SHALL BE SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
BUTITLE. SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL BE BASED ON THE CRITERIA PROMULGATED
UNDER SUBSECTION (A) AND SHALL BE REVISED FROM TIME TO TIME THEREAFTER
AS MAY BE APPROPRIATE.
"(C) PETITION BY STATE GOVERNOR. -- AT ANY TIME AFTER THE DATE
EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE ENACTMENT OF THIS TITLE, THE GOVERNOR OF ANY
STATE MAY PETITION THE ADMINISTRATOR TO IDENTIFY OR LIST A MATERIAL AS A
HAZARDOUS WASTE. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ACT UPON SUCH PETITION WITHIN
NINETY DAYS FOLLOWING HIS RECEIPT THEREOF AND SHALL NOTIFY THE GOVERNOR
OF SUCH ACTION. IF THE ADMINISTRATOR DENIES SUCH PETITION BECAUSE OF
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS, IN PROVIDING SUCH NOTICE TO THE GOVERNOR HE
SHALL INCLUDE A STATEMENT CONCERNING SUCH CONSIDERATIONS.
ANTE, P. 2799.
REGULATIONS 42 USC 6922
"SEC. 3002. NOT LATER THAN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF THE
ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, AND AFTER NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC
HEARINGS AND AFTER CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE FEDERAL AND STATE
AGENCIES, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROMULGATE REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING
SUCH STANDARDS, APPLICABLE TO GENERATORS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED
OR LISTED UNDER THIS SUBTITLE, AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO PROTECT HUMAN
HEALTH AND THE ENFIRONMENT. SUCH STANDARDS SHALL ESTABLISH REQUIREMENTS
RESPECTING.
"(1) RECORDKEEPING PRACTICES THAT ACCURATELY IDENTIFY THE QUANTITIES
OF SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE GENERATED, THE CONSTITUENTS THEREOF WHICH ARE
SIGNIFICANT IN QUANTITY OR IN POTENTIAL HARM TO HUMAN HEALTH OR THE
ENVIRONMENT, AND THE DISPOSTION OF SUCH WASTES;
(2) LABELING PRACTICES FOR ANY CONTAINERS USED FOR THE STORAGE
TRANSPORT, OR DISPOSAL OF SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE SUCH AS WILL IDENTIFY
ACCURATELY SUCH WASTE;
"(3) USE OF APPROPRIATE CONTAINERS FOR SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE;
"(4) FURNISHING OF INFORMATION OF THE GENERAL CHEMCIAL COMPSITION OF
SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE TO PERSONS TRANSPORTING, TREATING, STORING, OR
DISPOSING OF SUCH WASTES.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 058 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105355
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(5) USE OF A MANIFEST SYSTEM TO ASSURE THAT ALL SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE
GENERATED IS DESIGNATED FOR TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL IN
TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL FACILITIES (OTHER THAN FACILITIES ON THE
PREMISES WHERE THE WASTE IS GENERATED) FOR WHICH A PERMIT HAS BEEN
ISSUED AS PROVIDED IN THIS SUBTITLE; AND
REPORTS. "(6) SUBMISSION OF REPORTS TO THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR THE
STATE AGENCY IN ANY CASE IN WHICH SUCH AGENCY CARRIES OUT AN AUTHORIZED
PERMIT PROGRAM PURSUANT TO THIS SUBTITLE AT SUCH TIMES AS THE
ADMINISTRATOR (OR THE STATE AGENCY IF APPROPRIATE) DEEMS NECESSARY,
SETTING OUT
"(A) THE QUANTITIES OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED UNDER
THIS SUBTITLE THAT HE HAS GENERATED DURING A PARTICULAR TIME PERIOD;
AND
"(B) THE DISPOSITION OF ALL HAZARDOUS WASTE REPORTED UNDER
SUBPARAGRAPH (A).
REGULATIONS, 42 USC 6923. "SEC. 3003. (A) STANDARDS. -- NOT LATER
THAN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, AND
AFTER OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARINGS, THE ADMINISTRATOR, AFTER
CONSULTATION WITH THE SECRETARY OF TRANSPORTATION AND THE STATES, SHALL
PROMULGATE REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING SUCH STANDARDS, APPLICABLE TO
TRANSPORTERS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE, AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO PROTECT HUMAN HEALTH AND THE
ENVIRONMENT. SUCH STANDARDS SHALL INCLUDE BUT NEED NOT BE LIMITED TO
REQUIREMENTS RESPECTING.
"(1) RECORDKEEPING CONCERNING SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE TRANSPORTED, AND
THEIR SOURCE AND DELIVERY POINTS;
"(2) TRANSPORTATION OF SUCH WASTE ONLY IF PROPERLY LABELED;
"(3) COMPLIANCE WITH THE MANIFEST SYSTEM REFERRED TO IN SECTION 3002
(5); AND
"(4) TRANSPORTATION OF ALL SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE ONLY TO THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL FACILITIES WHICH THE SHIPPER
DESIGNATES ON THE MANIFEST FORM TO BE A FACILITY HOLDING A PERMIT ISSUED
UNDER THIS SUBTITLE.
RECOMMENDATIONS. "(B) COOPERATION WITH REGULATIONS OF SECRETARY OF
TRANSPORATION. -- IN CASE OF ANY HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED
UNDER THIS SUBTITLE WHICH IS SUBJECT TO THE HAZARDOUS MATERIALS
TRANSPORTATION ACT (88 STAT. 2156; 49 U.S.C. 1801 AND FOLLOWING), THE
REGULATIONS PROMULGATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR UNDER THIS SUBTITLE SHALL
BE CONSISTENT WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF SUCH ACT AND THE REGULATIONS
THEREUNDER. THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS TO
THE SECRETARY OF TRANSPORTATION RESPECTING THE REGULATIONS OF SUCH
HAZARDOUS WASTE UNDER THE HAZARDOUS MATERIALS TRANSPORTATION ACT AND FOR
ADDITION OF MATERIALS TO BE COVERED BY SUCH ACT.
REGULATIONS, 42 USC 6924. "SEC. 3004. NOT LATER THAN EIGHTEEN
MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, AND AFTER
OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARINGS AND AFTER CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE
FEDERAL AND STATE AGENCIES, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROMULGATE
REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING SUCH PERFORMANCE STANDARDS APPLICABLE TO OWNERS
AND OPERATORS OF FACILITIES FOR THE TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED UNDER THIS SUBTITLE, AS MAY BE
NECESSARY TO PROTECT HUMAN HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 059 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105356
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
SUCH STANDARDS SHALL INCLUDE, BUT NEED NOT BE LIMITED TO,
REQUIREMENTS RESPECTING.
"(1) MAINTAINING RECORDS OF ALL HAZARDOUS WASTES IDENTIFIED OR LISTED
UNDER THIS TITLE WHICH IS TREATED, STORED, OR DISPOSED OF, AS THE CASE
MAY BE, AND THE MANNER IN WHICH SUCH WASTES WERE TREATED, STORED, OR
DISPOSED OF;
"(2) SATISFACTORY REPORTING, MONITORING, AND INSPECTION AND
COMPLIANCE WITH THE MANIFEST SYSTEM REFERRED TO IN SECTION 3002(5);
"(3) TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL OF ALL SUCH WASTE RECEIVED BY
THE FACILITY PURSUANT TO SUCH OPERATING METHODS, TECHNIQUES, AND
PRACTICES AS MAY BE SATISFACTORY TO THE ADMINISTRATOR;
"(4) THE LOCATION, DESIGN, AND CONSTRUCTION OF SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE
TREATMENT, DISPOSAL, OR STORAGE FACILITIES;
"(5) CONTINGENCY PLANS FOR EFFECTIVE ACTION TO MINIMIZE UNANTICIPATED
DAMAGE FROM ANY TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL OF ANY SUCH HAZARDOUS
WASTE;
"(6) THE MAINTENANCE OF OPERATION OF SUCH FACILITIES AND REQUIRING
SUCH ADDITIONAL QUALIFICATIONS AS TO OWNERSHIP, CONTINUITY OF OPERATION,
TRAINING FOR PERSONNEL, AND FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AS MAY BE NECESSARY
OR DESIRABLE; AND
"(7) COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 3005 RESPECTING
PERMITS FOR TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL.
NO PRIVATE ENTITY SHALL BE PRECLUDED BY REASON OF CRITERIA
ESTABLISHED UNDER PARAGRAPH (6) FROM THE OWNERSHIP OR OPERATION OF
FACILITIES PROVIDING HAZARDOUS WASTE TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL
SERVICES WHERE SUCH ENTITY CAN PROVIDE ASSURANCES OF FINANCIAL
RESPONSIBILITY AND CONTINUITY OF OPERATION CONSISTENT WITH THE DEGREE
AND DURATION OF RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH THE TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR
DISPOSAL OF SPECIFIED HAZARDOUS WASTE.
42 USC 6925. "SEC. 3005. (A) PERMITE REQUIREMENTS. -- NOT LATER
THAN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF THE ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION,
THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROMULGATE REGULATIONS REQUIRING EACH PERSON
OWNING OR OPERATING A FACILITY FOR THE TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL
OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED UNDER THIS SUBTITLE TO HAVE A
PERMIT ISSUED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION. SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL TAKE
EFFECT ON THE DATE PROVIDED IN SECTION 3010 AND UPON AND AFTER SUCH DATE
THE DISPOSAL OF ANY SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE IS PROHIBITED EXCEPT IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SUCH A PERMIT.
"(B) REQUIREMENTS OF PERMIT APPLICATION. -- EACH APPLICATION FOR A
PERMIT UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL CONTAIN SUCH INFORMATION AS MAY BE
REQUIRED UNDER REGULATIONS PROMULGATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, INCLUDING
INFORMATION RESPECTING.
"(1) ESTIMATES WITH RESPECT TO THE COMPOSITION, QUANTITIES, AND
CONCENTRATIONS OF ANY HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE, OR COMBINATIONS OF ANY SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE AND ANY OTHER
SOLID WASTE, PROPOSED TO BE DISPOSED OF, TREATED, TRANSPORTED, OR
STORED, AND THE TIME, FREQUENCY, OR RATE OF WHICH SUCH WASTE IS PROPOSED
TO BE DISPOSED OF, TREATED, TRANSPORTED, OR STORED; AND
"(2) THE SITE AT WHICH SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE OR THE PRODUCTS OF
TREATMENT OF SUCH HAZARDOUS WASTE WILL BE DISPOSED OF, TREATED,
TRANSPORTED TO, OR STORED.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 060 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105357
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(C) PERMIT ISSUANCE. -- UPON A DETERMINATION BY THE ADMINISTRATOR
(OR A STATE, IF APPLICABLE), OF COMPLIANCE BY A FACILITY FOR WHICH A
PERMIT IS APPLIED FOR UNDER THIS SECTION WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS
SECTION AND SECTION 3004, THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR THE STATE) SHALL ISSUE A
PERMIT FOR SUCH FACILITIES. IN THE EVENT PERMIT APPLICANTS PROPOSE
MODIFICATION OF THEIR FACILITIES, OR IN THE EVENT THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR
THE STATE) DETERMINES THAT MODIFICATIONS ARE NECESSARY TO CONFORM TO THE
REQUIREMENTS UNDER THIS SECTION AND SECTION 3004, THE PERMIT SHALL
SPECIFY THE TIME ALLOWED TO COMPLETE THE MODIFICATIONS.
"(D) PERMIT REVOCATION. -- UPON A DETERMINATION BY THE ADMINISTRATOR
(OR BY A STATE, IN THE CASE OF A STATE HAVING AN AUTHORIZED HAZARDOUS
WASTE PROGRAM UNDER SECTION 3006) OF NONCOMPLIANCE BY A FACILITY HAVING
A PERMIT UNDER THIS TITLE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION OR
SECTION 3004, THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR STATE, IN THE CASE OF A STATE
HAVEING AN AUTHORIZED HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM UNDER SECTION 3006) SHALL
REVOKE SUCH PERMIT.
"(E) INTERMIN STATUS. -- ANY PERSON WHO
"(1) OWNS OR OPERATES A FACILITY REQUIRED TO HAVE A PERMIT UNDER THIS
SECTION WHICH FACILITY IS IN EXISTENCE ON THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS
ACT,
"(2) HAS COMPLIED WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 3010(A), AND
"(3) HAS MADE AN APPLICATION FOR A PERMIT UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE
TREATED AS HAVING BEEN ISSUED SUCH PERMIT UNTIL SUCH TIME AS FINAL
ADMINISTRATIVE DISPOSITION OF SUCH APPLICATION IS MADE, UNLESS THE
ADMINISTRATOR OR OTHER PLAINTIFF PROVES THAT FINAL ADMINISTRATIVE
DISPOSITION OF SUCH APPLICATION HAS NOT BEEN MADE BECAUSE OF THE FAILURE
OF THE APPLICANT TO FURNISH INFORMATION REASONABLY REQUIRED OR REQUESTED
IN ORDER TO PROCESS THE APPLICATION.
42 USC 6926. "SEC. 3006. (A) FEDERAL GUIDELINES. -- NOT LATEF THAN
EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT, THE
ADMINISTRATOR, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH STATE AUTHORIITIES, SHALL
PROMULGATE GUIDELINES TO ASSIST STATES IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF STATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS.
"(B) AUTHORIZATION OF STATE PROGRAM. -- ANY STATE WHICH SEEKS TO
ADMINISTER AND ENFORCE A HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM PURSUANT TO THIS
SUBTITLE MAY DEVELOP AND, AFTER NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC
HEARING, SUBMIT TO THE ADMINISTRATOR AN APPLICATION, IN SUCH FORM AS HE
SHALL REQUIRE, FOR AUTHORIZATION OF SUCH PROGRAM. WITHIN NINETY DAYS
FOLLOWING SUBMISSION OF AN APPLICATION UNDER THIS SUBSECTION, THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ISSUE A NOTICE AS TO WHETHER OR NOT HE EXPECTS SUCH
PROGRAM TO BE AUTHORIZED, AND WITHIN NINETY DAYS FOLLWOING SUCH NOTICE
(AND AFTER OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARING) HE SHALL PUBLISH HIS FINDINGS
AS TO WHETHER OR NOT THE CONDITIONS LISTED IN ITEMS (1), (2), AND (3)
BELOW HAVE BEEN MET. SUCH STATE IS AUTHORIZED TO CARRY OUT SUCH PROGRAM
IN LIEU OF THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER THIS SUBTITLE IN SUCH STATE AND TO
ISSUE AND ENFORCE PERMITS FOR THE STORAGE, TREATMENT, OR DISPOSAL OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE UNLESS, WITHIN NINETY DAYS FOLLOWING SUBMISSION OF THE
APPLICATION THE ADMINISTRATOR NOTIFIES SUCH STATE THAT SUCH PROGRAM MAY
NOT BE AUTHORIZED AND, WITHIN NINETY DAYS FOLLOWING SUCH NOTICE AND
AFTER OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARING, HE FINDS THAT (1) SUCH STATE
PROGRAM IS NOT EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER THIS SUBTITLE,
(2) SUCH PROGRAM IS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE FEDERAL OR STATE PROGRAMS
APPLICABLE IN OTHER STATES, OR (3) SUCH PROGRAM DOES NOT PROVIDE
ADEQUATE ENFORCEMENT OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS
SUBTITLE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 061 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105358
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(C) INTERIM AUTHORIZATION. -- ANY STATE WHICH HAS IN EXISTENCE A
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM PURSUANT TO STATE LAW BEFORE THE DATE NINETY
DAYS AFTER THE DATE REQUIRED FOR PROMULGATION OF REGULATIONS UNDER
SECTIONS 3002, 3003, 3004, AND 3005, SUBMIT TO THE ADMINISTRATOR
EVIDENCE OF SUCH EXISTING PROGRAM AND MAY REQUEST A TEMPORARY
AUTHORIZATION TO CARRY OUT SUCH PROGRAM UNDER THIS SUBTITLE. THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, IF THE EVIDENCE SUBMITTED SHOWS THE EXISTING STATE
PROGRAM TO BE SUBSTANTIALLY EQUIVALENT TO THE FEDERAL PROGRAM UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE, GRANT AN INTERIM AUTHORIZATION TO THE STATE TO CARRY OUT SUCH
PROGRAM IN LIEU OF THE FEDERAL PROGRAM PURSUANT TO THIS SUBTITLE FOR A
TWENTY-FOUR MONTH PERIOD BEGINNING ON THE DATE SIX MONTHS AFTER THE DATE
REQUIRED FOR PROMULGATION OF REGULATIONS UNDER SECTIONS 3002 THROUGH
3005.
"(D) EFFECT OF STATE PERMIT. -- ANY ACTION TAKEN BY A STATE UNDER A
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM AUTHORIZED UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL HAVE THE
SAME FORCE AND EFFECT AS ACTION TAKEN BY THE ADMINISTRATOR UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE.
"(E) WITHDRAWAL OF AUTHORIZATION. -- WHENEVER THE ADMINISTRATOR
DETERMINES AFTER PUBLIC HEARING THAT A STATE IS NOT ADMINISTERING AND
ENFORCING A PROGRAM AUTHORIZED UNDER THIS SECTION IN ACCORDANCE WITH
REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION, HE SHALL SO NOTIFY THE STATE AND, IF
APPROPRIATE CORRECTIVE ACTION IS NOT TAKEN WITHIN A REASONABLE TIME, NOT
TO EXCEED NINETY DAYS, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL WITHDRAW AUTHORIZATION OF
SUCH PROGRAM AND ESTABLISH A FEDERAL PROGRAM PURSUANT TO THIS SUBTITLE.
THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL NOT WITHDRAW AUTHORIZATION OF ANY SUCH PROGRAM
UNLESS HE SHALL FIRST HAVE NOTIFIED THE STATE, AND MADE PUBLIC, IN
WRITING, THE REASONS FOR SUCH WITHDRAWAL.
42 USC 6927. "SEC. 3007. (A) ACCESS ENTRY. -- FOR PURPOSES OF
DEVELOPING OR ASSISTING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF ANY REGULATION OR
ENFORCING THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SUBTITLE, ANY PERSON WHO GNEERATES,
STORES, TREATS, TRANSPORTS, DISPOSES OF, OR OTHERWISE HANDLES HAZARDOUS
WASTES SHALL, UPON REQUEST OF ANY OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, DULY DESIGNATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR,
OR UPON REQUEST OF ANY DULY DESIGNATED OFFICER EMPLOYEE OF A STATE
HAVING AN AUTHORIZED HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM, FURNISH OR PERMIT SUCH
PERSON AT ALL REASONSABLE TIMES TO HAVE ACCESS TO, AND TO COPY ALL
RECORDS RELATING TO SUCH WASTES. FOR THE PURPOSES OF DEVELOPING OR
ASSISTING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF ANY REGULATION OR ENFORCING THE
PROVISIONS OF THIS TITLE, SUCH OFFICERS OR EMPLOYEES ARE AUTHORIZED.
"(1) TO ENTER AT REASONABLE TIMES ANY ESTABLISHMENT OR OTHER PLACE
MAINTAINED BY ANY PERSON WHERE HAZARDOUS WASTES ARE GENERATED, STORED,
TREATED, OR DISPOSED OF;
"(2) TO INSPECT AND OBTAIN SAMPLES FROM ANY PERSON OF ANY SUCH WASTES
AND SAMPLES OF ANY CONTAINERS OR LABELING FOR SUCH WASTES.
EACH SUCH INSPECTION SHALL BE COMMENCED AND COMPLETED WITH REASONABLE
PROMPTNESS. IF THE OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE OBTAINS ANY SAMPLES, PRIOR TO
LEAVING THE PREMISES, HE SHALL GIVE TO THE OWNER, OPERATOR, OR AGENT IN
CHARGE A RECEIPT DESCRIBING THE SAMPLE OBTAINED AND IF REQUESTED A
PORTION OF EACH SUCH SAMPLE EQUAL IN VOLUME OR WEIGHT TO THE PROTION
RETAINED. IF ANY ANALYSIS IS MADE OF SUCH SAMPLES, A COPY OF THE
RESULTS OF SUCH ANAYLSIS SHALL BE FURNISHED PROMPTLY TO THE OWNER,
OPERATOR, OR AGENT IN CHARGE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 062 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105359
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(B) ADVAILABILITY TO PUBLIC. -- ANY RECORDS, REPORTS, OR INFORMATION
OBTAINED FROM ANY PERSON UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE AVAILABLE TO THE
PUBLIC, EXCEPT THAT UPON A SHOWING SATISFACTORY TO THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR
THE STATE, AS THE CASE MAY BE) BY ANY PERSON THAT RECORDS, REPORTS, OR
INFORAMTION, OR PARTICULAR PART THEREOF, TO WHICH THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR
THE STATE, AS THE CASE MAY BE) HAS ACCESS UNDER THIS SECTION IF MADE
PUBLIC, WOULD DIVULGE INFORMATION ENTITLED TO PROTECTION UNDER SECTION
1905 OF TITLE 18 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE, THE ADMINISTRATOR (OR THE
STATE, AS THE CASE MAY BE) SHALL CONSIDER SUCH IFNORMATION OR PARTICULAR
PORTION THEREOF CONFIDENTIAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PURPOSES OF THAT
SECTION, EXCEPT THAT SUCH RECORD, REPORT, DOCUMENT, OR INFORMATION MAY
BE DISCLOSED TO OTHER OFFICERS, EMPLOYEES, OR AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES
OF THE UNITED STATES CONCERNED WITH CARRYING OUT THIS ACT, OR WHEN
RELEVANT IN ANY PROCEEDING UNDER THIS ACT. 3"FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT
42 USC 6928. "SEC. 3008. (A) COMPLIANCE ORDERS. -- (1) EXCEPT AS
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH (2), WHENEVER ON THE BASIS OF ANY INFORMATION THE
ADMINISTRATOR DETERMINES THAT ANY PERSON IS IN VIOLATION OF ANY
REQUIREMENT OF THIS SUBTITLE, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL GIVEN NOTICE TO
THE VIOLATOR OF HIS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SUCH REQUIREMENT. IF SUCH
VIOLATION EXTENDS BEYOND THE THIRTIETH DAY AFTER THE ADMINISTRATOR'S
NOTIFICATION, THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE AN ORDER REQUIRING COMPLIANCE
WITHIN A SPETIFIED TIME PERIOD OR THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY COMMENCE A CIVIL
ACTION IN THEUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT IN THE DISTRICT IN WHICH THE
VIOLATION OCCURRED FOR APPROPRIATE RELIEF, INCLUDING A TEMPORARY OR
PERMANENT INJUNCTION.
"(2) IN THE CASE OF A VIOLATION OF ANY REQUIREMENT OF THIS SUBTITLE
WHERE SUCH VIOLATION OCCURS IN A STATE WHICH IS AUTHORIZED TO CARRY OUT
A HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAM UNDER SECTION 3006, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL
GIVEN NOTICE TO THE STATE IN WHICH SUCH VIOLATION HAS OCCURRED THIRTY
DAYS PRIOR TO ISSUING AN ORDER OR COMMENCING A CIVIL ACTION UNDER THIS
SECTION.
PENALTY. "(3) IF SUCH VIOLATOR FAILS TO TAKE CORRECTIVE ACTION
WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED IN THE ORDER, HE SHALL BE LIABLE FOR A CIVIL
PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN $25,000 FOR EACH DAY OF CONTINUED NONCOMPLIANCE
AND THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY SUSPEND OR REVOKE ANY PERMIT ISSUED TO THE
VIOLATOR (WHETHER ISSUED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR OR THE STATE).
SUBPENAS. "(B) PUBLIC HEARING. -- ANY ORDER OR ANY SUSPENSION OR
REVOCATION OF A PERMIT SHALL BECOME FINAL UNLESS, NO LATER THAN THIRTY
DAYS AFTER THE ORDER OR NOTICE OF THE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION IS
SERVED, THE PERSON OR PERSONS NAMED THEREIN REQUEST A PUBLIC HEARING.
UPON SUCH REQUEST THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROMPTLY CONDUCT A PUBLIC
HEARING. IN CONNECTION WITH ANY PROCEEDING UNDER THIS SECTION THE
ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE SUBPENAS FOR THE ATTENDANCE AND TESTIMONY OF
WITNESSES AND THE PRODUCTION OF RELEVANT PAPERS, BOOKS, AND DOCUMENTS,
AND MAY PROMULGATE RULES FOR DISCOVERY PROCEDURES.
PENALTY. "(C) REQUIREMENTS OF COMPLIANCE ORDERS. -- ANY ORDER ISSUED
UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL STATE WITH REASONABLE SPECIFICITY THE NATURE OF
THE VIOLATION AND SPECIFY A TIME FOR COMPLIANCE AND ASSESS A PENALTY, IF
ANY, WHICH THE ADMINISTRATOR DETERMINES IS REASONABLE TAKING INTO
ACCOUNT THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE VIOLATION AND ANY GOOD FAITH EFFORTS TO
COMPLY WITH THE APPLICABLE REQUIREMENTS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 063 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105360
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(D) CRIMINAL PEANALTY. -- ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY.
"(1) TRANSPORTS ANY HAZARDOUS WASTE LISTED UNDER THIS SUBTITLE TO A
FACILITY WHICH DOES NOT HAVE A PERMIT UNDER SECTION 3005 (OR 3006 IN THE
CASE OF A STATE PROGRAM),
"(2) DISPOSES OF ANY HAZARDOUS WASTE LISTED UNDER THIS SUBTITLE
WITHOUT HAVING OBTAINED A PERMIT THEREFOR UNDER THIS SUBTITLE,
"(3) MAKES ANY FALSE STATEMENT OR REPRESENTATION IN ANY APPLICATION,
LABEL, MANIFEST, RECORD, REPORT, PERMIT OR OTHER DOCUMENT FILED,
MAINTAINED, OR USED FOR PURPOSES OF COMPLIANCE WITH THIS SUBTITLE.
SHALL, UPON CONVICTION, BE SUBJECT TO A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $25,000
FOR EACH DAY OF VIOLATION, OR TO IMPRISONMENT NOT TO EXCEED ONE YEAR, OR
BOTH. IF THE CONVICTION IS FOR A VIOLATION COMMITTED AFTER A FIRST
CONVICTION OF SUCH PERSON UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH, PUNISHMENT SHALL BE BY A
FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $50,000 PER DAY OF VIOLATION, OR BY IMPRISONMENT
FOR NOT MORE THAN TWO YEARS, OR BY BOTH.
42 USC 6929. "SEC. 3009. UPON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF REGULATIONS
UNDER THIS SUBTITLE NO STATE OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION MAY IMPOSE ANY
REQUIREMENTS LESS STRINGENT THAN THOSE AUTHORIZED UDNER THIS SUBTITLE
RESPECTING THE SAME MATTER AS GOVERNED BY SUCH REGULATIONS, EXCEPT THAT
IF APPLICATION OF A REGULATION WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE IS POSTPONED OR ENJOINED BY THE ACTION OF ANY COURT, NO STATE
OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION SHALL BE PROHIBITED FROM ACTING WITH RESPECT TO
THE SAME ASPECT OF SUCH MATTER UNTIL SUCH TIME AS SUCH REGULATION TAKES
EFFECT.
42 USC 6930. "SEC. 3010. (A) PRELIMINARY NOTIFICATION. -- NOT LATER
THAN NINETY DAYS AFTER PROMULGATION OR REVISION OF REGULATIONS UNDER
SECTION 3001 IDENTIFYING BY ITS CHARACTERISTICS OR LISTING ANY SUBSTANCE
AS HAZARDOUS WASTE SUBJECT TO THIS SUBTITLE, ANY PERSON GENERATING OR
TRANSPORTING SUCH SUBSTANCE OR OWNING OR OPERATING A FACILITY FOR
TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL OF SUCH SUBSTANCE SHALL FILE WITH THE
ADMINISTRATOR (OR WITH STATES HAVING AUTHORIZED HAZARDOUS WASTE PERMIT
PROGRAMS UNDER SECTION 3006) A NOTIFICATION STATING THE LOCATION AND
GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF SUCH ACTIVITY AND THE IDENTIFIED OR LISTED
HAZARDOUS WASTES HANDLED BY SUCH PERSON. NOT MORE THAN ONE SUCH
NOTIFICATION SHALL BE REQUIRED TO BE FILED WITH RESPECT TO THE SAME
SUBSTANCE. NO IDENTIFIED OR LISTED HAZARDOUS WASTE SUBJECT TO THIS
SUPTITLE MAY BE TRANSPORTED, TREATED, STORED, OR DISPOSED OF UNLESS
NOTIFICATION HAS BEEN GIVEN AS REQUIRED UNDER THIS SUBSECTION.
"(B) EFFECTIVE DATE OR REGULATION. -- THE REGULATIONS UNDER THIS
SUBTITLE RESPECTING REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO THE GENERATION,
TRANSPORTATION, TREATMENT, STORAGE, OR DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
(INDLUDING REQUIREMENTS RESPECTING PERMITS FOR SUCH TREATMENT, STORAGE,
OR DISPOSAL) SHALL TAKE EFFECT ON THE DATE SIX MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF
PROMULGATION THEREOF (OR SIC MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF REVISION IN THE
CASE OF ANY REGULATION WHICH IS REVISED AFTER THE DATE REQUIRED FOR
PROMULGATION THEREOF).
42 USC 6931. SEC. 3011. (A) AUTHORIZATION. -- THERE IS AUTHORIZED
TO BE A-PROPRIATED $25,000,000 FOR EACH OF THE FISCAL YEARS 1978 AND
1979 TO BE USED TO MAKE GRANTS TO THE STATES FOR PURPOSES OF ASSISTING
THE STATES IN THE DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF AUTHORIZED STATE
HAZARDOUS WASTE PROGRAMS.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 064 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105361
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
"(B) ALLOCATION. -- AMOUNTS AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED UNDER
SUBSECTION (A) SHALL BE ALLOCATED AMONG THE STATES ON THE BASIS OF
REGULATIONS PROMULGATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH
THE STATES, WHICH TAKE INTO ACCOUNT, THE EXTENT TO WHICH HAZARDOUS WASTE
IS GENERATED, TRANSPORTED, TREATED, STORED, AND DISPOSED OF WITHIN SUCH
STATE, THE EXTENT OF EXPOSURE OF HUMAN BEINGS AND THE ENVIRONMENT WITHIN
SUCH STATE TO SUCH WASTE, AND SUCH OTHER FACTORS AS THE ADMINISTRATOR
DEEMS APPROPRIATE.
96TH CONGRESS 2ND SESSION
REPORT ON HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT.
800300
800319
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
CHAPTER 1 SECTION 3001
CORNERSTONE OF SUBTITLE C; REVISION AND
REDUCTION
CHAPTER 2 DELAYS IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUBTITLE C
CHAPTER 3 NATIONAL RESPONSE AND ENFORCEMENT
CHAPTER 4 INADEQUATE ORGANIZATIONAL EMPHASIS ON HAZARDOUS WASTES: MEDIA TRANSMISSION APPROACH
APPENDIX 1
THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND RECOVERY ACT: LEGISLATION AIMED AT CLOSING THE GAP IN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
90 STAT 2806
PUBLIC LAW 94-580 761021 AN ACT
APPENDIX 2
PART 065 OF 65
RIBICOFF A CHAIRMAN
LEVIN C CHAIRMAN
COSTLE DM
MARINO AA EXECUTIVE OFFICER
SUBCOMMITTEE ON OVERSIGHT GOVERNMENT MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL AFFAIRS UNITED STATES SENATE
US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
CALIFORNIA SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD
105362
REPORT STUDY
CORRESPONDENCE
ACT
SENATE
IN CONGRESSIONAL TESTIMONY AND CORRESPONDENCE, THE CALIFORNIA STATE
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD HAS NOTED THE SUPERIOR POSITION ACCORDED
AIR AND WATER QUALITY PROGRAMS WITHIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGENCY (EPA) HIERARCHY. AIR AND WATER QUALTIY PROGRAMS ARE WELL
ESTABLISHED AND PROPERLY FUNDED. SOLID WASTE MANAGMEENT, ON THE OTHER
HAND, IS IN A FORMATIVE STAGE, ITS PROGRAMS DEVELOPMENTAL AND ITS
FUNDING UNCERTAIN. FOR THESE AND OTHER REASONS THE ADMINISTRATORS OF
EPA'S AIR AND WATER PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN GIVEN THE STATUS OF ASSISTANT
ADMINISTRATORS, WHILE THE ADMINISTRATOR OF SOLID WASTE IS CONSIDERED A
DEPUTY ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR.
WE THINK THIS SHOULD CHANGE: THE OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE SHOULD BE
GIVEN EQUAL RANK WITH AIR AND WATER PROGRAMS WITH AN ACCOMPANYING
ELEVATION IN THE RANK OF THE CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER FOR SOLID
WASTE. SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT (WHICH WE IN CALIFORNIA CALL THE "3RD
ENVIRONMENT"), IS AN EMERGING AND FAST GROWING CONCERN, ENCOMPASSING AIR
AND WATER ISSUES AS WELL AS HEALTH AND SAFETY PROBLEMS, AESTHETIC AND
NUISANCE PROBLEMS, LAND USE PROBLEMS, BUSINESS AND CONSUMER PROBLEMS,
AND POLITICAL PROBLEMS. SUCH A DIVERSE CONCERN DESERVES APPROPRIATE
ORGANIZATIONAL ATTENTION.
NUMBEROUS CITIES IN AMERICA ARE FACED WITH SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
CRISES -- PARTICULARLY PROBLEMS WITH SITING NEEDED DISPOSAL AREAS, AND
CONSEQUENT PROBLEMS OF WHERE TO DISPOSE OUR WASTE. AT TIMES THE SITING
PROBLEMS ARE POLITICAL AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC, WHILE AT OTHER TIMES THE
PROBLEMS ARE ENVIRONMENTAL. THESE PROBLEMS DEMAND SUITABLE ATTENTION
FROM THE LOCAL LEVEL TO THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT, IS BECOMING THE MOST CAREFULLY
SCRUTINIZED ASPECT OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT. PRIVATE CITIZENS,
POLITICIANS, ENVIRONMENTAL GROUPS, AND THE MEDIA ARE EXPRESSING A
CONCERN THAT SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT, ESPECIALLY HAZARDOUS WASTE, WILL
BECOME THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEM OF THE 1980'S. THE DANGER IS AT ONCE
IMMINENT AND UNCLEAR, THE MANAGEMENT UNCERTAIN, AND THE FUNDING
INADEQUATE.
PRESENTLY, THE MONIES AVAILABLE FOR GRANTS UNDER SOLID-WASTE PROGRAMS
CANNOT COMPARE WITH THE FUNDS AVILABLE UNDER THE AIR AND WATER PROGRAMS.
CLEARLY, THIS SITUATION SHOULD CHANGE FOR THE ABOVE STATED REASONS.
THE REQUESTS FOR FUNDING TO DETERMINE 'IMMINENT HAZARDS' FROM IMPROPER
WASTE DISPOSAL WOULD SUBSTANTIALLY INCREASE AVAILABLE MONIES.
CONSEQUENTLY, SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT WILL PROBABLY SURPASS THE AIR
QUALITY PROGRAMS' SIGNFICANCE AND FUNDING LEVELA ND BE COMPARABLE WITH
THE WATER QUALITY PROGRAMS. THIS PROVIDES FURTHER JUSTIFICATION FOR THE
ELEVATION OF THE OFFICE OF SOLID WASTE AND ITS ADMINISTRATOR. FURTHER,
WITHOUT ADMINISTRATION OF EAUAL RANK TO WATER AND AIR, SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT CONCERNS ARE SECONDARY TO THE OTHER TWO ENVIRONMENTS. THIS
COULD RESULT IN EXPENDITURES TO CLEAN AIR AND WATERWAYS, AT THE EXPENSE
OF BEING ABLE TO PROPERLY DISPOSE OF SOLID WASTE. SOLUTION TO ONE
PROBLEM SHOULD NOT BE AT THE EXPENSE OF SOLVING THE OTHER.
IN SUMMARY, THE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT BOARD SUPPORTS A MOVE TO
UPGRAD THE STATUS OF THE OFFICE FO SOLID WASTE. SOLID WASTE MANAGMEENT
DESERVES PROPER FUNDING AND ADMINISTRATIVE ATTENTION. FOR TOO LONG, THE
POLLUTION OF THE LAND HAS BEEN UNCHECKED, WHILE AIR AND WATER POLLUTION
HAVE BEEN COMBATTED VIGOROUSLY. HOWEVER, THIS CANNOT CONTINUE;
POLLUTION OF THE LAND WILL REMAIN AN ENVIRONMENTAL PROBLEM UNLESS
PROPERLY MITIGATED. AN ASSISTANT ADMINISTRATOR FOR SOLID WASTE WILL
ENHANCE THIS STRUGGLE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
HEARINGS BEFORE THE PANEL ON MATERIALS POLICY OF THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION OF THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
UNITED STATES SENATE NINETY-THIRD CONGRESS SECOND SESSION ON S. 3560, S. 3549, S. 1086, S. 3277, AND S. 3954 SERIAL NO. 93-H47 PART 2
740709, 740710, 740711, 740715, 740716
US. SENATE
COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION
106446
S641-12
HEARINGS
TRANSCRIPT
SENATE
PRINTED FOR THE USE OF THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC ORKS
COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS EDMUND S. MUSKIE, MAINE JOSEPH M. MONOYA,
NEW MEXICO MIKE GRAVEL, ALASKA LLOYD BENTSEN, TEXAS QUENTIN N. BURDICK,
NORTH DAKOTA DICK CLARK, IOWA JOSEPH R. BIDEN, JR., DELAWARE HOWARD H.
BAKER, JR., TENNESSEE JAMES L. BUCKLEY, NEW YORK ROBERT T. STAFFORD,
VERMONT WILLIAM L. SCOTT, VIRGINIA JAMES A. MCCLURE, IDAHO PETE V.
DOMENICI, NEW MEXICO M. BARBY MEYER, CHIEF COUNSEL AND CHIEF CLERK
BAILEY GUARD, MINORITY CLERK; RICHARD A HELLMAN, MINORITY COUNSEL LEON
G. BILLINGS, SENIOR STAFF MEMBER PHILIP T CUMMINGS, ASSISTANT CHIEF
COUNSEL; JOHN W. YAGO, JR., ASSISTANT CHIEF CLERK JAMES R. READLE,
RICHARD M HARRIS, MARGARET L. WORKMAN, AND RICHARD E. HEROD (MINORITY),
ASSISTANT COUNSELS RICHARD E. KAIT (MINORITY), LEGAL ASSISTANT
PROFESSIONAL AND RESEARCH STAFF: KARL R. BRAITHWAITE
HAROLD H. BRAYMAN, PAUL CHIMES, TRENTON CROW, KATHERINE Y. CUDLIPP
PAUL F. EBELTOFT, JR., GEORGE F. FENTON, JR., RANDOLPH G. FLOOD
KATHALEEN R. E. FORCUM, ANN GARRABRANT, RICHARD T. GREER,
RICHARD D. GRUNDY, WESLEY F. HAYDEN, VERONICA A. HOLLAND
RONALD L. KATZ, LARRY D. MEYERS, CLARK F. NORTON, JUDY F. PARSENTE
JOHN B. PURINTON, JACQUELINE E. SCHAFER, DIANE L. STEWART,
CHARLENE A. STORBITTS, E. STEVENS SWAIN, JR.,AND SALLY W. WALKER.
SUBCOMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION EDMUND S MUSKIE, MAINE,
CHAIRMAN JENNINGS RANDOLPH, WEST VIRGINIA LLOYD BENTSEN, TEXAS DICK
CLARK, IOA JOSEPH R. BIDEN, JR., DELAWARE JAMES L. BUCKLEY, NEW YORK
HOWARD H. BAKER, JR., TENNESSEE ROBERT T. STAFFORD, VERMONT JAMES A.
MCCLURE, IDAHO PETE V. DOMENICI, NEW MEXICO
PANEL ON MATERIALS POLICY JENNINGS RANDOLPH, WEST VIRGINIA EDMUND S.
MUSKIE, MAINE LLOYD BENTSEN, TEXAS JOSEPH R. BIDEN, JR., DELAWARE ROBERT
T. STAFFORD, VERMONT JAMES A. MCCLURE, IDAHO PETE V. DOMENICI, NEW
MEXICO
CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS OMITTED
TABLE OF CONTENTS OMITTED
OPENING STATEMENT OF RANDOLPH J
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
RANDOLPH J SENATOR, WV
U.S. SENATE
106450
HEARING
TRANSCRIPT
SENATE
TUESDAY, JULY 9, 1974
THE PANEL MET AT 9:30 A.M.,PURSUANT TO CALL, IN ROOM 4200, DIRKSEN
SEATE OFFICE BUILDING, HON. JENNINGS RANDOLPH (CHAIRMAN OF THE FULL
COMMITTEE) PRESIDING.
PRESENT: SENATORS RANDOLPH, GRAVEL, BIDEN, STAFFORD, AND DOMENICI.
SENATOR RANDOLPH. GOOD MORNING, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN.
NEARLY 1 MONTH AGO OUR PANEL ON MATERIALS POLICY FORMALLY BEGAN TO
FUNCTION BY CONVENING A SERIES OF HEARINGS ON MATERIALS POLICY AND SOLID
WASTE ISSUES.
TODAY IS THE FIRST OF 7 DAYS OF HEARINGS ON SPECIFIC LEGISLATIVE
PROPOSALS THAT ATTEMPT TO COPE WITH THE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY PROBLEM FACING AMERICAN CITIES. WE TRUST THAT WE WILL
PROCEED IN A PRODUCTIVE MANNER.
THESE HEARINGS WILL REVIEW THE FOLLOWING BILLS: S.3560, THE SOLID
WASTE UTILIZATION ACT OF 1974, WHICH I INTRODUCED IN THE SENATE;
S.3549, THE ENERGY RECOVERY AND RESOURCE CONSERVATION ACT OF 1974,
INTRODUCED BY SENATOR MUSKIE; S.3277, THE ENERGY AND RESOURCE RECOVERY
ACTOF 1974, SINTRODUCED BY SENATOR DOMENICI; S.1086, THE HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT ACT OF 1973, INTRODUCED BY SENATOR BAKER ON BEHALF OF
THE ADMINISTRATION; AND S.3954, THE RESOURCE CONSERVATION AND ENERGY
RECOVERY ACT OF 1974, INTRODUCED BY SENATOR HART.
I THINK IT IS NECESSARY AT THE OUTSET TO EXPLAIN THE LEGISLATIVE
SITUATION AS WE MOVE FORWARD IN THESE HEARINGS. I REFER TO A VERSION OF
SENATOR HART'S BILL WHICH IS BEFORE THE COMMITTEE ON COMMERCE. IT ALSO
WAS REINTRODUCED BY THE ABLE SENATOR FROM MICHIGAN FOR PURPOSES OF
CONSIDERATION BY THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS.
THIS MORNING THE PANEL ON MATERIALS POLICY WILL HEAR WITNESSES
REPRESENTING STATE AND COUNTY AND CITY GOVERNMENTS. IT IS AT THE LOCAL
LEVEL THAT THE SOLID WASTE BATTLE MUST BE FOUGHT. IF THE PREDICTION
THAT AMERICA WILL BE BURIED IN ITS OWN GARBAGE IS TO BE MADE A FALSE
PROPHECY, LOCAL PUBLIC OFFICIALS ON THE FIRING LINE ARE WELL AWARE OF
THE MAGNITUDE OF THE PROBLEM.
IN A RECENT POLL, MUNICIPAL OFFICIALS LIST SOLID WASTE AT THE TOP OF
28 MAJOR PROBLEMS FACING URBAN AREAS.
SOLID WASTE PROBLEMS INVOLVE MORE THAN JUST MERE DISPOSAL OF WHAT WE
CALL DISCARDS. THE ENERGY CRISIS AND THE CONTINUING ATTENTION WHICH WE
MUST GIVE TO THIS SUBJECT AND THE GROWING SHORTAGES OF RAW MATERIALS
MAKE IT ESSENTIAL THAT WE DEVISE AND IMPLEMENT RESOURCE RECOVERY.
THIS COUNTRY, OUR ECONOMY GENERALLY, HAS GROWN RICH WITH USE AND
DISCARD ATTITUDES MADE POSSIBLE BY WHAT WE THOUGHT WAS AN INEXHAUSTIBLE
SUPPLY OF RESOURCES.
I PAUSE TO SAY WE HAVE HAD A RUDE AWAKENING, THAT THAT IS A FALSE
ASSUMPTION. REALITY IS NOW FORCING US TO ADOPT CONSERVATION ATTITUDES
AND TO DEVELOP THE POTENTIAL FOR REUSING MANY MATERIALS THAT WE FORMERLY
CONSIDERED AS WASTE.
IN THE ENERGY FIELD ALONE THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
ESTIMATES THAT WE CAN SAVE THE EQUIVALENT OF 521,000 BARRELS OF OIL --
NOT MONTHLY, NOT WEEKLY -- BUT DAILY, THROUGH BETTER SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY METHODS. THIS IS EQUIVALENT TO 35
PERCENT OF THE OIL THAT WILL BE DELIVERED THROUGH THE ALASKA PIPELINE.
THE SOLID WASTE AND RESOURCE RECOVERY LEGISLATION THAT IS NOW PENDING
BEFORE US REFLECTS A GROWING CONCERN I HOPE BY ALL THE AMERICAN PEOPLE,
NOT ONLY BY THOSE IN CONGRESS, TO THE MAGNITUDE OF THIS NATIONAL AND
CONSTANTLY GROWING PROBLEM.
THE MEASURES THAT WE HAVE BEFORE US INCLUDE A VARIETY OF APPROACHES
TO MEET THE CHALLENGE. I THINK ALL THE BILLS ARE WITH ONE MAIN PURPOSE.
DURING THESE HEARINGS WE WILL EXPLORE WITH WITNESSES HOW BEST TO
CREATE A PROGRAM THAT WILL PROVIDE A REALISTIC AND WORKABLE RESPONSE TO
THE MULTIPLE SOLID WASTE AND RESOURCE RECOVERY QUESTIONS THAT CONTINUE
TO BE DISCUSSED.
SHORTLY AFTER THESE HEARINGS HAVE CONCLUDED WE WILL MEET TO DRAFT A
COMPREHENSIVE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY BILL. IT IS
MY HOPE, AND I THINK IT IS SHARED BY OTHER MEMERS OF THE PANEL AND OUR
COMMITTEE, THAT WE WILL PRODUCE PERHAPS A WIDE RANGING BILL REFLECTING
THE BEST ELEMENTS OF ALL OF THE MEASURES THAT ARE BEFORE US THAT I HAVE
MENTIONED AND PERHAPS ADDITIONAL LEGISLATIVE PROPOSALS THAT WILL COME TO
OUR ATTENTION.
THEN WE WILL FACILITATE SUBSTANTIAL NEW EFFORTS IN THIS VITAL AREA OF
ATTENTION AND CONCERN.
DURING THESE HEARINGS WE ARE GOING TO HAVE MANY INDIVIDUALS AND
ORGANIZATIONS TESTIFY. DIFFERING VIEWPOINTS OF COURSE WILL BE SET
FORTH.
AS THE CHAIRMAN OF THE PANEL I WELCOME EXPRESSIONS OF DIVERSE OPINION
FOR IT IS HIGHLY IMPORTANT AS A PART OF THE LEGISLATIVE PROCESS THAT WE
KNOW AND IF WE CAN UNDERSTAND THE THOUGHTS, THE CONVICTIONS OF THE
PEOPLE AND, OF COURSE,THIS MEANS ALL OF THE PEOPLE IF THEY RESPOND WHO
ARE AFFECTED BY WHAT WE IN PART SHALL DO HERE.
A NATION, I REMIND ALL OF US THIS MORNING, THAT PRODUCES NEARLY 4.5
BILLION TONS OF SOLID WASTE A YEAR MUST CERTAINLY GIVE A MAJOR ATTENTION
TO WAYS OF CONVERTING THIS HUGE WASTE INTO USEFUL MATERIALS -- I REPEAT,
4.5 BILLION TONS OF SOLID WASTE A YEAR.
SO THAIS OUR PURPOSE THIS MORNING THROUGH THESE HEARINGS AND IN THE
COMING WEEKS.
I AM SURE THAT THE MEMBERS OF OUR PANEL WISH TO EXPLORE IN DEPTH
THESE MATTERS. THEY ARE OF MUTUAL CONCERN NOT ONLY OF THE MEMBERS OF
THE PANEL BUT THOSE WHO TESTIFY AND THOSE WHO ARE GUESTS AT THE
HEARINGS. INDIVIDUAL CITIZENS WILL CAREFULLY EXAMINE WHAT WE ARE DOING
HERE. THEREFORE I AGAIN EXPRESS THE THOUGHT THAT THOSE PERSONS WHO
WOULD WISH TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE COMMITTEE SHOULD ADDRESS THEIR
LETTERS TO US BECAUSE IT IS UNDERSTANDABLE THAT WE MAY OVERLOOK
INFORMATION, BACKGROUND MATERIAL, AND INNOVATIVE PROPOSALS THAT YOU AND
OTHERS WHO ARE NOT HERE TODAY MIGHT PLACE BEFORE US.
SENATOR STAFFORD, AS WE BEGIN THESE IMPORTANT HEARINGS KNOING OF YOUR
INTENSE INTEREST IN THIS SUBJECT MATTER, I WOULD WISH TO GIVE YOU THE
OPPORTUNITY FOR ANY COMMENT BEFORE TEE WITNESSE ARE HEARD.
OPENING STATEMENT OF STAFFORD RT
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
STAFFORD R T SENATOR, VT
U.S. SENATE
106452
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
SENATOR STAFFORD. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR CHAIRMAN.
I AM PLEASED, MR CHAIRMAN, THAT UNDER YOUR LEADERSHIP WE HAVE BEGUN
THE LEGISLATIVE HEARINGS THAT WILL PERMIT US TO REPORT NEW
COMPREHENSIVE, SOLID WASTE RESOURCE RECOVERY LEGISLATION IN THE WEEKS
AHEAD. I AM PARTICULARLY PLEASED WE ARE STARTING THESE HEARINGS WITH
WITNESSES FROM STATE, COUNTY, AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS. THESE INDIVIDUALS
ARE IN THE FRONT LINES OF THE BATTLE AGAINST SOLID WASTE AND FOR
IMPROVED RESOURCE RECOVERY.
I TRUST THAT LEGISLATION WHICH WE DEVELOP AS A RESULT OF THESE
HEARINGS WILL BE CONSTRUCTIVE AND POSITIVE IN AIDING STATES AND
LOCALITIES TO BETTER WAGE THIS BATTLE.
WITHOUT ATTEMPTING TO PREJUDGE WHAT FORM THAT LEGISLATION MIGHT TAKE
I BELIEVE THAT THE PRESSURE OF TIME UNDER WHICH WE ARE WORKING MAY MAKE
IT IMPOSSIBLE TO PRODUCE AS COMPREHENSIVE A BILL IN TERMS OF REGULATION
AND ASSISTANCE THAT WE MIGHT WISH.
IF THIS PERCEPTION PROVES TO BE CORRECT I HOPE THAT WE WILL AT
LEAST NOT ENACT ANY PROVISIONS THAT INHIBIT INNOVATIVE AND
WORTHWHILE STEPS BY STATES AND LOCALITIES TO REDUCE THE SOLID
WASTE BURDENS AND BETTER RECOVER ENERGY AND MATERIALS FROM SOLID
WASTE THAT ARE COLLECTED.
IN THIS REGARD I AM PLEASED TO NOTE THAT GRANT MERRITT IN HIS
PREPARED STATEMENT TO BE GIVEN THIS MORNING RECOGNIZES THAT SOURCE
REDUCTION PROGRAMS SHOULD COEXIST WITH RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAMS.
WITH THESE FEW REMARKS, MR CHAIRMAN, I LOOK FORWARD TO HEARING OUR
WITNESSES THIS MORNING AND IN THE NEXT 6 DAYS OF HEARINGS. I THINK WE
ARE WELL ON OUR WAY TOWARDS HAVING SIGNIFICANT NEW ENERGY AND RESOURCE
RECOVERY LEGISLATION WITH THE MAJOR AIR AND WATER QUALITY AUTHORITIES
THAT THIS COMMITTEE HAS PRODUCED.
I AM ALWAYS VERY PLEASED, MR CHAIRMAN, TO SERVE UNDER YOUR LEADERSHIP
ON ANY COMMITTEE IN THE SENATE THAT WE WORK ON TOGETHER.
SENATOR RANDOLPH. THANK YOU, SENATOR STAFFORD. WE WILL CONTINUE TO
APPROACH THESE PROBLEMS IN THE OBJECTIVE, CONSTRUCTIVE WAY THAT IS THE
COMMITMENT OF THIS PANEL. WE APPRECIATE YOUR PRESENCE HERE AT THE
OPENING SESSION.
SENATOR DOMENICI, YOU ARE THE AUTHOR OF ONE OF THE BILLS THAT WILL BE
ACTIVELY CONSIDERED DURING THESE HEARINGS AND THE MARKUP SESSIONS. I
KNOW OF YOUR CONSIDERABLE STUDY IN PREPARATION FOR THESE HEARINGS AND WE
WOULD WELCOME COMMENTS FROM YOU BEFORE THE WITNESSES ARE HEARD TODAY.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 001 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106453
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SENATOR DOMENICI. THANK YOU VERY MUCH, MR. CHAIRMAN.
I, TOO, ECHO THE REMARKS OF OUR RANKING MEMBER. I AM PARTICULARLY
PLEASED TO PARTICIPATE IN THESE HEARINGS BECAUSE I BELIEVE THEY MARK A
TURNING POINT IN OUR ATTITUDE TOWARD THE TREATMENT OF SOLID WASTE.
THE BILL WHICH WILL EMERGE AS A RESULT OF THESE HEARINGS AND
SUBSEQUENT EFFORTS OF THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS MAY WELL HAVE THE
SAME KIND OF VITALIZING EFFECT AS THE CLEAN AIR AMENDMENTS OF 1970 HAD
IN THE EFFORT AGAINST AIR POLLUTION. TO AN ACT WHICH WAS PRIMARILY
ORIENTED TOWARD RESEARCH AND STUDY, THOSE AMENDMENTS ADDED BOTH
INDUCEMENTS AND REQUIREMENTS TO ACTION; THEY PROVIDED BOTH THE CARROT
AND STICK.
ALTHOUGH THE PATH HAS BEEN DIFFICULT, AND STILL IS, PEOPLE NOW KNOW
WHAT THEY CAN EXPECT, AND POLLUTERS HAVE A CLEAR DEFINITION OF WHAT THEY
MUST ACHIEVE. WE HAVE PROGRESSED FROM WORRYING ABOUT WHAT TO DO, TO
DISCUSSING HOW WE CAN DO IT, AND WHEN.
ALTHOUGH IT HAS BEEN IN EXISTENCE NEARLY AS LONG AS THE CLEAN AIR
ACT, THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT IS STILL RELATIVELY TOOTHLESS. IT
DEALS ALMOST ENTIRELY WITH RESEARCH, DEMONSTRATION AND PLANNING. ITS
ONLY MEANS OF INDUCING ACTION IS GRANTS FOR PLANNING, RESEARCH,
DEMONSTRATION OF NEW DISPOSAL SYSTEMS, CONSTRUCTION OF NEEDED MUNICIPAL
FACILITIES, AND TRAINING OF THE MANPOWER NEEDED TO OPERATE AND MANAGE
DISPOSAL FACILITIES. BUT THERE ARE TIMES WHEN COAXING ISN'T ENOUGH. IT
IS PARTICULARLY HARD WHEN THE FUNDS ARE IMPOUNDED, OR LEFT OUT OF THE
FEDERAL BUDGET, AS NEARLY HAPPENED LAST YEAR.
WE ARE GOING TO PUT TEETH IN THE SOLID WASTE ACT. EACH OF THE
PENDING BILLS INVOLVES SOME KIND OF STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS WHICH ARE
TO BE MET. MOST OF THE BILLS EXPLICITLY INCLUDE PROCEDURES FOR
ENFORCING THOSE STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS, AND DEADLINES FOR PUTTING
THEM INTO EFFECT.
IT WAS THIS COMBINATION OF STANDARDS AND DEADLINES WHICH MADE THE
CLEAN AIR ACT AN EFFECTIVE INSTRUMENT OF PUBLIC POLICY. WE WILL PROVIDE
THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE EPA WITH AN EQUALLY EFFECTIVE TOOL FOR DEALING
WITH SOLID WASTE TREATMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY.
A SECOND MAJOR CHANGE IS THE HEAVY EMPHASIS ON RECOVERY OF ENERGY AND
RESOURCES FROM SOLID WASTE. IN THE ORIGINAL SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT OF
1965, THE FLAVOR WAS VERY MUCH THAT SOLID WASTE WAS A NUISANCE, AND THE
PROBLEM WAS TO GET RID OF IT IN THE LEAST OBJECTIONABLE MANNER POSSIBLE.
THE RESOURCE RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 INTRODUCED THE CONCEPT OF RESOURCE
RECOVERY FROM SOLID WASTES ON A MORE OR LESS EQUAL FOOTING WITH
DISPOSAL. BUT, IN PRACTICE, THE EMPHASIS HAS REMAINED ON DISPOSAL
SYSTEMS. THE ENERGY CRISIS HAS MADE IT CLEAR THAT WE MUST PAY MORE
ATTENTION TO THE WASTE OF OUR ENERGY SOURCES AND, BY EXTENSION, OF OUR
OTHER NONRENEWABLE RESOURCES. WE REALIZE MORE CLEARLY NOW THAT SIMPLE
DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE IS, ITSELF, WASTEFUL.
THE TITLES OF THE BILLS NOW PENDING REFLECT THIS CONCERN: "THE SOLID
WASTE UTILIZATION ACT", "THE ENERGY RECOVERY AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
ACT", AND MY BILL, "THE ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY ACT".
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 002 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106454
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
I BELIEVE THAT THIS ASPECT OF SOLID WASTE TREATMENT IS SO IMPORTANT
THAT MY BILL. S. 3277, INCLUDES A PROVISION FOR ESTABLISHING WITHIN THE
EPA AN OFFICE OF ENERGY AND RESOURCE RECOVERY, SO THAT AN IDENTIFIABLE
GOVERNMENTAL UNIT EXISTS WHOSE RESPONSIBILITY IT IS TO SEE THAT WE MAKE
THE BEST REUSE POSSIBLE OF RESOURCES WHICH HAS BEEN THROUGH OUR ECONOMIC
SYSTEM AND DISCARDED.
WE STILL HAVE MUCH TO LEARN ABOUT HOW TO DO THIS. THE PENDING BILLS
SHOW A RECOGNITION OF THIS FACT IN THEIR EXPANSION OR CONTINUATION OF
THE RESEARCH GRANT SYSTEM OF THE ORIGINAL SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT. I
BELIEVE THAT THIS ASPECT NEEDS EVEN MORE EMPHASIS. I HAVE THEREFORE
PROVIDED IN MY BILL FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF STATE ENERGY AND RESOURCES
RECOVERY RESEARCH INSTITUTES AT A COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY IN EACH STATE.
I BELIEVE THAT THESE CENTERS CAN PROVIDE IDEAS AND TALENTS TO
SUPPLEMENT THE RESEARCH NOW BEING CARRIED ON AT EPA LABORATORIES AND
UNDER SPECIFIC GRANTS, AND CAN RESPOND MORE EFFECTIVELY TO THE UNIQUE
PROBLEMS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR RESOURCE RECOVERY WHICH EXIST IN EACH
STATE AND LOCALITY.
THIS EMPHASIS ON LOCAL RESPONSE TO LOCAL PROBLEMS IS ANOTHER
COMMON FEATURE OF THE BILLS BEFORE US. 2. 3277, FOR INSTANCE,
EVEN PROVIDES FOR TRANSFER OF ENFORCEMENT OF STANDARDS TO STATE
AGENCIES, AS WELL AS THE MORE USUAL CONSULTATION WITH STATE
AND LOCAL OFFICIALS IN DEVELOPING THE STANDARDS.
FURTHER, I SHARE WITH OUR CHAIRMAN, THE DISTINGUISHED SENATOR FROM
WEST VIRGINIA, THE BELIEF THAT PRIVATE ORGANIZATIONS AND INDIVIDUALS CAN
PLAY AN IMPORTANT ROLE IN REDUCING SOLID WASTE AND IN RECOVERING
RESOURCES FROM IT.
IN MY BILL, THIS TAKES THE FORM OF SMALL BUSINESS LOANS TO ASSIST IN
MAKING ADDITIONS OR ALTERATIONS IN FACILITIES OR METHODS OF OPERATION TO
RECOVER ENERGY AND RESOURCES FROM SOLID WASTE.
BEFORE I CLOSE, I WOULD LIKE TO POINT OUT ONE RATHER SUBTLE CHANGE
INCLUDED IN THE BILL INTRODUCED BY MY COLLEAGUE FROM MAINE. MR. MUSKIE.
THE DEFINITION OF "SOLID WASTE" HAS BEEN EXPANDED TO INCLUDE, AMONG
OTHER THINGS, WASTE OIL. I AGREE WITH MY COLLEAGUE THAT, WHETHER IT IS
SOLID OR NOT, WASTE OIL IS PART AND PARCEL OF THE PROBLEM OF DISPOSAL,
AND OF ENERGY AND RESOURCE RECOVERY.
I BELIEVE, HOWEVER, THAT IT HAS SOME UNIQUE CHARACTERISTICS, AND
REQUIRES SOMEWHAT DIFFERENT TREATMENT THAN MOST OTHER WASTES WITH WHICH
WE ARE DEALING.
FOR THAT REASON, I HAVE INTRODUCED A SEPARATE BILL. S. 3625,
PROVIDING APPROACHES WHICH SHOULD BE EFFECTIVE IN RETURNING MORE OF THIS
VALUABLE AND INCREASINGLY SCARCE MATERIAL TO USE.
ALTHOUGH THESE HEARINGS DO NOT DEAL WITH THAT SUBJECT, I WOULD
RESPECTFULLY SUGGEST TO THE CHARIMAN THAT THIS PANEL MIGHT HOLD HEARINGS
ON IT SOON, SO THAT THE BILL TO BE DEVELOPED IN THE PUBLIC WORKS
COMMITTEE MAY CONTAIN APPROPRIATE PROVISIONS TO DEAL WITH THIS PROBLEM.
THIS, BRIEFLY, IS MY POSITION AS THESE HEARINGS OPEN. PROGRESS HAS
BEEN MADE, BUT THE MOST IMPORTANT PROGRESS LIES BEFORE US. THESE
HEARINGS WILL SET THE STAGE FOR IT. I AM EAGER TO HEAR HOW OUR
WITNESSES VIEW THE PROBLEMS AND OUR PROPOSED SOLUTIONS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 003 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106455
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
I DON'T WANT TO TAKE ANY FURTHER TIME FROM THE WITNESSES. I DO
EXPRESS MY THANKS TO THE CHAIRMAN FOR ORIGINATING THIS PANEL. I DO
BELIEVE THE U.S. SENATE WILL PRODUCE A MEANINGFUL BILL IN ONE OF THE
MOST SIGNIFICANT AREAS AT LEAST OF MUNICIPAL PROBLEMS IN THIS COUNTRY.
I THINK IF WE COMBINE REGULATION AND STANDARDS WITH RESOURCE
CONVERSION WE WILL INDEED MAKE A GIANT STRIDE BOTH AT CLEANING UP
AMERICA AND AT BETTER UTILIZATION OF MANY RESOURCES AND MATERIALS WHICH
WE INTEND TO WASTE AS PEOPLE.
I AM PREPARED TO PARTICIPATE FULLY WITH THE HOPE THAT IN THE VERY
NEAR FUTURE WE WILL BE AT MARKUP AND HAVE A SUBSTANTIAL BILL BEFORE THE
U.S. SENATE BEFORE THIS SESSION OF CONGRESS ENDS.
I THANK THE CHAIRMAN FOR HIS KINDNESS.
SENATOR RANDOLPH. THANK YOU, SENATOR DOMENICI.
(THE BILLS S.3560, S. 3549, S.1086, S.3277, AND S. 3954 FOLLOW:)
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 004 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106456
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
MR. RANDOLPH INTRODUCED THE FOLLOWING BILL; WHICH WAS READ TWICE AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
TO AMEND THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT SO AS TO ENCOURAGE TO THE
GREATEST EXTENT PRACTICABLE THE RECOVERY OF MATERIALS AND ENERGY FROM
SOLID WASTE RESIDUES, TO AUTHORIZE REGIONAL SOLID WASTE SYSTEM AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY PLANNING GRANTS, TO PROVIDE INCENTIVES FOR THE
RECOVERY OF RESOURCES FROM SOLID WASTES, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN CONGRESS ASSEMBLED, THAT THIS ACT, DIVIDED
INTO TITLES AND SECTIONS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING TABLE OF
CONTENTS, MAY BE CITED AS THE "SOLID WASTE UTILIZATION ACT OF 1974".
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 005 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106457
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS OMITTED.
DECLARATION OF POLICY
SEC. 2. IT IS HEREBY DECLARED TO BE THE NATIONAL POLICY TO ENCOURAGE
TO THE GREATEST EXTENT PRACTICABLE THE RECOVERY OF RESOURCES, INCLUDING
ENERGY, FROM SOLID WASTE. IN THE FURTHERANCE OF THIS POLICY, IT IS THE
OBJECTIVE OF THIS ACT:
(A) TO PROHIBIT ALL OPEN BURNING OR OPEN DUMPING OF SOLID WASTE;
(B) TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR THE
CONSTRUCTION OF RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS;
(C) TO REQUIRE THE PLANNING OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS,
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEMS ON A
REGIONAL BASIS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 006 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106458
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(D) TO ENHANCE MARKETS FOR RECOVERED RESOURCES THROUGH (1) A
PREFERENCE IN FEDERAL PROCUREMENT POLICIES FOR GOODS OR MATERIALS
CONTAINING RECOVERED RESOURCES AND (2) THE AUTHORIZATION OF PAYMENT OF
THOSE ADDITIONAL PROCUREMENT COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH SUCH GOODS OR
MATERIALS; AND
(E) TO REQUIRE A MARKET FOR ALL RESOURCES RECOVERED FROM CONTAINERS
WHICH ARE GUARANTEED BY THE MANUFACTURERS OF SUCH CONTAINERS OR THE
MANUFACTURERS OF THE PRIMARY MATERIALS FROM WHICH SUCH CONTAINERS ARE
PRODUCED.
SEC. 3. THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED BY THE RESOURCE
RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 (84 STAT. 1230), IS AMENDED BY INSERTING AFTER
SECTION 212 THE FOLLOWING NEW SECTIONS AND RENUMBERING SUCCEEDING
SECTIONS ACCORDINGLY:
"SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL STANDARDS
"SEC. 213 (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY
DAYS AFTER THE ENACTMENT OF THE SOLID WASTE UTILIZATION ACT OF 1974,
PROMULGATE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL STANDARDS, INCLUDING METHODS AND
OPERATIONAL PROCEDURES, FOR THE DISPOSAL, INCLUDING STORAGE. SUCH
STANDARDS SHALL APPLY (1) TO THE DISPOSAL, INCLUDING STORAGE, OF ALL
INDUSTRIAL SOLID WASTE NOT COLLECTED BY ANY MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE
MANAGMENT SYSTEM, (2) TO THE DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE FROM ANY
MUNICIPALITY WHICH HAS A POPULATION GREATER THAN TWO THOUSAND FIVE
HUNDRED, AND (3) TO THE DISPOSAL OF AGRICULTURAL AND MINERAL SOLID
WASTES NOT COLLECTED BY ANY MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 007 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106459
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) SUCH STANDARDS, AT THE MINIMUM, SHALL REQUIRE:
"(1) THE PROHIBITION OF ALL OPEN BURNING OR OPEN DUMPING OF SOLID
WASTES;
"(2) COMPLIANCE WITH EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS, SCHEDULES OR TIMETABLES
FOR COMPLIANCE OR OTHER REQUIREMENTS ESTABLISHED UNDER AN IMPLEMENTATION
PLAN PURSUANT TO SECTION 110 OF THE CLEAN AIR ACT, AS AMENDED (84 STAT.
1680), OR ANY NEW SOURCE STANDARD OF PERFORMANCE PROMULGATED UNDER
SECTION 111 OF SUCH ACT;
"(3) COMPLIANCE WITH ANY EFFLUENT LIMITATION OR CONDITION OF A PERMIT
UNDER THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT, AS AMENDED (86 STAT.
816), AND ANY REQUIREMENT FOR AREA-WIDE SOURCES ESTABLISHED UNDER
SECTION 208 OF SUCH ACT; AND
"(4) CONSIDERATION OF THE TOTAL IMPACT OF SUCH DISPOSAL ON (A) THE
ENVIRONMENT, INCLUDING GROUNDWATERS, AND (B) ANY ESTABLISHED OR PROPOSED
LAND USE PLANS FOR THE EFFECTED AREA.
"(C) IN ORDER TO PROVIDE FOR THE ENFORCEMENT OF STANDARDS PROMULGATED
UNDER THIS SECTION, AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF SUCH STANDARDS EACH
SYSTEM FOR THE DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE SHALL BE DEEMED A POINT SOURCE
WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT, AS
AMENDED (86 STAT. 816), AND SHALL BE REQUIRED TO OBTAIN A PERMIT IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 402 OF SUCH ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 008 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106460
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
"SEC. 214. (A) IN CARRYING OUT THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT, THE
ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO STATES,
MUNICIPALITIES, AND AGENCIES DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 215 OF THIS
ACT, TO FACILITATE:
"(1) THE PLANNING AND IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS,
INCLUDING SYSTEMS INTENDED TO RECOVER SIGNIFICANT AMOUNTS OF ENERGY FROM
MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE;
"(2) THE IMPLEMENTATION AND OPERATION OF EFFICIENT CONVENTIONAL SOLID
WASTE MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS;
"(3) THE PLANNING AND IMPLEMENTATION OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
SYSTEMS FOR THE DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE REIDUES RESULTING FROM AIR
POLLUTION CONTROL AND WATER POLLUTION CONTROL REQUIREMENTS OF FEDERAL,
STATE, OR LOCAL GOVERNMENT AGENCIES; AND
"(4) THE PLANNING AND IMPLEMENTATION OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENTS
SYSTEMS FOR THE DISPOSAL, INCLUDING STORAGE, OF HAZARDOUS WASTES.
"(B) SUCH ASSISTANCE SHALL INCLUDE, BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO, PROJECT
PLANNING AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES, MANAGEMENT AND OPERATIONAL ASSISTANCE,
THE PROVISION OF EXPERT CONSULTATION, AND THE DISSEMINATION OF TECHNICAL
INFORMATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 009 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106461
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SUCH ASSISTANCE MAY BE PROVIDED THROUGH (1) PERSONNEL OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, INCLUDING DETAIL OF SUCH PERSONNEL TO
AN AGENCY ELIGIBLE FOR ASSISTANCE UNDER THIS SECTION, (2) THE PAYMENT OF
FUNDS AUTHORIZED FOR THIS SECTION TO OTHER DEPARTMENTS OR AGENCIES OF
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT, (3) THE EMPLOYMENT OF PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS,
PARTNERSHIPS, CORPORATIONS, OR SUITABLE INSTITUTIONS UNDER CONTRACTS
ENTERED INTO FOR SUCH PURPOSES, OR (4) GRANTS-IN-AID TO SUCH STATE,
MUNICIPALITY OR INTERMUNICIPALITY AGENCY DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SECTION
215 OF THIS ACT.
"(C) OF THE FUNDS AUTHORIZED IN SECTION 222 OF THIS ACT FOR EACH
FISCAL YEAR BEGINNING AFTER JUNE 20, 1974, $5,000,000 SHALL BE AVAILABLE
TO CARRY OUT CLAUSE (A)(2) OF THIS SECTION.
"REGIONAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM
PLANNING
"SEC. 215. (A) FOR THE PURPOSE OF ENCOURAGING AND FACILITATING THE
DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF REGIONAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
SYSTEM, RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEM
PLANNING:
"(1) THE ADMINISTRATOR, WITHIN NINETY DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF
ENACTMENT OF THE SOLID WASTE UTILIZATION ACT OF 1974 AND AFTER
CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE FEDERAL, STATE, AND LOCAL AUTHORITIES,
SHALL BE REGULATION PUBLISH GUIDELINES FOR THE IDENTIFICATION OF THOSE
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREAS WHICH, AS A RESULT OF URBAN-INDUSTRIAL
CONCENTRATIONS OR OTHER FACTORS, ARE APPROPRIATE PLANNING UNITS FOR THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF REGIONAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS, RESOURCE
RECOVERY SYSTEMS, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEMS, AND THE SITING
OF FACILITIES FOR INTERMUNICIPAL SYSTEMS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 010 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106462
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
EACH SUCH AREA SHALL CONTAIN AT LEAST ONE URBAN CENTER AND THE
MAXIMUM SURROUNDING TERRITORY WHICH CAN BE IDENTIFIED WITH SUCH URBAN
CENTER BY TRADING PATTERNS, LABOR MARKETS, GEOGRAPHIC FEATURES,
POLITICAL BOUNDARIES, OR OTHER FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH THE MORE
EFFICIENT SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND WITH THE FACILITATION OF MORE
ECONOMIC RECOVERY OF RESOURCES FROM SOLID WASTES.
"(2) THE GOVERNOR OF EACH STATE, WITHIN SIXTY DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION
OF THE GUIDELINES ISSUES PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS SUBSECTION,
SHALL IDENTIFY EACH SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREA WITHIN THE STATE WHICH,
COMPLIES WITH SUCH GUIDELINES. NOT LATER THAN ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY
DAYS FOLLOWING SUCH IDENTIFICATION AND AFTER CONSULTATION WITH
APPROPRIATE ELECTED AND OTHER OFFICIALS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS HAVING
JURISDICTION IN SUCH AREAS, THE GOVERNOR SHALL DESIGNATE (A) THE
BOUNDARIES OF EACH SUCH AREA, AND (B) A SINGLE REPRESENTATIVE
ORGANIZATION, INCLUDING ELECTED OFFICIALS FROM LOCAL GOVERNMENTS, OR
THEIR DESIGNEES, CAPABLE OF DEVELOPING EFFECTIVE REGIONAL SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT, RESOURCE RECOVERY, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISOPSAL SYSTEM PLANS
FOR SUCH AREA.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 011 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106463
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
THE GOVERNOR IN THE SAME MANNER AT ANY LATER TIME MAY IDENTIFY ANY
ADDITIONAL AREA (OR MODIFY AN EXISTING AREA) FOR WHICH HE DETERMINES
REGIONAL PLANNING TO BE APPROPRIATE AND DESIGNATE THE BOUNDARIES OF SUCH
AREAS, AND MAY DESIGNATE AN ORGANIZATION CAPABLE OF DEVELOPING EFFECTIVE
REGIONAL PLANS FOR SUCH AREA.
"(3) WITH RESPECT TO ANY SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREA WHICH, PURSUANT
TO THE GUIDELINES PUBLISHED UNDER PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS SUBSECTION, IS
LOCATED IN TWO OR MORE STATES, THE GOVERNORS OF THE RESPECTIVE STATES
SHALL CONSULT AND COOPERATE IN CARRYING OUT THE PROVISIONS OF PARAGRAPH
(2) OF THIS SUBSECTION, WITH A VIEW TOWARD (A) DESIGNATING THE
BOUNDARIES OF SUCH INTERSTATE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREA FOR THE
PURPOSE OF DEVELOPING THE MOST EFFECTIVE REGIONAL SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT, RESOURCE RECOVERY, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEM
PLANS, AND (B) DESIGNATING, WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY DAYS AFTER
PUBLICATION OF GUIDELINES ISSUED PURSUANT TO PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS
SUBSECTION, A SINGLE REPRESENTATIVE ORGANIZATION CAPABLE OF DEVELOPING
EFFECTIVE REGIONAL PLANS FOR SUCH AREA.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 012 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106464
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(4) IF A GOVERNOR DOES NOT ACT, EITHER BY DESIGNATING OR DETERMINING
NOT TO MAKE A DESIGNATION OF A SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREA UNDER
PARAGRAPH (2) OF THIS SUBSECTION WITHIN THE TIME REQUIRED BY SUCH
PARAGRAPH OR IF, IN THE CASE OF AN INTERSTATE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
AREA, THE GOVERNORS OF THE STATES INVOLVED DO NOT DESIGNATE A PLANNING
ORGANIZATION WITHIN THE TIME REQUIRED BY PARAGRAPH (3) OF THIS
SUBSECTION, THE CHIEF ELECTED OFFICIALS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTS WITHIN AN
AREA MAY BY AGREEMENT DESIGNATE (A) THE BOUNDARIES OF SUCH AN AREA, AND
(B) SINGLE REPRESENTATIVE ORGANIZATION INCLUDING ELECTED OFFICIALS FROM
SUCH LOCAL GOVERNMENTS, OR THEIR DESIGNEES, CAPABLE OF DEVELOPING A
REGIONAL PLAN FOR SUCH AREA.
"(5) EXISTING REGIONAL AGENCIES MAY BE DESIGNATED UNDER PARACRAPHS
(2), (3), AND (4) OF THIS SUBSECTION.
"(6) DESIGNATIONS UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE SUBJECT TO THE
APPROVAL OF THE ADMINISTRATOR.
"(B)(1) WITHIN ONE YEAR AFTER THE DATE OF DESIGNATION OF ANY
ORGANIZATION UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION SUCH ORGANIZATION
SHALL HAVE IN OPERATION A CONTINUING REGIONAL SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT,
RESOURCE RECOVERY, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEM PLANNING PROCESS
CONSISTENT WITH SECTION 213 OF THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 013 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106465
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
PLANS PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS PROCESS SHALL CONTAIN
ALTERNATIVES FOR SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT, RESOURCE RECOVERY, AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL AND SHALL BE APPLICABLE TO ALL SOLID WASTES
GENERATED WITHIN THE AREA INVOLVED. THE INITIAL PLAN PREPARED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SUCH PROCESS SHALL BE CERTIFIED BY THE GOVERNOR AND
SUBMITTED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR NOT LATER THAN TWO YEARS AFTER THE
PLANNING PROCESS IS INITIATED.
"(2) ANY PLAN FOR A SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AREA PREPARED UNDER SUCH
PLANNING PROCESS SHALL INCLUDE, BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO:
"(A)(I) THE IDENTIFICATION OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT, RESOURCE
RECOVERY, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL NEEDS OVER FIVE-, TEN-, AND
TWENTY-YEAR PERIODS, UPDATED EVERY THREE YEARS, INCLUDING PUBLIC AND
PRIVATE FACILITIES, AND ANY REQUIREMENTS FOR THE ACQUISITION OF LAND AND
(II) A PROGRAM TO PROVIDE THE NECESSARY FINANCIAL ARRANGEMENTS TO MEET
SUCH NEEDS;
"(B) THE ESTABLISHMENT OF CONSTRUCTION PRIORITIES FOR SUCH SYSTEMS OR
FACILITIES AND TIME SCHEDULES FOR THEIR INITIATION AND COMPLETION;
"(C) THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A REGULATORY PROGRAM TO REGULATE THE
LOCATION, MODIFICATION, AND CONSTRUCTION OF ANY FACILITIES;
"(D) THE IDENTIFICATION OF THOSE AGENCIES NECESSARY TO CONSTRUCT,
OPERATE, AND MAINTAIN ALL FACILITIES REQUIRED BY THE PLANS AND TO
OTHERWISE CARRY OUT THE PLANS;
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 014 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106466
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(E) THE IDENTIFICATION OF THE MEASURES NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE
PLANS INCLUDING (I) FINANCING, (II) THE PERIOD OF TIME NECESSARY TO
CARRY OUT THE PLANS, (III) THE COSTS OF CARRYING OUT THE PLANS WITHIN
THE TIME PERIOD SPECIFIED, AND (IV) THE ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT OF CARRYING OUT THE PLANS WITHIN SUCH TIME PERIOD;
AND
"(F) PROVISIONS TO ASSURE COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 213 OF THIS ACT.
"(3) SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT, RESOURCE RECOVERY, AND HAZARDOUS WASTE
DISPOSAL SYSTEM PLANS SHALL BE CERTIFIED ANNUALLY BY THE GOVERNOR OR HIS
DESIGNEE (FOR GOVERNORS OR THEIR DESIGNEES, WHERE MORE THAN ONE STATE IS
INVOLVED) AS BEING CONSISTENT WITH APPLICABLE STATEWIDE POLICIES. SUCH
PLANS SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR HIS APPROVAL.
"(E)(1) THE GOVERNOR OF EACH STATE, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE PLANNING
AGENCY DESIGNAGED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION, AT THE TIME ANY
PLAN IS SUBMITTED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR, SHALL DESIGNATE ONE OR MORE
MANAGEMENT AGENCIES (WHICH MAY BE AN EXISTING OR NEWLY CREATED LOCAL,
REGIONAL, OR STATE AGENCY OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION) FOR EACH SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT AREA DESIGNATED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION AND
SUBMIT SUCH DESIGNATIONS TO THE ADMINISTRATOR.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 015 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106467
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ACCEPT ANY SUCH DESIGNATION, UNLESS,
WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY DAYS OF SUCH DESIGNATION, HE FINDS THAT
THE DESIGNATED MANAGEMENT AGENCY (OR AGENCIES) DOES NOT HAVE ADEQUATE
AUTHORITY:
"(A) TO CARRY OUT APPROPRIATE PORTIONS OF REGIONAL PLANS DEVELOPED
UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION;
"(B) TO MANAGE EFFECTIVELY RELATED FACILITIES SERVING SUCH AREA IN
CONFORMANCE WITH ANY PLAN REQUIRED BY SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION;
"(C) DIRECTLY OR BY CONTRACT, TO DESIGN AND CONSTRUCT NEW SYSTEMS OR
FACILITIES, AND TO OPERATE AND MAINTAIN NEW AND EXISTING SYSTEMS OR
FACILITIES, AS REQUIRED BY ANY PLAN DEVELOPED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (B)
OF THIS SECTION;
"(D) TO ACCEPT AND UTILIZE GRANTS, OR OTHER FUNDS FROM ANY SOURCE,
FOR THESE PURPOSES;
"(E) TO RAISE REVENUES, INCLUDING THE ASSESSMENT OF SOLID WASTE
COLLECTION OR DISPOSAL CHARGES;
"(F) TO INCUR SHORT- AND LONG-TERM INDEBTEDNESS;
"(G) TO ASSURE IN IMPLEMENTATION OF SUCH PLANS THAT EACH
PARTICIPATING MUNICIPALITY PAYS AND RECEIVES PROPORTIONATE SHARE OF
COSTS AND REVENUES;
"(H) TO REFUSE TO RECEIVE ANY WASTES FROM ANY MUNICIPALITY WHICH DOES
NOT COMPLY WITH ANY PROVISIONS OF AN APPROVED PLAN UNDER THIS SECTION
APPLICABLE TO SUCH AREA; AND
"(I) TO ACCEPT SOLID WASTES FROM INDUSTRIAL SOURCES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 016 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106468
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(D) AFTER A MANAGEMENT AGENCY, HAVING THE AUTHORITY REQUIRED BY
SUBSECTION (C) OF THIS SECTION, HAS BEEN DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SUCH
SUBSECTION FOR AN AREA AND A PLAN FOR SUCH AREA HAS BEEN APPROVED
PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL NOT
MAKE ANY GRANT OR LOAN UNDER THIS ACT WITHIN SUCH AREA EXCEPT TO SUCH
DESIGNATED AGENCY AND FOR SYSTEMS OR FACILITIES IN CONFORMITY WITH SUCH
PLAN.
"(E) NO PERMIT UNDER SECTION 402 OF THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL ACT, AS AMENDED (86 STAT. 816), SHALL BE ISSUED FOR ANY POINT
SOURCE WHICH IS IN CONFLICT WITH A PLAN APPROVED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION
(B) OF THIS SECTION.
"(F)(1) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL MAKE GRANTS TO ANY PLANNING AGENCY
DESIGNATED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION FOR PAYMENT OF THE
REASONABLE COSTS OF DEVELOPING AND OPERATING A CONTINUING PLANNING
PROCESS UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION.
"(2) THE AMOUNT GRANTED TO ANY AGENCY UNDER PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS
SUBSECTION SHALL BE 100 PER CENTUM OF THE COSTS OF DEVELOPING AND
OPERATING A CONTINUING PLANNING PROCESS UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS
SECTION FOR EACH OF THE FISCAL YEARS ENDING JUNE 30, 1975, JUNE 30,
1976, AND JUNE 30, 1977, AND SHALL NOT EXCEED 75 PER CENTUM OF SUCH
COSTS IN EACH SUCCEEDING FISCAL YEAR.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 017 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106469
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(3)(A) EACH APPLICANT FOR A GRANT UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL SUBMIT
TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR HIS APPROVAL EACH PROPOSAL FOR WHICH A GRANT IS
APPLIED FO UNDER THIS SUBSECTION. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ACT UPON SUCH
PROPOSAL AS SOON AS PRACTICABLE AFTER IT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED, AND HIS
APPROVAL OF THAT PROPOSAL SHALL BE DEEMED A CONTRACTUAL OBLIGATION OF
THE UNITED STATES FOR THE PAYMENT OF ITS CONTRIBUTION TO SUCH PROPOSAL.
"(B) THERE IS AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO CARRY OUT THIS
SUBSECTION NOT TO EXCEED $50,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1975, NOT TO EXCEED $75,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 39,
1076, AND NOT TO EXCEED $100,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1977.
"LOANS AND LOAND GUARANTEES FOR RECOVERY SYSTEMS
"SEC. 216. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO PURCHASE EVIDENCES
OF INDEBTEDNESS AND TO MAKE LOANS (WHICH FOR PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION
SHALL INCLUDE PARTICIPATION IN LOANS) TO MUNICIPALITIES OR AGENCIES
DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 215 OF THIS ACT TO AID IN FINANCING ANY
PROJECT IN CONNECTION WITH A RESOURCE OR ENERGY RECOVERY SYSTEM SERVING
ALL OR A SUBSTANTIAL PART OF THE RECIPIENT'S JURISDICTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 018 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106470
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO GUARANTEE LOANS MADE TO
PRIVATE BORROWERS BY PRIVATE LENDING INSTITUTIONS IN CONNECTION WITH A
RESOURCE, INCLUDING ENERGY, RECOVERY SYSTEM SERVING ALL OR A SUBSTANTIAL
PART OF THE JURISDICTION OF THE MUNICIPALITY OR REGIONAL AGENCY
DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 214 OF THIS ACT IN WHICH IT IS LOCATED.
"(C) FUNDS LOANED OR THE REPAYMENT OF WHICH IS GUARANTEED UNDER THIS
SECTION SHALL BE USED FOR THE PURCHASE OR DEVELOPMENT OF LAND AND
FACILITIES (INCLUDING MACHINERY AND EQUIPMENT) AND FOR WORKING CAPITAL
NECESSARY FOR A RESOURCE OR ENERGY RECOVERY SYSTEM, AND SHALL NOT BE
USED FOR OPERATION OR MAINTENANCE OF ANY ELEMENT IN SUCH SYSTEM AFTER AN
INITIAL STARTUP PERIOD.
"(D) LOANS AND LOAN GUARANTEES UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE MADE UPON
SUCH TERMS AND CONDITIONS AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY BY REGULATION
PRESCRIBE: PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT NO SUCH GUARANTEE SHALL AT ANY TIME
EXCEED 90 PER CENTUM OF THE AMOUNT OF THE OUTSTANDING UNPAID BALANCE OF
SUCH INDEBTEDNESS.
"(E) NO LOAN OR LOAN GUARANTEE UNDER THIS ACT SHALL BE MADE AFTER
JULY 1, 1979.
"(F) LOAN GUARANTEES UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE MADE ONLY AFTER THE
ADMINISTRATOR DETERMINES THAT THE RESOURCE, INCLUDING ENERGY, RECOVERY
SYSTEM BEING FINANCED IS CONSISTENT WITH THE PLANS ESTABLISHED PURSUANT
TO SECTION 215 OF THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 019 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106471
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(G) LOANS MADE AND LOANS GUARANTEED UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE
REPAID OUT OF CHARGES PAID BY THE USERS OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL
SYSTEM OR FROM RECOVERED RESOURCES, INCLUDING ENERGY, AFTER THE OWNER OR
OPERATOR OF SUCH SYSTEM RECEIVES OUT OF SUCH CHARGES AND PROCEEDS THE
COSTS OF OPERATING AND MAINTAINING SUCH SYSTEM AND A REASONABLE RATE OF
RETURN, AS DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
"MARKETS FOR RECOVERED RESOURCES
"SEC. 217. (A)(1) EACH FEDERAL AGENCY WHICH PROCURES GOODS,
MATERIALS, OR ENERGY FOR ITS OWN USE OR FOR THE USE OF OTHER GOVERNMENT
AGENCIES, WHETHER THROUGH ADVERTISEMENTS FOR BIDS OR THROUGH ANY OTHER
PROCESS OF PROCUREMENT, SHALL GIVE PREFERENCE TO THE PURCHASE OF ENERGY
AND OF GOODS AND MATERIALS MANUFACTURED IN WHOLE OR IN PART FROM OR WITH
RECOVERED RESOURCES, AND SHALL GIVE ADDITIONAL PREFERENCE TO THE
PURCHASE OF GOODS AND MATERIALS MANUFACTURED WITH THE GREATEST
PROPORTION OF RECOVERED RESOURCES AMONG COMPETING ITEMS.
"(2) THE ADMINISTRATOR, IN COOPERATION WITH THE ADMINISTRATOR OF
GENERAL SERVICES, WITHIN SIXTY DAYS AFTER THE ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION
SHALL PUBLISH GUIDELINES FOR THE USE OF FEDERAL AGENCIES IN CARRYING OUT
THE REQUIREMENTS OF PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS SUBSECTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 020 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106472
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SUCH GUIDELINES MAY PROVIDE THAT A MINIMUM PERCENTAGE OF EACH
AGENCY'S PROCUREMENT BE SET ASIDE FOR THE PURCHASE OF RECOVERED
RESOURCES, INCLUDING ENERGY, OR THAT CERTAIN CLASSES OR CATEGORIES OF
GOODS OR MATERIALS PROCURED FOR USE BY ANY FEDERAL AGENCY CONTAIN AT
LEAST A MINIMUM PERCENTAGE OF RECOVERED RESOURCES.
"(3) IN ORDER TO ENCOURAGE THE DEVELOPMENT OF STABLE MARKETS FOR
RECOVERED RESOURCES, DURING THE FIVE FULL FISCAL YEARS FOLLOWING
ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, ANY FEDERAL AGENCY MAY PURCHASE RECOVERED
RESOURCES, INCLUDING ENERGY OR GOODS AND MATERIALS MANUFACTURED WITH A
SUBSTANTIAL USE OF RECOVERED RESOURCES AT A PRICE NO MORE THAN 125 PER
CENTUM OF THE CURRENT MARKET PRICE FOR EQUIVALENT GOODS OR MATERIALS
PURCHASED WITHOUT REGARD TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SUBSECTION:
PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT WHEN A PURCHASE OF A SINGLE ITEM, OR A CLASS OR
CATEGORY OF ITEMS, IS BEING MADE FROM AMONG COMPETING SUPPLIERS WHERE
THE PERCENTAGE OF RECOVERED RESOURCES IS ESSENTIALLY THE SAME, THE
PURCHASE SHALL BE SO AS TO BE TO THE GREATEST ADVANTAGE TO THE
GOVERNMENT.
"(4) THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SUBSECTION APPLY TO THE PROCUREMENT OF
ENERGY OR MATERIALS NECESSARY FOR THE PRODUCTION OF ENERGY.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 021 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106473
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO MAKE GRANTS TO ANY STATE,
MUNICIPALITY, AGENCY DESIGNATED PURSUANT TO SECTION 215 OF THIS ACT, OR
PRIVATE NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION SERVING ALL OF AN AREA DESIGNATED
PURSUANT TO SECTION 215 OF THIS ACT FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT AND OPERATION
OF CENTERS FOR THE COLLECTION OF SOLID WASTE FROM WHICH RECYCLABLE
CONTAINERS OR OTHER RECOVERABEL RESOURCES MAY BE RECOVERED. SUCH GRANTS
SHALL BE MADE IN CASES WHERE THE CONCENTRATION OF SUCH MATERIALS IN SUCH
CENTERS MAKES ECONOMICAL THE RECOVERY OF RESOURCES, INCLUDING ENERGY, OR
THE TRANSPORTATION OF SUCH MATERIALS UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH OTHERWISE
WOULD NOT BE ECONOMICALLY FEASIBLE.
"RESPONSIBILITIES OF PRIMARY PRODUCERS AND PACKAGING AND CONTAINER
MANUFACTURERS
"SEC. 218. (A) IN ORDER TO ASSURE THE DEVELOPMENT OF MARKETS FOR
RECOVERED RESOURCES, (1) A MANUFACTURER OF PRIMARY MATERIALS FROM WHICH
CONTAINERS ARE MANUFACTURED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ALUMINUM,
GLASS, PAPER, PLASTIC, AND STEEL, OR (2) A MANUFACTURER OF CONTAINERS,
DIRECTLY OR THROUGH CONTRACT WITH MANUFACTURERS OF SUCH PRIMARY
MATERIALS, SHALL AS A CONDITION OF ENTERING SUCH CONTAINERS INTO
INTERSTATE COMMERCE GUARANTEE PURCHASE OF ALL RECOVERED RESOURCES FROM
CONTAINERS RECOVERED FROM RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS CONSTRUCTED UNDER
SECTION 208 OR SECTION 216, IF REQUESTED TO DO SO BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
SUCH GUARANTEE SHALL BE FOR THE PURCHASE AT PREVAILING MARKET VALUE (AT
THE PRIMARY MANUFACTURER'S PLACE OF BUSINESS OR AT THE APPROPRIATE
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM) OF RECOVERED RESOURCES THAT MEET MARKET
SPECIFICATIONS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 022 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106474
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SUCH GUARANTEES SHALL BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH REGULATIONS
PROMULGATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR. IN SUCH REGULATIONS THE ADMINISTRATOR
SHALL PROVIDE FOR THE CONSIDERATION OF THE MANUFACTURER'S CONTRIBUTION
TO THE TOTAL CONTAINER MARKET, THE CHEMICAL OR METALLURGICAL CAPACITY OF
SUCH MANUFACTURER'S PRODUCTION PROCESS TO UTILIZE SUCH RECOVERED
RESOURCES, AND ANY OTHER FACTOR AFFECTING SUCH MANUFACTURER'S ABILITY TO
UTILIZE SUCH RECOVERED RESOURCES OR OTHERWISE GUARANTEE UTILIZATION OF
SUCH RECOVERED RESOURCES.
"(B) NO STATE OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION THEREOF WHICH RECEIVES
ASSISTANCE UNDER THIS ACT, OR IN WHICH FUNDS UNDER THIS ACT ARE
EXPENDED, MAY ADOPT OR ENFORCE ANY RESTRICTIONS, PROHIBITIONS, TAXES,
FEES, DEPOSITS, OR OTHER CONTROLS ON THE MANUFACTURE OR SALE OF
CONTAINERS BASED ON THE DISPOSAL CHARACTERISTICS OF SUCH CONTAINERS,
WHEN SUCH RESTRICTION, PROHIBITION, TAX, FEE, DEPOSIT, OR OTHER CONTROL
WOULD PLACE AN UNREASONABLE BURDEN ON INTERSTATE COMMERCE OR
SUBSTANTIALLY ALTER OR MODIFY THE DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM FOR CONTAINERS OR
THEIR CONTENTS IN SUCH AREA. THIS SUBSECTION SHALL APPLY ONLY IN
JURISDICTIONS WHERE THE GUARANTEES REQUIRED BY SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS
SECTION ARE PROVIDED AND IN CASES WHERE THE FACILITIES FOR COLLECTION
AND RECOVERY OF RESOURCES FROM SUCH CONTAINERS ARE PRESENT IN SUCH
STATE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 023 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106475
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SEC. 4 (A) SUBSECTION (A) OF SECTION 208 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL
ACT, AS AMENDED BY THE RESOURCE RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 (84 STAT. 1230), IS
AMENDED BY INSERTING AFTER "AGENCY" THE WORDS, "AND CONTRACTS WITH ANY
PRIVATE ORCANIZATION OR INDIVIDUALS,".
(B) SECTION 208 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED BY THE
RESOURCE RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 (84 STAT. 1230), IS AMENDED BY INSERTING
"OR CONTRACT" AFTER "GRANT" WHEREVER IT APPEARS AND BY INSERTING "OR
CONTRACTS" AFTER "GRANTS" WHEREVER IT APPEARS.
(C) SUBSECTION (B) OF SECTION 208 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS
AMENDED BY THE RESOURCE RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 (84 STAT. 1230), IS
AMENDED BY ADDING AT THE END THEREOF THE FOLLOWING NEW PARAGRAPH:
"(C) GRANTS OR CONTRACTS UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL ENCOURAGE THE
DEMONSTRATION OF NEW RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS AND COMPONENTS THEREOF
AND THE DEMONSTRATION OF THE REPLICABILITY OR APPLICABILITY OF SUCH
SYSTEMS UNDER VARYING CONDITIONS OF SIZE, LOCATION, AND OTHER FACTORS."
SEC. 5. SECTION 203 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED BY
THE RESOURCE RECOVERY ACT OF 1970 (84 STAT. 1228), IS AMENDED BY ADDING
AT THE END THEREOF THE FOLLOWING NEW PARAGRAPH:
"(11) THE TERM 'CONTAINER' MEANS THE IMMEDIATE CONTAINER OR PACKAGE
USED FOR THE TRANSPORT AND DELIVERY OF ANY COMMODITY TO HOUSEHOLD
CONSUMERS, BUT DOES NOT INCLUDE ANY CONTAINER OR PACKAGE IN WHICH SUCH
IMMEDIATE CONTAINER OR PACKAGE IS PLACED FOR DISPLAY OR FOR OTHER
PURPOSES NOR ANY BOX, CARTON, OR OTHER CONTAINER IN WHICH ONE OR MORE
SUCH IMMEDIATE CONTAINERS OR PACKAGES ARE SHIPPED."
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 024 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106476
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SEC. 6 SECTION 222 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT (AS SO
REDESIGNATED BY SECTION 3 OF THIS ACT) IS AMENDED TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
"SEC. 222. (A) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO CARRY OUT
THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT, OTHER THAN SECTION 208, NOT TO EXCEED
$200,000,000 FOR EACH OF THE FISCAL YEARS ENDING JUNE 30, 1975, JUNE 30,
1976, AND JUNE 30, 1977.
"(B) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO CARRY OUT SECTION 208
OF THIS ACT NOT TO EXCEED $140,000,000 FOR EACH OF THE FISCAL YEARS
ENDING JUNE 30, 1975, AND JUNE 30, 1976."
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 025 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106477
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
MR. MUSKIE INTRODUCED THE FOLLOWING BILL; WHICH WAS READ TWICE AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
TO AMEND THE SOLIDWASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED BY THE RESOURCE
RECOVERY ACT OF 1970.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN CONGRESS ASSEMBLED,
SECTION 1. THIS ACT MAY BE CITED AS THE "ENERGY RECOVERY AND
RESOURCE CONSERVATION ACT OF 1974".
SEC. 2. THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED BY THE RESOURCE
RECOVERY ACT OF 1970, IS AMENDED TO REAS AS FOLLOWS:
"TITLE I
"FINDINGS AND PURPOSES
"SEC. 102.(A) THE CONGRESS FINDS THAT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 026 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106478
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(1) THE ENERGY RECOVERY POTENTIAL FROM MATERIALS NOW BEING DISCARDED
IN SOLID WASTE COULD SUBSTANTIALLY CONTRIBUTE TO NEEDED ENERGY
PRODUCTION; "(2) THE CONTINUING TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS IN METHODS
OF MANUFACTURE, PACKAGING, AND MARKETING OF CONSUMER PRODUCTS HAVE
RESULTED IN AN EVER-MOUNTING INCREASE, AND IN A CHANGE IN THE
CHARACTERISTICS, OF THE MASS OF MATERIAL DISCARDED BY THE PURCHASERS OF
SUCH PRODUCTS;
"(3) THE ECONOMIC AND POPULATION GROWTH OF OUR NATION, AND THE
IMPROVEMENTS IN THE STANDARD OF LIVING ENJOYED BY OUR POPULATION, HAVE
REQUIRED INCREASED INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTION TO MEET OUR NEEDS, NAD HAVE
MADE NECESSARY THE DEMOLITION OF OLD BUILDINGS, THE CONSTRUCTION OF NEW
BUILDINGS, AND THE PROVISION OF HIGHWAYS AND OTHER AVENUES OF
TRANSPORTATION, WHICH, TOGETHER WITH RELATED INDUSTRIAL, COMMERCIAL, AND
AGRICULTURAL OPERATIONS, HAVE RESULTED IN A RISING TIDE OF SCRAP,
DISCARDED, AND WASTE MATERIALS;
"(4) THE CONTINUING SHIFTS IN OUR POPULATION HAVE PRESENTED MANY
COMMUNITIES WITH SERIOUS FINANCIAL, MANAGEMENT, INTERGOVERNMENTAL,AND
TECHNICAL PROBLEMS IN THE RECOVERY AND DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTES,
RESULTING FROM INDUSTRIAL, COMMERCIAL, DOMESTIC, RECREATIONAL, AND OTHER
ACTIVITIES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 027 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106479
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(5) THE PRESENT PROLIFERATION OF SOLID WASTES AND INEFFICIENT AND
IMPROPER METHODS OF RECOVERY AND DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTES ARE CREATING
INCREASINGLY SERIOUS HAZARDS TO THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE, INCLUDING
POLLUTION OF AIR AND WATER RESOURCES, ACCIDENT HAZARDS, INCREASES IN
RODENT AND INSECT VECTORS OF DISEASE, AND SCENIC BLIGHTS THAT HAVE AN
ADVERSE EFFECT ON LAND VALUES, CREATE PUBLIC NUISANCES, AND OTHERWISE
INTERFERE WITH COMMUNITY LIFE AND DEVELOPMENT;
"(6) THE FAILURE OR INABLITY TO SALVAGE, RECOVER, AND REUSE SUCH
MATERIALS AND THE ENERGY FROM SUCH MATERIALS ECONOMICALLY RESULTS IN THE
UNNECESSARY WASTE AND DEPLETION OF OUR INCREASINGLY SCARCE NATURAL
RESOURCES; AND
"(7) WHILE THE COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTES SHOULD
CONTINUE TO BE PRIMARILY THE FUNCTION OF STATE, REGIONAL, AND LOCAL
AGENCIES, THE PROBLEMS OF WASTE RECOVERY AND DISPOSAL AS SET FORTH ABOVE
HAVE BECOME A MATTER NATIONAL IN SCOPE AND CONCERN AND NECESSITATE
FEDERAL ACTION THROUGH CHANGES IN POLICIES AND PROGRAMS, DEVELOPMENT OF
REGULATIONS, AND PRIVISION OF FINANCIAL AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO
PROVIDE LEADERSHIP IN THE DEVELOPMENT, DEMONSTRATION, AND APPLICATION OF
NEW AND IMPROVED METHODS, PROCESSES, AND POLICIES TO REDUCE THE AMOUNT
OF WASTE AND UNSALVAGEABLE MATERIALS AND TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER AND
ECONOMICAL SOLID WASTE RECOVERY AND DISPOSAL PRACTICES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 028 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106480
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT THEREFORE ARE:
"1) TO PROMOTE THE DEMONSTRATION, CONSTRUCTION, AND APPLICATION OF
ENERGY RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS
WHICH CONSERVE NATURAL RESOURCES AND PRESERVE AND ENHANCE THE QUALITY OF
AIR, WATER, AND LAND RESOURCES;
"(2) TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL AND FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO STATES AND
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND INTERSTATE AGENCIES IN THE PLANNING AND
DEVELOPMENT OF SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS;
"(3) TO PROMOTE A NATIONAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM FOR
IMPROVEMENT MANAGEMENT TECHNIQUES, MORE EFFECTIVE ORGANIZATIONAL
ARRANGEMENTS, AND NEW AND IMPROVED METHODS OF COLLECTION, SEPARATION,
RECOVERY, AND RECYCLING OF SOLID WASTES, AND THE ENVIRONMENTALLY SAFE
DISPOSAL OF NONRECOVERABLE RESIDUES;
"(4) TO PROVIDE FOR TRAINING GRANTS IN OCCUPATIONS INVOLVING THE
DESIGN, OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE OF RESOURCE RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL SYSTEMS;
"(5) TO ENCOURAGE COOPERATIVE ACTIVITIES BY THE STATES AND LOCAL
GOVERNMENTS IN THE DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL AND RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS; AND ENCOURAGE THE ENACTMENT OF
IMPROVED AND, SO FAR AS PRACTICABLE, UNIFORM STATE AND LOCAL LAWS
GOVERNING SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND RESOURCES RECOVERY.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 029 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106481
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(6) TO AID THE CLEANUP OF INNER CITY AREAS AND OTHER PLACES WHICH
HAVE ENCOUNTERED PARTICULARLY SEVERE HEALTH PROBLEMS AND OTHER
ENVIRONMENTAL DANGERS BECAUSE OF THE PROLIFERATION OF SOLID WASTE;
"(7) TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE THROUGH ESTABLISHMENT
OF REGULATIONS FOR PACKAGING PRACTICES AND OTHER MANUFACTURING PROCESSES
AND PRODUCTS WHICH CONTRIBUTE TO SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PROBLEMS; AND
"(8) TO ESTABLISH AND EXPAND PROGRAMS AND POLICIES IN THE INTEREST OF
PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE TO EMPHASIZE RECYCLING AND RECOVERY OF
RESOURCES, RATHER THAN WASTE DISPOSAL AND EXCESSIVE USE OF RAW
MATERIALS.
"DEFINITIONS
"SEC. 103. WHEN USED IN THIS ACT:
"(1) THE TERM 'ADMINISTRATOR' MEANS THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 030 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106482
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) THE TERM 'CONSTRUCTION', WITH RESPECT TO ANY PROJECT OF
CONSTRUCTION UNDER THIS ACT, MEANS (A) THE ERECTION OR BUILDING OF NEW
STRUCTURES AND ACQUISITION OF LANDS OR INTERESTS THEREIN, OR THE
ACQUISITION, REPLACEMENT, EXPANSION, REMODELING, ALTERATION,
MODERNIZATION, OR EXTENSION OF EXISTING STRUCTURES, AND (B) THE
ACQUISITION AND INSTALLATION OF INITIAL EQUIPMENT OF, OR REQUIRED IN
CONNECTION WITH, NEW OR NEWLY ACQUIRED STRUCTURES OR THE EXPANDED,
REMODELED, ALTERED, MODERNIZED, OR EXTENDED PART OF EXISTING STRUCTURES
(INCLUDING TRUCKS AND OTHER MOTOR VEHICLES, AND TRACTORS, CRANES, AND
OTHER MACHINERY) NECESSARY FOR THE PROPER UTILIZATION AND OPERATION OF
THE FACILITY AFTER COMPLETION OF THE PROJECT; AND INCLUDES PRELIMINARY
PLANNING TO DETERMINE THE ECONOMIC AND ENGINEERING FEASIBILITY AND THE
PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY ASPECTS OF THE PROJECT, THE ENGINEERING,
ARCHITECTURAL, LEGAL, FISCAL, AND ECONOMIC INVESTIGATIONS AND STUDIES,
AND ANY SURVEYS, DESIGNS, PLANS, WORKING DRAWINGS, SPECIFICATIONS, AND
OTHER ACTION NECESSARY FOR THE CARRYING OUT OF THE PROJECT, AND (C) THE
INSPECTION AND SUPERVISION OF THE PROCESS OF CARRYING OUT THE PROJECTS
TO COMPLETION.
"(3) THE TERM 'CONSUMER PRODUCT' MEANS THOSE PRODUCTS WHICH ARE NOT
NORMALLY DISPOSED OF IN SOLID OR LIQUID WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INCLUDING
ANY FOOD OR BEVERAGE AND INCLUDING THOSE PRODUCTS INTENDED FOR
CONSUMPTION BY ANIMALS, AND ANY OTHER OBJECT INTENDED FOR OR CAPABLE OF
RETAIL SALE AND RESIDENTIAL, COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, OR RECREATIONAL
USE, EXCEPT WHERE SUCH OBJECT IS INTENDED TO BECOME PART OF A COMMERCIAL
OR INDUSTRIAL PROCESS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 031 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106483
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(4) THE TERM 'CONTAINER' MEANS ANY CONTAINER, PACKAGE, OR WRAPPING
MATERIAL WHICH IS SOLD WITH A CONSUMER PRODUCT OR SHIPPED WITH SUCH
PRODUCT FROM THE FACILITY AT WHICH SUCH PRODUCT IS CREATED BUT WHICH WAS
NOT PART OF SUCH PRODUCT IN ITS RAW AGRICULTURAL OR VIRGIN MATERIAL
STATE AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED WITH SUCH PRODUCT AT THE TIME OF
SALE TO ITS ULTIMATE PURCHASER.
"(5) THE TERM 'INTERMUNICIPAL AGENCY' MEANS AN AGENCY ESTABLISHED BY
TWO OR MORE MUNICIPALITIES WITHIN ONE STATE, WITH RESPONSIBILITY FOR
PLANNING OR ADMINISTRATION OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND RESOURCE RECOVERY
SYSTEMS.
"(6) THE TERM 'INTERSTATE AGENCY' MEANS AN AGENCY OF TWO OR MORE
MUNICIPALITIES IN DIFFERENT STATES, OR AN AGENCY ESTABLISHED BY TWO OR
MORE STATES, WITH AUTHORITY TO PROVIDE FOR SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS SERVING TWO OR MORE MUNICIPALITIES LOCATED IN
DIFFERENT STATES.
"(7) THE TERM 'MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE' MEANS ANY OBJECT OR PART OF
AN OBJECT REGULARLY UTILIZED FOR COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, RESIDENTIAL, OR
RECREATIONAL PURPOSES OR TRANSPORTATION WHICH HAS (A) A GROSS WEIGHT OF
MORE THAN TEN POUNDS, (B) A LIQUID CARRYING CAPACITY OR MORE THAN FIVE
GALLONS, OR (C) A TOTAL VOLUME OF MORE THAN FIVE CUBIC FEET, AND IS
DESIGNATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR AS A MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 032 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106484
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(8) THE TERM 'MUNICIPALITY' MEANS A CITY, TOWN, BOROUGH, COUNTY,
PARISH, DISTRICT, OR OTHER PUBLIC BODY CREATED BY OR PURSUANT TO STATE
LAW WITH RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE PLANNING OR ADMINISTRATION OF SOLID
WASTE DISPOSAL, OR AN INDIAN TRIBE.
"(9) THE TERM 'RECOVERED RESOURCES' MEANS USABLE MATERIALS OR ENERGY
RECOVERED FROM SOLID WASTES.
"(10) THE TERM 'RECYCLE' MEANS TO (A) REUSE FOR THE SAME PURPOSE AS
ORIGINALLY SOLD, (B) CONVERT INTO A RAW MATERIAL FROM WHICH THE ORIGINAL
PRODUCT OR ANOTHER TANGIBLE OBJECT FOR WHICH THERE IS A VIABLE MARKET
CAN BE CREATED, OR (C) CONVERT INTO ANOTHER TANGIBLE OBJECT FOR WHICH
THERE IS A VIABLE MARKET.
"(11) THE TERM 'RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM' MEANS A SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM WHICH PROVIDES FOR COLLECTION, SEPARATION, RECYCLING,
REUSE, AND RECOVERY OF SOLID WASTES, INCLUDING DISPOSAL OR
NONRECOVERABLE WASTE RESIDUES.
"(12) THE TERM 'SOLID WASTE' MEANS GARBAGE, REFUSE, CONSTRUCTION
DEBRIS, AND OTHER DISCARDED SOLID MATERIALS, INCLUDING SOLID WASTE
MATERIALS, WASTE OIL AND OTHER LIQUID MATERIALS IN CONTAINERS OR
ORIGINATING IN CONTAINERS, AND RESIDUAL BYPRODUCTS RESULTING FROM
INDUSTRIAL, COMMERCIAL, MINING, AND AGRICULTURAL OPERATIONS (INCLUDING
POLLUTION CONTROL); AND FROM COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES.
"(13) THE TERM 'SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL' MEANS THE COLLECTION, STORAGE,
TREATMENT, UTILIZATION, PROCESSING, OR FINAL DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 033 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106485
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(14) THE TERM 'STATE' MEANS A STATE, THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, THE
COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO, THE VIRGIN ISLANDS, GUAM, AND AMERICAN
SAMOA.
"RESEARCH, TRAINING, TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE, AND OTHER ACTIVITIES
"SEC. 104. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CONDUCT, AND ENCOURAGE,
COOPERATE WITH, AND RENDER FINANCIAL, TECHNICAL, AND OTHER ASSISTANCE TO
APPROPRIATE PUBLIC (WHETHER FEDERAL, STATE, INTERSTATE, OR LOCAL)
AUTHORITIES, AGENCIES, AND INSTITUTIONS, PRIVATE AGENCIES AND
INSTITUTIONS, AND INDIVIDUALS IN THE CONDUCT OF, AND PROMOTE THE
COODINATION OF, RESEARCH, INVESTIGATIONS, EXPERIMENTS, TRAINING,
DEMONSTRATIONS, SURVEYS, AND STUDIES RELATING TO:
"(1) ANY ADVERSE HEALTH AND WELFARE EFFECTS OF THE RELEASE INTO THE
ENVIRONMENT OF MATERIAL PRESENT IN SOLID WASTE, AND METHODS TO ELIMINATE
SUCH EFFECTS;
"(2) THE OPERATION AND FINANCING OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL PROGRAMS;
"(3) MEASURES NECESSARY TO AID THE CLEANUP OF INNER CITY AREAS AND
OTHER PLACES WHICH FACE PARTICULARLY SEVERE PUBLIC HEALTH PROBLEMS OR
OTHER DANGERS BECAUSE OF ACCUMULATIONS OF SOLID WASTE;
"(4) THE REDUCTION OF THE AMOUNT OF SOLID WASTE AND UNSALVAGEABLE
WASTE MATERIALS AND PROCEDURES TO ENCOURAGE THE SEPARATION AND
PREPARATION OF WASTE FOR RECOVERY.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 034 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106486
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(5) THE DEVELOPMENT AND APPLICATION OF NEW AND IMPROVED METHODS OF
COLLECTING AND DISPOSING OF SOLID WASTE AND PROCESSING AND RECOVERING
MATERIALS AND ENERGY FROM SOLID WASTES;
"(6) THE IDENTIFICATION OF SOLID WASTE COMPONENTS AND POTENTIAL
MATERIALS AND ENERGY RECOVERABEL FROM SUCH WASTE COMPONENTS;
"(7) THE DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF STANDARDS AND REGULATIONS
TO CONTROL AND REDUCE THE VOLUME OF SOLID WASTE REACHING THE DISPOSAL
SYSTEM; AND
"(8) ANY OTHER MATTER WHICH MAY BE INCLUDED IN THE ANNUAL REPORTS
REQUIRED BY SECTION 119 OF THIS ACT.
"(B) IN CARRYING OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THE PRECEDING SUBSECTION, THE
ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO:
"(1) COLLECT AND MAKE AVAILABLE, THROUGH PUBLICATIONS AND OTHER
APPROPRIATE MEANS, THE RESULTS OF, AND OTHER INFORMATION PERTAINING TO,
SUCH RESEARCH AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, INCLUDING APPROPRIATE
RECOMMENDATIONS IN CONNECTION THEREWITH;
"(2) COOPERATE WITH PUBLIC AND PRIVATE AGENCIES, INSTITUTIONS, AND
ORGANIZATIONS, AND WITH ANY INDUSTRIES INVOLVED, IN THE PREPARATION AND
THE CONDUCT OF SUCH RESEARCH AND OTHER ACTIVITIES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 035 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106487
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(3) RECOMMEND MODEL CODES, ORDINANCES, AND STATUTES WHICH ARE
DESIGNED TO IMPLEMENT THE PURPOSE OF THIS ACT;
"(4) ISSUE TO APPROPRIATE FEDERAL, INTERSTATE, REGIONAL, AND LOCAL
AGENCIES INFORMATION ON AND GUIDELINES FOR TECHNICALLY FEASIBLE SOLID
WASTE COLLECTION, SEPARATION, DISPOSAL, RECYCLING, REUSE, AND RECOVERY
METHODS WHICH ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE POLICIES AND PURPOSES OF THIS ACT,
INCLUDING DATA ON THE COST OF CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE
OF SUCH METHODS; AND
"(5) MAKE GRANTS-IN-AID TO PUBLIC OR PRIVATE AGENCIES, AND
INSTITUTIONS AND TO INDIVIDUALS FOR RESEARCH, TRAINING PROJECTS,
SURVEYS, AND DEMONSTRATIONS (INCLUDING CONSTRUCTION OF FACILITIES), AND
PROVIDE FOR THE CONDUCT OF RESEARCH, TRAINING, SURVEYS, AND
DEMONSTRATIONS BY CONTRACT WITH PUBLIC OR PRIVATE AGENCIES AND
INSTITUTIONS AND WITH INDIVIDUALS; AND SUCH CONTRACTS FOR RESEARCH OR
DEMONSTRATIONS OR BOTH (INCLUDING CONTRACTS FOR CONSTRUCTION) MAY BE
MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH AND SUBJECT TO THE LIMITATIONS PROVIDED WITH
RESPECT TO RESEARCH CONTRACTS OF THE MILITARY DEPARTMENTS IN TITLE 10,
UNITED STATES CODE, SECTION 2353, EXCEPT THAT THE DETERMINATION,
APPROVAL, AND CERTIFICATION REQUIRED THEREBY SHALL BE MADE BY THE
ADMINISTRATOR.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 036 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106488
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(C) ANY GRANT, AGREEMENT, OR CONTRACT MADE OR ENTERED INTO UNDER
THIS SECTION SHALL CONTAIN PROVISIONS TO INSURE THAT ALL INFORMATION,
USES, PROCESSES, PATENTS, AND OTHER DEVELOPMENTS RESULTING FROM ANY
ACTIVITY UNDERTAKEN PURSUANT TO SUCH GRANT, AGREEMENT, OR CONTRACT WILL
BE MADE READILY AVAILABLE ON FAIR AND EQUITABLE TERMS TO INDUSTRIES AND
PUBLIC AGENCIES WHICH MIGHT UTILIZE PROCESSES TO REDUCE THE VOLUME OF
SOLID WASTES, EMPLOY METHODS OF RESOURCE RECOVERY, RECYCLING, OR SOLID
WASTE DISPOSAL, OR ENGAGE IN FURNISHING DEVICES, FACILITIES, EQUIPMENT,
AND SUPPLIES TO BE USED IN CONNECTION WITH REDUCING THE VOLUME OF SOLID
WASTE, DISPOSING OF SOLID WASTE OR RECOVERY AND RECYCLING OF RESOURCES.
IN CARRYING OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION, THE ADMINISTRATOR AND
EACH DEPARTMENT, AGENCY, AND OFFICER OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAVING
FUNCTIONS OR DUTIES UNDER THIS ACT SHALL MAKE USE OF AND ADHERE TO THE
STATEMENT OF GOVERNMENT PATENT POLICY WHICH WAS PROMULGATED BY THE
PRESIDENT IN HIS MEMORANDUM OF OCTOBER 10, 1963. (3 CFR, 1963
SUPPLEMENTAL, PAGE 238.)
"(D) NO SERVICE CHARGE OR OTHER COST REQUIREMENT SHALL BE IMPOSED AS
A CONDITION OF PARTICIPATION BY ANY EMPLOYEE OF A STATE OR MUNICIPAL
GOVERNMENT AGENCY IN ANY TRAINING PROGRAM AUTHORIZED BY THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 037 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106489
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"SPECIAL STUDY AND DEMONSTRATION PROJECTS ON RECOVERY OF USEFUL
ENERGY AND MATERIALS
"SEC. 105. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CARRY OUT AN INVESTIGATION AND
STUDY TO DETERMINE MEANS TO RECOVERING ENERGY AND MATERIALS FROM SOLID
WASTE, RECOMMENDED USES OF SUCH MATERIALS AND ENERGY FOR NATIONAL OR
INTERNATIONAL WELFARE, INCLUDING IDENTIFICATION OF POTENTIAL MARKETS FOR
SUCH RECOVERED RESOURCES, AND THE IMPACT OF DISTRIBUTION OF SUCH
RESOURCES ON EXISTING MARKETS.
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO CARRY OUT DEMONSTRATION
PROJECTS TO TEST AND DEMONSTRATE METHODS AND TECHNIQUES DEVELOPED
PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (A).
"GRANTS FOR STATE PROGRAMS AND STATE, INSTERSTATE, AND LOCAL PLANNING
"SEC. 106. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY FROM TIME TO TIME, UPON SUCH
TERMS AND CONDITIONS CONSISTENT WITH THIS SECTION AS HE DEEMS
APPROPRIATE TO CARRY OUT THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT, MAKE GRANTS TO
STATES, INTERSTATE, MUNICIPAL, AND INTERMUNICIPAL AGENCIES, AND
ORGANIZATIONS COMPOSED OF PUBLIC OFFICIALS WHICH ARE ELIGIBLE FOR
ASSISTANCE UNDER SECTION 701 (G) OF THE HOUSING ACT OF 1954, OF NOT TO
EXCEED 66 2/3 PER CENTUM OF THE COST OF AN APPLICATION WITH RESPECT TO
AN AREA INCLUDING ONLY ONE MUNICIPALITY, AND NOT TO EXCEED 75 PER CENTUM
OF THE COST IN ANY OTHER CASE, OF:
"(1) MAKING SURVEYS OF RESOURCE RECOVERY (INCLUDING ENERGY RECOVERY)
AND SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL PRACTICES AND PROBLEMS WITHIN THE
JURISDICTIONAL AREAS OF SUCH AGENCIES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 038 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106490
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) DEVELOPING AND REVISING RESOURCE RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL PLANS AS PART OF REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION SYSTEMS FOR
SUCH AREAS, PROVIDING FOR RECYCLING OR RECOVERY OF MATERIALS FROM WASTES
WHENEVER POSSIBLE AND INCLUDING PLANNING FOR THE REUSE OF SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL AREAS AND STUDIES OF THE EFFECT AND RELATIONSHIP OF SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL PRACTICES ON AREAS ADJACENT TO WASTE DISPOSAL SITES;
"(3) DEVELOPING PROPOSALS FOR PROJECTS TO BE CARRIED OUT PURSUANT TO
SECTIONS 106 AND 107 OF THIS ACT;
"(4) PLANNING PROGRAMS FOR THE REMOVAL AND PROCESSING OF ABANDONED
MOTOR VEHICLE BULKS AND OTHER MAJOR ITEMS OF SOLID WASTE;
"(5) DEVELOPING STATE LAWS AND LOCAL ORDINANCES TO IMPROVE SOLID
WASTE MANACEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY AND RECYCLING SYSTEMS; OR
"(6) PLANNING PROGRAMS TO ACHIEVE RAPID CLEANUP OF AREAS WITH SEVERE
HEALTH PROBLEMS BECAUSE OF LARGE AMOUNTS OF UNCOLLECTED SOLID WASTE.
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY, FROM TIME TO TIME, UPON SUCH TERMS AND
CONDITIONS CONSISTENT WITH THIS SECTION AS HE DEEMS APPROPRIATE MAKE
GRANTS TO STATES FOR THE PURPOSES OF ESTABLISHING STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAMS, WHICH GRANT SHALL NOT EXCEED
75 PER CENTUM OF THE COST OF ESTABLISHING A STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAM IF SUCH GRANT IS MADE DURING
FISCAL YEAR 1975, 1976, OR 1977, AND SHALL NOT EXCEED 60 PER CENTUM OF
THE COSTS OF SUCH PROGRAM IN EACH OF THE THREE SUCCEEDING FISCAL YEARS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 039 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106491
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(C) AFTER JANUARY 1, 1977, NO STATE SHALL BE ELIGIBLE FOR A GRANT
UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION UNLESS THAT STATE HAS:
"(1) ESTABLISHED A SINGLE STATE AGENCY TO BE RESPONSIBLE FOR
MAINTAINING THE STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY
PROGRAM, WHICH STATE AGENCY MAY ALSO HAVE OTHER FUNCTIONS IN AREAS
RELATING TO THE ENVIRONMENT;
"(2) ESTABLISHED SUCH LEGAL AUTHORITY AS NECESSARY TO IMPLEMENT A
STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY PLAN; AND
"(3) DEVELOPED A STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE
RECOVERY PLAN SUBMITTED TO AND APPROVED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR CONSISTENT
WITH THE INTENT AND REQUIREMENTS OF THIS ACT, WHICH PLAN SHALL:
"(A) INCLUDE A LAND USE PLAN SPECIFYING THOSE AREAS WHICH ARE
PRESENTLY USED AND MAY BE USED IN THE FUTURE AS SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL
SITES;
"(B) INCLUDE A PROGRAM FOR ISSUING PERMITS FOR ALL PUBLICLY OWNED
SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL SITES WITHIN STANDARD METROPOLITAN AREAS WITH
POPULATION GREATER THAN TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND AS DEFINED IN THE 1970
CENSUS OF THE UNITED STATES COMMERCE DEPARTMENT AND A PROGRAM FOR
ISSUING SUCH PERMITS IN THE REMAINDER OF THE STATE BY 1980.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 040 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106492
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(C) PROVIDE FOR COORDINATION OF THE ACTIVITIES OF THE STATE AND AND
MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENTS RELATING TO SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE
RECOVERY TO ASSURE MOST EFFICIENT METHODS FOR (I) LIMITING THE COSTS AND
IMPROVING THE EFFICIENCY OF COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL AND (II) RECOVERING
THE GREATEST PERCENTAGE OF RECYCLABLE OR REUSABLE MATERIALS;
"(D) ASSURE SAFE AND SANITARY COLLECTION AND RECYCLING OF MATERIALS
DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR TO BE TOXIC OR HAZARDOUS, AND ASSURE
DISPOSAL OF TOXIC OR HAZARDOUS MATERIALS THAT CANNOT BE RECYCLED IN A
MANNER WHICH WILL NOT RESULT IN VIOLATION OF EFFLUENT OR EMISSION
LIMITATIONS, STANDARDS, OR OTHER REQUIREMENTS OF THE CLEAN AIR ACT OR
THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT;
"(E) IDENTIFY METHODS AND PROCEDURES TO BE USED IN THE COLLECTION AND
TRANSPORTATION OF MATERIALS WHICH ARE AVAILABLE FOR REUSE OR RECYCLING;
"(F) ASSURE THAT STATE, MUNICIPAL, AND PRIVATE RESOURCE RECOVERY AND
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND DISPOSAL PRACTICES WILL NOT RESULT IN A
VIOLATION OF EFFLUENT OR EMISSION LIMITATIONS, STANDARDS, OR OTHER
REQUIREMENTS OF THE CLEAN AIR ACT OR THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL
ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 041 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106493
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(G) INCLUDE (I) PROGRAM PROHIBITING WITHIN TWO YEARS OF THE APPROVAL
OF SUCH PLAN THE OPERATION OF ANY OPEN DUMP WITHIN OR RECEIVING SOLID
WASTE FROM ANY STANDARD METROPOLITAN STATISTICAL AREA WITH A POPULATION
GREATER THAN TWO HUNDRED THOUSAND AS DEFINED IN THE 1970 CENSUS OF THE
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE, (II) A PROGRAM PROHIBITING WITHIN
SEVEN YEARS OF THE APPROVAL OF SUCH PLAN THE OPERATION OF OTHER OPEN
DUMPS IN THE REMAINDER OF THE STATE THAT ARE DEEMED BY THE STATE TO BE
ENVIRONMENTALLY UNSOUND TO A SIGNIFICANT DEGREE;
"(H) INCLUDE PLANS FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF TRANSFER FACILITIES TO
FACILITATE THE INCLUSION OF SOLID WASTE FROM RURAL AREAS IN RESOURCE
RECOVERY SYSTEMS SERVING AREAS OF THE STATE HAVING HIGHER POPULATION
DENSITY, EXCEPT WHERE THE STATE DETERMINES THAT THE PROJECTED ECONOMIC
FEASIBILITY OF SUCH SYSTEM (INCLUDING PROJECTED GROWTH OF THE AREA
INVOLVED) DOES NOT JUSTIFY INCLUSION OF THE RURAL AREAS IN SUCH A
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM;
"(I) INCLUDE A PROGRAM OF TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FOR SMALL- AND
MEDIUM-SIZED COMMUNITIES TO AID IN THE ADOPTION OF UP-TO-DATE RESOURCE
RECOVERY SYSTEMS AND SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL PRACTICES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 042 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106494
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(D) UPON RECEIPT OF A STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMETN AND RESOURCE
RECOVERY PLAN SUBMITTED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION, THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, WITHIN FOUR MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF RECEIPT,
APPROVE OR DISAPPROVE SUCH PLAN, OR ANY PORTION THEREOF. THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL APPROVE SUCH PLAN, OR ANY PORTION THEREOF, IF HE
DETERMINES THAT IT WAS ADOPTED AFTER REASONABLE NOTICE AND HEARINGS AND
THAT:
"(1) IT COMPLIES WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF PARAGRAPH (3) SUBSECTION
"C); AND
"(2) IT WAS DEVELOPED THROUGH A PROCESS CLOSELY COORDINATED WITH THE
PLANNING PROCESSES OF SECTION 208 OF THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL
ACT AND SECTION 110 OF THE CLEAN AIR ACT; AND
"(3) THE STATE ASSIGNED PRIMARY RESPONSIBILITY AND AUTHORITY FOR PLAN
DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OT GENERAL PURPOSE UNITS OF GOVERNMENT,
AND INCLUDES PLANS DEVELOPED BY SUCH UNITS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT, UNLESS
THE STATE (1) DETERMINED THAT ANY SUCH PLAN, OR ITS IMPLEMENTATION, (A)
FAILED TO MEET ANY REQUIREMENT OF THIS ACT OR STATE STANDARDS OR
CRITERIA INTENDED TO EFFECTUATE SUCH REQUIREMENT; (B) WAS INCONSISTENT
WITH ANY OTHER SUCH PLAN OR WITH ANY AREAWIDE WASTE MANAGEMENT AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY PLAN WHICH MET ALL APPLICABLE REQUIREMENTS, STANDARDS,
AND CRITERIA; OR (C) WAS INCONSISTENT WITH ANY STATE LAND USE, AIR
POLLUTION, WATER POLLUTION, NOISE POLLUTION, OR OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL PLAN
OR REQUIREMENT AND (2) PROVIDED AN ADEQUATE OPPORTUNITY FOR
ADMINISTRATIVE OR JUDICIAL APPEAL OF SUCH DETERMINATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 043 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106495
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(4) IT ASSURES, EXCEPT IN ANY PROCEEDINGS OF THE STATE LEGISLATURE,
THE PARTICIPATION OF OFFICIALS OR REPRESENTATIVES OF GENERAL UNITS OF
LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND THE PUBLIC IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF SUBSEQUENT
REVISIONS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF AND THE FORMULATION OF GUIDELINES,
RULES, AND REGULATIONS CONCERNING THE WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE
RECOVERY PROGRAM.
"(E) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL AFTER CONSIDERATION OF ANY STATE HEARING
RECORD, PROMPTLY PREPARE AND PUBLISH REGULATIONS SETTING FORTH SUGGESTED
REVISIONS IN A STATEWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY
PLAN IF HE DETERMINES THAT THE PLAN, OR ANY PORTION THEREOF, SUBMITTED
FOR SUCH STATE IS DETERMINED NOT TO BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION. THE STATE MAY THEN RESUBMIT A PLAN
REVISED TO TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THE SUGGESTIONS OF THE ADMINISTRATOR.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 044 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106496
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(F) IN THE EVENT THAT A STATE DOES NOT SUBMIT A PLAN BY JANUARY 1,
1977, THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY RECEIVE AREAWIDE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY PLANS FROM MULTIJURISDICTIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
REPRESENTING GENERAL UNITS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT. APPROVAL OF SUCH PLANS
SHALL BE CONDITIONED UPON THE CRITERIA GOVERNING STATEWIDE PLANS, AND
APPROVAL SHALL ALLOW THE UNITS OF GOVERNMENT WITHIN THE AREA COVERED TO
BECOME ELIGIBLE FOR FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE UNDER THIS ACT TO THE SAME
EXTENT THAT APPROVAL OF A STATEWIDE PLAN WOULD FULFILL SUCH ELIGIBILITY
REQUIREMENTS.
"(G) GRANTS PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION MAY BE MADE UPON APPLICATION
THEREFOR WHICH:
"(1) DESIGNATES OR ESTABLISHES A SINGLE AGENCY (WHICH MAY BE AN
INTERDEPARTMENTAL AGENCY) AS THE SOLE AGENCY FOR CARRYING OUT THE
PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION FOR THE AREA INVOLVED;
"(2) INDICATES THE MANNER IN WHICH PROVISION WILL BE MADE TO ASSURE
FULL CONSIDERATION OF ALL ASPECTS OF PLANNING ESSENTIAL TO AREAWIDE
PLANNING FOR PROPER AND EFFECTIVE RESOURCE RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL CONSISTENT WITH THE PROTECTION OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND
WELFARE, INCLUDING SUCH FACTORS AS POPULATION GROWTH, URBAN AND
METROPOLITAN DEVELOPMENT, LAND USE PLANNING, WATER POLLUTION CONTROL,
AIR POLLUTION CONTROL, AND THE FEASIBILITY OF REGIONAL DISPOSAL AND
RESOURCE RECOVERY PROGRAM;
"(3) SETS FORTH PLANS FOR EXPENDITURES OF SUCH GRANT, WHICH PLANS
PROVIDE REASONABLE ASSURANCE OF CARRYING OUT THE PURPOSES FOR WHICH THE
GRANT IS INTENDED.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 045 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106497
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(4) PROVIDES FOR SUBMISSION OF SUCH REPORTS OF THE ACTIVITIES OF THE
AGENCY IN CARRYING OUT THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, IN SUCH FORM AND
CONTAINING SUCH INFORMATION, AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY FROM TIME TO TIME
FIND NECESSARY FOR CARRYING OUT THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION AND FOR
KEEPING SUCH RECORDS AND AFFORDING SUCH ACCESS THERETO AS HE MAY FIND
NECESSARY; AND
"(5) PROVIDES FOR SUCH FISCAL-CONTROL AND FUND-ACCOUNTING PROCEDURES
AS MAY BE NECESSARY TO ASSURE PROPER DISBURSEMENT OF AND ACCOUNTING FOR
FUNDS PAID TO THE AGENCY UNDEF THIS SECTION.
"(H) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL MAKE A GRANT UNDER THIS SECTION ONLY IF
HE FINDS THAT THERE IS SATISFACTORY ASSURANCE THAT ANY PLANNING FOR
RESOURCE RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT WILL BE COORDINATED, SO FAR
AS PRACTICABLE, WITH AND NOT DUPLICATE OTHER RELATED STATE, INTERSTATE,
REGIONAL, AND LOCAL LAND USE AND RELATED PLANNING ACTIVITIES, INCLUDING
ANY INTERNATIONAL PLANNING ACTIVITIES AND AGREEMENTS, AND INCLUDING
PLANNING ACTIVITIES MAINTAINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CLEAN AIR ACT AND
THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION CONTROL ACT AND THOSE FINANCED IN PART WITH
FUNDS PURSUANT TO SECTION 701 OF THE HOUSING ACT OF 1954.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 046 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106498
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(I) NOT MORE THAN 10 PER CENTUM OF THE TOTAL OF FUNDS AUTHORIZED TO
BE APPROPRIATED UNDER THIS SECTION FOR ANY FISCAL YEAR SHALL BE GRANTED
UNDER THIS SECTION FOR PROJECTS IN ANY ONE STATE.
"(J) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR OF
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO CARRY OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
SECTION, NOT TO EXCEED $50,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1975, NOT TO EXCEED $75,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1976, AND NOT TO EXCEED $100,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1977.
"GRANTS FOR ENERGY AND RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS
AND IMPROVED SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITIES
"SEC. 107. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO MAKE GRANTS
PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION TO ANY STATE, MUNICIPAL, OR INTERSTATE OR
INTERMUNICIPAL AGENCY FOR THE DEMONSTRATION OF ENERGY RESOURCE RECOVERY
SYSTEMS OR FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF NEW OR IMPROVED SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL
FACILITIES.
"(B)(1) A GRANT UNDER THIS SECTION FOR THE DEMONSTRATION OF A
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM MAY BE MADE ONLY IF IT (A) IS CONSISTENT WITH
ANY PLANS WHICH MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 106 (D)(2) OF THIS ACT;
(B) IS CONSISTENT WITH ANY GUIDELINES RECOMMENDED PURSUANT TO SECTION
104 (B)(4) OF THIS ACT; (C) IS DESIGNED TO PROVIDE AREAWIDE RESOURCE
RECOVERY SYSTEMS CONSISTENT WITH THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT, AS DETERMINED
BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, PURSUANT TO REGULATIONS PROMULGATED UNDER
SUBSECTION (D) OF THIS SECTION; AND (D) PROVIDES AN EQUITABLE SYSTEM
FOR DISTRIBUTING THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND
MAINTENANCE OF ANY RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM AMONG THE USERS OF SUCH
SYSTEM.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 047 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106499
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) THE FEDERAL SHARE FOR ANY PROJECT TO WHICH PARAGRAPH (1) APPLIES
SHALL NOT BE MORE THAN 75 PER CENTUM.
"(C)(1) A GRANT UNDER THIS SECTION FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW OR
IMPROVED SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITY MAY BE MADE ONLY IF:
"(A) A STATE OR INTERSTATE PLAN FOR SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL HAS BEEN
ADOPTED WHICH APPLIES TO THE AREA INVOLVED, AND THE FACILITY TO BE
CONSTRUCTED (I) IS CONSISTENT WITH SUCH PLAN, (II) IS INCLUDED IN A
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR THE AREA INVOLVED WHICH IS SATISFACTORY TO THE
ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT, AND (III) IS CONSISTENT WITH
ANY GUIDELINES RECOMMENDED UNDER SECTION 104(B)(4), AND
"(B) THE PROJECT ADVANCES THE STATE OF THE ART BY APPLYING NEW AND
IMPROVED TECHNIQUES IN REDUCING THE ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT OF SOLID WASTE
DISPOSAL, IN ACHIEVING RECOVERY OF ENERGY OR RESOURCES, OR IN RECYCLYING
USEFUL MATERIALS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 048 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106500
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) THE FEDERAL SHARE FOR ANY PROJECT TO WHICH PARAGRAPH (1) APPLIES
SHALL BE NOT MORE THAN 50 PER CENTUM IN THE CASE OF A PROJECT SERVING AN
AREA WHICH INCLUDES ONLY ONE MUNICIPALITY, AND NOT MORE THAN 75 PER
CENTUM IN ANY OTHER CASE.
"(D) IN TAKING ACTION ON APPLICATIONS FOR GRANTS UNDER THIS SECTION,
CONSIDERATION SHALL BE GIVEN BY THE ADMINISTRATOR (A) TO THE PUBLIC
BENEFITS TO BE DERIVED BY THE CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION AND THE
PROPRIETY OF FEDERAL AID IN MAKING SUCH GRANT; (B) TO THE EXTENT
APPLICABLE, TO THE ECONOMIC AND COMMERCIAL VIABILITY OF THE PROJECT
(INCLUDING CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS WITH THE PRIVATE SECTOR TO MARKET
ANY RESOURCES RECOVERED); AND (C) TO THE USE BY THE APPLICANT OF
COMPREHENSIVE REGIONAL OR METROPOLITAN AREA PLANNING.
"(E) A GRANT UNDER THIS SECTION:
"(1) MAY BE MADE ONLY IN THE AMOUNT OF THE FEDERAL SHARE OF (A) THE
ESTIMATED TOTAL DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION COSTS, PLUS (B) IN THE CASE OF A
GRANT TO WHICH SUBSECTION (B)(1) APPLIES, THE FIRST-YEAR OPERATION AND
MAINTENANCE COSTS;
"(2) MAY NOT BE PROVIDED FOR LAND ACQUISITION OR (EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH (1)(B)) FOR OPERATING OR MAINTENANCE COSTS;
"(3) MAY NOT BE MADE UNTIL THE APPLICANT HAS MADE PROVISION
SATISFACTORY TO THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR PROPER AND EFFICIENT OPERATION AND
MAINTENANCE OF THE PROJECT (SUBJECT TO PARAGRAPH (1)(B)); AND
"(4) MAY BE MADE SUBJECT TO SUCH CONDITIONS AND REQUIREMENTS, IN
ADDITION TO THOSE PROVIDED IN THIS SECTION, AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY
REQUIRE TO PROPERLY CARRY OUT HIS FUNCTIONS PURSUANT TO THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 049 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106501
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
FOR PURPOSES OF PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS SUBSECTION THE NON-FEDERAL
SHARE MAY BE IN ANY FORM, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, LANDS OR
INTERESTS THEREIN NEEDED FOR THE PROJECT OR PERSONAL PROPERTY OR
SERVICES, THE VALUE OF WHICH SHALL BE DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
"(F) NO GRANT SHALL BE MADE UNDER THIS SECTION FOR ANY PROJECT IN A
STATE WHICH ON OR AFTER JULY 1, 1976, IS NOT ELIGIBLE FOR A GRANT UNDER
SUBSECTION (B) OF SECTION 106 OF THIS ACT.
"(G)(1) NOT MORE THAN 15 PER CENTUM OF THE TOTAL OF FUNDS AUTHORIZED
TO BE APPROPRIATED UNDER THIS SECTION FOR ANY FISCAL YEAR SHALL BE
GRANTED UNDER THIS SECTION FOR PROJECTS IN ANY ONE STATE.
"(2) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PRESCRIBE BY REGULATION THE MANNER IN
WHICH THIS SUBSECTION SHALL APPLY TO A GRANT UNDER THIS SECTION FOR A
PROJECT IN AN AREA WHICH INCLUDES ALL OR PART OF MORE THAN ONE STATE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 050 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106502
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(H) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR OF
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO CARRY OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
SECTION NOT TO EXCEED $75,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1975, AND NOT TO EXCEED $50,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1976, AND NOT TO EXCEED $25,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30,
1977.
"LOANS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS
"SEC. 108. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO MAKE LOANS PURSUANT
TO THIS SECTION TO ANY STATE, MUNICIPAL, OR INTERMUNICIPAL AGENCY FOR
THE IMPLEMENTATION OF RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS IN THOSE AREAS WHERE
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS IN PRIVATE INDUSTRY ARE UNABLE TO ASSURE THE
ENERGY AND MATERIALS RECOVERY RO DISPOSAL OF ALL MATERIALS GENERATED IN
COLLECTION ACTIVITIES.
"(B)(1) A LOAN UNDER THIS SECTION FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF A
RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM MAY BE MADE ONLY IF THE PROPOSED SYSTEM (A) IS
CONSISTENT WITH ANY PLANS WHICH MEET THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION
105(D)(2) OF THIS ACT; (B) IS CONSISTENT WITH ANY GUIDELINES
RECOMMENDED PURSUANT TO SECTION 104(B)(4) OF THIS ACT; (C) IS DESIGNED
TO PROVIDE AREAWIDE RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEMS CONSISTENT WITH THE
PURPOSES OF THIS ACT, AS DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, PURSUANT TO
REGULATIONS PROMULGATED UNDER SUBSECTION (C) OF THIS SECTION; AND (D)
PROVIDES AN EQUITABLE SYSTEM FOR DISTRIBUTING THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH
CONSTRUCTION, OPERATION, AND MAINTENANCE OF ANY RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM
AMONG THE USERS OF SUCH SYSTEMS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 051 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106503
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) THE AMOUNT OF THE LOAN FOR ANY PROJECT TO WHICH PARAGRAPH (1)
APPLIES SHALL BE NOT MORE THAN 75 PER CENTUM OF THE PROJECT COSTS AS
DETERMINED UNDER SUBSECTION (E) OF SECTION 106 OF THIS ACT, AND SUCH
AMOUNTS SHALL BE AVAILABLE AT AN INTEREST RATE NOT TO EXCEED 3 PER
CENTUM PER ANNUM, AS DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
"(3) A LOAN FOR ANY PROJECT UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE GRANTED BY
THE ADMINISTRATOR ON CONDITION THAT IT BE REPAID WITHIN A PERIOD OF NOT
MORE THAN TWENTY YEARS FROM THE DATE OF THE LOAN, EXCEPT THAT, ON AN
ANNUAL BASIS, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL REDUCE SUCH PAYMENT OF PRINCIPAL
AND INTEREST DUE FOR THAT YEAR BY AN AMOUNT EQUAL TO ONE-HALF OF ANY
FUNDS RECEIVED BY THE LOAN RECIPIENT FROM THE SALE OF SOLID WASTE, OR
MATERIAL DERIVED THEREFROM, WHICH HAS BEEN RECOVERED FROM OPERATION OF
THE RESOURCE RECOVERY SYSTEM DURING THE PREVIOUS YEAR.
"(C)(1) THE ADMINISTRATOR, WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY DAYS AFTER
THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS SECTION, SHALL PROMULGATE REGULATIONS
ESTABLISHING PROCEDURES FOR AWARDING LOANS UNDER THIS SECTION WHICH
SHALL INCLUDE DEADLINES FOR SUBMISSION, AND ACTION ON, LOAN REQUESTS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 052 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106504
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) IN TAKING ACTION ON APPLICATIONS FOR LOANS UNDER THIS SECTION,
CONSIDERATION SHALL BE GIVEN BY THE ADMINISTRATOR (A) TO THE PUBLIC
BENEFITS TO BE DERIVED BY THE CONSTRUCTION AND OPERATION AND THE
PROPRIETY OF FEDERAL AID IN MAKING SUCH LOANS; (B) TO THE EXTENT
APPLICABLE, TO THE ECONOMIC AND COMMERCIAL VIABILITY OF THE PROJECT
(INCLUDING CONTRACTUAL ARRANGEMENTS WITH THE PRIVATE SECTOR TO MARKET
ANY RESOURCES RECOVERED); AND (C) TO THE USE BY THE APPLICANT OF
COMPREHENSIVE REGIONAL OR METROPOLITAN AREA PLANNING.
"(D) NO LOAN SHALL BE MADE UNDER THIS SECTION FOR ANY PROJECT IN A
STATE WHICH ON OR AFTER JULY 1, 1976, IS NOT ELIGIBLE FOR A GRANT UNDER
SUBSECTION (B) OF SECTION 106 OF THIS ACT.
"(E) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR,
FOR REPAYMENT OF LOANS TO CARRY OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION, SUCH
SUMS AS MAY BE NECESSARY.
"GRANTS OR CONTRACTS FOR TRAINING PROJECTS
"SEC. 109. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO MAKE GRANTS TO, AND
CONTRACTS WITH, ANY ELIGIBLE ORGANIZATION. FOR PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION
THE TERM 'ELIGIBLE ORGANIZATION' MEANS A STATE OR INTERSTATE AGENCY, A
MUNICIPALITY, EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION, AND ANY OTHER ORGANIZATION WHICH
IS CAPABLE OF EFFECTIVELY CARRYING OUT A PROJECT WHICH MAY BE FUNDED BY
GRANT UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 053 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106505
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B)(1) SUBJECT TO THE PROVISIONS OF PARAGRAPH (2), GRANTS OR
CONTRACTS MAY BE MADE TO PAY ALL OR PART OF THE COSTS, AS MAY BE
DETERMINED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, OR ANY PROJECT OPERATED OR TO BE
OPERATED BY AN ELIGIBLE ORGANIZATION, WHICH IS DESIGNED:
"(A) TO DEVELOP, EXPAND, OR CARRY OUT A PROGRAM (WHICH MAY COMBINE
TRAINING, EDUCATION, AND EMPLOYMENT) FOR TRAINING PERSONS FOR
OCCUPATIONS INVOLVING THE MANAGEMENT, SUPERVISION, DESIGN, OPERATION, OR
MAINTENANCE OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND RESOURCE RECOVERY EQUIPMENT AND
FACILITIES; AND
"(B) TO TRAIN INSTRUCTORS AND SUPERVISORY PERSONNEL TO TRAIN OR
SUPERVISE PERSONS IN OCCUPATIONS INVOLVING THE DESIGN, OPERATION, AND
MAINTENANCE OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL AND RESOURCE RECOVERY EQUIPMENT AND
FACILITIES.
"(2) A GRANT OR CONTRACT AUTHORIZED BY PARAGRAPH (1) OF THIS
SUBSECTION MAY BE MADE ONLY UPON APPLICATION TO THE ADMINISTRATOR AT
SUCH TIME OR TIMES AND CONTAINING SUCH INFORMATION AS HE MAY PRESCRIBE,
EXCEPT THAT NO SUCH APPLICATION SHALL BE APPROVED UNLESS IT PROVIDES FOR
THE SAME PROCEDURES AND REPORTS (AND ACCESS TO SUCH REPORTS AND TO OTHER
RECORDS) AS IS REQUIRED BY SECTION 105(D) (4) AND (5) WITH RESPECT TO
APPLICATIONS MADE UNDER THIS SUCH SECTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 054 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106506
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"FEDERAL AGENCY ACTIVITIES
"SEC. 110. (A) NOT LATER THAN ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY DAYS AFTER THE
DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, AFTER
CONSULTATION WITH OTHER APPROPRIATE FEDERAL AGENCIES, PUBLISH IN THE
FEDERAL REGISTER PROPOSED REGULATIONS RECOMMENDING EFFECTIVE RESOURCE
RECOVERY AND SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES FOR USE BY FEDERAL
AGENCIES. THESE REGULATIONS SHALL:
"(1) ESTABLISH GUIDELINES THAT, TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT FEASIBLE,
ASSURE THE PURCHASE BY FEDERAL AGENCIES OF MATERIALS AND PRODUCTS WHICH
HAVE BEEN RECYCLED AND MAY BE RECYCLED OR REUSED WHEN DISCARDED;
"(2) ENCOURAGE ALL FEDERAL AGENCIES TO MINIMIZE THE ACCUMULATION OF
SOLID WASTE BY LIMITING, TO THE GREATEST EXTENT PRACTICABLE, THE VOLUME
OF MATERIALS AND PRODUCTS USED AND DISCARDED, AND
"(3) ENCOURAGE EACH AGENCY TO ESTABLISH SYSTEMS FOR THE COLLECTION OF
MATERIALS FOR RECYCLING (OR ENERGY RECOVERY), REUSE AND PROVIDE
ASSURANCE THAT SUCH MATERIAL AND PRODUCTS, ONCE COLLECTED, WILL BE MADE
AVAILABLE, WHENEVER POSSIBLE, TO AN APPROPRIATE PUBLIC AGENCY OR PRIVATE
INDUSTRY FOR REUSE OR RECYCLING;
"(B)(1) NOT LATER THAN ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF
ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR, IN COOPERATION WITH THE
ADMINISTRATOR OF THE GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION AND THE PUBLIC
PRINTER, SHALL PUBLISH IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER PROPOSED REGULATIONS
ESTABLISHING GUIDELINES FOR USE OF RECYCLED PAPER AND PAPER PRODUCTS BY
ALL AGENCIES OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AS WELL AS PUBLIC AND PRIVATE
AGENCIES, INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS WHO CONTRACT WITH THE FEDERAL
GOVERNMENT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 055 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106507
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(2) SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL DESIGNATE CATEGORIES OF PAPER AND PAPER
PRODUCTS WITH THE GREATEST POTENTIAL AND FEASIBILITY OF BEING COMPOSED
OF RECYCLED PAPER AND MATERIALS AND SHALL SPECIFY THE NATURE AND
PERCENTAGE OF SUCH RECYCLED MATERIALS TO BE CONTAINED IN SUCH PRODUCTS.
SUCH REGULATIONS SHALL REQUIRE THAT ALL FEDERAL AGENCIES AND ALL FEDERAL
CONTRACTORS, IN THE PERFORMANCE OF THEIR CONTRACT WORK, SHALL USE
RECYCLED PAPER AND PAPER PRODUCTS MEETING THE SPECIFICATIONS OF
REGULATIONS PROMULGATED PURSUANT TO THIS PARAGRAPH IN ALL PURCHASES OR
ACQUISITIONS OF ANY PROPERTY HAVING A FAIR MARKET VALUE OF $5,000 OR
MORE AND WITH RESPECT TO ANY PURCHASE OR ACQUISITION ON A RECURRING OR
CONTINUING BASIS OF THE SAME OR A FUNCTIONALLY EQUIVALENT MATERIAL,
PRODUCT, OR ITEM WHERE THE FAIR MARKET VALUE OF THE QUANTITY THEREOF
PURCHASED OR ACQUIRED IN THE COURSE OF THE PRECEDING FISCAL YEAR WAS
$5,000 OR MORE.
"(C) THE REQUIREMENTS OF PARAGRAPHS (1) AND (2) OF THIS SECTION SHALL
NOT APPLY TO ANY PROCUREMENT BY A PROCURING AGENCY IF THE PROCUREMENT
ITEM WHICH MEETS SUCH REQUIREMENTS AND REGULATIONS (A) IS NOT REASONABLY
AVAILABLE WITHIN A REASONABLE PERIOD OF TIME; (B) DOES NOT MEET
REASONABLE PERFORMANCE STANDARDS SET BY SUCH AGENCY; (C) IS ONLY
AVAILABLE AT A PRICE WHICH UNREASONABLY EXCEEDS THE CURRENT MARKET PRICE
FOR COMPETING ITEMS; OR (D) CANNOT BE PURCHASED CONSISTENT WITH ANY
OTHER FEDERAL LAW.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 056 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106508
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(D) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PUBLISH FINAL REGULATIONS TO IMPLEMENT
SUBSECTION (A) AND SUBSECTION (B) RESPECTIVELY WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND
TWENTY DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION OF THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS, AND SUCH
REGULATIONS SHALL BECOME EFFECTIVE NOT MORE THAN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY
DAYS THEREAFTER.
"(E) THE PRESIDENT SHALL PRESCRIBE REGULATIONS TO CARRY OUT THIS
SECTION WHICH SHALL INSURE THAT:
"(1) EACH EXECUTIVE AGENCY (AS DEFINED IN SECTION 105 OF TITLE 5,
UNITED STATES CODE) SHALL INSURE COMPLIANCE OF ITS OWN ACTIVITIES WITH
THE REGULATIONS RECOMMENDED UNDER THIS SECTION AND THE PURPOSES OF THIS
ACT;
"(2) EACH EXECUTIVE AGENCY WHICH ENTERS INTO A CONTRACT WITH ANY
PERSON FOR THE OPERATION BY SUCH PERSON OF ANY FEDERAL PROPERTY OR
FACILITY OR THE PERFORMANCE BY SUCH PERSON OF ANY FUNCTION OF THAT
AGENCY, SHALL INSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQULATIONS RECOMMENDED UNDER
THIS SECTION AND THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT IN THE OPERATION OR
ADMINISTRATION OF SUCH PROPERTY OR FACILITY, OR THE PERFORMANCE OF SUCH
CONTRACT, AS THE CASE MAY BE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 057 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106509
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(3) EACH EXECUTIVE AGENCY WHICH PERMITS THE USE OF FEDERAL PROPERTY
FOR PURPOSES OF DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE SHALL INSURE COMPLIANCE WITH THE
REGULATIONS RECOMMENDED UNDER THIS SECTION AND THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT
IN THE DISPOSAL OF SUCH WASTE; AND
"(4) EACH EXECUTIVE AGENCY WHICH ISSUES ANY LICENSE OR PERMIT FOR
DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE SHALL, PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF SUCH LICENSE OR
PERMIT, CONSULT WITH THE ADMINISTRATOR TO INSURE COMPLIANCE WITH
REGULATIONS RECOMMENDED UNDER THIS SECTION AND THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT.
"(F) THE PRESIDENT MAY EXEMPT ANY SINGLE ACTIVITY OR FACILITY OF ANY
DEPARTMENT, AGENCY, OR INSTRUMENTALITY IN THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH FROM
COMPLIANCE WITH ANY REGULATIONS RECOMMENDED UNDER THIS SECTION IF HE
DETERMINES IT TO BE IN THE PARAMOUNT INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES TO DO
SO; EXCEPT THAT NO EXEMPTION SHALL BE GRANTED DUE TO LACK OF
APPROPRIATION UNLESS THE PRESIDENT SHALL HAVE SPECIFICALLY REQUESTED
SUCH APPROPRIATION AS A PART OF THE BUDGETARY PROCESS AND THE CONGRESS
SHALL HAVE FAILED TO MAKE AVAILABLE SUCH REQUESTED APPROPRIATION. ANY
EXEMPTION SHALL BE FOR A PERIOD NOT IN EXCESS OF ONE YEAR, BUT
ADDITIONAL EXEMPTIONS MAY BE GRANTED FOR PERIODS OF NOT TO EXCEED ONE
YEAR UPON THE PRESIDENT'S MAKING A NEW DETERMINATION. THE PRESIDENT
SHALL REPORT EACH JANUARY TO THE CONGRESS ALL EXEMPTIONS FROM THE
REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION GRANTED DURING THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR,
TOGETHER WITH HIS REASON FOR GRANTING SUCH EXEMPTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 058 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106510
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"PACKAGING, PRODUCTS, AND CONTAINERS
SEC. 111. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE
FEDERAL, STATE, INTERSTATE, AND MUNICIPAL AGENCIES AND EITHER INTERSTED
PERSONS, SHALL WITHIN SIX MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT
(AND FROM TIME TO TIME THEREAFTER REVISE) PUBLISH CRITERIA TO BE USED IN
CLASSIFYING PRODUCTS, CONTAINERS, AND PACKAGING BASED UPON (1) THE SOLID
WASTE DISPOSAL, RESOURCE CONSUMPTION, AND ENERGY CONSUMPTION PROBLEMS
CAUSED BY THE ITEMS, (2) THE POTENTIAL FOR SIGNIFICANT REUSE OF SUCH
ITEMS, AND (3) THE POTENTIAL FOR RESOURCE RECOVERY OR RECYCLABILITY OF
SUCH ITEMS.
"(B) WITHIN NINETY DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF PUBLICATION OF THE CRITERIA
UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PUBLISH
(AND FROM TIME TO TIME THEREAFTER REVISE) PUBLISH A LIST OF ITEMS FOR
WHICH REGULATIONS WILL BE PUBLISHED UNDER THIS SECTION. SUCH LIST SHALL
BE BASED ON A BALANCING OF THE FACTORS CONSIDERED IN THE CRITERIA
PUBLISHED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION.
"(C) WITHIN ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTY DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF PUBLICATION
OF THE LIST UNDER SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION, THE ADMINISTRATOR, IN
ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 553 OF TITLE 5 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE, SHALL
PUBLISH PROPOSED REGULATIONS FOR THE MANUFACTURE, DISTRIBUTION, REUSE,
AND RECYCLING OF PRODUCTS, CONTAINERS, OR PACKAGING.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 059 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106511
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
SUCH STANDARDS MAY INCLUDE MINIMUM PERCENTAGES OF RECYCLED MATERIALS
WHICH SHALL BE CONTAINED IN SUCH ITEMS, MAXIMUM PERMISSABLE QUANTITIES
OF COMPONENT MATERIALS AND MAY PRESCRIBE METHODS OF DISTRIBUTION FOR
CERTAIN ITEMS AND PROHIBITIONS AGAINST THE MANUFACTURE AND SALE OF
SPECIFIC ITEMS. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PUBLISH A NOTICE FOR A PUBLIC
HEARING ON SUCH PROPOSED REGULATIONS TO BE HELD WITHIN SIXTY DAYS. AS
SOON AS POSSIBLE AFTER SUCH HEARING, BUT NOT LATER THAN SIX MONTHS AFTER
PUBLICATION OF THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS, UNLESS THE ADMINISTRATOR FINDS,
ON THE RECORD, THAT A MODIFICATION OF SUCH PROPOSED STANDARD IS
JUSTIFIED BASED UPON A PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE ADDUCED AT SUCH
HEARINGS, SUCH STANDARD SHALL BE PROMULGATED. IF AFTER A PUBLIC HEARING
THE ADMINISTRATOR FINDS THAT A MODIFICATION OF SUCH PROPOSED STANDARD IS
JUSTIFIED, REVISED REGULATIONS SHALL BE PROMULGATED IMMEDIATELY. SUCH
REGULATIONS SHALL BE REVIEWED AND, IF APPROPRIATE, REVISED AT LEAST
EVERY THREE YEARS.
"SEC. 112. (A) NOT LATER THAN ONE YEAR AFTER ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT
THE ADMINISTRATOR, AFTER A PUBLIC HEARING, SHALL PUBLISH:
"(1) A CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM OF MAJOR ITEMS OF SOLID WASTE BASED
UPON:
"(A) THE SOLID WASTE AND RESOURCE CONSUMPTION PROBLEMS CAUSED BY THE
ITEM,
"(B) THE POTENTIAL FOR INCREASING THE USEFUL LIFE OF THE ITEM, AND
"(C) SUCH OTHER FACTORS, AS DEEMED APPROPRIATE; AND
"(2) PROPOSED REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING THE MINIMUM LIFE FOR MAJOR
ITEMS CLASSIFIED AS CONTRIBUTING SIGNIFICANTLY TO SOLID WASTE OR
RESOURCE CONSUMPTION PROBLEMS AND HAVING SUBSTANTIAL POTENTIAL FOR
INCREASED USEFUL LIFE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 060 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106512
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ESTABLISH A SYSTEM OF FEES OR SOME OTHER
MECHANISM OF SYSTEM TO ENCOURAGE RECONDITIONING, REUSE, RECYCLING, OR
DISPOSAL WITHOUT HARM TO THE ENVIRONMENT OR VIOLATION OF ANY APPLICABLE
AIR OR WATER QUALITY REQUIREMENTS OF MAJOR ITEMS.
"(C) NOT LATER THAN ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY DAYS AFTER PUBLICATION OF
THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS THE ADMINISTRATOR AFTER PUBLIC HEARINGS SHALL
PUBLISH FINAL REGULATIONS GOVERNING MAJOR ITEMS OF SOLID WASTE WHICH
REGULATIONS SHALL BECOME EFFECTIVE TWENTY-FOUR MONTHS AFTER PUBLICATION.
"(D) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL REQUIRE THAT ANY MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID
WASTE FOR WHICH STANDARDS HAVE BEEN PROMULGATED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION
AND WHICH IS MANUFACTURED AFTER THE DATE OR WHICH SUCH STANDARDS BECOME
EFFECTIVE SHALL INCLUDE A LABEL WHICH SPECIFIES THE CONDITIONS SET OUT
IN THE STANDARD FOR THAT MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE FOR ITS REUSE,
RECYCLING, OR DISPOSAL AND SHALL INCLUDE INFORMATION AS TO ANY
REIMBURSABLE FEES PAYABLE TO THE HOLDER OF THAT MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID
WASTE AT SUCH TIME AS THE ITEM IS RETURNED FOR REUSE, RECYCLING, OR
DISPOSAL AS INDICATED ON THE LABEL.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 061 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106513
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"IMPORTS
"SEC. 113. ANY PRODUCT OFFERED FOR ENTRY INTO THE UNITED STATES FOR
WHICH A STANDARD HAS BECOME EFFECTIVE PURSUANT TO SECTION 111 OR 112 OF
THIS ACT, WHICH IS NOT ACCOMPANIED BY A CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE IN THE
FORM PRESCRIBED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, SHALL BE REFUSED ENTRY INTO THE
UNITED STATES. IF A PRODUCT IS REFUSED ENTRY, THE SECRETARY OF THE
TREASURY SHALL REFUSE DELIVERY TO THE CONSIGNEE AND SHALL REQUIRE
STORAGE OF ANY PRODUCT REFUSED DELIVERY WHICH HAS NOT BEEN EXPORTED BY
THE CONSIGNEE WITHIN THREE MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF NOTICE OF SUCH
REFUSAL UNDER SUCH REGULATIONS AS THE SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY MAY
PRESCRIBE, EXCEPT THAT THE SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY MAY DELIVER TO THE
CONSIGNEE SUCH PRODUCT PENDING EXAMINATION AND DECISION IN THE MATTER ON
EXECUTION OF BOND FOR THE AMOUNT OF THE FULL INVOICE VALUE OF SUCH
PRODUCT, TOGETHER WITH THE DUTY THEREON, AND ON REFUSAL TO RETURN SUCH
PRODUCT FOR ANY CAUSE TO THE CUSTODY OF THE SECRETARY OF THE TREASURY,
WHEN DEMANDED, FOR THE PURPOSE OF EXCLUDING IT FROM THE COUNTRY, OR FOR
ANY PURPOSE, SAID CONSIGNEE SHALL FORFEIT THE FULL AMOUNT OF SAID BOND.
ALL CHARGES FOR STORAGE, CARTAGE, AND LABOR ON PRODUCTS WHICH ARE
REFUSED ADMISSION OR DELIVERY UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL BE PAID BY THE
OWNER OR CONSIGNEE, AND IN DEFAULT OF SUCH PAYMENT SHALL CONSTITUTE A
LIEN AGAINST ANY FUTURE IMPORTATION MADE BY SUCH OWNER OR CONSIGNEE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 062 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106514
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"PROHIBITED ACTS
"SEC. 114. (A) EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS
SECTION, THE FOLLOWING ACTS OR THE CAUSING THEREOF ARE PROHIBITED;
"(1) AT ANY TIME LATER THAN ONE YEAR AFTER PUBLICATION OF FINAL
REGULATIONS FOR PRODUCTS, PACKAGING, AND CONTAINERS UNDER SECTION 111 OF
THIS ACT, THE MANUFACTURE, DISTRIBUTION, SALE, OR OFFERING FOR SALE OF
ANY PRODUCT PACKAGING, OR CONTAINER NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH SUCH
REGULATIONS;
"(2) THE MANUFACTURE, DISTRIBUTION, SALE, OR OFFERING FOR SALE OF ANY
MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE IN VIOLATION OF CONDITIONS OR PROCEDURES
ESTABLISHED BY STANDARDS PROMULGATED AND IN EFFECT FOR SUCH MAJOR ITEMS
OF SOLID WASTE IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 112 OF THIS ACT;
"(3) THE REMOVAL BY ANY PERSON OF ANYLBEL AFFIXED TO A MAJOR ITEM OF
SOLID WASTE PURSUANT TO REGULATIONS PROMULGATED UNDER SECTION 112(D) OF
THIS ACT PRIOR TO SALE OF SUCH ITEM TO THE ULTIMATE PURCHASER, OR THE
SALE OF A MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE FROM WHICH SUCH LABEL HAS BEEN
REMOVED.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 063 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106515
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(4) THE IMPORTATION INTO THE UNITED STATES FOR RESALE BY ANY PERSON
OF ANY CONSUMER PRODUCTS OR MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE IN VIOLATION OF
REGULATIONS PROMULGATED UNDER SECTION 113 OF THIS ACT THAT ARE
APPLICABLE TO SUCH PRODUCT;
"(5) THE FAILURE OF ANY PERSON TO COMPLY WITH ANY ORDER ISSUED UNDER
SECTION 115(D) OF THIS ACT.
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY, AFTER PUBLIC HEARINGS EXEMPT FOR A
SPECIFIED PERIOD OF TIME NOT TO EXCEED ONE YEAR, ANY MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID
WASTE OR CLASS THEREOF, FROM PARAGRAPHS (1) AND (3) OF SUBSECTION (A) OF
THIS SECTION UPON SUCH TERMS AND CONDITIONS AS HE MAY FIND NECESSARY TO
PROTECT THE PUBLIC HEALTH OR WELFARE, FOR THE PURPOSE OF RESEARCH,
INVESTIGATIONS, STUDIES, DEMONSTRATIONS, OR TRAINING, OR FOR REASONS OF
NATIONAL SECURITY.
"ENFORCEMENT
"SEC. 115. (A) ANY PERSON WHO WILLFULLY VIOLATES PARAGRAPH (1), (2),
(3), OR (4) OF SUBSECTION (A) OF SECTION 114 OF THIS ACT SHALL BE
PUNISHED BY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $5,000 FOR EACH VIOLATION, OR BY
IMPRISONMENT FOR NOT MORE THAN ONE YEAR, OR BY BOTH. IF THE CONVICTION
IS FOR A VIOLATION COMMITTED AFTER A FIRST CONVICTION OF SUCH PERSON
UNDER THIS PARAGRAPH, PUNISHMENT SHALL BE BY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN
$10,000 FOR EACH VIOLATION, OR BY IMPRISONMENT FOR NOT MORE THAN TWO
YEAR, OR BY BOTH.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 064 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106516
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) ANY PERSON WHO VIOLATES PARAGRAPH (1), (2), (3), OR (4) OF
SUBSECTION (A) OF SECTION 113 OF THIS ACT SHALL BE SUBJECT TO A CIVIL
PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN $5,000 FOR EACH VIOLATION.
"(C) THE DISTRICT COURTS OF THE UNITED STATES SHALL HAVE JURISDICTION
OF ACTIONS BROUGHT BY AND IN THE NAME OF THE UNITED STATES TO RESTRAIN
ANY VIOLATION OF SECTION 114 OF THIS ACT.
"(D) WHENEVER ANY PERSON IS IN VIOLATION OF SECTION 114(A) OF THIS
ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ISSUE AN ORDER SPECIFYING SUCH RELIEF AS HE
DETERMINES IS NECESSARY TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE. SUCH
RELIEF MAY INCLUDE AN ORDER REQUIRING SUCH PERSON TO CEASE SUCH
VIOLATION, AND MAY ALSO INCLUDE THE SIEZURE OF ANY SUCH PRODUCTS BY THE
ADMINISTRATOR.
"(2) ANY ORDER UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE ISSUED ONLY AFTER
NOTICE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR A HEARING IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 554 OF
TITLE 5 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE.
"CITIZEN SUITS
"SEC. 116 (A) EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (B) OF THIS SECTION,
ANY PERSON MAY COMMENCE A CIVIL ACTION ON HIS OWN BEHALF:
"(1) AGAINST ANY PERSON (INCLUDING (A) THE UNITED STATES, AND (B) ANY
OTHER GOVERNMENTAL INSTRUMENTALITY OR AGENCY TO THE EXTENT PERMITTED BY
THE ELEVENTH AMENDMENT TO THE CONSTITUTION) WHO IS ALLEGED TO BE IN
VIOLATION OF ANY CERTIFICATION, STANDARD, OR REGULATION WHICH HAS BECOME
EFFECTIVE PURSUANT TO THIS ACT; AND
"(2) AGAINST THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY
WHERE THERE IS ALLEGED A FAILURE OF SUCH ADMINISTRATOR TO PERFORM ANY
ACT OR DUTY UNDER THIS ACT WHICH IS NOT DISCRETIONARY WITH SUCH
ADMINISTRATOR.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 065 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106517
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
THE DISTRICT COURTS OF THE UNITED STATES SHALL HAVE JURISDICTION,
WITHOUT REGARD TO THE AMOUNT IN CONTROVERSY OR THE CITIZENSHIP OF THE
PARTIES, TO ENFORCE SUCH STANDARD OR REQUIREMENT OR TO ORDER SUCH
ADMINISTRATOR TO PERFORM SUCH ACT OR DUTY, AS THE CASE MAY BE.
"(B) NO ACTION MAY COMMENCED:
"(1) UNDER SUBSECTION (A)(1) OF THIS SECTION:
"(A) PRIOR TO THIRTY DAYS AFTER THE PLAINTIFF HAS GIVEN NOTICE OF THE
VIOLATION (I) TO THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
AGCNEY AND (II) TO ANY ALLEGED VIOLATOR OF SUCH CERTIFICATION, STANDARD,
OR REGULATION, OR
"(B) IF THE ADMINISTRATOR HAS COMMENCED AND IS DILIGENTLY PROSECUTING
A CIVIL ACTION TO REQUIRE COMPLIANCE WITH SUCH CERTIFICATION, STANDARD,
OR REGULATION, BUT IN ANY SUCH ACTION IN A COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
ANY PERSON MAY INTERVENE AS A MATTER OF RIGHT; OR
"(2) UNDER SUBSECTION (A)(2) OF THIS SECTION PRIOR TO THIRTY DAYS
AFTER THE PLAINTIFF HAS GIVEN NOTICE TO THE DEFENDANT THAT HE WILL
COMMENCE SUCH ACTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 066 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106518
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
NOTICE UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE GIVEN IN SUCH MANNER AS THE
ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY SHALL PRESCRIBE BY
REGULATION.
"(C) IN AN ACTION UNDER THIS SECTION, THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY MAY INTERVENE AS A MATTER OF RIGHT.
"(D) THE COURT, IN ISSUING ANY FINAL ORDER IN ANY ACTION BROUGHT
PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION, MAY AWARD COSTS OF
LITIGATION(INCLUDING REASONABLE ATTORNEY AND EXPERT WITNESS FEES) TO ANY
PARTY, WHENEVER THE COURT DETERMINES SUCH AN AWARD IS APPROPRIATE.
"(E) NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL RESTRICT ANY RIGHT WHICH ANY
PERSON (OR CLASS OF PERSONS) MAY HAVE UNDER ANY STATUTE OR COMMON LAW TO
SEEK ENFORCEMENT OF ANY STANDARD OR REQUIREMENT RELATING TO SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT OR TO SEEK ANY OTHER RELIEF (INCLUDING RELIEF AGAINST THE
ADMINISTRATOR).
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 067 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106519
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"JUDICIAL REVIEW
"SEC. 117. ANY JUDICIAL REVIEW OF FINAL REGULATIONS PROMULGATED UNDER
THIS ACT SHALL BE IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTIONS 701 THROUGH 706 OF TITLE 5
OF THE UNITED STATES CODE, EXCEPT THAT:
"(A) A PETITION FOR REVIEW OF ACTION OF THE ADMINISTRATOR IN
PROMULGATING ANY STANDARD, REGULATION, OR LABELING REQUIREMENT UNDER
THIS ACT MAY BE FILED ONLY IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA. ANY SUCH PETITION SHALL BE FILED WITHIN SIXTY
DAYS FROM THE DATE OF SUCH PROMULGATION, OR AFTER SUCH DATE IF SUCH
PETITION IS BASED SOLELY ON GROUNDS ARISING AFTER SUCH SIXTIETH DAY.
ACTION OF THE ADMINISTRATOR WITH RESPECT TO WHICH REVIEW COULD HAVE BEEN
OBTAINED UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL NOT BE SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW
IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS FOR ENFORCEMENT EXCEPT AS TO WHETHER THE
ADMINISTRATIVE AND JUDICIAL PROCEDURES OF THIS ACT HAVE BEEN OBSERVED;
"(B) IF A PARTY SEEKING REVIEW UNDER THIS ACT APPLIES TO THE COURT
FOR LEAVE TO ADDUCE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE, AND SHOWS TO THE SATISFACTION
OF THE COURT THAT THE INFORMATION IS MATERIAL AND WAS NOT AVAILABLE AT
THE TIME OF THE PROCEEDING BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATOR, THE COURT MAY ORDER
SUCH ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE (AND EVIDENCE IN REBUTTAL THEREOF) TO BE TAKEN
BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATOR, AND TO BE ADDUCED UPON THE HEARING IN SUCH
MANNER AND UPON SUCH TERMS AND CONDITIONS AS THE COURT MAY DEEM PROPER.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 068 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106520
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
THE ADMINSTRATOR MAY MODIFY HIS FINDINGS AS TO THE FACTS, OR MAKE NEW
FINDINGS, BY REASON OF THE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE SO TAKEN, AND HE SHALL
FILE WITH THE COURT SUCH MODIFIED OR NEW FINDINGS AND HIS
RECOMMENDATION, IF ANY, FOR THE MODIFICATION OR SETTING ASIDE OF HIS
ORIGINAL ORDER, WITH THE RETURN OF SUCH ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE;
"(C) WITH RESPECT TO RELIEF PENDING REVIEW OF AN ACTION BY THE
ADMINISTRATOR, NO STAY OF AN AGENCY ACTION MAY BE GRANTED UNLESS THE
REVIEWING COURT DETERMINES THAT THE PARTY SEEKING SUCH STAY IS (1)
LIKELY TO PREVAIL ON THE MERITS IN THE REVIEW PROCEEDING AND (2) WILL
SUFFER IRREPARABLE HARM PENDING SUCH PROCEEDING.
"RECORDS, REPORTS, AND INFORMATION
"SEC. 118. (A) ANY MANUFACTURER, DISTRIBUTOR, OR OTHER SELLER OF A
PRODUCT, PACKAGE, OR CONTAINER OF ANY MAJOR ITEM OF SOLID WASTE FOR
WHICH ANY CERTIFICATION, STANDARD, OR REGULATION HAS BEEN PROMULGATED
PURSUANT TO THIS ACT SHALL (1) ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN SUCH RECORDS, MAKE
SUCH REPORTS, AND PROVIDE SUCH INFORMATION AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY
REASONABLY REQUIRE TO ENABLE HIM TO DETERMINE WHETHER SUCH MANUFACTURER,
DISTRIBUTOR, OR OTHER SELLER HAS ACTED OR IS ACTING IN COMPLIANCE WITH
THIS ACT, AND (2) UPON REQUEST OF AN OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE DULY DESIGNATED
BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, PERMIT SUCH OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE AT REASONABLE
TIMES TO HAVE ACCESS TO SUCH INFORMATION: PROVIDED, HOWEVER, THAT SUCH
RECORDS, REPORTS, OR OTHER MATERIALS AS ARE REQUIRED BY THIS SUBSECTION
TO BE SHOWN TO THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL NOT BE USED AS EVIDENCE IN ANY
ACTION UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF SECTION 114 OF THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 069 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106521
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) FOR THE PURPOSE OF OBTAINING INFORMATION TO CARRY OUT THIS ACT,
THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE SUBPENAS FOR THE ATTENDANCE AND TESTIMONY OF
WITNESSES AND THE PRODUCTION OF RELEVANT PAPERS, BOOKS, AND DOCUMENTS,
AND HE MAY ADMINISTER OATHS. WITNESSES SUMMONED SHALL BE PAID THE SAME
FEES AND MILEAGE THAT ARE PAID WITNESSES IN THE COURTS OF THE UNITED
STATES. IN CASES OF CONTUMACY OR REFUSAL TO OBEY A SUBPENA SERVED UPON
ANY PERSON UNDER THIS SUBSECTION, THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES FOR ANY DISTRICT IN WHICH SUCH PERSON IS FOUND OR RESIDES OR
TRANSACTS BUSINESS, UPON APPLICATION BY THE UNITED STATES AND AFTER
NOTICE TO SUCH PERSON, SHALL HAVE JURISDICTION TO ISSUE AN ORDER
REQUIRING SUCH PERSON TO APPEAR AND GIVE TESTIMONY BEFORE THE
ADMINISTRATOR, TO APPEAR AND PRODUCE PAPERS, BOOKS, AND DOCUMENTS,
BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATOR, OR BOTH, AND ANY FAILURE TO OBEY SUCH ORDER OF
THE COURT MAY BE PUNISHED BY SUCH COURT AS A CONTEMPT THEREOF.
"(C) ANY RECORDS, REPORTS, OR INFORMATION OBTAINED UNDER THIS SECTION
SHALL BE AVAILABEL TO THE PUBLIC, EXCEPT THAT UPON A SHOWING
SATISFACTORY TO THE ADMINISTRATOR BY ANY PERSON THAT RECORDS, REPORTS,
OR INFORMATION OR PARTICULAR PART THEREOF TO WHICH THE ADMINISTRATOR HAS
ACCESS UNDER THIS SECTION IF MADE PUBLIC, WOULD DIVULGE METHODS OR
PROCESSES ENTITLED TO PROTECTION AS TRADE SECRETS OF SUCH PERSON, THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CONSIDER SUCH RECORD, REPORT, OR INFORMATION OR
PARTICULAR PORTION THEREOF CONFIDENTIAL IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PURPOSES
OF SECTION 19.05 OF TITLE 18 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE, EXCEPT THAT SUCH
RECORD, REPORT, OR INFORMATION MAY BE DISCLOSED TO OTHER OFFICERS,
EMPLOYEES, OR AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVES OF THE UNITED STATES CONCERNED
WITH CARRYING OUT THIS ACT OR WHEN RELEVANT IN ANY PROCEEDING UNDER THIS
ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 070 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106522
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL AUTHORIZE THE WITHHOLDING OF
INFORMATION BY THE ADMINISTRATOR OR ANY OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE UNDER HIS
CONTROL, FROM THE DULY AUTHORIZED COMMITTEES OF THE CONGRESS.
"(D) ANY COMMUNICATION FROM A PERSON OR ANY FEDERAL AGENCY TO THE
ADMINISTRATOR OR ANY OTHER EMPLOYEE OF THE AGENCY CONCERNING A MATTER
UNDER CONSIDERATION IN A RULEMAKING OR ADJUDICATORY PROCEEDING IN THE
AGENCY SHALL BE MADE A PART OF THE PUBLIC FILE OF THAT PROCEEDING AND
SHALL BE AVAILABLE FOR INSPECTION DURING REGULAR BUSINESS HOURS UNLESS
IT IS A COMMUNICATION ENTITLED TO PROTECTION UNDER SUBSECTION (C) OF
THIS SECTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 071 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106523
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(E) ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY MAKES ANY FALSE STATEMENT,
REPRESENTATION, OR CERTIFICATION IN ANY APPLICATION, RECORD, REPORT,
PLAN, OR OTHER DOCUMENT FILED OR REQUIRED TO BE MAINTAINED UNDER THIS
ACT SHALL UPON CONVICTION BE PUNISHED BY A FINE OF NOT MORE THAN $10,000
OR BY IMPRISONMENT FOR NOT MORE THAN SIX MONTHS, OR BY BOTH.
"PUBLIC RULEMAKING
"SEC. 119. AFTER PUBLICATION OF ANY PROPOSED STANDARDS OR
REGULATIONS UNDER THIS ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, AFTER ADEQUATE
NOTICE, HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE PROPOSED STANDARDS OR REGULATIONS
AND SHALL ALSO ALLOW THE PUBLIC AN OPPORTUNITY TO PARTICIPATE IN
RULEMAKING IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 553 OF TITLE 5, UNITED STATES
CODE.
"ANNUAL REPORT
"SEC. 120. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL COMPILE AND PUBLISH ANNUALLY A
REPORT TO THE CONGRESS:
"(1) THE STATUS AND PROGRESS OF ACTIVITIES RELATING TO REDUCTION OF
SOLID WASTE AND THE REUSE, RECYCLING, AND DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE;
"(2) THE IMPACT OF FEDERAL PROCUREMENT, REGULATORY, AND TAX AND
ECONOMIC POLICIES ON RESOURCE RECOVERY AND RECYCLING;
"(3) THE DEVELOPMENT OF MARKETS FOR RECYCLED MATERIALS;
"(4) THE ADEQUACY OF DISPOSAL SITES FOR HAZARDOUS WASTES AND OTHER
DISPOSAL ITEMS;
"(5) EFFORTS OF STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS AND PRIVATE INDUSTRY IN
IMPROVED SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT;
"(6) NEW TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENTS AND OTHER PROCESSES AND SYSTEMS
TO IMPROVE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND RESOURCE RECOVERY EFFORTS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 072 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106524
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(7) THE NEED FOR TRAINING AND RECRUITING PERSONNEL FOR SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS;
"(8) THE STATUS OF ANY ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE
ADMINISTRATOR.
"(B) NO REPORT REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
SECTION, NOR ANY DRAFT OR PORTION THEREOF, SHALL BE SUBMITTED TO THE
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET OR ANY OTHER FEDERAL AGENCY ON A DATE
ANY EARLIER THAN THAT ON WHICH SUCH REPORT, OR DRAFT OR PORTION THEREOF,
IS SUBMITTED TO THE CONGRESS.
"LABOR STANDARDS
"SEC. 121. NO GRANT FOR A PROJECT OF CONSTRUCTION UNDER THIS ACT
SHALL BE MADE UNLESS THE ADMINISTRATOR FINDS THAT THE APPLICATION
CONTAINS OR IS SUPPORTED BY REASONABLE ASSURANCE THAT ALL LABORERS AND
MECHANICS EMPLOYED BY CONTRACTORS OR SUBCONTRACTORS ON PROJECTS OF THE
TYPE COVERED BY THE DAVIS-BACON ACT, AS AMENDED (40 U.S.C. 276A-276A-5),
WILL BE PAID WAGES AT RATES NOT LESS THAN THOSE PREVAILING ON SIMILAR
WORK IN THE LOCALITY AS DETERMINED BY THE SECRETARY OF LABOR IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THAT ACT; AND THE SECRETARY OF LABOR SHALL HAVE WITH
RESPECT TO THE LABOR STANDARDS SPECIFIED IN THIS SECTION THE AUTHORITY
AND FUNCTIONS SET FORTH IN REORGANIZATION PLAN NUMBERED 14 OF 1950 (15
F.R. 3176; 5 U.S.C. 133Z-15) AND SECTION 2 OF THE ACT OF JUNE 13, 1934,
AS AMENDED (40 U.S.C. 276C).
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 073 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106525
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"EMPLOYEE PROTECTION
"SEC. 122. (A) NO PERSON SHALL FIRE, OR IN ANY OTHER WAY DISCRIMINATE
AGAINST, OR CAUSE TO BE FIRED OR DISCRIMINATED AGAINST, ANY EMPLOYEE OR
ANY AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE OF EMPLOYEES BY REASON OF THE FACT THAT
SUCH EMPLOYEE OR REPRESENTATIVE HAS FILED, INSTITUTED, OR CAUSED TO BE
FILED OR INSTITUTED, ANY PROCEEDING UNDER THIS ACT, OR HAS TESTIFIED OR
IS ABOUT TO TESTIFY IN ANY PROCEEDINGS RELATED TO OR RESULTING FROM THE
ADMINISTRATION OR ENFORCEMENT OF THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT.
"(B) ANY EMPLOYEE OR A REPRESENTATIVE OF EMPLOYEES WHO BELIEVES THAT
HE HAS BEEN FIRED OR OTHERWISE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST BY ANY PERSON IN
VIOLATION OF SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS SECTION MAY, WITHIN THIRTY DAYS
AFTER SUCH ALLEGED VIOLATION OCCURS, APPLY TO THE SECRETARY OF LABOR FOR
REVIEW OF SUCH FIRING OR ALLEGED DISCRIMINATION. A COPY OF THE
APPLICATION SHALL BE SENT TO SUCH PERSON WHO SHALL BE THE RESPONDENT.
UPON RECEIPT OF SUCH APPLICATION, THE SECRETARY OF LABOR SHALL CAUSE
SUCH INVESTIGATION TO BE MADE AS HE DEEMS APPROPRIATE. SUCH
INVESTIGATION SHALL PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY FOR A PUBLIC HEARING AT THE
REQUEST OF ANY PARTY TO SUCH REVIEW TO ENABLE THE PARTIES TO PRESENT
INFORMATION RELATING TO SUCH ALLEGED VIOLATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 074 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106526
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
THE PARTIES SHALL BE GIVEN WRITTEN NOTICE OF THE TIME AND PLACE OF
THE HEARING AT LEAST FIVE DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING. ANY SUCH HEARING
SHALL BE OF RECORD AND SHALL BE SUBJECT TO SECTION 544 OF TITLE 5 OF THE
UNITED STATES CODE. UPON RECEIVING THE REPORT OF SUCH INVESTIGATION,
THE SECRETARY OF LABOR SHALL MAKE FINDINGS OF FACT. IF HE FINDS THAT
SUCH VIOLATION DID OCCUR, HE SHALL ISSUE A DECISION, INCORPORATING AN
ORDER THEREIN AND HIS FINDINGS, REQUIRING THE PARTY COMMITTING SUCH
VIOLATION TO TAKE SUCH AFFIRMATIVE ACTION TO ABATE THE VIOLATION AS THE
SECRETARY OF LABOR DEEMS APPROPRIATE, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
REHIRING OR REINSTATEMENT OF THE EMPLOYEE OR REPRESENTATIVE OF EMPLOYEES
TO HIS FORMER POSITION WITH COMPENSATION. IF HE FINDS THAT THERE WAS NO
SUCH VIOLATIONS, HE SHALL ISSUE AN ORDER DENYING THE APPLICATION. SUCH
ORDER ISSUED BY THE SECRETARY OF LABOR UNDER THIS SUBPARAGRAPH SHALL BE
SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW IN THE SAME MANNER AS ORDERS AND DECISIONS OF
THE ADMINISTRATOR ARE SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL REVIEW UNDER THIS A.
"(C) WHENEVER AN ORDER IS ISSUED UNDER THIS SECTION TO ABATE SUCH
VIOLATION, AT THE REQUEST OF THE APPLICANT, A SUM EQUAL TO THE AGGREGATE
AMOUNT OF ALL COSTS AND EXPENSES (INCLUDING THE ATTORNEY'S FEES), AS
DETERMINED BY THE SECRETARY OF LABOR TO HAVE BEEN REASONABLY INCURRED BY
THE APPLICANT FOR, OR IN CONNECTION WITH, THE INSTITUTION AND
PROSECUTION OF SUCH PROCEEDINGS, SHALL BE ASSESSED AGAINST THE PERSON
COMMITTING SUCH VIOLATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 075 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106527
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(D) THIS SECTION SHALL HAVE NO APPLICATION TO ANY EMPLOYEE WHO,
ACTING WITHOUT DIRECTION FROM HIS EMPLOYER (OR HIS AGENT) DELIBERATELY
VIOLATES OR CAUSES TO BE VIOLATED ANY PROHIBITION OR LIMITATION
ESTABLISHED UNDER THIS ACT OR WHO COMMITS ANY ACT PROHIBITED BY THIS
ACT.
"(E) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CONDUCT CONTINUING EVALUATIONS OF
POTENTIAL LOSS OR SHIFTS OF EMPLOYMENT WHICH MAY RESULT FROM THE
ISSUANCE OF ANY STANDARD, REGULATION, OR ORDER UNDER THIS ACT,
INCLUDING, WHERE APPROPRIATE, INVESTIGATING THREATENED PLANT CLOSURES OR
REDUCTIONS IN EMPLOYMENT ALLEGEDLY RESULTING FROM SUCH STANDARD,
REGULATION, OR ORDER. ANY EMPLOYEE WHO IS DISCHARGED OR LAID OFF,
THREATENED WITH DISCHARGE OR LAYOFF, OR OTHERWISE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST
BY ANY PERSON BECAUSE OF THE ALLEGED RESULTS OF ANY STANDARD,
REGULATION, OR ORDER ISSUED UNDER THIS ACT, OR ANY REPRESENTATIVE OF
SUCH EMPLOYEE, MAY REQUEST THE ADMINISTRATOR TO CONDUCT A FULL
INVESTIGATION OF THE MATTER. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL THEREUPON
INVESTIGATE THE MATTER AND, AT THE REQUEST OF ANY PARTY, SHALL HOLD
PUBLIC HEARINGS ON NOT LESS THAN FIVE DAYS NOTICE, AND SHALL AT SUCH
HEARINGS REQUIRE THE PARTIES, INCLUDING THE EMPLOYER INVOLVED, TO
PRESENT INFORMATION RELATING TO THE ACTUAL OR POTENTIAL EFFECT OF SUCH
STANDARD, REGULATION, OR ORDER ON EMPLOYMENT AND ON ANY ALLEGED
DISCHARGE, LAYOFF, OR OTHER DISCRIMINATION AND THE DETAILED REASONS OR
JUSTIFICATION THEREOF.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 076 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106528
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
ANY SUCH HEARING SHALL BE OF RECORD AND SHALL BE SUBJECT TO SECTION
554 OF TITLE 5 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE. UPON RECEIVING THE REPORT OF
SUCH INVESTIGATION, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL MAKE FINDINGS OF FACT AS TO
THE EFFECT OF SUCH STANDARD, REGULATION OR ORDER ON EMPLOYMENT AND ON
THE ALLEGED DISCHARGE, LAYOFF, OR DISCRIMINATION AND SHALL MAKE SUCH
RECOMMENDATIONS AS HE DEEMS APPROPRIATE. SUCH REPORT, FINDINGS, AND
RECOMMENDATIONS SHALL BE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC. NOTING IN THIS
SUBSECTION SHALL BE CONSTRUED TO REQUIRE OR AUTHORIZE THE ADMINISTRATOR
TO MODIFY OR WITHDRAW ANY STANDARD, REGULATION, OR ORDER ISSUED UNDER
THIS ACT.
"STATE AND LOCAL AUTHORITY
"SEC. 123. NOTHING IN THIS ACT SHALL BE INTERPRETED AS PRECLUDING OR
DENYING THE RIGHT OF ANY STATE OR POLITICAL SUBDIVISION THEREOF TO ADOPT
OR ENFORCE ANY STANDARD OR REGULATION RELATING TO SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT
OR REUSE, RECYCLING, OR DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE WHICH IS MORE STRINGENT
THAN STANDARDS OR REGULATIONS IMPOSED UNDER THIS ACT.
"GENERAL PROVISIONS
"SEC. 124. (A) PAYMENTS OF GRANTS UNDER THIS ACT MAY BE MADE (AFTER
NECESSARY ADJUSTMENT ON ACCOUNT OF PREVIOUSLY MADE UNDERPAYMENTS OR
OVERPAYMENTS) IN ADVANCE OR BY WAY OF REIMBURSEMENT, AND IN SUCH
INSTALLMENTS AND ON SUCH CONDITIONS AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY DETERMINE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 077 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106529
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) NO GRANT MAY BE MADE UNDER THIS ACT TO PRIVATE PROFITMAKING
ORGANIZATIONS.
"(C) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE ADMINISTRATOR OF
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO CARRY OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THIS
ACT, OTHER THAN SECTION 106 AND SECTION 107 NOT TO EXCEED $50,000,000
FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1975, NOT TO EXCEED $60,000,000 FOR
THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1976, AND NOT TO EXCEED $70,000,000 FOR
THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1977.
"(D) THERE ARE AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE SECRETARY OF THE
INTERIOR TO CARRY OUT THIS ACT NOT TO EXCEED $25,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL
YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 1975, NOT TO EXCEED $25,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR
ENDING JUNE 30, 1976, AND NOT TO EXCEED $25,000,000 FOR THE FISCAL YEAR
ENDING JUNE 30, 1977. PRIOR TO EXPENDING ANY FUNDS AUTHORIZED TO BE
APPROPRIATED BY THIS SUBSECTION, THE SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR SHALL
CONSULT WITH THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY TO
ASSURE THAT THE EXPENDITURE OF SUCH FUNDS WILL BE CONSISTENT WITH THE
PURPOSES OF THIS ACT.
"(E) SUCH PORTION AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY DETERMINE BUT NOT MORE
THAN 1 PER CENTUM, OF ANY APPROPRIATION FOR GRANTS, CONTRACTS, OR OTHER
PAYMENTS UNDER ANY PROVISION OF THIS ACT FOR ANY FISCAL YEAR BEGINNING
AFTER JUNE 30, 1970, SHALL BE AVAILALBE FOR EVALUATION (DIRECTLY, OR BY
GRANTS OR CONTRACTS) OF ANY PROGRAM AUTHORIZED BY THIS ACT.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 078 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106530
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(F) SUMS APPROPRIATED UNDER THIS ACT SHALL REMAIN AVAILABLE UNTIL
EXPENDED.
"(G) ANY AND ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED TO THE CONGRESS, THE OFFICE OF
MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET, OR ANY OTHER FEDERAL AGENCY WITH RESPECT TO A
PROPOSED BUDGET TO IMPLEMENT ANY OF THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT SHALL BE
MADE AVAILABLE FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION DURING REGULAR BUSINESS HOURS AT A
PLACE TO BE DESIGNATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR.
"SEPARABILITY
"SEC. 125. IF ANY PROVISION OF THIS ACT, OR THE APPLICATION OF ANY
PROVISION OF THIS ACT TO ANY PERSON OR CIRCUMSTANCE, IS HELD INVALID,
THE APPLICATION OF SUCH PROVISION TO OTHER PERSONS OR CIRCUMSTANCES, AND
THE REMAINDER OF THIS ACT, SHALL NOT BE AFFECTED THEREBY.
"WATER POLLUTION FROM SANITARY LANDFILLS
"SEC. 126. SUBSECTION 304(E)(2) OF THE FEDERAL WATER POLLUTION
CONTROL ACT IS AMENDED BY STRIKING 'AND' AT THE END OF SUBPARAGRAPH (E),
INSERTING 'AND' AT THE END OF SUBPARAGRAPH (F) AND ADDING A NEW
SUBPARAGRAPH TO READ AS FOLLOWS:
"'(G) SANITARY LANDFILL SITES AND OTHER SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL
ACTIVITIES'.".
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 079 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106531
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
93D CONGRESS 1ST SESSION
MR. BAKER INTRODUCED THE FOLLOWING BILL; WHICH WAS READ TWICE AND
REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
TO ASSURE PROTECTION OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS FROM
THE ADVERSE IMPACT OF THE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES, TO AUTHORIZE A
RESEARCH PROGRAM WITH RESPECT TO HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL, AND FOR OTHER
PURPOSES.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN CONGRESS ASSEMBLED,
SECTION 1. THIS ACT MAY BE CITED AS THE "HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT
ACT OF 1973".
FINDINGS AND PURPOSE
SEC. 2(A) THE CONGRESS FINDS:
(1) THAT CONTINUING TECHNOLOGICAL PROGRESS, IMPROVEMENT IN THE
METHODS OF MANUFACTURE, AND ABATEMENT OF AIR AND WATER POLLUTION HAS
RESULTED IN AN EVER-MOUNTING INCREASE OF HAZARDOUS WASTES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 080 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106532
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(2) THAT IMPROPER LAND DISPOSAL AND OTHER MANAGEMENT PRACTICES OF
SOLID, LIQUID, AND SEMISOLID HAZARDOUS WASTES WHICH ARE A PART OF
INTERSTATE COMMERCE ARE RESULTING IN ADVERSE IMPACT ON HEALTH AND OTHER
LIVING ORGANISMS;
(3) THAT THE KNOWLEDGE AND TECHNOLOGY NECESSARY FOR ALLEVIATING
ADVERSE HEALTH, ENVIRONMENTAL, AND ESTHETIC IMPACTS ASSOCIATED WITH
CURRENT WASTE MANAGEMENT AND DISPOSAL PRACTICES ARE GENERALLY AVAILABLE
AT COSTS WITHIN THE FINANCIAL CAPACITY OF THOSE WHO GENERATE SUCH
WASTES, EVEN THOUGH THIS KNOWLEDGE AND TECHNOLOGY ARE NOT WIDELY
UTILIZED;
(4) THAT PRIVATE INDUSTRY HAS DEMONSTRATED ITS CAPACITY AND
WILLINGNESS TO DEVELOP, FINANCE, CONSTRUCT, AND OPERATE FACILITIES AND
TO PERFORM OTHER ACTIVITIES FOR THE ADEQUATE DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS AND
OTHER WASTE MATERIALS;
(5) THAT WHILE THE COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL OF WASTES SHOULD CONTINUE
TO BE A RESPONSIBILITY OF PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS AND THE
CONCERN OF STATE, REGIONAL, AND LOCAL AGENCIES, THE PROBLEMS OF
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL AS SET FORTH ABOVE AND AS AN INTRINSIC PART OF
INTERSTATE COMMERCE HAVE BECOME A MATTER NATIONAL IN SCOPE AND IN
CONCERN, AND NECESSITATE FEDERAL ACTION THROUGH REGULATION OF THE
TREATMENT AND THE DISPOSAL OF THE MOST HAZARDOUS OF THESE WASTES, AND
THROUGH TECHNICAL AND OTHER ASSISTANCE IN THE APPLICATION OF NEW AND
IMPROVED METHODS AND PROCESSES TO PROVIDE FOR PROPER WASTE DISPOSAL
PRACTICES AND REDUCTIONS IN THE AMOUNT OF WASTE AND UNSALVAGEABLE
MATERIALS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 081 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106533
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) THE PURPOSES OF THIS ACT THEREFORE ARE:
(1) TO PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH AND OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS THROUGH
FEDERAL REGULATION IN THE TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL OF CERTAIN HAZARDOUS
WASTES;
(2) TO PROVIDE FOR THE PROMULGATION OF FEDERAL GUIDELINES FOR STATE
REGULATION OF THE TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES NOT SUBJECT
TO FEDERAL REGULATION;
(3) TO PROVIDE TECHNICAL AND OTHER ASSISTANCE TO PUBLIC AND PRIVATE
INSTITUTIONS IN THE APPLICATION OF EFFICIENT AND EFFECTIVE WASTE
MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS;
(4) TO PROMOTE A NATIONAL RESEARCH PROGRAM RELATING TO THE HEALTH AND
OTHER EFFECTS OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND THE PREVENTION OF ADVERSE IMPACTS
RELATING TO HEALTH AND OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 082 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106534
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
DEFINITIONS
SEC. 3. WHEN USED IN THIS ACT:
(1) THE TERM "ADMINISTRATOR" MEANS THE ADMINISTRATOR OF THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY.
(2) THE TERM "STATE" MEANS A STATE, THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, AND THE
COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO.
(3) THE TERM "WASTE" MEANS USELESS, UNWANTED, OR DISCARDED SOLID,
SEMISOLID OR LIQUID MATERIALS.
(4) THE TERM "HAZARDOUS WASTE" MEANS ANY WASTE OR COMBINATION OF
WASTES WHICH POSE A SUBSTANTIAL PRESENT OR POTENTIAL HAZARD TO HUMAN
HEALTH OR LIVING ORGANISMS BECAUSE SUCH WASTES ARE NONDEGRADABLE OR
PERSISTENT IN NATURE OR BECAUSE THEY CAN BE BIOLOGICALLY MAGNIFIED, OR
BECAUSE THEY CAN BE LETHAL, OR BECAUSE THEY MAY OTHERWISE CAUSE OR TEND
TO CAUSE DETRIMENTAL CUMULATIVE EFFECTS.
(5) THE TERM "SECONDARY MATERIAL" MEANS A MATERIAL THAT IS OR CAN BE
UTILIZED IN PLACE OF A PRIMARY OR RAW MATERIAL IN MANUFACTURING A
PRODUCT.
(6) THE TERM "GENERATION" MEANS THE ACT OR PROCESS OF PRODUCING WASTE
MATERIALS.
(7) THE TERM "STORAGE" MEANS THE INTERIM CONTAINMENT OF WASTE AFTER
GENERATION AND PRIOR TO ULTIMATE DISPOSAL. CONTAINMENT FOR MORE THAN
TWO YEARS SHALL BE CONSIDERED DISPOSAL.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 083 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106535
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(8) THE TERM "TRANSPORT" MEANS THE MOVEMENT OF WASTES FROM THE POINT
OF GENERATION TO ANY INTERMEDIATE TRANSFER POINTS, AND FINALLY TO THE
POINT OF ULTIMATE DISPOSAL.
(9) THE TERM "TREATMENT" MEANS ANY ACTIVITY OR PROCESSING DESIGNED TO
CHANGE THE PHYSICAL FORM OR CHEMICAL COMPOSITION OF WASTE SO AS TO
RENDER SUCH MATERIALS NONHAZARDOUS.
(10) THE TERM "DISPOSAL OF WASTE" MEANS THE DISCHARGE, DEPOSIT, OR
INJECTION INTO SUBSURFACE STRATA OR EXCAVATIONS OR THE ULTIMATE
DISPOSITION ONTO THE LAND OF ANY WASTE.
(11) THE TERM "DISPOSAL SITE" MEANS THE LOCATION WHERE ANY FINAL
DEPOSITION OF WASTE MATERIALS OCCURS.
(12) THE TERM "TREATMENT FACILITY" MEANS A LOCATION AT WHICH WASTE IS
SUBJECTED TO TREATMENT AND MAY INCLUDE A FACILITY WHERE WASTE HAS BEEN
GENERATED.
(13) THE TERM "PERSON" MEANS ANY INDIVIDUAL, PARTNERSHIP,
COPARTNERSHIP, FIRM, COMPANY, CORPORATION, ASSOCIATION, JOINT STOCK
COMPANY, TRUST, STATE, MUNICIPALITY, OR ANY LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE AGENT
OR ASSIGNS.
(14) THE TERM "MUNICIPALITY" MEANS A CITY, TOWN, BOROUGH, COUNTY,
PARISH, DISTRICT, OR OTHER PUBLIC BODY CREATED BY OR PURSUANT TO STATE
LAW WITH RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE PLANNING OR ADMINISTRATION OF WASTE
MANAGEMENT, OR AN INDIAN TRIBE OR AN AUTHORIZED INDIAN TRIBAL
ORGANIZATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 084 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106536
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(15) THE TERM "WASTE MANAGEMENT" MEANS THE SYSTEMATIC CONTROL OF THE
GENERATION, STORAGE, TRANSPORT, TREATMENT, RECYCLING, RECOVERY, OR
DISPOSAL OF WASTE MATERIALS.
STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR STATE REGULATION
SEC. 4 (A) WITHIN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS
ACT, AND FROM TIME TO TIME THEREAFTER, THE ADMINISTRATOR PURSUANT TO
THIS SECTION AND AFTER CONSULTATION WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF APPROPRIATE
FEDERAL AGENCIES SHALL BY REGULATION:
(1) IDENTIFY HAZARDOUS WASTES;
(2) ESTABLISH STANDARDS FOR TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL OF SUCH WASTES;
AND
(3) ESTABLISH GUIDELINES FOR STATE PROGRAMS FOR IMPLEMENTING SUCH
STANDARDS.
(B) IN IDENTIFYING A WASTE AS HAZARDOUS, PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION,
THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL SPECIFY QUANTITY, CONCENTRATION, AND THE
PHYSICAL, CHEMICAL, OR BIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF SUCH WASTE, TAKING INTO
ACCOUNT MEANS OF DISPOSAL, DISPOSAL SITES, AND AVAILABLE DISPOSAL
PRACTICES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 085 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106537
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(C) THE STANDARDS ESTABLISHED UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL INCLUDE
MINIMUM STANDARDS OF PERFORMANCE REQUIRED TO PROTECT HUMAN HEALTH AND
OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS AND MINIMUM ACCEPTABLE CRITERIA AS TO
CHARACTERISTICS AND CONDITIONS OF DISPOSAL SITES AND OPERATING METHODS,
TECHNIQUES, AND PRACTICES OF HAZARDOUS WASTES DISPOSAL TAKING INTO
ACCOUNT THE NATURE OF THE HAZARDOUS WASTE TO BE DISPOSED. SUCH
STANDARDS SHALL INCLUDE BUT NOT BE LIMITED TO REQUIREMENTS THAT ANY
PERSON GENERATING WASTE MUST (1) APPROPRIATELY LABEL ALL CONTAINERS USED
FOR ONSITE STORAGC OR FOR TRANSPORT OF HAZARDOUS WASTE; (2) FOLLOW
APPROPRIATE PROCEDURES FOR TREATING HAZARDOUS WASTE ONSITE; (3)
TRANSPORT ALL HAZARDOUS WASTE INTENDED FOR OFFSITE DISPOSAL TO A
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL FACILITY FOR WHICH APERMIT HAS BEEN ISSUED. IN
ESTABLISHING SUCH STANDARDS THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL TAKE INTO ACCOUNT
THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COSTS AND BENEFITS OF ACHIEVING SUCH STANDARDS.
(D) THE GUIDELINES ESTABLISHED UNDER PARAGRAPH (A)(3) OF THIS SECTION
SHALL PROVIDE THAT;
(1) WITH RESPECT TO DISPOSAL SITES FOR HAZARDOUS WASTES, THE STATE
PROGRAM REQUIRES THAT ANY PERSON OBTAIN FROM THE STATE A PERMIT TO
OPERATE SUCH SITE;
(2) SUCH PERMITS REQUIRE COMPLIANCE WITH THE MINIMUM STANDARDS OF
PERFORMANCE ACCEPTABLE SITE CRITERIA SET BY THE GUIDELINES;
(3) THE STATE HAVE SUCH REGULATORY AND OTHER AUTHORITIES AS MAY BE
NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE PURPOSE OF THIS ACT, INCLUDING, BUT NOT
LIMITED TO, THE AUTHORITY TO INSPECT DISPOSAL SITES AND RECORDS, AND TO
JUDICIALLY ENFORCE COMPLIANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF AN APPROVED
PROGRAM AGAINST ANY PERSON.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 086 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106538
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(E) WITHIN EIGHTEEN MONTHS OF THE PROMULGATION OF FINAL REGULATIONS
UNDER THIS ACT, EACH STATE SHALL SUBMIT TO THE ADMINISTRATOR EVIDENCE,
IN SUCH FORM AS HE SHALL REQUIRE, THAT THE STATE HAS ESTABLISHED A STATE
PROGRAM WHICH MEETS THE REQUIREMENT OF THE GUIDELINES OF PARAGRAPH
(A)(3) OF THIS SECTION. IF A STATE FAILS TO SUBMIT SUCH EVIDENCE, IN
WHOLE OR IN PART, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PUBLISH NOTICE OF SUCH FAILURE
IN THE FEDERAL REGISTER AND PROVIDE SUCH FURTHER NOTIFICATION, IN SUCH
FORM AS HE CONSIDERS APPROPRIATE, TO INFORM THE PUBLIC IN SUCH STATE OF
SUCH FAILURE.
FEDERAL REGULATION
SEC. 5.(A) WITHIN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS
ACT AND FROM TIME TO TIME THEREAFTER, THE ADMINISTRATOR AFTER
CONSULTATION WITH REPRESENTATIVES OF APPROPRIATE FEDERAL AGENCIES MAY
WITH RESPECT TO THOSE HAZARDOUS WASTES IDENTIFIED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION
(A)(1) OF SECTION 4 DETERMINE IN REGULATIONS THOSE OF SUCH WASTES WHICH
BECAUSE OF THEIR QUANTITY OR CONCENTRATION, OR BECAUSE OF THEIR CHEMICAL
CHARACTERISTICS, COULD IF ALLOWED TO BE DISPERSED INTO THE ENVIRONMENT
RESULT IN, OR CONTRIBUTE TO, THE LOSS OF HUMAN LIFE OR SUBSTANTIAL
DAMAGE TO HUMAN HEALTH OR TO OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 087 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106539
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY PROMULGATE REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING FEDERAL
STANDARDS AND PROCEDURES FOR THE TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL OF SUCH WASTES.
SUCH FEDERAL STANDARDS AND PROCEDURES SHALL BE DESIGNED TO PREVENT
DAMAGE TO HUMAN HEALTH OR LIVING ORGANISMS FROM EXPOSURE TO SUCH WASTES
IDENTIFIED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (A) AND MAY INCLUDE:
(1) WITH RESPECT TO HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SITES:
(A) MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS AS TO THE CHARACTERISTICS AND CONDITIONS OF
SUCH SITES,
(B) MINIMUM STANDARDS OF PERFORMANCE FOR THE OPERATION AND
MAINTENANCE OF SUCH SITES, AND
(C) RECOMMENDATIONS AS TO SPECIFIC DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION CRITERIA
FOR SUCH SITES; AND
(2) WITH RESPECT TO HAZARDOUS WASTE TREATMENT FACILITIES:
(A) MINIMUM STANDARDS OF PERFORMANCE FOR THE OPERATION AND
MAINTENANCE, AND
(B) RECOMMENDATIONS BASED ON AVAILABLE TECHNOLOGY AS TO APPROPRIATE
METHODS, TECHNIQUES, OR PRACTICES FOR THE TREATMENT OF SPECIFIC WASTES.
(C) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE A PERMIT FOR THE OPERATION OF A
HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL SITE OR TREATMENT FACILITY IF, AFTER A REVIEW
OF THE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION, AND PROPOSED OPERATION OF SUCH SITE OR
FACILITY, HE DETERMINES THAT SUCH OPERATION WILL MEET THE REQUIREMENTS
AND STANDARDS PROMULGATED PURSUANT TO SUBSECTION (B).
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 088 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106540
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(D) WITHIN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT,
THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PROMULGATE REGULATIONS ESTABLISHING REQUIREMENTS
FOR GENERATORS OF HAZARDOUS WASTES SUBJECT TO REGULATION UNDER THIS
SECTION TO:
(1) MAINTAIN RECORDS INDICATING THE QUANTITIES OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
GENERATED AND THE DISPOSITION THEREOF;
(2) PACKAGE HAZARDOUS WASTE IN SUCH A MANNER SO AS TO PROTECT HUMAN
HEALTH AND OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS, AND LABEL SUCH PACKAGING SO AS TO
IDENTIFY ACCURATELY SUCH WASTES;
(3) TREAT OR DISPOSE OF ALL HAZARDOUS WASTE AT A HAZARDOUS WASTE
DISPOSAL SITE OR TREATMENT FACILITY FOR WHICH A PERMIT HAS BEEN ISSUED
UNDER THIS ACT;
(4) HANDLE AND STORE ALL HAZARDOUS WASTE IN SUCH A MANNER SO AS NOT
TO POSE A THREAT TO HUMAN HEALTH OR OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS;
(5) SUBMIT REPORTS TO THE ADMINISTRATOR, AT SUCH TIMES AS THE
ADMINISTRATOR DEEMS NECESSARY, SETTING OUT:
(A) THE QUANTITIES OF HAZARDOUS WASTE SUBJECT TO FEDERAL REGULATION
UNDER THIS SUBSECTION THAT HE HAS GENERATED.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 089 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106541
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) THE NATURE AND QUANTITY OF ANY OTHER WASTE WHICH HE HAS GENERATED
WHICH HE HAS REASON TO BELIEVE MAY HAVE A SUBSTANTIAL ADVERSE EFFECT ON
HUMAN HEALTH AND OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS; AND
(C) THE DISPOSITION OF ALL WASTE INCLUDED IN CATEGORIES (A) AND (B).
(E) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY PRESCRIBE REGULATIONS REQUIRING ANY PERSON
WHO STORES, TREATS, DISPOSES OF, OR OTHERWISE HANDLES HAZARDOUS WASTES
SUBJECT TO REGULATION UNDER THIS SECTION TO MAINTAIN SUCH RECORDS WITH
RESPECT TO THEIR OPERATIONS AS THE ADMINISTRATOR DETERMINES ARE
NECESSARY FOR THE EFFECTIVE ENFORCEMENT OF THIS ACT.
(F) THE ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO ENTER INTO COOPERATIVE
AGREEMENTS WITH STATES TO DELEGATE TO ANY STATE WHICH MEETS SUCH MINIMUM
REQUIREMENTS AS THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ESTABLISH BY REGULATION THE
AUTHORITY TO ENFORCE THIS SECTION AGAINST ANY PERSON.
FEDERAL ENFORCEMENT
SEC. 6 (A) WHENEVER ON THE BASIS OF ANY INFORMATION THE ADMINISTRATOR
DETERMINES THAT ANY PERSON IS IN VIOLATION OF REQUIREMENTS UNDER SECTION
5 OR OF ANY STANDARD UNDER SECTION 4(A)(2) UNDER THIS ACT, THE
ADMINISTRATOR MAY GIVE NOTICE TO THE VIOLATOR OF HIS FAILURE TO COMPLY
WITH SUCH REQUIREMENTS OR MAY REQUEST THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO COMMENCE A
CIVIL ACTION IN THE APPROPRIATE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR
APPROPRIATE RELIEF, INCLUDING TEMPORARY OR PERMANENT INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 090 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106542
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
IF SUCH VIOLATION EXTENDS BEYOND THE THIRTIETH DAY AFTER THE
ADMINISTRATOR'S NOTIFICATION, THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE AN ORDER
REQUIRING COMPLIANCE WITHIN A SPECIFIED TIME PERIOD OR THE ADMINISTRATOR
MAY REQUEST THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO COMMENCE A CIVIL ACTION IN THE
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT IN THE DISTRICT IN WHICH THE VIOLATION
OCCURRED FOR APPROPRIATE RELIEF, INCLUDING A TEMPORARY OR PERMANENT
INJUNCTION: PROVIDED, THAT, IN THE CASE OF A VIOLATION OF ANY STANDARD
UNDER SECTION 4(A)(2) WHERE SUCH VIOLATION OCCURS IN A STATE WHICH HAS
SUBMITTED THE EVIDENCE REQUIRED UNDER SECTION 4(E), THE ADMINISTRATOR
SHALL GIVE NOTICE TO THE STATE IN WHICH SUCH VIOLATION HAS OCCURRED
THIRTY DAYS PRIOR TO ISSUING AN ORDER OR REQUESTING THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
TO COMMENCE A CIVIL ACTION. IF SUCH VIOLATOR FAILS TO TAKE CORRECTIVE
ACTION WITHIN THE TIME SPECIFIED IN THE ORDER, HE SHALL BE LIABLE FOR A
CIVIL PENALTY OF NOT MORE THAN $25,000 FOR EACH DAY OF CONTINUED
NONCOMPLIANCE. THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY SUSPEND OR REVOKE ANY PERMIT
ISSUED TO THE VIOLATOR.
(B) ANY ORDER OR ANY SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION OF A PERMIT SHALL
BECOME FINAL UNLESS, NO LATER THAN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ORDER OR NOTICE OF
THE SUSPENSION OR REVOCATION IS SERVED, THE PERSON OR PERSONS NAMED
THEREIN REQUEST A PUBLIC HEARING. UPON SUCH REQUEST THE ADMINISTRATOR
SHALL PROMPTLY CONDUCT A PUBLIC HEARING.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 091 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106543
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
IN CONNECTION WITH ANY PROCEEDING UNDER THIS SECTION THE
ADMINISTRATOR MAY ISSUE SUBPENAS FOR THE ATTENDANCE AND TESTIMONY OF
WITNESSES AND THE PRODUCTION OF RELEVANT PAPERS, BOOKS, AND DOCUMENTS,
AND MAY PROMULGATE RULES FOR DISCOVERY PROCEDURES.
(C) ANY ORDER ISSUED UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL STATE WITH REASONABLE
SPECIFICITY THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION AND SPECIFY A TIME FOR
COMPLIANCE AND ASSESS A PENALTY, IF ANY, WHICH THE ADMINISTRATOR
DETERMINES IS A REASONABLE PERIOD AND PENALTY TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE
SERIOUSNESS OF THE VIOLATION AND ANY GOOD FAITH EFFORTS TO COMPLY WITH
THE APPLICABLE REQUIREMENTS.
(D) ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY VIOLATES ANY REQUIREMENT OF THIS ACT OR
COMMITS ANY PROHIBITED ACT SHALL, UPON CONVICTION, BE SUBJECT TO A FINE
OF NOT MORE THAN $25,000 FOR EACH DAY OF VIOLATION, OR TO IMPRISONMENT
NOT TO EXCEED ONE YEAR, OR BOTH.
RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT, INVESTIGATIONS, TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND OTHER
ACTIVITIES
SEC. 7(A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CONDUCT, ENCOURAGE, COOPERATE WITH,
AND RENDER FINANCIAL AND OTHER ASSISTANCE TO APPROPRIATE PUBLIC (WHETHER
FEDERAL, STATE, INTERSTATE, OR LOCAL) AUTHORITIES, AGENCIES, AND
INSTITUTIONS, PRIVATE AGENCIES AND INSTITUTIONS, AND INDIVIDUALS IN THE
CONDUCT OF, AND PROMOTE THE COORDINATION OF, RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT,
INVESTIGATIONS, EXPERIMENTS, SURVEYS, AND STUDIES RELATING TO:
(1) ANY ADVERSE HEALTH AND WELFARE EFFECTS ON THE RELEASE INTO THE
ENVIRONMENT OF MATERIAL PRESENT IN WASTE, AND METHODS TO ELIMINATE SUCH
EFFECTS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 092 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106544
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(2) THE OPERATION OR FINANCING OF WASTE MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS;
(3) THE DEVELOPMENT AND APPLICATION OF NEW AND IMPROVED METHODS OF
COLLECTING AND DISPOSING OF WASTE AND PROCESSING AND RECOVERING
MATERIALS AND ENERGY FROM WASTES; AND
(4) THE REDUCTION OF WASTE GENERATION AND THE RECOVERY OF SECONDARY
MATERIALS AND ENERGY FROM SOLID, LIQUID, AND SEMISOLID WASTES.
(B) IN CARRYING OUT THE PROVISIONS OF THE PRECEDING SUBSECTION, THE
ADMINISTRATOR IS AUTHORIZED TO:
(1) COLLECT AND MAKE AVAILABLE, THROUGH PUBLICATION AND OTHER
APPROPRIATE MEANS, THE RESULTS OF, AND OTHER INFORMATION PERTAINING TO,
SUCH RESEARCH AND OTHER ACTIVITIES, INCLUDING APPROPRIATE
RECOMMENDATIONS IN CONNECTION THEREWITH;
(2) COOPERATE WITH PUBLIC AND PRIVATE AGENCIES, INSTITUTIONS, AND
ORGANIZATIONS, AND WITH ANY INDUSTRIES INVOLVED, IN THE PREPARATION AND
THE CONDUCT OF SUCH RESEARCH AND OTHER ACTIVITIES; AND
(3) MAKE GRANTS-IN-AID TO AND CONTRACT WITH PUBLIC OR PRIVATE
AGENCIES AND INSTITUTIONS AND INDIVIDUALS FOR RESEARCH, SURVEYS,
DEVELOPMENT, AND PUBLIC EDUCATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 093 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106545
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
CONTRACTS MAY BE ENTERED INTO WITHOUT REGARD TO SECTIONS 3648 AND
3709 OF THE REVISED STATUTES (31 U.S.C. 529; 41 U.S.C.5).
(C) THE INTERSTATE COMMERCE COMMISSION, THE FEDERAL MARITIME
COMMISSION, AND THE OFFICE OF OIL AND GAS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF THE
INTERIOR, IN CONSULTATION WITH THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY AND
WITH OTHER FEDERAL AGENCIES AS APPROPRIATE, SHALL CONDUCT WITHIN TWELVE
MONTHS OF THE DATE OF ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT AND SUBMIT TO CONGRESS, A
THOROUGH AND COMPLETE STUDY OF RATE SETTING PRACTICES WITH REGARD TO THE
CARRIAGE OF SECONDARY MATERIALS BY RAIL AND OCEAN CARRIERS. SUCH STUDY
SHALL INCLUDE A COMPARISON OF SUCH PRACTICES WITH RATE SETTING PRACTICES
WITH REGARD TO OTHER MATERIALS AND SHALL EXAMINE THE EXTENT TO WHICH, IF
AT ALL, THERE IS DISCRIMINATION AGAINST SECONDARY MATERIALS.
INSPECTIONS
SEC. 8.(A) FOR THE PURPOSE OF DEVELOPING OR ASSISTING IN THE
DEVELOPMENT OF ANY REGULATION OR ENFORCING THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT,
ANY PERSON WHO STORES, TREATS, TRANSPORTS, DISPOSES OF, OR OTHERWISE
HANDLES HAZARDOUS WASTES SHALL, UPON REQUEST OF ANY OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE
OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY OR OF ANY STATE OR POLITICAL
SUBDIVISION, DULY DESIGNATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR, FURNISH OR PERMIT
SUCH PERSON AT ALL REASONABLE TIMES TO HAVE ACCESS TO, AND TO COPY ALL
RECORDS RELATING TO SUCH WASTES.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 094 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106546
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) FOR THE PURPOSES OF DEVELOPING OR ASSISTING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF
ANY REGULATION OR ENFORCING THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT, OFFICERS OR
EMPLOYEES DULY DESIGNATED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR ARE AUTHORIZED:
(1) TO ENTER AT REASONABLE TIMES ANY ESTABLISHMENT OR OTHER PLACE
MAINTAINED BY ANY PERSON WHERE HAZARDOUS WASTES ARE STORED, TREATED, OR
DISPOSED OF:
(2) TO INSPECT AND OBTAIN SAMPLES FROM ANY PERSON OF ANY SUCH WASTES
AND SAMPLES OF ANY CONTAINERS OR LABELING FOR SUCH WASTES. BEFORE
UNDERTAKING SUCH INSPECTION, THE OFFICERS OR EMPLOYEES MUST PRESENT TO
THE OWNER, OPERATOR, OR AGENT IN CHARGE OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OR OTHER
PLACE WHERE HAZARDOUS WASTES ARE STORED, TREATED, OR DISPOSED OF
APPROPRIATE CREDENTIALS AND A WRITTEN STATEMENT AS TO THE REASON FOR THE
INSPECTION. EACH SUCH INSPECTION SHALL BE COMMENCED AND COMPLETED WITH
REASONABLE PROMPTNESS. IF THE OFFICER OR EMPLOYEE OBTAINS ANY SAMPLES,
PRIOR TO LEAVING THE PREMISES, HE SHALL GIVE TO THE OWNER, OPERATOR, OR
AGENT IN CHARGE A RECEIPT DESCRIBING THE SAMPLE OBTAINED AND IF
REQUESTED A PORTION OF EACH SUCH SAMPLE EQUAL IN VOLUME OR WEIGHT TO THE
PORTION RETAINED.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 095 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106547
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
IF AN ANALYSIS IS MADE OF SUCH SAMPLES, A COPY OF THE RESULTS OF SUCH
ANALYSIS SHALL BE FURNISHED PROMPTLY TO THE OWNER, OPERATOR, OR AGENT IN
CHARGE.
(C) ANY RECORDS, REPORTS, OR INFORMATION OBTAINED FROM ANY PERSON
UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC, EXCEPT THAT UPON
A SHOWING SATISFACTORY TO THE ADMINISTRATOR BY ANY PERSON THAT RECORDS,
REPORTS, OR INFORMATION, OR PARTICULAR PART THEREOF, TO WHICH THE
ADMINISTRATOR HAS ACCESS UNDER THIS SECTION IF MADE PUBLIC, WOULD
DIVULGE INFORMATION ENTITLED TO PROTECTION UNDER SECTION 1905 OF TITLE
18 OF THE UNITED STATES CODE, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL CONSIDER SUCH
INFORMATION OR PARTICULAR PORTION THEREOF CONFIDENTIAL IN ACCORDANCE
WITHIN THE PURPOSES OF THAT SECTION.
ENCOURAGEMENT OF INTERSTATE AND INTERLOCAL COOPERATION
SEC. 9. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ENCOURAGE COOPERATIVE ACTIVITIES BY
THE STATES AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS IN CONNECTION WITH WASTE DISPOSAL
PROGRAMS, ENCOURAGE, WHERE PRACTICABLE, INTERSTATE, INTERLOCAL, AND
REGIONAL PLANNING FOR, AND THE CONDUCT OF, INTERSTATE, INTERLOCAL, AND
REGIONAL HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PROGRAMS; AND ENCOURAGE THE ENACTMENT
OF IMPROVED AND, SO FAR AS PRACTICABLE, UNIFORM STATE AND LOCAL LAWS
GOVERNING WASTE DISPOSAL.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 096 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106548
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
IMMINENT HAZARD
SEC. 10(A) AN IMMINENT HAZARD SHALL BE CONSIDERED TO EXIST WHEN THE
ADMINISTRATOR HAS REASON TO BELIEVE THAT HANDLING OR STORAGE OF A
HAZARDOUS WASTE PRESENTS AN IMMINENT AND SUBSTANTIAL DANGER TO HUMAN
HEALTH OR OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS THE CONTINUED OPERATION OF A DISPOSAL
SITE WILL RESULT IN SUCH DANGER WHEN A STATE OR LOCAL AUTHORITY HAS NOT
ACTED TO ELIMINATE SUCH RISK.
(B) IF AN IMMINENT HAZARD EXISTS, THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY REQUEST
THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO PETITION THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES IN THE DISTRICT WHERE SUCH HAZARD EXISTS, TO ORDER ANY
DISPOSAL SITE OPERATOR OR OTHER PERSON HAVING CUSTODY OF SUCH
WASTE TO TAKE SUCH ACTION AS IS NECESSARY TO ELIMINATE THE
IMMINENT HAZARD, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PERMANENT OR
TEMPORARY CESSATION OF OPERATION OF A DISPOSAL SITE, OR SUCH
OTHER REMEDIAL MEASURES AS THE COURT DEEMS APPROPRIATE.
PROHIBITED ACTS
SEC. 11. THE FOLLOWING ACTS AND THE CAUSING THEREOF ARE PROHIBITED
AND SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ENFORCEMENT IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF
SUBSECTION 6(D) OF THIS ACT;
(A) OPERATING ANY DISPOSAL SITE FOR HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED
PURUSANT TO SECTION 5 WITHOUT HAVING OBTAINED AN OPERATING PERMIT
PURSUANT TO SUCH SECTION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 097 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106549
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) DISPOSING OF HAZARDOUS WASTE IDENTIFIED PURSUANT TO SECTION 5 IN
A MANNER NOT IN COMPLIANCE WITH REQUIREMENTS UNDER SECTION 5.
(C) FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF SECTION 5 IN LABELING
CONTAINERS USED FOR THE STORAGE, TRANSPORT, OR DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS
WASTE.
(D) FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH (1) THE CONDITIONS OF ANY FEDERAL PERMIT
ISSUED UNDER THIS ACT, (2) ANY REGULATION PROMULGATED BY THE
ADMINISTRATOR PURSUANT TO SECTION 4(A) (2) OR SECTION 5 OF THIS ACT, OR
(3) ANY ORDER ISSUED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR PURSUANT TO THIS ACT.
APPLICATION OF STANDARDS TO FEDERAL AGENCIES
SEC. 12.(A) EACH DEPARTMENT, AGENCY, AND INSTRUMENTALITY OF THE
EXECUTIVE, LEGISLATIVE, AND JUDICIAL BRANCHES OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
HAVING JURISDICTION OVER ANY PROPERTY OR FACILITY, OR ENGAGED IN ANY
ACTIVITY WHICH GENERATES, OR WHICH MAY GENERATE, WASTES SHALL INSURE
COMPLIANCE WITH SUCH STANDARDS PURSUANT TO SUBSECTIONS 4(A) (2), 5(A),
AND 5(C) AS MAY BE ESTABLISHED BY THE ADMINISTRATOR FOR THE TREATMENT
AND DISPOSAL OF SUCH WASTES.
(B) THE PRESIDENT OR HIS DESIGNEE MAY EXEMPT ANY FACILITY OR ACTIVITY
OF ANY DEPARTMENT, AGENCY, OR INSTRUMENTALITY IN THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH
FROM COMPLIANCE WITH GUIDELINES ESTABLISHED UNDER SECTION 4 IF HE
DETERMINES IT TO BE IN THE PARAMOUNT INTEREST OF THE UNITED STATES TO DO
SO. ANY EXEMPTION SHALL BE FOR A PERIOD NOT IN EXCESS OF ONE YEAR, BUT
ADDITIONAL EXEMPTIONS MAY BE GRANTED FOR PERIODS OF NOT TO EXCEED ONE
YEAR UPON THE PRSIDENT'S OR HIS DESIGNEE'S MAKING OF A NEW
DETERMINATION.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 098 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106550
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ASCERTAIN THE EXEMPTIONS GRANTED UNDER THIS
SUBSECTION AND SHALL REPORT EACH JANUARY TO THE CONGRESS ALL EXEMPTIONS
FROM THE REQUIREMENTS OF THIS SECTION GRANTED DURING THE PRECEDING
CALENDAR YEAR.
(C) WITHIN EIGHTEEN MONTHS AFTER ENACTMENT OF THIS ACT AND FROM TIME
TO TIME THEREAFTER, THE ADMINISTRATOR, IN CONSULTATION WITH OTHER
APPROPRIATE FEDERAL AGENCIES, SHALL IDENTIFY PRODUCTS WHICH CAN UTILIZE
SIGNIFICANT QUANTITIES OF SECONDARY MATERIALS AND SHALL ISSUE GUIDELINES
WITH RESPECT TO THE INCLUSION OF SUCH SECONDARY MATERIALS TO THE MAXIMUM
EXTENT PRACTICABLE IN PRODUCTS PROCURED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT.
(D) IN ANY PROCEEDING INITIATED BEFORE THE INTERSTATE COMMERCE
COMMISSION OR THE FEDERAL MARITIME COMMISSION AFTER THE ENACTMENT OF
THIS ACT WHERE A DETERMINATION IS MADE BY SUCH COMMISSION AS TO ANY
INDIVIDUAL OR JOINT RATE, FARE, OR CHARGE WHATSOEVER DEMANDED, CHARGED,
OR COLLECTED BY ANY COMMON CARRIER OR CARRIERS, A SPECIFIC FINDING BY
THE COMMISSION WILL BE REQUIRED THAT SUCH RATE, FARE, OR CHARGE DOES NOT
OR WILL NOT CAUSE DISCRIMINATION AGAINST SECONDARY MATERIALS.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 099 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106551
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
CITIZEN SUITES
SEC. 13(A) EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SUBSECTION (B) ANY PERSON MAY
COMMENCE A CIVIL ACTION FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF ON HIS OWN BEHALF:
(1) AGAINST ANY PERSON WHO IS ALLEGED TO BE IN VIOLATION OF ANY
REGULATION PROMULGATED OR ORDER ISSUED UNDER THIS ACT;
(2) AGAINST THE ADMINISTRATOR WHERE THERE IS ALLEGED A FAILURE OF THE
ADMINISTRATOR TO PERFORM ANY ACT OR DUTY UNDER THIS ACT WHICH IS NOT
DISCRETIONARY WITH THE ADMINISTRATOR.
ANY ACTION UNDER PARAGRAPH (A)(1) OF THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE BROUGHT
IN THE DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT IN WHICH THE ALLEGED VIOLATION
OCCURRED AND ANY ACTION BROUGHT UNDER PARAGRAPH (A)(2) OF THIS
SUBSECTION SHALL BE BROUGHT IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE DISTRICT OF
COLUMBIA. THE DISTRICT COURTS SHALL HAVE JURISDICTION, WITHOUT REGARD
TO THE AMOUNT IN CONTROVERSY OR THE CITIZENSHIP OF THE PARTIES, TO
ENFORCE SUCH REGULATION OR ORDER, OR TO ORDER THE ADMINISTRATOR TO
PERFORM SUCH ACT OR DUTY AS THE CASE MAY BE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 100 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106552
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(B) NO ACTION MAY BE COMMENCED:
(1) UNDER SUBSECTION (A)(1) OF THIS SECTION:
(A) PRIOR TO SIXTY DAYS AFTER THE PLAINTIFF HAS GIVEN NOTICE OF THE
VIOLATION (I) TO THE ADMINISTRATOR, (II) TO THE STATE IN WHICH THE
ALLEGED VIOLATION OCCURS, AND (III) TO ANY ALLEGED VIOLATOR OF THE
STANDARD, LIMITATION, OR ORDER, OR
(B) IF THE ADMINISTRATOR OR STATE HAS CAUSED TO BE COMMENCED AND IS
DILIGENTLY PROSECUTING A CIVIL OR CRIMINAL ACTION IN A COURT OF THE
UNITED STATES OR A STATE TO REQUIRE COMPLIANCE WITH REQUIREMENTS OF THIS
ACT OR ORDER ISSUED HEREUNDER;
(2) UNDER SUBSECTION (A)(2) PRIOR TO SIXTY DAYS AFTER PLAINTIFF HAS
GIVEN NOTICE OF SUCH ACTION TO THE ADMINISTRATOR.
NOTICE UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE GIVEN IN SUCH MANNER AS THE
ADMINISTRATOR SHALL PRESCRIBE BY REGULATION.
(3) IN SUCH ACTION UNDER THIS SECTION, IF THE UNITED STATES IS NOT A
PARTY, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY INTERVENE AS A MATTER OF RIGHT.
(D) THE COURT, IN ISSUING ANY FINAL ORDER IN ANY ACTION BROUGHT
PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION, MAY AWARD COSTS OF LITIGATION (INCLUDING
REASONABLE ATTORNEY AND EXPERT WITNESS FEES) TO ANY PARTY, WHENEVER THE
COURT DETERMINES SUCH AWARD IS APPROPRIATE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 101 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106553
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(E) NOTHING IN THIS SECTION SHALL RESTRICT ANY RIGHT WHICH ANY PERSON
(OR CLASS OF PERSONS) MAY HAVE UNDER ANY STATUTE OR COMMON LAW TO SEEK
ENFORCEMENT OF ANY REGULATION OR TO SEEK ANY OTHER RELIEF (INCLUDING
RELIEF AGAINST THE ADMINISTRATOR OR A STATE AGENCY).
STATE AUTHORITY
SEC. 14 (A) IF THE ADMINISTRATOR HAS PROMULGATED REGULATIONS UNDER
SECTION 5 NO STATE OR MUNICIPALITY MAY WITHOUT THE APPROVAL OF THE
ADMINISTRATOR IMPOSE MORE STRINGENT REQUIREMENTS THAN THOSE IMPOSED
UNDER THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 5 ON THE TRANSPORT, TREATMENT, OR
DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES.
(B) NO STATE OR MUNICIPALITY SHALL IMPOSE, ON WASTES ORIGINATING IN
OTHER STATES OR MUNICIPALITIES, REQUIREMENTS RESPECTING THE TRANSPORT OF
SUCH WASTES INTO OR DISPOSAL WITHIN ITS JURISDICTION WHICH ARE MORE
STRINGENT THAN THOSE REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO WASTES ORIGINATING
WITHIN SUCH RECEIVING STATES AND MUNICIPALITIES.
AUTHORIZATION AND APPROPRIATION
SEC. 15. THERE IS HEREBY AUTHORIZED TO BE APPROPRIATED TO THE
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY SUCH SUMS AS MAY BE NECESSARY FOR THE
PURPOSES AND ADMINISTRATION OF THIS ACT.
JUDICIAL REVIEW
SEC. 16. (A) A PETITION FOR REVIEW OF ACTION OF THE ADMINISTRATOR IN
PROMULGATING ANY REGULATION PURSUANT TO SECTIONS 4 OR 5 SHALL BE FILED
IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 102 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106554
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
ANY PERSON WHO WILL BE ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY A FINAL ORDER OR OTHER
FINAL DETERMINATION ISSUED UNDER SECTION 6 MAY FILE A PETITION WITH THE
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE CIRCUIT WHEREIN SUCH PERSON
RESIDES OR HAS HIS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS, FOR A JUDICIAL REVIEW OF
SUCH ORDER OR DETERMINATION. ANY SUCH PETITION SHALL BE FILED WITHIN
THIRTY DAYS FROM THE DATE OF SUCH ACTION OR ORDER, OR AFTER SUCH DATE IF
SUCH PETITION IS BASED SOLELY ON GROUNDS ARISING AFTER SUCH THIRTIETH
DAY.
(B) ACTION OF THE ADMINISTRATOR WITH RESPECT TO WHICH REVIEW COULD
HAVE BEEN OBTAINED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) SHALL NOT BE SUBJECT TO JUDICIAL
REVIEW IN CIVIL OR CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS FOR ENFORCEMENT.
(C) IN ANY JUDICIAL PROCEEDING IN WHICH REVIEW IS SOUGHT OF AN ACTION
UNDER THIS ACT REQUIRED TO BE MADE ON THE RECORD AFTER NOTICE AND
OPPORTUNITY FOR HEARING, IF ANY PARTY APPLIES TO THE COURT FOR LEAVE TO
ADDUCE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE, AND SHOWS TO THE SATISFACTION OF THE COURT
THAT SUCH ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE IS MATERIAL AND THAT THERE WERE REASONABLE
GROUNDS FOR THE FAILURE TO ADDUCE SUCH EVIDENCE IN THE PROCEEDINGS
BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATOR, THE COURT MAY ORDER SUCH ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE
(AND EVIDENCE IN REBUTTAL THEREOF) TO BE TAKEN BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATOR,
IN SUCH MANNER AND UPON SUCH TERMS AND CONDITIONS AS THE COURT MAY DEEM
PROPER. THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY MODIFY HIS FINDINGS AS TO THE FACTS, OR
MAKE NEW FINDINGS, BY REASON OF THE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE SO TAKEN AND HE
SHALL FILE SUCH MODIFIED OR NEW FINDINGS, AND HIS RECOMMENDATION, IF
ANY, FOR THE MODIFICATION OR SETTING ASIDE OF HIS ORIGINAL
DETERMINATION, WITH THE RETURN OF SUCH ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 103 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106555
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER LAWS
SEC. 17 (A) THIS ACT SHALL NOT APPLY TO:
(1) ANY SOURCE MATERIAL, SPECIAL NUCLEAR MATERIAL, OR BYPRODUCT
MATERIAL SUBJECT TO REGULATION OR CONTROL PURSUANT TO THE ATOMIC ENERGY
ACT OF 1954, AS AMENDED;
(2) LETHAL CHEMICALS SUBJECT TO REGULATION PURSUANT TO TITLE 50,
UNITED STATES CODE, SECTION 1511, AND THE FOLLOWING, AS AMENDED.
(B) THIS ACT SHALL NOT BE CONSTRUED TO RELIEVE ANY PERSON FROM ANY
PRESENT OR FUTURE REQUIREMENT ARISING FROM ANY OTHER FEDERAL LAW.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 104 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106556
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
MR. DOMENICI (FOR HIMSELF, MR. BAKER, MR. MCCLURE, MR. MUSKIE, MR.
RANDOLPH, AND MR. STAFFORD) INTRODUCED THE FOLLOWING BILL; WHICH WAS
READ TWICE AND REFERRED TO THE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC WORKS
TO AMEND THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, TO ENCOURACE FULL RECOVERY OF
ENERGY AND RESOURCES FROM SOLID WASTE, TO PROTECT HEALTH AND THE
ENVIRONMENT FROM THE ADVERSE EFFECTS OF SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL, AND FOR
OTHERPURPOSES.
BE IT ENACTED BY THE SENATE AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN CONGRESS ASSEMBLED, THAT THIS ACT MAY BE
CITED AS THE "ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY ACT OF 1974".
FINDINGS AND PURPOSES
SEC. 2. (A) THE CONGRESS FINDS
(1) THAT THE REQUIREMENTS FOR ENERGY AND RESOURCE RECOVERY ARE
NATIONAL IN SCOPE AND CONCERN AND NECESSITATE FEDERAL LEADERSHIP THROUGH
FINANCIAL AND TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND THROUGH THE DEVELOPMENT OF NEW
AND IMPROVED METHODS AND STANDARDS TO ENCOURAGE GREATER UTILIZATION OF
THE WEALTH OF NATURAL RESOURCES IN SOLID WASTE;
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 105 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106557
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(2) THAT THE VOLUME OF WASTE AND DISCARDING OF SALVAGEABLE MATERIALS
CAN BE REDUCED MARKEDLY AND THAT THE RESULTANT REDUCED VOLUME OF WASTE
THAN CAN BE DISPOSED OF IN AN ECONOMICAL AND ENVIRONMENTALLY SOUND
MANNER;
(3) THAT ENERGY SUPPLIES FROM SOURCES SUCH AS PETROLEUM PRODUCTS,
NATURAL GAS, AND HYDROELECTRIC GENERATION HAVE FAILED TO MEET CONSTANTLY
INCREASING CONSUMER DEMANDS AND THEREFORE, THE NEED EXISTS TO DEVELOP
ALTERNATIVE SOURCES OF ENERGY FOR PUBLIC AND PRIVATE CONSUMPTION;
(4) THAT INCREASING DEMAND FOR PRODUCTS MADE FROM TIMBER, MINERAL,
AND NONMINERAL NATURAL RESOURCES IS CAUSING THE DEPLETION OF THESE
RESOURCES, WHILE MORE EFFICIENT USE OF SUCH RESOURCES WOULD EXTEND THE
LIFESPAN OF THE WORLD'S EXISTING RESERVES;
(5) THAT THE TECHNOLOGY AND ECONOMICS EXIST TO SUPPORT RECYCLING OF
SOLID WASTE AS A PRACTICAL MEANS OF INCREASED RESOURCE UTILITY;
(6) THAT ENERGY AND MATERIALS CAN BE RECOVERED EFFICIENTLY FROM SOLID
WASTE;
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 106 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106558
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(7) THAT RESOURCE RECOVERY TECHNIQUES ARE NOT PRESENTLY UTILIZED TO A
SUFFICIENT EXTENT; AND
(8) THAT SUCH TRADITIONAL METHODS OF WASTE DISPOSAL AS LANDFILL AND
INCINERATION ARE BECOMING IMPRACTICABLE AND COSTLY, AND CONTRIBUTE TO
UNACCEPTABLE LEVELS OF AIR, WATER, AND LAND POLLUTION. (B) THE PURPOSES
OF THIS ACT THEREFORE ARE
(1) TO ENCOURAGE FULL RECOVERY WHEREVER PRACTICABLE OF ENERGY AND
MATERIALS FROM MUNICIPAL, INDUSTRIAL, AND OTHER SOURCES OF SOLID WASTE
BY 1985;
(2) TO ASSIST STATES AND LOCALITIES IN CARRYING OUT THEIR PRIMARY
RESPONSIBILITIES FOR SOLID WASTE COLLECTION, HANDLING, RECYCLING, AND
DISPOSAL, WITH PRIORITY ATTENTION TO METROPOLITAN AND OTHER AREAS WHERE
LAND USE PATTERNS INHIBIT SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL;
(3) TO INSURE THAT RECYCLING OR DISPOSAL OF HAZARDOUS WASTES IS
CONTROLLED TO AVOID ADVERSE EFFECTS ON HEALTH AND THE ENVIRONMENT;
(4) TO PROVIDE FOR USE OF BEST TECHNOLOGICAL PRACTICES TO MINIMIZE
ADVERSE EFFECTS ON AIR AND WATER QUALITY WHERE LAND DISPOSAL OFHAZARDOUS
AND OTHER WASTES IS THE ONLY PRACTICABLE METHOD, AND TO ASSURE
CONSIDERATION OF ALTERNATIVEUSES OF THE LAND;
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 107 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106559
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
(5) TO PROVIDE FOR PROGRAMS OF RESEARCH, DEVELOPMENT, AND
DEMONSTRATION TO SUPPORT ACHIEVEMENT OF THESE PURPOSES; AND
(6) TO ESTABLISH THE OFFICE OF ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY, UNDER
THE DIRECTION OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY, TO ACHIEVE THE
PURPOSES AND ADMINISTER THE PROVISIONS OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT,
AS AMENDED.
SEC. 3. SECTION 216 OF THE SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT, AS AMENDED (42
U.S.C. 3259) IS AMENDED BY ADDING AT THE END THEREOF THE FOLLOWING NEW
SECTIONS:
"ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY OFFICE
"SEC. 217. THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ESTABLISH WITHIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY AN OFFICE OF ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY TO ACHIEVE
THE PURPOSES AND ADMINISTER THE PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT, AS AMENDED BY
THE ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY ACT OF 1974.
"FEDERAL SOLID WASTE STANDARDS
"SEC. 218. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL, WITHIN ONE YEAR OF THE DATE
OF ENACTMENT OF THE ENERGY AND RESOURCES RECOVERY ACT OF 1974, AFTER
CONSULTATION WITH APPROPRIATE FEDERAL, STATE, INTERSTATE, REGIONAL, AND
LOCAL AGENCIES AND AFTER OPPORTUNITY FOR PUBLIC HEARINGS, PROMULGATE
STANDARDS FOR COLLECTION, HANDLING DISPOSAL, AND RECOVERY OF ALL
HAZARDOUS AND OTHER SOLID WASTE WHICH MAY, IF IMPROPERLY DISPOSED OF,
CAUSE AIR OR WATER POLLUTION OR OTHER ENVIRONMENTAL DAMAGE.
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 108 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106560
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(B) SUCH STANDARDS SHALL
"(1) IDENTIFY HAZARDOUS AND OTHER WASTES TO BE REGULATED;
"(2) BE SPECIFIC IN TERMS OF ALLOWABLE QUANTITIES, CONCENTRATIONS,
AND PHYSICAL, CHEMICAL, OR BIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF SUCH WASTE, TAKING
INTO ACCOUNT LIKELY DISPOSAL SITES AND METHODS OF DISPOSAL OR RECYCLING;
"(3) CONTRIBUTE TO THE ACHIEVEMENT AND MAINTENANCE OF EMISSION OR
EFFLUENT LIMITATIONS, AIR QUALITY IMPLEMENTATION PLANS, AND ANY
ESTABLISHED OR PROPOSED LAND USE PLANS, AND
"(4) CONTRIBUTE TO THE ENHANCEMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT.
"FEDERAL REGULATIONS
"SEC. 219. (A) THE ADMINISTRATOR, IN CARRYING OUT THE PROVISIONS OF
THIS ACT, MAY REQUIRE THE OPERATOR OF ANY DISPOSAL SYSTEM FOR HAZARDOUS
OR OTHER SOLID WASTE TO
"(1) ESTABLISH AND MAINTAIN SUCH RECORDS,
"(2) MAKE SUCH REPORTS,
"(3) INSTALL, USE, AND MAINTAIN SUCH MONITORING EQUIPMENT OR METHODS,
AND
"(4) PROVIDE SUCH OTHER INFORMATION AS HE MAY REQUIRE.
"(B) THE ADMINISTRATOR OR HIS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE, UPON
PRESENTATION OF HIS CREDENTIALS;
THE NEED FOR A NATIONAL MATERIALS POLICY
OPENING STATEMENT OF DOMENICI PV
S 3560, 740531
S 3549, 740530
S 1086, 730306
S 3277, 740329
S 3954, 740822
PART 109 OF 196
DOMENICI PV SENATOR, NM
U.S. SENATE
106561
HEARING
SENATE
TRANSCRIPT
BILL
"(1) SHALL HAVE A RIGHT TO ENTRY TO, UPON, OR THROUGH ANY PREMISES IN
WHICH A HAZARDOUS OR OTHER SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL SYSTEM IS LOCATED OR IN
WHICH ANY RECORDS REQUIRED TO BE MAINTAINED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS
SECTION ARE LOCATED, AND
"(2) MAY HAVE ACCESS TO AND COPY ANY RECORDS, AND INSPECT ANY
MONITORING EQUIPMENT OR METHOD REQUIRED UNDER SUBSECTION (A) OF THIS
SECTION.
"(C) THE ADMINISTRATOR MAY MAKE SUCH RULES AND REGULATIONS, AFTER
OPPORTUNITY FOR HEARING, AS HE CONSIDERS NECESSARY TO CARRY OUT THE
PROVISIONS OF THIS ACT.
"ENFORCEMENT
"SEC. 220. (A) (1) WHENEVER, ON THE BASIS OF ANY INFORMATION
AVAILABLE TO HIM, THE ADMINISTRATOR FINDS THAT ANY PERSON IS IN
VIOLATION OF ANY RULE, REGULATION, PERMIT, OR OTHER REQUIREMENT WHICH
IMPLEMENTS SECTIONS 218 AND 219 OF THIS ACT, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL
GIVE NOTICE TO THE VIOLATOR OF HIS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH SUCH
REQUIREMENT OR HE SHALL REQUEST THE ATTORNEY GENERAL TO COMMENCE A CIVIL
ACTION IN THE APPROPRIATE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR APPROPRIATE
RELIEF INCLUDING TEMPORARY OR PERMANENT INJUNCTIVE RELIEF. IF SUCH
VIOLATION EXTENDS BEYOND THE THIRTIETH DAY AFTER THE ADMINISTRATOR'S
NOTIFICATION, THE ADMINISTRATOR SHALL ISSUE AN ORDER REQUIRING
COMPL